A considerable success in phenomenological description of [Formula: see text] superconductors has been achieved within the paradigm of Quantum Critical Point (QCP)-a parental state of a variety of exotic phases that is characterized by dense entanglement and absence of well-defined quasiparticles. However, the microscopic origin of the critical regime in real materials remains an open question. On the other hand, there is a popular view that a single-band t-[Formula: see text] Hubbard model is the minimal model to catch the main relevant physics of superconducting compounds. Here, we suggest that emergence of the QCP is tightly connected with entanglement in real space and identify its location on the phase diagram of the hole-doped t-[Formula: see text] Hubbard model. To detect the QCP we study a weighted graph of inter-site quantum mutual information within a four-by-four plaquette that is solved by exact diagonalization. We demonstrate that some quantitative characteristics of such a graph, viewed as a complex network, exhibit peculiar behavior around a certain submanifold in the parametric space of the model. This method allows us to overcome difficulties caused by finite size effects and to identify precursors of the transition point even on a small lattice, where long-range asymptotics of correlation functions cannot be accessed.
Detecting quantum critical points in the t-t′ Fermi-Hubbard model via complex network theory
A considerable success in phenomenological description of [Formula: see text] superconductors has been achieved within the paradigm of Quantum Critical Point (QCP)-a parental state of a variety of exotic phases that is characterized by dense entanglement and absence of well-defined quasiparticles. However, the microscopic origin of the critical regime in real materials remains an open question. On the other hand, there is a popular view that a single-band t-[Formula: see text] Hubbard model is the minimal model to catch the main relevant physics of superconducting compounds. Here, we suggest that emergence of the QCP is tightly connected with entanglement in real space and identify its location on the phase diagram of the hole-doped t-[Formula: see text] Hubbard model. To detect the QCP we study a weighted graph of inter-site quantum mutual information within a four-by-four plaquette that is solved by exact diagonalization. We demonstrate that some quantitative characteristics of such a graph, viewed as a complex network, exhibit peculiar behavior around a certain submanifold in the parametric space of the model. This method allows us to overcome difficulties caused by finite size effects and to identify precursors of the transition point even on a small lattice, where long-range asymptotics of correlation functions cannot be accessed.
Emerging quantum simulator technologies provide a new challenge to quantum many body theory. Quantifying the emergent order in and predicting the dynamics of such complex quantum systems requires a new approach. We develop such an approach based on complex network analysis of quantum mutual information. First, we establish the usefulness of quantum mutual information complex networks by reproducing the phase diagrams of transverse Ising and Bose-Hubbard models. By quantifying the complexity of quantum cellular automata we then demonstrate the applicability of complex network theory to non-equilibrium quantum dynamics. We conclude with a study of student collaboration networks, correlating a student's role in a collaboration network with their grades. This work thus initiates a quantitative theory of quantum complexity and provides a new tool for physics education research. We find that network density, clustering coefficient, disparity, and Pearson R correlation show systematic finite size scaling towards critical points of the transverse Ising model and the Bose-Hubbard model. Using matrix product state methods we are able to simulate lattices of hundreds of qubits, allowing us to verify the critical point of the transverse Ising model to within 0.001% of its known value. Furthermore, we find that complex network analysis identifies the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless critical point of the Bose-Hubbard to within 3.6% of its accepted value. Finally, we identify the boundary separating the Mott Insulator phase from a superfluid phase in the Bose-Hubbard model by extremizing network density, clustering coefficient, and disparity. After studying the static properties of quantum many body systems, we study the entanglement and complexity generated by Hamiltonian based quantum cellular automata. In quantum cellular automata one defines a set of local rules that govern the evolution of the quantum state. A site in a quantum lattice evolves if the set of sites around it are in certain configurations. Configurations are defined in terms of the number of sites in the ``alive'' state about a site. We quantify entanglement in terms of the central bond entropy, and complexity in terms of persistent fluctuations of the central bond entropy, complex network measures of quantum mutual information networks far from their values for random/well known quantum states, and robust dynamical features. These Hamiltonians are a generalization of the Bleh, Calarco, Montangero Hamiltonian. Before beginning our study of the entanglement and complexity generated by these Hamiltonians we first perform a convergence analysis of the dynamics of the Bleh, Calarco, Montangero Hamiltonian using an open source matrix product state code, Open Source Matrix Product States. We find that the Bleh, Calarco, Montangero Hamiltonian rapidly saturates the entanglement cutoff of Open Source Matrix Product States for all initial conditions studied and is thus not a viable numerical method for studying the dynamics of quantum cellular automata. We conclude our convergence study with a case study of an emergent quantum blinker pattern also observed in exact simulation and a case study of a nearest neighbor quantum cellular automata. We conclude that while for generic initial conditions Open Source Matrix Product States is unable to meet its internal convergence criteria, for particular initial conditions and quantum cellular automata it is able to provide reliable estimates of entanglement and complexity measures. The failure of OpenMPS to provide reliably converged quantum states leads us to study our quantum cellular automata using a Trotter-based time evolution scheme. We quantify the entanglement and complexity generated by 13 next-nearest neighbor quantum cellular automata. We also define Goldilocks rules, rules that produce activity at a site if there are exactly the right number of alive sites in the neighborhood of a site, not too few, not too many. We identify a Goldilocks rule, rule 4, as the best complexity-generating rule out of the 13 rules tested, verifying our hypothesis that only Goldilocks rules are complexity generating. We also find that non-Goldilocks rules tend toward thermalization as quantified by reduced fluctuations in the central bond entropy. We find that both highly entangled quantum states and lowly entangled quantum states have complex structure in their quantum mutual information adjacency matrices. Finally, in keeping with the strong physics education research focus at the Colorado School of Mines, we apply complex network analysis to a key issue germane to the student experience, namely student collaboration networks. We compute nodal centrality measures on the collaboration networks of students enrolled in three upper-division physics courses at the Colorado School of Mines. These are networks in which links between students indicate assistance with homework. The courses included in the study are intermediate classical mechanics, introductory quantum mechanics, and intermediate electromagnetism. We find that almost all of the measures considered correlate with analytical homework grades. In contrast only net out-strength correlates with exam grade. The benefits of collaboration do not extend from homework to exams, and students who help more than they are helped perform well on exams. Centrality measures between simultaneous collaboration networks (analytical vs. numerical homework collaboration) composed of the same students correlate with each other. Students take on similar roles in response to analytical vs. numerical homework assignments. Changes in collaboration across semesters are also considered as students transition from classical mechanics in the fall to quantum mechanics and electromagnetism in the spring. We find the most frequent transition is that students that help many others and have high grades will continue to help many others and have high grades. Students that help few more frequently transition from low grades to high grades than students that help many.
We demonstrate that a finite-doping quantum critical point (QCP) naturally descends from the existence of a first-order Mott transition in the phase diagram of a strongly correlated material. In a prototypical case of a first-order Mott transition the surface associated with the equation of state for the homogeneous system is "folded" so that in a range of parameters stable metallic and insulating phases exist and are connected by an unstable metallic branch. Here we show that tuning the chemical potential, the zero-temperature equation of state gradually unfolds. Under general conditions, we find that the Mott transition evolves into a first-order transition between two metals, associated with a phase separation region ending in the finite-doping QCP. This scenario is here demonstrated solving a minimal multiorbital Hubbard model relevant for the iron-based superconductors, but its origin-the splitting of the atomic ground state multiplet by a small energy scale, here Hund's coupling-is much more general. A strong analogy with cuprate superconductors is traced.
Abstract We present a T = 0 K renormalization group (RG) phase diagram for the hole-doped 2D Hubbard model on the square lattice. The RG method employed is nonperturbative in treating quantum fluctuations of the single-particle occupation number via the unitarily decoupling of one electronic state at every RG step. As a result, the RG phase diagram possesses the quantum fluctuation energy scale (ω) as one of its axes. Using effective Hamiltonians and wavefunctions for the low-energy many-body eigenstates for the doped Mott liquid obtained from the stable fixed point of the RG flows, we demonstrate the collapse of the pseudogap for charge excitations (Mottness) at a quantum critical point (QCP) possessing a nodal non-Fermi liquid with superconducting fluctuations, and spin-pseudogapping near the antinodes. The QCP is characterised using both thermodynamic and quantum information-theoretic measures. d-wave superconducting order is shown to arise from this quantum critical state of matter. The pseudogap phase possesses a variety of fluctuations that lead to several symmetry-broken phases at low-energies. Benchmarking of the ground state energy per particle and the double-occupancy fraction obtained from a finite-size scaling analysis against existing numerical results yields excellent agreement. We present detailed insight into the T = 0 origin of several experimentally observed findings in the cuprates, including Homes law and Planckian dissipation. We also establish that the heirarchy of temperature scales for the pseudogap (T PG), onset temperature for pairing (T ons), formation of the Mott liquid (T ML) and superconductivity (T C) obtained from our analysis is quantitatively consistent with that observed experimentally for some members of the cuprates. Our results offer insight on the ubiquitous origin of superconductivity in doped Mott insulating states, and pave the way towards a systematic search for higher superconducting transition temperatures in such systems.
Quantum phase transitions in strongly correlated electron materials are one of the most intriguing phenomena in condensed matter physics. In fact, the rich phase-diagrams of these systems usually allow for the presence of several quantum phase transitions. At the same time, a comprehensive theoretical description of the quantum critical properties of correlated electrons has been not fully developed yet. For one of the most fundamental model in solid state physics, the 3D Hubbard model, quantum critical behaviour appears to violate the conventional Hertz-Millis- Moriya theory. This unexpected finding has been ascribed to the presence of specific features on the Fermi surface (FS), such as Kohn points and/or lines. If this is the case, the correct description of 3D correlated metal should be already accessible by means of Dynamical Mean Field Theory (DMFT) calculations. DMFT, in fact, preserves the information about the FS geometry and correctly captures temporal fluctuations, crucial for the description of quantum criticality. The main aim of this work is to test the hypothesis that DMFT treatment is sufficient to describe the quantum critical behaviour of 3D correlated metals, without resorting to more advanced (and much heavier!) quantum many-body schemes. Our DMFT results for the hole-doped 3D-Hubbard model have allowed to determine the location of the quantum-critical point of the magnetic transition and to highlight promising trends for the associated quantum critical exponents.
Transport measurements on the cuprates suggest the presence of a quantum critical point (QCP) hiding underneath the superconducting dome near optimal hole doping. We provide numerical evidence in support of this scenario via a dynamical cluster quantum Monte Carlo study of the extended two-dimensional Hubbard model. Single-particle quantities, such as the spectral function, the quasi-particle weight and the entropy, display a crossover between two distinct ground states: a Fermi liquid at low filling and a non-Fermi liquid with a pseudo-gap at high filling. Both states are found to cross over to a marginal Fermi-liquid state at higher temperatures. For finite next-nearest-neighbour hopping t', we find a classical critical point at temperature T(c). This classical critical point is found to be associated with a phase-separation transition between a compressible Mott gas and an incompressible Mott liquid corresponding to the Fermi liquid and the pseudo-gap state, respectively. Since the critical temperature T(c) extrapolates to zero as t' vanishes, we conclude that a QCP connects the Fermi liquid to the pseudo-gap region, and that the marginal Fermi-liquid behaviour in its vicinity is the analogue of the supercritical region in the liquid-gas transition.
For doped two-dimensional Mott insulators in their normal state, the challenge is to understand the evolution from a conventional metal at high doping to a strongly correlated metal near the Mott insulator at zero doping. To this end, we solve the cellular dynamical mean-field equations for the two-dimensional Hubbard model using a plaquette as the reference quantum impurity model and continuous-time quantum Monte Carlo method as impurity solver. The normal-state phase diagram as a function of interaction strength U, temperature T, and filling n shows that, upon increasing n toward the Mott insulator, there is a surface of first-order transition between two metals at nonzero doping. That surface ends at a finite temperature critical line originating at the half-filled Mott critical point. Associated with this transition, there is a maximum in scattering rate as well as thermodynamic signatures. These findings suggest a new scenario for the normal-state phase diagram of the high temperature superconductors. The criticality surmised in these systems can originate not from a T = 0 quantum critical point, nor from the proximity of a long-range ordered phase, but from a low temperature transition between two types of metals at finite doping. The influence of Mott physics therefore extends well beyond half-filling.