Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1905.10921 · IEEE Transactions on Information Theory

On the Commitment Capacity of Unfair Noisy Channels

Claude Crépeau, Rafael Dowsley, Anderson C. A. Nascimento

Published Jan 17, 2020• 15 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Noisy channels are a valuable resource from a cryptographic point of view. They can be used for exchanging secret-keys as well as realizing other cryptographic primitives such as commitment and oblivious transfer. To be really useful, noisy channels have to be considered in the scenario where a cheating party has some degree of control over the channel characteristics. Damgård et al. (EUROCRYPT 1999) proposed a more realistic model where such level of control is permitted to an adversary, the so called unfair noisy channels, and proved that they can be used to obtain commitment and oblivious transfer protocols. Given that noisy channels are a precious resource for cryptographic purposes, one important question is determining the optimal rate in which they can be used. The commitment capacity has already been determined for the cases of discrete memoryless channels and Gaussian channels. In this work we address the problem of determining the commitment capacity of unfair noisy channels. We compute a single-letter characterization of the commitment capacity of unfair noisy channels. In the case where an adversary has no control over the channel (the fair case) our capacity reduces to the well-known capacity of a discrete memoryless binary symmetric channel.

DOI
10.1109/tit.2020.2967048

Related papers

Commitment over Unreliable Noisy Channels: When Awareness Meets Control

Amitalok J. Budkuley, Pranav Joshi, Manideep Mamindlapally +1 more

We study commitments over unreliable compound noisy channels, where parties may know the compound channel state but lack control over that state. Commitment is one of the common building blocks for many cryptographic protocols which realize multi-party computational functionalities in a secure manner. A noisy channel, among others, is widely acknowledged as a promising resource for realizing information-theoretically secure cryptographic primitives, including commitment. However, unreliable noisy channels with poorly or imprecisely characterized statistical behaviour can severely degrade commitment guarantees. Our focus is unreliability on account of a compound channel state, albeit under public awareness of that state.Building on prior work, we seek to characterize the optimal commitment throughput or commitment capacity of compound binary symmetric channels when parties may be state-aware. State-awareness implies a passive and publicly known capability of precise channel knowledge (whether said party is honest or dishonest); however, state-awareness precludes any active and private channel state control as in, for instance, the classic unfair noisy channels (UNCs). We present new results on the commitment capacity under all possible configurations where individual parties may (or may not) be state-aware. An important takeaway of our work is the following: even a fairly weak capability of state-awareness (albeit when asymmetric and only at the committer-side) can degrade the commitment throughput to the same extent as under strongly capable parties that can privately control the compound state.

IEEE Information Theory Workshop (ITW)•Nov 1, 2022•2 citations

String commitment from unstructured noise

Jiawei Wu, Masahito Hayashi, Marco Tomamichel

Noisy channels are a foundational resource for constructing cryptographic primitives such as string commitment and oblivious transfer. The noisy channel model has been extended to unfair noisy channels, where adversaries can influence the parameters of a memoryless channel. In this work, we introduce the unstructured noisy channel model as a generalization of the unfair noisy channel model to allow the adversary to manipulate the channel arbitrarily subject to certain entropic constraints. We present a string commitment protocol with established security and derive its achievable commitment rate, demonstrating the feasibility of commitment against this stronger class of adversaries. Furthermore, we show that the entropic constraints in the unstructured noisy channel model can be derived from physical assumptions such as noisy quantum storage. Our work thus connects two distinct approaches to commitment, i.e., the noisy channel and physical limitations.

arXiv:2501.00281•Dec 31, 2024•2 citations

Oblivious Transfer from Weak Noisy Channels.

Jürg Wullschleger

Abstract. Various results show that oblivious transfer can be implemented using the assumption of noisy channels. Unfortunately, this assumption is not as weak as one might think, because in a cryptographic setting, these noisy channels must satisfy very strong security requirements. Unfair noisy channels, introduced by Damg˚ard, Kilian and Salvail [Eurocrypt ’99], reduce these limitations: They give the adversary an unfair advantage over the honest player, and therefore weaken the security requirements on the noisy channel. However, this model still has many shortcomings: For example, the adversary’s advantage is only allowed to have a very special form, and no error is allowed in the implementation. In this paper we generalize the idea of unfair noisy channels. We introduce two new models of cryptographic noisy channels that we call the weak erasure channel and the weak binary symmetric channel, and show how they can be used to implement oblivious transfer. Our models are more general and use much weaker assumptions than unfair noisy channels, which makes implementation a more realistic prospect. For example, these are the first models that allows the parameters to come from experimental evidence. 1

•Jan 1, 2008•0 citations

On the (Im)possibility of Commitment over Gaussian Unfair Noisy Channels

Amitalok J. Budkuley, Pranav Joshi, Manideep Mamindlapally +1 more

Commitment is a key primitive which resides at the heart of several cryptographic protocols. Noisy channels can help realize information-theoretically secure commitment schemes; however, their imprecise statistical characterization can severely impair such schemes, especially their security guarantees. Keeping our focus on channel ‘unreliability’ in this work, we study commitment over unreliable continuous alphabet channels called the Gaussian unfair noisy channels or Gaussian UNCs.We present the first results on the optimal throughput or commitment capacity of Gaussian UNCs. It is known that ‘classical’ Gaussian channels have infinite commitment capacity, even under finite transmit power constraints. For ‘unreliable’ Gaussian UNCs, we prove the surprising result that their commitment capacity may be finite, and in some cases, zero. When commitment is possible, we present achievable rate lower bounds by constructing positive-throughput protocols under given input power constraint, and (two-sided) channel elasticity at committer Alice and receiver Bob. Our achievability results establish an interesting fact – Gaussian UNCs with zero elasticity have infinite commitment capacity. This result brings a completely new perspective as to why classic Gaussian channels, i.e., Gaussian UNCs with zero elasticity, have infinite capacity. Finally, we precisely characterize the positive commitment capacity threshold for a Gaussian UNC in terms of the channel elasticity, when the transmit power tends to infinity.

arXiv:2305.07118•IEEE International Symposium on Information Theory (ISIT)•Jun 25, 2023•1 citation

Unfair Noisy Channels and Oblivious Transfer

Ivan Damgård, Serge Fehr, Kirill Morozov +1 more

In a paper from EuroCrypt'99, Damgård, Kilian and Salvail show various positive and negative results on constructing Bit Commitment (BC) and Oblivious Transfer (OT) from Unfair Noisy Channels (UNC), i.e., binary symmetric channels where the error rate is only known to be in a certain interval [gamma ..delta] and can be chosen adversarily. They also introduce a related primitive called PassiveUNC. We prove in this paper that any OT protocol that can be constructed based on a PassiveUNC and is secure against a passive adversary can be transformed using a generic "compiler'' into an OT protocol based on a UNC which is secure against an active adversary. Apart from making positive results easier to prove in general, this also allows correcting a problem in the EuroCrypt'99 paper: There, a positive result was claimed on constructing from UNC an OT that is secure against active cheating. We point out that the proof sketch given for this was incomplete, and we show that a correct proof of a much stronger result follows from our general compilation result and a new technique for transforming between weaker versions of OT with different parameters.

BRICS Report Series•Nov 6, 2003•1 citation

On Reverse Elastic Channels and the Asymmetry of Commitment Capacity Under Channel Elasticity

Amitalok J. Budkuley, Pranav Joshi, Manideep Mamindlapally +1 more

Commitment is an important cryptographic primitive. It is well known that noisy channels are a promising resource to realize commitment in aninformation-theoreticallysecure manner. However, oftentimes, channel behaviour may be poorly characterized thereby limiting the commitment throughput and/or degrading the security guarantees; a particularly problematic situation arises when a dishonest party, unbeknown to the honest one, maliciously alters the channel characteristics. Reverse elastic channels (RECs) are an interesting class of suchunreliablechannels where only a dishonestcommitter, say Alice, can maliciously alter the channel. RECs have attracted recent interest in the study of several cryptographic primitives. Our principal contribution is the REC commitment capacity characterization; this proves a recent related conjecture. A key result is our tight converse which analyses a specific cheating strategy by Alice. Along with elastic channels (ECs), where only a dishonestreceiverBob can alter the channel, RECs are also closely related to the classic unfair noisy channels (UNCs). In stark contrast to UNCs, both RECs and ECs always exhibit positive commitment throughput for all non-trivial channel parameters. Interestingly, our results show that channels with exclusiveone-sided elasticityfor dishonest parties, exhibit a fundamentalasymmetrywhere, a committer with one-sided elasticity has a significantly more debilitating effect on the commitment throughput than a similarly capable receiver.

arXiv:2111.08477•IEEE Journal on Selected Areas in Communications•Jan 26, 2022•9 citations
Noisy channels are a valuable resource from a cryptographic point of view. They can be used for exchanging secret-keys as well as realizing other cryptographic primitives such as commitment and oblivious transfer. To be really useful, noisy channels have to be considered in the scenario where a cheating party has some degree of control over the channel characteristics. Damgård et al. (EUROCRYPT 1999) proposed a more realistic model where such level of control is permitted to an adversary, the so called unfair noisy channels, and proved that they can be used to obtain commitment and oblivious transfer protocols. Given that noisy channels are a precious resource for cryptographic purposes, one important question is determining the optimal rate in which they can be used. The commitment capacity has already been determined for the cases of discrete memoryless channels and Gaussian channels. In this work we address the problem of determining the commitment capacity of unfair noisy channels. We compute a single-letter characterization of the commitment capacity of unfair noisy channels. In the case where an adversary has no control over the channel (the fair case) our capacity reduces to the well-known capacity of a discrete memoryless binary symmetric channel.
We study commitments over unreliable compound noisy channels, where parties may know the compound channel state but lack control over that state. Commitment is one of the common building blocks for many cryptographic protocols which realize multi-party computational functionalities in a secure manner. A noisy channel, among others, is widely acknowledged as a promising resource for realizing information-theoretically secure cryptographic primitives, including commitment. However, unreliable noisy channels with poorly or imprecisely characterized statistical behaviour can severely degrade commitment guarantees. Our focus is unreliability on account of a compound channel state, albeit under public awareness of that state.Building on prior work, we seek to characterize the optimal commitment throughput or commitment capacity of compound binary symmetric channels when parties may be state-aware. State-awareness implies a passive and publicly known capability of precise channel knowledge (whether said party is honest or dishonest); however, state-awareness precludes any active and private channel state control as in, for instance, the classic unfair noisy channels (UNCs). We present new results on the commitment capacity under all possible configurations where individual parties may (or may not) be state-aware. An important takeaway of our work is the following: even a fairly weak capability of state-awareness (albeit when asymmetric and only at the committer-side) can degrade the commitment throughput to the same extent as under strongly capable parties that can privately control the compound state.
Noisy channels are a foundational resource for constructing cryptographic primitives such as string commitment and oblivious transfer. The noisy channel model has been extended to unfair noisy channels, where adversaries can influence the parameters of a memoryless channel. In this work, we introduce the unstructured noisy channel model as a generalization of the unfair noisy channel model to allow the adversary to manipulate the channel arbitrarily subject to certain entropic constraints. We present a string commitment protocol with established security and derive its achievable commitment rate, demonstrating the feasibility of commitment against this stronger class of adversaries. Furthermore, we show that the entropic constraints in the unstructured noisy channel model can be derived from physical assumptions such as noisy quantum storage. Our work thus connects two distinct approaches to commitment, i.e., the noisy channel and physical limitations.
Abstract. Various results show that oblivious transfer can be implemented using the assumption of noisy channels. Unfortunately, this assumption is not as weak as one might think, because in a cryptographic setting, these noisy channels must satisfy very strong security requirements. Unfair noisy channels, introduced by Damg˚ard, Kilian and Salvail [Eurocrypt ’99], reduce these limitations: They give the adversary an unfair advantage over the honest player, and therefore weaken the security requirements on the noisy channel. However, this model still has many shortcomings: For example, the adversary’s advantage is only allowed to have a very special form, and no error is allowed in the implementation. In this paper we generalize the idea of unfair noisy channels. We introduce two new models of cryptographic noisy channels that we call the weak erasure channel and the weak binary symmetric channel, and show how they can be used to implement oblivious transfer. Our models are more general and use much weaker assumptions than unfair noisy channels, which makes implementation a more realistic prospect. For example, these are the first models that allows the parameters to come from experimental evidence. 1
Commitment is a key primitive which resides at the heart of several cryptographic protocols. Noisy channels can help realize information-theoretically secure commitment schemes; however, their imprecise statistical characterization can severely impair such schemes, especially their security guarantees. Keeping our focus on channel ‘unreliability’ in this work, we study commitment over unreliable continuous alphabet channels called the Gaussian unfair noisy channels or Gaussian UNCs.We present the first results on the optimal throughput or commitment capacity of Gaussian UNCs. It is known that ‘classical’ Gaussian channels have infinite commitment capacity, even under finite transmit power constraints. For ‘unreliable’ Gaussian UNCs, we prove the surprising result that their commitment capacity may be finite, and in some cases, zero. When commitment is possible, we present achievable rate lower bounds by constructing positive-throughput protocols under given input power constraint, and (two-sided) channel elasticity at committer Alice and receiver Bob. Our achievability results establish an interesting fact – Gaussian UNCs with zero elasticity have infinite commitment capacity. This result brings a completely new perspective as to why classic Gaussian channels, i.e., Gaussian UNCs with zero elasticity, have infinite capacity. Finally, we precisely characterize the positive commitment capacity threshold for a Gaussian UNC in terms of the channel elasticity, when the transmit power tends to infinity.
In a paper from EuroCrypt'99, Damgård, Kilian and Salvail show various positive and negative results on constructing Bit Commitment (BC) and Oblivious Transfer (OT) from Unfair Noisy Channels (UNC), i.e., binary symmetric channels where the error rate is only known to be in a certain interval [gamma ..delta] and can be chosen adversarily. They also introduce a related primitive called PassiveUNC. We prove in this paper that any OT protocol that can be constructed based on a PassiveUNC and is secure against a passive adversary can be transformed using a generic "compiler'' into an OT protocol based on a UNC which is secure against an active adversary. Apart from making positive results easier to prove in general, this also allows correcting a problem in the EuroCrypt'99 paper: There, a positive result was claimed on constructing from UNC an OT that is secure against active cheating. We point out that the proof sketch given for this was incomplete, and we show that a correct proof of a much stronger result follows from our general compilation result and a new technique for transforming between weaker versions of OT with different parameters.
Commitment is an important cryptographic primitive. It is well known that noisy channels are a promising resource to realize commitment in aninformation-theoreticallysecure manner. However, oftentimes, channel behaviour may be poorly characterized thereby limiting the commitment throughput and/or degrading the security guarantees; a particularly problematic situation arises when a dishonest party, unbeknown to the honest one, maliciously alters the channel characteristics. Reverse elastic channels (RECs) are an interesting class of suchunreliablechannels where only a dishonestcommitter, say Alice, can maliciously alter the channel. RECs have attracted recent interest in the study of several cryptographic primitives. Our principal contribution is the REC commitment capacity characterization; this proves a recent related conjecture. A key result is our tight converse which analyses a specific cheating strategy by Alice. Along with elastic channels (ECs), where only a dishonestreceiverBob can alter the channel, RECs are also closely related to the classic unfair noisy channels (UNCs). In stark contrast to UNCs, both RECs and ECs always exhibit positive commitment throughput for all non-trivial channel parameters. Interestingly, our results show that channels with exclusiveone-sided elasticityfor dishonest parties, exhibit a fundamentalasymmetrywhere, a committer with one-sided elasticity has a significantly more debilitating effect on the commitment throughput than a similarly capable receiver.