Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1905.03614 · Physical Review Research

Measurement incompatibility and steering are necessary and sufficient for operational contextuality

Armin Tavakoli, Roope Uola

Published Jan 6, 2020• 74 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Two fundamental features of quantum theory are that measurements cannot be performed jointly and that entangled states can be steered through action-at-a-distance. Here it is shown that both these phenomena are in one-to-one correspondence with the failure of noncontextual models to explain the predictions of quantum theory.
DOI
10.1103/physrevresearch.2.013011

Related papers

Contextuality without Incompatibility

John H. Selby, David Schmid, Elie Wolfe +3 more

The existence of incompatible measurements is often believed to be a feature of quantum theory which signals its inconsistency with any classical worldview. To prove the failure of classicality in the sense of Kochen-Specker noncontextuality, one does indeed require sets of incompatible measurements. However, a more broadly applicable notion of classicality is the existence of a generalized-noncontextual ontological model. In particular, this notion can imply constraints on the representation of outcomes even within a single nonprojective measurement. We leverage this fact to demonstrate that measurement incompatibility is neither necessary nor sufficient for proofs of the failure of generalized noncontextuality. Furthermore, we show that every proof of the failure of generalized noncontextuality in a quantum prepare-measure scenario can be converted into a proof of the failure of generalized noncontextuality in a corresponding scenario with no incompatible measurements.

arXiv:2106.09045•Physical Review Letters•Jun 6, 2023•48 citations

Simultaneous measurement of two quantum observables: Compatibility, broadcasting, and in-between

Teiko Heinosaari

One of the central features of quantum theory is that there are pairs of quantum observables that cannot be measured simultaneously. This incompatibility of quantum observables is a necessary ingredient in several quantum phenomena, such as measurement uncertainty relations, violation of Bell inequalities, and steering. Two quantum observables that admit a simultaneous measurement are, in this respect, classical. A finer classification of classicality can be made by formulating four symmetric relations on the set of observables that are stronger than compatibility; they are broadcastability, one-side broadcastability, mutual nondisturbance, and nondisturbance. It is proven that the five relations form a hierarchy and their differences in terms of the required devices needed in a simultaneous measurement are explained. All four relations that are stronger than compatibility are completely characterized in the case of qubit observables.

arXiv:1604.00775•Physical Review A•Apr 25, 2016•24 citations

Complete Resource Theory of Quantum Incompatibility as Quantum Programmability

Francesco Buscemi, Eric Chitambar, Wenbin Zhou

Measurement incompatibility describes two or more quantum measurements whose expected joint outcome on a given system cannot be defined. This purely nonclassical phenomenon provides a necessary ingredient in many quantum information tasks such as violating a Bell inequality or nonlocally steering part of an entangled state. In this Letter, we characterize incompatibility in terms of programmable measurement devices and the general notion of quantum programmability. This refers to the temporal freedom a user has in issuing programs to a quantum device. For devices with a classical control and classical output, measurement incompatibility emerges as the essential quantum resource embodied in their functioning. Based on the processing of programmable measurement devices, we construct a quantum resource theory of incompatibility. A complete set of convertibility conditions for programmable devices is derived based on quantum state discrimination with postmeasurement information.

arXiv:1908.11274•Physical Review Letters•Mar 24, 2020•89 citations

The Missing Piece of the Quantum Puzzle

Ghenadie N. Mardari

Modern theoretical physics is built around two myths. The first one is that quantum observables are inseparable from the act of measurement. In some cases, this “observer effect” is supposed to be so strong that some qualities are mutually exclusive. Though, what is the difference between quantum contextuality and classical contextuality? This is where the second myth comes in. Objectively incompatible properties are treated as if they do not exist in classical physics. Instead, only two types of observables are considered: the ones that can occur at the same time as part of a single system, and the ones that are produced by measurement artifacts. As a result, we have a gap between two incomplete theories: a “quantum” theory without objective processes and a “classical” theory without mutually exclusive events. Together, they create the false impression that quantum entanglement is non-local. This is illustrated below with a clockwork mechanism for predetermined sequential properties. The system produces super-quantum Bell violations, as well as the features of quantum monogamy, in ideal experiments without loopholes. A separate illustration, with a classical fluid flow-splitter, is used to explain quantum-like Bell violations with independent and random measurement settings at remote stations. Objective contextuality is the missing piece of the quantum puzzle.

•Nov 12, 2024•0 citations

Can There be Given Any Meaning to Contextuality Without Incompatibility?

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

Abstract Our aim is to compare the fundamental notions of quantum physics - contextuality vs. incompatibility. One has to distinguish two different notions of contextuality,Bohr-contextualityandBell-contextuality. The latter is defined operationally via violation of noncontextuality (Bell type) inequalities. This sort of contextuality will be compared with incompatibility. It is easy to show that, for quantum observables, there isno contextuality without incompatibility.The natural question arises: What is contextuality without incompatibility? (What is “dry-residue”?) Generally this is the very complex question. We concentrated on contextuality for four quantum observables. We shown that, for “natural quantum observables” ,contextuality is reduced to incompatibility.But, generally contextuality without incompatibility may have some physical content. We found a mathematical constraint extracting the contextuality component from incompatibility. However, the physical meaning of this constraint is not clear. In Appendix 1, we briefly discuss another sort of contextuality based on Bohr’s contextuality-incompatibility principle. Bohr-contextuality plays the crucial role in quantum foundations. Incompatibility is, in fact, a consequence of Bohr-contextuality. Finally, we remark that outside of physics, e.g., in cognitive psychology and decision making Bell-contextuality distilled of incompatibility can play the important role.

arXiv:2005.05124•International Journal of Theoretical Physics•Dec 2, 2020•16 citations

Quantum Measurements Are Noncontextual

Robert B. Griffiths

Quantum measurements are noncontextual, with outcomes independent of which other commuting observables are measured at the same time, when consistently analyzed using principles of Hilbert space quantum mechanics rather than classical hidden variables.

arXiv:1302.5052•Feb 20, 2013•3 citations
The existence of incompatible measurements is often believed to be a feature of quantum theory which signals its inconsistency with any classical worldview. To prove the failure of classicality in the sense of Kochen-Specker noncontextuality, one does indeed require sets of incompatible measurements. However, a more broadly applicable notion of classicality is the existence of a generalized-noncontextual ontological model. In particular, this notion can imply constraints on the representation of outcomes even within a single nonprojective measurement. We leverage this fact to demonstrate that measurement incompatibility is neither necessary nor sufficient for proofs of the failure of generalized noncontextuality. Furthermore, we show that every proof of the failure of generalized noncontextuality in a quantum prepare-measure scenario can be converted into a proof of the failure of generalized noncontextuality in a corresponding scenario with no incompatible measurements.
One of the central features of quantum theory is that there are pairs of quantum observables that cannot be measured simultaneously. This incompatibility of quantum observables is a necessary ingredient in several quantum phenomena, such as measurement uncertainty relations, violation of Bell inequalities, and steering. Two quantum observables that admit a simultaneous measurement are, in this respect, classical. A finer classification of classicality can be made by formulating four symmetric relations on the set of observables that are stronger than compatibility; they are broadcastability, one-side broadcastability, mutual nondisturbance, and nondisturbance. It is proven that the five relations form a hierarchy and their differences in terms of the required devices needed in a simultaneous measurement are explained. All four relations that are stronger than compatibility are completely characterized in the case of qubit observables.
Measurement incompatibility describes two or more quantum measurements whose expected joint outcome on a given system cannot be defined. This purely nonclassical phenomenon provides a necessary ingredient in many quantum information tasks such as violating a Bell inequality or nonlocally steering part of an entangled state. In this Letter, we characterize incompatibility in terms of programmable measurement devices and the general notion of quantum programmability. This refers to the temporal freedom a user has in issuing programs to a quantum device. For devices with a classical control and classical output, measurement incompatibility emerges as the essential quantum resource embodied in their functioning. Based on the processing of programmable measurement devices, we construct a quantum resource theory of incompatibility. A complete set of convertibility conditions for programmable devices is derived based on quantum state discrimination with postmeasurement information.
Modern theoretical physics is built around two myths. The first one is that quantum observables are inseparable from the act of measurement. In some cases, this “observer effect” is supposed to be so strong that some qualities are mutually exclusive. Though, what is the difference between quantum contextuality and classical contextuality? This is where the second myth comes in. Objectively incompatible properties are treated as if they do not exist in classical physics. Instead, only two types of observables are considered: the ones that can occur at the same time as part of a single system, and the ones that are produced by measurement artifacts. As a result, we have a gap between two incomplete theories: a “quantum” theory without objective processes and a “classical” theory without mutually exclusive events. Together, they create the false impression that quantum entanglement is non-local. This is illustrated below with a clockwork mechanism for predetermined sequential properties. The system produces super-quantum Bell violations, as well as the features of quantum monogamy, in ideal experiments without loopholes. A separate illustration, with a classical fluid flow-splitter, is used to explain quantum-like Bell violations with independent and random measurement settings at remote stations. Objective contextuality is the missing piece of the quantum puzzle.
Abstract Our aim is to compare the fundamental notions of quantum physics - contextuality vs. incompatibility. One has to distinguish two different notions of contextuality,Bohr-contextualityandBell-contextuality. The latter is defined operationally via violation of noncontextuality (Bell type) inequalities. This sort of contextuality will be compared with incompatibility. It is easy to show that, for quantum observables, there isno contextuality without incompatibility.The natural question arises: What is contextuality without incompatibility? (What is “dry-residue”?) Generally this is the very complex question. We concentrated on contextuality for four quantum observables. We shown that, for “natural quantum observables” ,contextuality is reduced to incompatibility.But, generally contextuality without incompatibility may have some physical content. We found a mathematical constraint extracting the contextuality component from incompatibility. However, the physical meaning of this constraint is not clear. In Appendix 1, we briefly discuss another sort of contextuality based on Bohr’s contextuality-incompatibility principle. Bohr-contextuality plays the crucial role in quantum foundations. Incompatibility is, in fact, a consequence of Bohr-contextuality. Finally, we remark that outside of physics, e.g., in cognitive psychology and decision making Bell-contextuality distilled of incompatibility can play the important role.