Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1905.02110 · Quantum

On the Entanglement Cost of One-Shot Compression

Shima Bab Hadiashar, Ashwin Nayak

Published Jun 25, 2020• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We revisit the task of visible compression of an ensemble of quantum states with entanglement assistance in the one-shot setting. The protocols achieving the best compression use many more qubits of shared entanglement than the number of qubits in the states in the ensemble. Other compression protocols, with potentially larger communication cost, have entanglement cost bounded by the number of qubits in the given states. This motivates the question as to whether entanglement is truly necessary for compression, and if so, how much of it is needed. Motivated by questions in communication complexity, we lift certain restrictions that are placed on compression protocols in tasks such as state-splitting and channel simulation. We show that an ensemble of the form designed by Jain, Radhakrishnan, and Sen (ICALP'03) saturates the known bounds on the sum of communication and entanglement costs, even with the relaxed compression protocols we study. The ensemble and the associated one-way communication protocol have several remarkable properties. The ensemble is incompressible by more than a constant number of qubits without shared entanglement, even when constant error is allowed. Moreover, in the presence of shared entanglement, the communication cost of compression can be arbitrarily smaller than the entanglement cost. The quantum information cost of the protocol can thus be arbitrarily smaller than the cost of compression without shared entanglement. The ensemble can also be used to show the impossibility of reducing, via compression, the shared entanglement used in two-party protocols for computing Boolean functions.

DOI
10.22331/q-2020-06-25-286

Related papers

Quantum Compression and Quantum Learning via Information Theory

Shima Bab Hadiashar

This thesis consists of two parts: quantum compression and quantum learning theory. A common theme between these problems is that we study them through the lens of information theory. \n \nWe first study the task of visible compression of an ensemble of quantum states with entanglement assistance in the one-shot setting. The protocols achieving the best compression use many more qubits of shared entanglement than the number of qubits in the states in the ensemble. Other compression protocols, with potentially higher communication cost, have entanglement cost bounded by the number of qubits in the given states. This motivates the question as to whether entanglement is truly necessary for compression, and if so, how much of it is needed. We show that an ensemble given by Jain, Radhakrishnan, and Sen (ICALP'03) cannot be compressed by more than a constant number of qubits without shared entanglement, while in the presence of shared entanglement, the communication cost of compression can be arbitrarily smaller than the entanglement cost. \n \nNext, we study the task of quantum state redistribution, the most general version of compression of quantum states. We design a protocol for this task with communication cost in terms of a measure of distance from quantum Markov chains. More precisely, the distance is defined in terms of quantum max-relative entropy and quantum hypothesis testing entropy. Our result is the first to connect quantum state redistribution and Markov chains and gives an operational interpretation for a possible one-shot analogue of quantum conditional mutual information. The communication cost of our protocol is lower than all previously known ones and asymptotically achieves the well-known rate of quantum conditional mutual information. \n \nIn the last part, we focus on quantum algorithms for learning Boolean functions using quantum examples. We consider two commonly studied models of learning, namely, quantum PAC learning and quantum agnostic learning. We reproduce the optimal lower bounds by Arunachalam and de Wolf (JMLR’18) for the sample complexity of either of these models using information theory and spectral analysis. Our proofs are simpler than the previous ones and the techniques can be possibly extended to similar scenarios.

•Dec 21, 2020•1 citation

Incompressibility of Classical Distributions

Anurag Anshu, Debbie Leung, Dave Touchette

Inblindcompression of quantum states, a sender Alice is given a specimen of a quantum state$\rho $drawn from a known ensemble (but without knowing what$\rho $is), and she transmits sufficient quantum data to a receiver Bob so that he can decode a near perfect specimen of$\rho $. For many such states drawn iid from the ensemble, the asymptotically achievable rate is the number of qubits required to be transmitted per state. The Holevo information is a lower bound for the achievable rate, and is attained for pure state ensembles, or in the related scenario of entanglement-assistedvisiblecompression of mixed states wherein Alice knows what state is drawn. In this paper, we prove a general and robust lower bound on the achievable rate for ensembles of classical states, which holds even in the least demanding setting when Alice and Bob share free entanglement and a constant per-copy error is allowed. We apply the bound to aspecificensemble of only two states and prove a near-maximal separation (saturating the dimension bound in leading order) between the best achievable rate and the Holevo information for constant error. This also implies that the ensemble is incompressible – compression does not reduce the communication cost by much. Since the states areclassical, the observed incompressibility is not fundamentally quantum mechanical. We lower bound the difference between the achievable rate and the Holevo information in terms of quantitative limitations to clone the specimen or to distinguish the two classical states.

arXiv:1911.09126•IEEE Transactions on Information Theory•Nov 23, 2021•8 citations

On communication over an entanglement-assisted quantum channel

A. Nayak, Julia Salzman

Shared entanglement is a resource available to parties communicating over a quantum channel, much akin to public coins in classical communication protocols: the two parties may be given some number of quantum bits jointly prepared in a fixed superposition, prior to communicating with each other. The quantum channel is then said to be "entanglement-assisted." Shared randomness does not help in the transmission of information from one party to another. Moreover, it does not significantly reduce the classical complexity of computing functions vis-a-vis private-coin protocols. On the other hand, prior entanglement leads to startling phenomena such as "quantum teleportation" and "superdense coding." The problem of characterising the power of prior entanglement has baffled many researchers, especially in the setting of bounded-error protocols. It is open whether it leads to more than a factor of two savings (using superdense coding) or more than an additive O(log) savings (when used to create shared randomness). Few lower bounds are known for communication problems in this setting, and are all derived using sophisticated information theoretic techniques. In this paper, we focus on the most basic problem in the setting of communication over an entanglement-assisted quantum channel, that of communicating classical bits from one party to another. We derive optimal bounds on the number of quantum bits required for this task, for any given probability of error.

IEEE Conference on Computational Complexity (CCC)•Jun 25, 2003•10 citations

New One Shot Quantum Protocols With Application to Communication Complexity

Anurag Anshu, Rahul Jain, Priyanka Mukhopadhyay +2 more

In this paper, we present the following quantum compression protocol `P': Let ρ,σ be quantum states, such that S (ρ∥σ)def= Tr(ρ log ρ - ρ log σ), the relative entropy between ρ and σ, is finite. Alice gets to know the eigendecomposition of ρ. Bob gets to know the eigendecomposition of σ. Both Alice and Bob know S(ρ∥σ) and an error parameter ε. Alice and Bob use shared entanglement and after communication of O((S(ρ∥σ) + 1)/ε4) bits from Alice to Bob, Bob ends up with a quantum state ̃ρ̃, such that F(ρ, ρ̃) ≥ 1-5ε, where F(·) represents fidelity. This result can be considered as a non-commutative generalization of a result due to Braverman and Rao where they considered the special case when ρ and σ are classical probability distributions (or commute with each other) and use shared randomness instead of shared entanglement. We use? to obtain an alternate proof of a direct-sum result for entanglement assisted quantum one-way communication complexity for all relations, which was first shown by Jain et al.. We also present a variant of protocol? in which Bob has some side information about the state with Alice. We show that in such a case, the amount of communication can be further reduced, based on the side information that Bob has. Our second result provides a quantum analog of the widely used classical correlated-sampling protocol. For example, Holenstein used the classical correlated-sampling protocol in his proof of a parallel-repetition theorem for two-player one-round games.

arXiv:1404.1366•IEEE Transactions on Information Theory•Oct 10, 2016•18 citations

On communication over an entanglement-assisted quantum channel

Ashwin Nayak, Julia Salzman

Shared entanglement is a resource available to parties communicating over a quantum channel, much akin to public coins in classical communication protocols. Whereas shared randomness does not help in the transmission of information, or significantly reduce the classical complexity of computing functions (as compared to private-coin protocols), shared entanglement leads to startling phenomena such as "quantum teleportation" and "superdense coding."The problem of characterising the power of prior entanglement has puzzled many researchers. In this paper, we revisit the problem of transmitting classical bits over an entanglement-assisted quantum channel. We derive a new, optimal bound on the number of quantum bits required for this task, for any given probability of error. All known lower bounds in the setting of bounded error entanglement-assisted communication are based on sophisticated information theoretic arguments. In contrast, our result is derived from first principles, using a simple linear algebraic technique.

ACM Symposium on Theory of Computing (STOC)•Jan 1, 2002•28 citations

Direct Sum Theorem for Bounded Round Quantum Communication Complexity

Dave Touchette

We prove a direct sum theorem for bounded round entanglement-assisted quantum communication complexity. To do so, we use the fully quantum definition for information cost and complexity that we recently introduced, and use both the fact that information is a lower bound on the communication, and the fact that a direct sum property holds for quantum information complexity. We then give a protocol for compressing a single copy of a protocol down to its quantum information cost, up to terms depending on the number of rounds and the allowed increase in error. Two important tools to derive this protocol are a smooth conditional min-entropy bound for a one-shot quantum state redistribution protocol, and the quantum substate theorem of Jain, Radhakrishnan and Sen (FOCS'02) to transform this bound into a von Neumann conditional entropy bound. This result further establishes the newly introduced notions of quantum information cost and complexity as the correct quantum generalisations of the classical ones in the standard communication complexity setting. Finding such a quantum generalization of information complexity was one of the open problem recently raised by Braverman (STOC'12).

arXiv:1409.4391•Sep 15, 2014•7 citations
We revisit the task of visible compression of an ensemble of quantum states with entanglement assistance in the one-shot setting. The protocols achieving the best compression use many more qubits of shared entanglement than the number of qubits in the states in the ensemble. Other compression protocols, with potentially larger communication cost, have entanglement cost bounded by the number of qubits in the given states. This motivates the question as to whether entanglement is truly necessary for compression, and if so, how much of it is needed. Motivated by questions in communication complexity, we lift certain restrictions that are placed on compression protocols in tasks such as state-splitting and channel simulation. We show that an ensemble of the form designed by Jain, Radhakrishnan, and Sen (ICALP'03) saturates the known bounds on the sum of communication and entanglement costs, even with the relaxed compression protocols we study. The ensemble and the associated one-way communication protocol have several remarkable properties. The ensemble is incompressible by more than a constant number of qubits without shared entanglement, even when constant error is allowed. Moreover, in the presence of shared entanglement, the communication cost of compression can be arbitrarily smaller than the entanglement cost. The quantum information cost of the protocol can thus be arbitrarily smaller than the cost of compression without shared entanglement. The ensemble can also be used to show the impossibility of reducing, via compression, the shared entanglement used in two-party protocols for computing Boolean functions.
This thesis consists of two parts: quantum compression and quantum learning theory. A common theme between these problems is that we study them through the lens of information theory. \n \nWe first study the task of visible compression of an ensemble of quantum states with entanglement assistance in the one-shot setting. The protocols achieving the best compression use many more qubits of shared entanglement than the number of qubits in the states in the ensemble. Other compression protocols, with potentially higher communication cost, have entanglement cost bounded by the number of qubits in the given states. This motivates the question as to whether entanglement is truly necessary for compression, and if so, how much of it is needed. We show that an ensemble given by Jain, Radhakrishnan, and Sen (ICALP'03) cannot be compressed by more than a constant number of qubits without shared entanglement, while in the presence of shared entanglement, the communication cost of compression can be arbitrarily smaller than the entanglement cost. \n \nNext, we study the task of quantum state redistribution, the most general version of compression of quantum states. We design a protocol for this task with communication cost in terms of a measure of distance from quantum Markov chains. More precisely, the distance is defined in terms of quantum max-relative entropy and quantum hypothesis testing entropy. Our result is the first to connect quantum state redistribution and Markov chains and gives an operational interpretation for a possible one-shot analogue of quantum conditional mutual information. The communication cost of our protocol is lower than all previously known ones and asymptotically achieves the well-known rate of quantum conditional mutual information. \n \nIn the last part, we focus on quantum algorithms for learning Boolean functions using quantum examples. We consider two commonly studied models of learning, namely, quantum PAC learning and quantum agnostic learning. We reproduce the optimal lower bounds by Arunachalam and de Wolf (JMLR’18) for the sample complexity of either of these models using information theory and spectral analysis. Our proofs are simpler than the previous ones and the techniques can be possibly extended to similar scenarios.
Inblindcompression of quantum states, a sender Alice is given a specimen of a quantum state$\rho drawnfromaknownensemble(butwithoutknowingwhatdrawn from a known ensemble (but without knowing whatdrawnfromaknownensemble(butwithoutknowingwhat\rho is),andshetransmitssufficientquantumdatatoareceiverBobsothathecandecodeanearperfectspecimenofis), and she transmits sufficient quantum data to a receiver Bob so that he can decode a near perfect specimen ofis),andshetransmitssufficientquantumdatatoareceiverBobsothathecandecodeanearperfectspecimenof\rho $. For many such states drawn iid from the ensemble, the asymptotically achievable rate is the number of qubits required to be transmitted per state. The Holevo information is a lower bound for the achievable rate, and is attained for pure state ensembles, or in the related scenario of entanglement-assistedvisiblecompression of mixed states wherein Alice knows what state is drawn. In this paper, we prove a general and robust lower bound on the achievable rate for ensembles of classical states, which holds even in the least demanding setting when Alice and Bob share free entanglement and a constant per-copy error is allowed. We apply the bound to aspecificensemble of only two states and prove a near-maximal separation (saturating the dimension bound in leading order) between the best achievable rate and the Holevo information for constant error. This also implies that the ensemble is incompressible – compression does not reduce the communication cost by much. Since the states areclassical, the observed incompressibility is not fundamentally quantum mechanical. We lower bound the difference between the achievable rate and the Holevo information in terms of quantitative limitations to clone the specimen or to distinguish the two classical states.
Shared entanglement is a resource available to parties communicating over a quantum channel, much akin to public coins in classical communication protocols: the two parties may be given some number of quantum bits jointly prepared in a fixed superposition, prior to communicating with each other. The quantum channel is then said to be "entanglement-assisted." Shared randomness does not help in the transmission of information from one party to another. Moreover, it does not significantly reduce the classical complexity of computing functions vis-a-vis private-coin protocols. On the other hand, prior entanglement leads to startling phenomena such as "quantum teleportation" and "superdense coding." The problem of characterising the power of prior entanglement has baffled many researchers, especially in the setting of bounded-error protocols. It is open whether it leads to more than a factor of two savings (using superdense coding) or more than an additive O(log) savings (when used to create shared randomness). Few lower bounds are known for communication problems in this setting, and are all derived using sophisticated information theoretic techniques. In this paper, we focus on the most basic problem in the setting of communication over an entanglement-assisted quantum channel, that of communicating classical bits from one party to another. We derive optimal bounds on the number of quantum bits required for this task, for any given probability of error.
In this paper, we present the following quantum compression protocol `P': Let ρ,σ be quantum states, such that S (ρ∥σ)def= Tr(ρ log ρ - ρ log σ), the relative entropy between ρ and σ, is finite. Alice gets to know the eigendecomposition of ρ. Bob gets to know the eigendecomposition of σ. Both Alice and Bob know S(ρ∥σ) and an error parameter ε. Alice and Bob use shared entanglement and after communication of O((S(ρ∥σ) + 1)/ε4) bits from Alice to Bob, Bob ends up with a quantum state ̃ρ̃, such that F(ρ, ρ̃) ≥ 1-5ε, where F(·) represents fidelity. This result can be considered as a non-commutative generalization of a result due to Braverman and Rao where they considered the special case when ρ and σ are classical probability distributions (or commute with each other) and use shared randomness instead of shared entanglement. We use? to obtain an alternate proof of a direct-sum result for entanglement assisted quantum one-way communication complexity for all relations, which was first shown by Jain et al.. We also present a variant of protocol? in which Bob has some side information about the state with Alice. We show that in such a case, the amount of communication can be further reduced, based on the side information that Bob has. Our second result provides a quantum analog of the widely used classical correlated-sampling protocol. For example, Holenstein used the classical correlated-sampling protocol in his proof of a parallel-repetition theorem for two-player one-round games.
Shared entanglement is a resource available to parties communicating over a quantum channel, much akin to public coins in classical communication protocols. Whereas shared randomness does not help in the transmission of information, or significantly reduce the classical complexity of computing functions (as compared to private-coin protocols), shared entanglement leads to startling phenomena such as "quantum teleportation" and "superdense coding."The problem of characterising the power of prior entanglement has puzzled many researchers. In this paper, we revisit the problem of transmitting classical bits over an entanglement-assisted quantum channel. We derive a new, optimal bound on the number of quantum bits required for this task, for any given probability of error. All known lower bounds in the setting of bounded error entanglement-assisted communication are based on sophisticated information theoretic arguments. In contrast, our result is derived from first principles, using a simple linear algebraic technique.
We prove a direct sum theorem for bounded round entanglement-assisted quantum communication complexity. To do so, we use the fully quantum definition for information cost and complexity that we recently introduced, and use both the fact that information is a lower bound on the communication, and the fact that a direct sum property holds for quantum information complexity. We then give a protocol for compressing a single copy of a protocol down to its quantum information cost, up to terms depending on the number of rounds and the allowed increase in error. Two important tools to derive this protocol are a smooth conditional min-entropy bound for a one-shot quantum state redistribution protocol, and the quantum substate theorem of Jain, Radhakrishnan and Sen (FOCS'02) to transform this bound into a von Neumann conditional entropy bound. This result further establishes the newly introduced notions of quantum information cost and complexity as the correct quantum generalisations of the classical ones in the standard communication complexity setting. Finding such a quantum generalization of information complexity was one of the open problem recently raised by Braverman (STOC'12).