Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1907.02433 · New Journal of Physics

Numerical simulation of critical dissipative non-equilibrium quantum systems with an absorbing state

Edward Gillman, Federico Carollo, Igor Lesanovsky

Published Sep 1, 2019• 37 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract The simulation of out-of-equilibrium dissipative quantum many body systems is a problem of fundamental interest to a number of fields in physics, ranging from condensed matter to cosmology. For unitary systems, tensor network methods have proved successful and extending these to open systems is a natural avenue for study. In particular, an important question concerns the possibility of approximating the critical dynamics of non-equilibrium systems with tensor networks. Here, we investigate this by performing numerical simulations of a paradigmatic quantum non-equilibrium system with an absorbing state: the quantum contact process. We consider the application of matrix product states and the time-evolving block decimation algorithm to simulate the time-evolution of the quantum contact process at criticality. In the Lindblad formalism, we find that the Heisenberg picture can be used to improve the accuracy of simulations over the Schrödinger approach, which can be understood by considering the evolution of operator-space entanglement. Furthermore, we also consider a quantum trajectories approach, which we find can reproduce the expected universal behaviour of key observables for a significantly longer time than direct simulation of the average state. These improved results provide further evidence that the universality class of the quantum contact process is not directed percolation, which is the class of the classical contact process.

DOI
10.1088/1367-2630/ab43b0

Related papers

Critical Behavior of the Quantum Contact Process in One Dimension

Federico Carollo, Edward Gillman, Hendrik Weimer +1 more

The contact process is a paradigmatic classical stochastic system displaying critical behavior even in one dimension. It features a nonequilibrium phase transition into an absorbing state that has been widely investigated and shown to belong to the directed percolation universality class. When the same process is considered in a quantum setting, much less is known. So far, mainly semiclassical studies have been conducted and the nature of the transition in low dimensions is still a matter of debate. Also, from a numerical point of view, from which the system may look fairly simple-especially in one dimension-results are lacking. In particular, the presence of the absorbing state poses a substantial challenge, which appears to affect the reliability of algorithms targeting directly the steady state. Here we perform real-time numerical simulations of the open dynamics of the quantum contact process and shed light on the existence and on the nature of an absorbing state phase transition in one dimension. We find evidence for the transition being continuous and provide first estimates for the critical exponents. Beyond the conceptual interest, the simplicity of the quantum contact process makes it an ideal benchmark problem for scrutinizing numerical methods for open quantum nonequilibrium systems.

arXiv:1902.04515•Physical Review Letters•Sep 6, 2019•62 citations

On the out-of-equilibrium dynamics with tensor networks

Ramos Marimón, Carlos

[eng] Quantum many-body dynamics is a vast field of physics at the intersection of statistical mechanics, condensed matter, quantum information, and computational physics. Understanding the time evolution of observable correlations—such as those involved in material responses—is both a milestone for technological advancement and a corner-stone for generating fundamental knowledge. At the intersection of emergent collective behavior in many-body systems, quantum physics, and information theory lies the classical simulation of out-of-equilibrium phenomena. Without numerical tools, progress in disciplines that require heavy computations with high-dimensional vectors and matrices would be limited to purely analytical predictions and constrained by the available expertise and resources needed to build benchmarking experiments. The goal of this thesis is to advance the classical simulation of quantum many-body systems using Tensor Networks. This technique has proven fruitful for predicting equilibrium ground states and thermal properties of one-dimensional systems, yet it still faces challenges when applied to out-of-equilibrium scenarios. In brief, the dynamics of experimentally accessible expectation values can be represented as a 2D Tensor Network, which must be contracted using iterative methods such as Time-Evolving Block Decimation. However, the memory and computational time required for these calculations—which reflect the methods’ complexity—are known to grow exponentially with the simulated physical time in generic systems. This limitation is often referred to in the literature as the entanglement barrier. This manuscript tackles the problem through the three inequivalent ways in which the 2D Tensor Network can be contracted. In Chapter 3, we study how Schrödinger-picture contraction from the state edge of the network can be modified to improve the convergence of iterative contraction and reduce truncation errors in small systems. To this end, we explore physical decoherence in optimized bases and artificial generalized decoherence, finding that both alternatives show promise for new protocols that overcome the entanglement barrier. In Chapter 4, we explore Heisenberg-picture contraction from the observable edge, combining the concept of generalized decoherence with Pauli Weight truncation. By thoroughly characterizing the Pauli weight requirements to accurately describe the time evolution of local expectation values from initial product states, we conclude that truncating off-diagonal Pauli Weights is an effective scheme for simulating long-time dynamics—and we successfully implement it. We conclude with a spatial characterization of Pauli Weight spreading, bridging Tensor Network simulations and the field of operator hydrodynamics. Finally, in Chapter 5, we focus on the transverse contraction of the 2D Tensor Net-work using the light-cone algorithm, analyzing its variants in terms of truncation strategies and convergence across different models. This leads to a systematic characterization of the method based on the integrability of the underlying Hamiltonians and single-spin noise models.

•Sep 10, 2025•0 citations

Entanglement-enabled Criticality in One-dimensional Quantum Contact Process

Ya-Xin Xiang, Tianyi Yan, Weibin Li +1 more

The contact process is a paradigmatic example of nonequilibrium dynamics, with broad applications ranging from chemistry to sociology. Its quantum counterpart, the quantum contact process (QCP), extends the classical model to include coherent processes. Despite sustained interest, the nature of the transition in the one-dimensional (1D) QCP remains debatable. Here, combining Liouvillian spectral analysis, the tensor jump method, exact quantum jump Monte Carlo, and truncated Wigner simulations, we show that 1D QCP undergoes a continuous absorbing-state phase transition, with critical exponents distinct from the classical case. We further find Liouvillian gap closes well below the critical point, highlighting that spectral gap analysis alone cannot distinguish a phase transition from metastability in the QCP. Crucially, the 1D QCP is weakly entangled, yet even this weak entanglement is indispensable for capturing the correct critical behavior, whereas semiclassical methods artificially stabilize the active state and predict a spurious first-order transition. Our work establishes the quantum origin of the phase transition in the 1D QCP and underscores the essential role of entanglement in dissipative quantum many-body systems.

quant-pharXiv:2608.30681•Sep 1, 2026•0 citations

A renormalisation group study of one-dimensional contact processes

Jef Hooyberghs

In the theory of stochastic many particle systems one models phenomena of non-equilibrium statistical mechanics by means of a Markov process. The master equation, describing the time evolution of such a process, can formally be interpreted as a Schrodinger equation in imaginary time. In this approach, the (non-Hermitian) generator of the process plays the role of the Hamiltonian. This mathematical equivalence permits the successful application to stochastic systems of a number of exact, approximative or numerical methods from quantum mechanics.A particularly interesting type of stochastic systems is formed by the processes having a phase transition between an absorbing state and an active state. Examples of these systems can be found in physics, chemistry and even biology. The best known process of this kind is the contact process. In this thesis real-space renormalisation group techniques, which were originally developed for quantum mechanical systems, are applied to study stochastic models on a one-dimensional lattice, more precisely the critical behaviour and the universality of absorbing state phase transitions. First, the standard renormalisation group (SRG) is adapted to a stochastic context resulting in one of the few analytical techniques capable of producing approximations for systems that can not be solved exactly. The SRG is successfully applied to the contact process for which it characterises the stationary critical behaviour with a competitive accuracy. Next a generalisation of the contact process to a model with several absorbing states is studied by means of the density matrix renormalisation group (DMRG) algorithm. The results for the cases with one and two absorbing states are consistent with what was known from simulations done by an other author. For the models with more than two absorbing states new results were found, which are supported by analytical considerations in a particular limit. Finally the experience of the previous two projects is used in the investigation of the quenched random contact process. In this model the local interactions on a lattice site are time-invariant stochastic variables, independently drawn from a given distribution with a certain variance, which gives a measure for the disorder. Very little was known about the stationary behaviour of this model since its extremely slow dynamics makes simulations inefficient. The renormalisation techniques in this thesis, suffer less from this problem. First, for the case of small disorder the SRG indicates that the critical behaviour is changed by the presence of disorder and the cross-over exponent is consistent with the Harris criterion. For intermediate disorder a DMRG study reveals that the critical exponents are continuously varying with the amount of disorder. Finally, an SRG calculation, suitably adapted to strong disorder, shows that in this case the phase transition is characterised by a fixed point at infinite randomness. In this limit the renormalisation is expected to be exact. It is the first time exact critical exponents are found for a phase transition out of an absorbing state. Moreover, the exponents are the same as those previously found in a class of disordered quantum chains, suggesting a new kind of universality for strongly disordered systems.

•Jan 1, 2002•0 citations

Efficient construction of time-invariant process tensors for simulating high-dimensional non-Markovian open quantum systems

Émile Cochin, Jonathan Keeling, Brendon W. Lovett +1 more

Numerical methods for obtaining exact dynamics of non-Markovian open quantum systems are mostly limited to either small systems or to short-time evolution only. Here, we propose a new algorithm for computing process tensors--matrix product operator (MPO) representations that capture the environment influence--which achieves greatly enhanced computational scalings with system size, while maintaining linear scaling with simulation length. We build on recent developments in the field which allow for long-time evolutions through process tensors which have a time-translational invariance. These can be built for general Gaussian environments and generic coupling operators with the system using infinite time-evolving block decimation (iTEBD). We introduce a modified iTEBD algorithm using intermediate compression steps which bring down the computation time scaling with system size $d$ from $\mathcal{O}(d^8)$ to $\mathcal{O}(d^4)$, as well as significantly lowering the required memory. To illustrate the power of this method, we apply it to the problem of dispersive qubit readout in circuit QED, which was previously out-of-reach numerically. The full treatment of the measurement resonator, which requires a large system space, combined with the long simulation times precipitated by the separation of timescales between the measurement drive and the environment dissipation, is now possible. The algorithm we introduce not only allows for capturing non-Markovian dynamics in large open quantum systems, but also further extends all the existing capabilities of process tensors, for example in quantum optimal control, or in computation of multi-time correlations or of steady states, to more complex systems with tens of levels.

quant-pharXiv:2603.06840•Mar 10, 2026•8 citations

Hamiltonian truncation tensor networks for quantum field theories

Philipp Schmoll, Jan Naumann, Alexander Nietner +2 more

Understanding the equilibrium properties and out of equilibrium dynamics of quantum field theories are key aspects of fundamental problems in theoretical particle physics and cosmology. However, their classical simulation is highly challenging. In this work, we introduce a tensor network method for the classical simulation of continuous quantum field theories that is suitable for the study of low-energy eigenstates and out-of-equilibrium time evolution. The method is built on Hamiltonian truncation and tensor network techniques, bridging the gap between two successful approaches. One of the key developments is the exact construction of matrix product state representations of global projectors, crucial for the implementation of interacting theories. Despite featuring a relatively high computational effort, our method dramatically improves predictive precision compared to exact diagonalisation-based Hamiltonian truncation, allowing the study of so far unexplored parameter regimes and dynamical effects. We corroborate trust in the accuracy of the method by comparing it with exact theoretical results for ground state properties of the sine-Gordon model. We then proceed with discussing $(1+1)$-dimensional quantum electrodynamics, the massive Schwinger model, for which we accurately locate its critical point and study the growth and saturation of momentum-space entanglement in sudden quenches.

arXiv:2312.12506•Dec 19, 2023•16 citations
Abstract The simulation of out-of-equilibrium dissipative quantum many body systems is a problem of fundamental interest to a number of fields in physics, ranging from condensed matter to cosmology. For unitary systems, tensor network methods have proved successful and extending these to open systems is a natural avenue for study. In particular, an important question concerns the possibility of approximating the critical dynamics of non-equilibrium systems with tensor networks. Here, we investigate this by performing numerical simulations of a paradigmatic quantum non-equilibrium system with an absorbing state: the quantum contact process. We consider the application of matrix product states and the time-evolving block decimation algorithm to simulate the time-evolution of the quantum contact process at criticality. In the Lindblad formalism, we find that the Heisenberg picture can be used to improve the accuracy of simulations over the Schrödinger approach, which can be understood by considering the evolution of operator-space entanglement. Furthermore, we also consider a quantum trajectories approach, which we find can reproduce the expected universal behaviour of key observables for a significantly longer time than direct simulation of the average state. These improved results provide further evidence that the universality class of the quantum contact process is not directed percolation, which is the class of the classical contact process.
The contact process is a paradigmatic classical stochastic system displaying critical behavior even in one dimension. It features a nonequilibrium phase transition into an absorbing state that has been widely investigated and shown to belong to the directed percolation universality class. When the same process is considered in a quantum setting, much less is known. So far, mainly semiclassical studies have been conducted and the nature of the transition in low dimensions is still a matter of debate. Also, from a numerical point of view, from which the system may look fairly simple-especially in one dimension-results are lacking. In particular, the presence of the absorbing state poses a substantial challenge, which appears to affect the reliability of algorithms targeting directly the steady state. Here we perform real-time numerical simulations of the open dynamics of the quantum contact process and shed light on the existence and on the nature of an absorbing state phase transition in one dimension. We find evidence for the transition being continuous and provide first estimates for the critical exponents. Beyond the conceptual interest, the simplicity of the quantum contact process makes it an ideal benchmark problem for scrutinizing numerical methods for open quantum nonequilibrium systems.
[eng] Quantum many-body dynamics is a vast field of physics at the intersection of statistical mechanics, condensed matter, quantum information, and computational physics. Understanding the time evolution of observable correlations—such as those involved in material responses—is both a milestone for technological advancement and a corner-stone for generating fundamental knowledge. At the intersection of emergent collective behavior in many-body systems, quantum physics, and information theory lies the classical simulation of out-of-equilibrium phenomena. Without numerical tools, progress in disciplines that require heavy computations with high-dimensional vectors and matrices would be limited to purely analytical predictions and constrained by the available expertise and resources needed to build benchmarking experiments. The goal of this thesis is to advance the classical simulation of quantum many-body systems using Tensor Networks. This technique has proven fruitful for predicting equilibrium ground states and thermal properties of one-dimensional systems, yet it still faces challenges when applied to out-of-equilibrium scenarios. In brief, the dynamics of experimentally accessible expectation values can be represented as a 2D Tensor Network, which must be contracted using iterative methods such as Time-Evolving Block Decimation. However, the memory and computational time required for these calculations—which reflect the methods’ complexity—are known to grow exponentially with the simulated physical time in generic systems. This limitation is often referred to in the literature as the entanglement barrier. This manuscript tackles the problem through the three inequivalent ways in which the 2D Tensor Network can be contracted. In Chapter 3, we study how Schrödinger-picture contraction from the state edge of the network can be modified to improve the convergence of iterative contraction and reduce truncation errors in small systems. To this end, we explore physical decoherence in optimized bases and artificial generalized decoherence, finding that both alternatives show promise for new protocols that overcome the entanglement barrier. In Chapter 4, we explore Heisenberg-picture contraction from the observable edge, combining the concept of generalized decoherence with Pauli Weight truncation. By thoroughly characterizing the Pauli weight requirements to accurately describe the time evolution of local expectation values from initial product states, we conclude that truncating off-diagonal Pauli Weights is an effective scheme for simulating long-time dynamics—and we successfully implement it. We conclude with a spatial characterization of Pauli Weight spreading, bridging Tensor Network simulations and the field of operator hydrodynamics. Finally, in Chapter 5, we focus on the transverse contraction of the 2D Tensor Net-work using the light-cone algorithm, analyzing its variants in terms of truncation strategies and convergence across different models. This leads to a systematic characterization of the method based on the integrability of the underlying Hamiltonians and single-spin noise models.
The contact process is a paradigmatic example of nonequilibrium dynamics, with broad applications ranging from chemistry to sociology. Its quantum counterpart, the quantum contact process (QCP), extends the classical model to include coherent processes. Despite sustained interest, the nature of the transition in the one-dimensional (1D) QCP remains debatable. Here, combining Liouvillian spectral analysis, the tensor jump method, exact quantum jump Monte Carlo, and truncated Wigner simulations, we show that 1D QCP undergoes a continuous absorbing-state phase transition, with critical exponents distinct from the classical case. We further find Liouvillian gap closes well below the critical point, highlighting that spectral gap analysis alone cannot distinguish a phase transition from metastability in the QCP. Crucially, the 1D QCP is weakly entangled, yet even this weak entanglement is indispensable for capturing the correct critical behavior, whereas semiclassical methods artificially stabilize the active state and predict a spurious first-order transition. Our work establishes the quantum origin of the phase transition in the 1D QCP and underscores the essential role of entanglement in dissipative quantum many-body systems.
In the theory of stochastic many particle systems one models phenomena of non-equilibrium statistical mechanics by means of a Markov process. The master equation, describing the time evolution of such a process, can formally be interpreted as a Schrodinger equation in imaginary time. In this approach, the (non-Hermitian) generator of the process plays the role of the Hamiltonian. This mathematical equivalence permits the successful application to stochastic systems of a number of exact, approximative or numerical methods from quantum mechanics.A particularly interesting type of stochastic systems is formed by the processes having a phase transition between an absorbing state and an active state. Examples of these systems can be found in physics, chemistry and even biology. The best known process of this kind is the contact process. In this thesis real-space renormalisation group techniques, which were originally developed for quantum mechanical systems, are applied to study stochastic models on a one-dimensional lattice, more precisely the critical behaviour and the universality of absorbing state phase transitions. First, the standard renormalisation group (SRG) is adapted to a stochastic context resulting in one of the few analytical techniques capable of producing approximations for systems that can not be solved exactly. The SRG is successfully applied to the contact process for which it characterises the stationary critical behaviour with a competitive accuracy. Next a generalisation of the contact process to a model with several absorbing states is studied by means of the density matrix renormalisation group (DMRG) algorithm. The results for the cases with one and two absorbing states are consistent with what was known from simulations done by an other author. For the models with more than two absorbing states new results were found, which are supported by analytical considerations in a particular limit. Finally the experience of the previous two projects is used in the investigation of the quenched random contact process. In this model the local interactions on a lattice site are time-invariant stochastic variables, independently drawn from a given distribution with a certain variance, which gives a measure for the disorder. Very little was known about the stationary behaviour of this model since its extremely slow dynamics makes simulations inefficient. The renormalisation techniques in this thesis, suffer less from this problem. First, for the case of small disorder the SRG indicates that the critical behaviour is changed by the presence of disorder and the cross-over exponent is consistent with the Harris criterion. For intermediate disorder a DMRG study reveals that the critical exponents are continuously varying with the amount of disorder. Finally, an SRG calculation, suitably adapted to strong disorder, shows that in this case the phase transition is characterised by a fixed point at infinite randomness. In this limit the renormalisation is expected to be exact. It is the first time exact critical exponents are found for a phase transition out of an absorbing state. Moreover, the exponents are the same as those previously found in a class of disordered quantum chains, suggesting a new kind of universality for strongly disordered systems.
Numerical methods for obtaining exact dynamics of non-Markovian open quantum systems are mostly limited to either small systems or to short-time evolution only. Here, we propose a new algorithm for computing process tensors--matrix product operator (MPO) representations that capture the environment influence--which achieves greatly enhanced computational scalings with system size, while maintaining linear scaling with simulation length. We build on recent developments in the field which allow for long-time evolutions through process tensors which have a time-translational invariance. These can be built for general Gaussian environments and generic coupling operators with the system using infinite time-evolving block decimation (iTEBD). We introduce a modified iTEBD algorithm using intermediate compression steps which bring down the computation time scaling with system size ddd from O(d8)\mathcal{O}(d^8)O(d8) to O(d4)\mathcal{O}(d^4)O(d4), as well as significantly lowering the required memory. To illustrate the power of this method, we apply it to the problem of dispersive qubit readout in circuit QED, which was previously out-of-reach numerically. The full treatment of the measurement resonator, which requires a large system space, combined with the long simulation times precipitated by the separation of timescales between the measurement drive and the environment dissipation, is now possible. The algorithm we introduce not only allows for capturing non-Markovian dynamics in large open quantum systems, but also further extends all the existing capabilities of process tensors, for example in quantum optimal control, or in computation of multi-time correlations or of steady states, to more complex systems with tens of levels.
Understanding the equilibrium properties and out of equilibrium dynamics of quantum field theories are key aspects of fundamental problems in theoretical particle physics and cosmology. However, their classical simulation is highly challenging. In this work, we introduce a tensor network method for the classical simulation of continuous quantum field theories that is suitable for the study of low-energy eigenstates and out-of-equilibrium time evolution. The method is built on Hamiltonian truncation and tensor network techniques, bridging the gap between two successful approaches. One of the key developments is the exact construction of matrix product state representations of global projectors, crucial for the implementation of interacting theories. Despite featuring a relatively high computational effort, our method dramatically improves predictive precision compared to exact diagonalisation-based Hamiltonian truncation, allowing the study of so far unexplored parameter regimes and dynamical effects. We corroborate trust in the accuracy of the method by comparing it with exact theoretical results for ground state properties of the sine-Gordon model. We then proceed with discussing (1+1)(1+1)(1+1)-dimensional quantum electrodynamics, the massive Schwinger model, for which we accurately locate its critical point and study the growth and saturation of momentum-space entanglement in sudden quenches.