Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1902.07841

An empiric logic approach to Einstein's version of the double-slit experiment

Arkady Bolotin

Published Feb 21, 2019• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

As per Einstein's design, particles are introduced into the double-slit experiment through a small hole in a plate which can either move up and down (and its momentum can be measured) or be stopped (and its position can be measured). Suppose one measures the position of the plate and this act verifies the statement that the interference pattern is observed in the experiment. However, if it is possible to think about the outcome that one would have obtained if one had measured plate's momentum instead of its position, then it is possible to consider, together with the aforesaid statement, another statement that each particle passes through either slit of the double-slit screen. Hence, the proposition affirming the wave-like behavior and the proposition affirming the particle-like behavior might be true together, which would imply that Bohr's complementarity principle is incorrect. The analysis of Einstein's design and ways to refute it based on an approach that uses exclusively assignments of the truth values to experimental propositions is presented in this paper.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1902.07841

Related papers

Complementarity in the double-slit experiment: Quantum nonseparability and a quantitative statement of Bohr's principle

William K. Wootters, Wojciech Hubert Zurek

A detailed analysis of Einstein's version of the double-slit experiment, in which one tries to observe both wave and particle properties of light, is performed. Quantum nonseparability appears in the derivation of the interference pattern, which proves to be surprisingly sharp even when the trajectories of the photons have been determined with fairly high accuracy. An information-theoretic approach to this problem leads to a quantitative formulation of Bohr's complementarity principle for the case of the double-slit experiment. A practically realizable version of this experiment, to which the above analysis applies, is proposed.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Jan 15, 1979•614 citations

A proposal to get some common-sense intuition for the paradox of the double-slit experiment

G. Coddens

We argue that the double-slit experiment can be understood much better by considering it as an experiment whereby one uses electrons to study the set-up rather than an experiment whereby we use a set-up to study the behaviour of electrons. We also show that the concept of undecidability (like e.g. occurs in G\odel's theorem) can be used in an intuitive way to make sense of the double-slit experiment and the quantum rules for calculating coherent and incoherent probabilities. We meet here a situation where the electrons always behave in a fully deterministic way, while the detailed design of the set-up may render the question about the way they move through the set-up experimentally undecidable. It is very important to make a distinction in quantum mechanics between the determinism of nature (Einstein) and the decidability of a question within an experimental set-up (Bohr). The former is about the absolute truth of an answer to a yes or no question, and follows binary logic (true or false), the latter about what an experimental set-up can decide and tell about the truth of that answer, and follows ternary logic (true, false or undecidable). Binary and ternary logic are incompatible. The viewpoints of Bohr and Einstein are thus operating on different levels and it is only by confusing these two levels that these two viewpoints seem to be irreconcilable. We show that the expression $\psi_{1} + \psi_{2}$ for the wave function of the double-slit experiment is numerically correct, but logically flawed. It has to be replaced in the interference region by the logically correct expression $\psi'_{1} + \psi'_{2}$, which has the same numerical value as $\psi_{1} + \psi_{2}$, such that $\psi'_{1} + \psi'_{2} = \psi_{1} + \psi_{2}$, but with $\psi'_{1} = {\psi_{1} +\psi_{2}\over{\sqrt{2}}} \,e^{\imath {\pi\over{4}} } \neq \psi_{1}$ and $\psi'_{2} = {\psi_{1} +\psi_{2}\over{\sqrt{2}}}\,e^{-\imath {\pi\over{4}}}\neq \psi_{2}$. Here $\psi'_{1}$ and $\psi'_{2}$ are the correct contributions from the slits to the total wave function $\psi'_{1} + \psi'_{2}$. We have then $p = |\psi'_{1} + \psi'_{2}|^{2} = |\psi'_{1}|^{2} + |\psi'_{2}|^{2} = p_{1}+p_{2} $ such that the paradox that quantum mechanics (QM) would not follow the traditional rules of probability calculus disappears. The paradox is rooted in the wrong intuition that $\psi_{1}$ and $\psi_{2}$ would be the true physical contributions to $\psi'_{1} + \psi'_{2} =\psi_{1} + \psi_{2}$ like in the case of waves in a water tank. The solution proposed here is not {\em ad hoc} but based on an extensive analysis of the geometrical meaning of spinors within group representation theory and its application to QM. Working further on the argument one can even show that an interference pattern is the only way to satisfy simultaneously two conditions: The condition obeying binary logic (in the spirit of Einstein) that the electron has only two mutually exclusive options to get to the detector (viz. going through slit S$_{1}$ or going through slit S$_{2}$) and the condition obeying ternary logic (in the spirit of Bohr) that the question which one of these two options the electron has taken is experimentally undecidable. A very important element in the analysis is the problem of the non-existence of {\em common} probability distributions for different experimental set-ups. And this is a recurrent theme in other situations that are felt as paradoxical. The CHSH inequality used in the experiments of Aspect {\em et al.} clashes with quantum mechanics because it is based on the assumption that there would exist a {\em common} probability distribution for the hidden variables in the different experiments that have to be made to determine the various quantities that intervene in the inequality. That common probability distribution for measured quantities does not exist is well known from quantum mechanics itself (because the operators that come into play do not commute and therefore do not have common eigenstates, i.e. common probability amplitudes). But this non-existence of common probability distributions applies also to certain variables in the set-ups of the different experiments and the latter fact can also be explained by purely classical reasoning.

•Oct 26, 2016•2 citations

Universal Mechanics: The Double-Slit Experiment

Asa Atallah

The double-slit experiment is usually taken as evidence that a particle is also a wave. Earlier versions of this record showed by simulation that a definite particle moving through a physical medium is steered to its landing by a wave in that medium after both slits have shaped it: fringes with two openings, the single-slit pattern with one. Those plates are shown again here, thirteen fringes with their envelope and side lobes on the best of them, and they are the target. In them the wave was supplied at the bench. Light from a star has no such supply. This version asks what that requires: the wave must be of the particle's own making, and it must travel with the particle without fading. Two answers are examined. A single push at launch makes a wave that passes both openings and steers the particle, and closing the opening the particle never passes changes where it lands; but that wave thins with distance, and the landings move as the launch is taken farther back. A particle that instead pushes the medium steadily as it moves carries a wave ahead of it that keeps its strength over the distances tested. At the slits such a particle flies straight along the centre line of a lone opening and is turned when the second opening is open, its direction set in a short stretch behind the wall and kept from there to the screen. With one opening the directions in which such particles leave span the width of the single-slit pattern; with two they have not yet been shown to gather at the fringes. The plate from single particles carrying their own sustained wave is not yet in hand, and is the work in progress. Two statements of version 2.0 are withdrawn: that a sustained wave is not the mechanism of the fringes, and that a particle cannot read a wave whose source is itself.

•Sep 10, 2026•0 citations

Quantum behavior in the Double Slit Experiment and the limitations of the equipment used.

Ernest Heinz

Abstract: Many problems exist in the Double Slit Experiment when you consider that the elements in the test are moving as waves. Outside of the pattern resembling peeks and troughs that overlap each other; there is no real scientific explanation on how this is taking place. In a more accurate and classical way, can we explain how the dark and light areas of the interference pattern are being made? Why is an Interference pattern being made when particles are being sent through the exercise one at a time? And how is it that through observation the Interference pattern collapses in on itself. Waves add more questions than they do answers, a very typical outcome of an incorrect solution. Maybe the unanswered questions left behind by the wave theory is a confirmation of its inaccuracy and not the mystique of its results. Rather than double down on the wave theory with time traveling particles, elements of duality, and the Copenhagen Interpretation; l reconsidered that elements tested in the double slit experiment behave as particles. But this time, I weighed the thought that these bits of matter are much smaller than previously thought. This new logic allowed particles with straight trajectories to interact with the edge of materials used in the double slit wall in a very detailed way. This created a storm of new ways to look at what is really taking place in the test; revealing the competence of the detectors utilized and the capacity of the Nonlinear Optical Crystal. Everything solved from just one idea, that quantum move as particles but on a much smaller scale. This is the enigma of the Double Slit Experiment.

•May 1, 2018•0 citations

Complementarity in the double-slit experiment: On simple realizable systems for observing intermediate particle-wave behavior

Lawrence S. Bartell

In the course of a detailed analysis of observable intermediate particle-wave aspects of light, Wootters and Zurek invented an ingenious but technically difficult practical apparatus for performing Einstein's version of the double-slit experiment. The present note discusses two very simple alternative systems for displaying the Bohr-Einstein particle-wave extremes or, if desired, any intermediate trajectory-interference manifestation associated with the double-slit experiment.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Mar 15, 1980•75 citations

A solution for the paradox of the double-slit experiment

G. Coddens

We argue that the double-slit experiment can be understood much better by considering it as an experiment whereby one uses electrons to study the set-up rather than an experiment whereby we use a set-up to study the behaviour of electrons. We also show how the concept of undecidability can be used in an intuitive way to make sense of the double-slit experiment and the quantum rules for calculating coherent and incoherent probabilities. We meet here a situation where the electrons always behave in a fully deterministic way (following Einstein's conception of reality), while the detailed design of the set-up may render the question about the way they move through the set-up experimentally undecidable (which follows more Bohr's conception of reality). We show that the expression $ψ_{1} + ψ_{2}$ for the wave function of the double-slit experiment is numerically correct, but logically flawed. It has to be replaced in the interference region by the logically correct expression $ψ'_{1} + ψ'_{2}$, which has the same numerical value as $ψ_{1} + ψ_{2}$, such that $ψ'_{1} + ψ'_{2} = ψ_{1} + ψ_{2}$, but with $ψ'_{1} = {ψ_{1} +ψ_{2}\over{\sqrt{2}}} \,e^{\imath {π\over{4}}} \neq ψ_{1}$ and $ψ'_{2} = {ψ_{1} +ψ_{2}\over{\sqrt{2}}}\,e^{-\imath {π\over{4}}}\neq ψ_{2}$. Here $ψ'_{1}$ and $ψ'_{2}$ are the correct contributions from the slits to the total wave function $ψ'_{1} + ψ'_{2}$. We have then $p = |ψ'_{1} + ψ'_{2}|^{2} = |ψ'_{1}|^{2} + |ψ'_{2}|^{2} = p_{1}+p_{2} $ such that the paradox that quantum mechanics (QM) would not follow the traditional rules of probability calculus disappears.

arXiv:1705.04150•May 9, 2017•2 citations
As per Einstein's design, particles are introduced into the double-slit experiment through a small hole in a plate which can either move up and down (and its momentum can be measured) or be stopped (and its position can be measured). Suppose one measures the position of the plate and this act verifies the statement that the interference pattern is observed in the experiment. However, if it is possible to think about the outcome that one would have obtained if one had measured plate's momentum instead of its position, then it is possible to consider, together with the aforesaid statement, another statement that each particle passes through either slit of the double-slit screen. Hence, the proposition affirming the wave-like behavior and the proposition affirming the particle-like behavior might be true together, which would imply that Bohr's complementarity principle is incorrect. The analysis of Einstein's design and ways to refute it based on an approach that uses exclusively assignments of the truth values to experimental propositions is presented in this paper.
A detailed analysis of Einstein's version of the double-slit experiment, in which one tries to observe both wave and particle properties of light, is performed. Quantum nonseparability appears in the derivation of the interference pattern, which proves to be surprisingly sharp even when the trajectories of the photons have been determined with fairly high accuracy. An information-theoretic approach to this problem leads to a quantitative formulation of Bohr's complementarity principle for the case of the double-slit experiment. A practically realizable version of this experiment, to which the above analysis applies, is proposed.
We argue that the double-slit experiment can be understood much better by considering it as an experiment whereby one uses electrons to study the set-up rather than an experiment whereby we use a set-up to study the behaviour of electrons. We also show that the concept of undecidability (like e.g. occurs in G\odel's theorem) can be used in an intuitive way to make sense of the double-slit experiment and the quantum rules for calculating coherent and incoherent probabilities. We meet here a situation where the electrons always behave in a fully deterministic way, while the detailed design of the set-up may render the question about the way they move through the set-up experimentally undecidable. It is very important to make a distinction in quantum mechanics between the determinism of nature (Einstein) and the decidability of a question within an experimental set-up (Bohr). The former is about the absolute truth of an answer to a yes or no question, and follows binary logic (true or false), the latter about what an experimental set-up can decide and tell about the truth of that answer, and follows ternary logic (true, false or undecidable). Binary and ternary logic are incompatible. The viewpoints of Bohr and Einstein are thus operating on different levels and it is only by confusing these two levels that these two viewpoints seem to be irreconcilable. We show that the expression ψ1+ψ2\psi_{1} + \psi_{2}ψ1​+ψ2​ for the wave function of the double-slit experiment is numerically correct, but logically flawed. It has to be replaced in the interference region by the logically correct expression ψ1′+ψ2′\psi'_{1} + \psi'_{2}ψ1′​+ψ2′​, which has the same numerical value as ψ1+ψ2\psi_{1} + \psi_{2}ψ1​+ψ2​, such that ψ1′+ψ2′=ψ1+ψ2\psi'_{1} + \psi'_{2} = \psi_{1} + \psi_{2}ψ1′​+ψ2′​=ψ1​+ψ2​, but with ψ1′=ψ1+ψ22 eıπ4≠ψ1\psi'_{1} = {\psi_{1} +\psi_{2}\over{\sqrt{2}}} \,e^{\imath {\pi\over{4}} } \neq \psi_{1}ψ1′​=2​ψ1​+ψ2​​e4π​=ψ1​ and ψ2′=ψ1+ψ22 e−ıπ4≠ψ2\psi'_{2} = {\psi_{1} +\psi_{2}\over{\sqrt{2}}}\,e^{-\imath {\pi\over{4}}}\neq \psi_{2}ψ2′​=2​ψ1​+ψ2​​e−4π​=ψ2​. Here ψ1′\psi'_{1}ψ1′​ and ψ2′\psi'_{2}ψ2′​ are the correct contributions from the slits to the total wave function ψ1′+ψ2′\psi'_{1} + \psi'_{2}ψ1′​+ψ2′​. We have then $p = |\psi'_{1} + \psi'_{2}|^{2} = |\psi'_{1}|^{2} + |\psi'_{2}|^{2} = p_{1}+p_{2} $ such that the paradox that quantum mechanics (QM) would not follow the traditional rules of probability calculus disappears. The paradox is rooted in the wrong intuition that ψ1\psi_{1}ψ1​ and ψ2\psi_{2}ψ2​ would be the true physical contributions to ψ1′+ψ2′=ψ1+ψ2\psi'_{1} + \psi'_{2} =\psi_{1} + \psi_{2}ψ1′​+ψ2′​=ψ1​+ψ2​ like in the case of waves in a water tank. The solution proposed here is not {\em ad hoc} but based on an extensive analysis of the geometrical meaning of spinors within group representation theory and its application to QM. Working further on the argument one can even show that an interference pattern is the only way to satisfy simultaneously two conditions: The condition obeying binary logic (in the spirit of Einstein) that the electron has only two mutually exclusive options to get to the detector (viz. going through slit S1_{1}1​ or going through slit S2_{2}2​) and the condition obeying ternary logic (in the spirit of Bohr) that the question which one of these two options the electron has taken is experimentally undecidable. A very important element in the analysis is the problem of the non-existence of {\em common} probability distributions for different experimental set-ups. And this is a recurrent theme in other situations that are felt as paradoxical. The CHSH inequality used in the experiments of Aspect {\em et al.} clashes with quantum mechanics because it is based on the assumption that there would exist a {\em common} probability distribution for the hidden variables in the different experiments that have to be made to determine the various quantities that intervene in the inequality. That common probability distribution for measured quantities does not exist is well known from quantum mechanics itself (because the operators that come into play do not commute and therefore do not have common eigenstates, i.e. common probability amplitudes). But this non-existence of common probability distributions applies also to certain variables in the set-ups of the different experiments and the latter fact can also be explained by purely classical reasoning.
The double-slit experiment is usually taken as evidence that a particle is also a wave. Earlier versions of this record showed by simulation that a definite particle moving through a physical medium is steered to its landing by a wave in that medium after both slits have shaped it: fringes with two openings, the single-slit pattern with one. Those plates are shown again here, thirteen fringes with their envelope and side lobes on the best of them, and they are the target. In them the wave was supplied at the bench. Light from a star has no such supply. This version asks what that requires: the wave must be of the particle's own making, and it must travel with the particle without fading. Two answers are examined. A single push at launch makes a wave that passes both openings and steers the particle, and closing the opening the particle never passes changes where it lands; but that wave thins with distance, and the landings move as the launch is taken farther back. A particle that instead pushes the medium steadily as it moves carries a wave ahead of it that keeps its strength over the distances tested. At the slits such a particle flies straight along the centre line of a lone opening and is turned when the second opening is open, its direction set in a short stretch behind the wall and kept from there to the screen. With one opening the directions in which such particles leave span the width of the single-slit pattern; with two they have not yet been shown to gather at the fringes. The plate from single particles carrying their own sustained wave is not yet in hand, and is the work in progress. Two statements of version 2.0 are withdrawn: that a sustained wave is not the mechanism of the fringes, and that a particle cannot read a wave whose source is itself.
Abstract: Many problems exist in the Double Slit Experiment when you consider that the elements in the test are moving as waves. Outside of the pattern resembling peeks and troughs that overlap each other; there is no real scientific explanation on how this is taking place. In a more accurate and classical way, can we explain how the dark and light areas of the interference pattern are being made? Why is an Interference pattern being made when particles are being sent through the exercise one at a time? And how is it that through observation the Interference pattern collapses in on itself. Waves add more questions than they do answers, a very typical outcome of an incorrect solution. Maybe the unanswered questions left behind by the wave theory is a confirmation of its inaccuracy and not the mystique of its results. Rather than double down on the wave theory with time traveling particles, elements of duality, and the Copenhagen Interpretation; l reconsidered that elements tested in the double slit experiment behave as particles. But this time, I weighed the thought that these bits of matter are much smaller than previously thought. This new logic allowed particles with straight trajectories to interact with the edge of materials used in the double slit wall in a very detailed way. This created a storm of new ways to look at what is really taking place in the test; revealing the competence of the detectors utilized and the capacity of the Nonlinear Optical Crystal. Everything solved from just one idea, that quantum move as particles but on a much smaller scale. This is the enigma of the Double Slit Experiment.
We argue that the double-slit experiment can be understood much better by considering it as an experiment whereby one uses electrons to study the set-up rather than an experiment whereby we use a set-up to study the behaviour of electrons. We also show how the concept of undecidability can be used in an intuitive way to make sense of the double-slit experiment and the quantum rules for calculating coherent and incoherent probabilities. We meet here a situation where the electrons always behave in a fully deterministic way (following Einstein's conception of reality), while the detailed design of the set-up may render the question about the way they move through the set-up experimentally undecidable (which follows more Bohr's conception of reality). We show that the expression ψ1+ψ2ψ_{1} + ψ_{2}ψ1​+ψ2​ for the wave function of the double-slit experiment is numerically correct, but logically flawed. It has to be replaced in the interference region by the logically correct expression ψ1′+ψ2′ψ'_{1} + ψ'_{2}ψ1′​+ψ2′​, which has the same numerical value as ψ1+ψ2ψ_{1} + ψ_{2}ψ1​+ψ2​, such that ψ1′+ψ2′=ψ1+ψ2ψ'_{1} + ψ'_{2} = ψ_{1} + ψ_{2}ψ1′​+ψ2′​=ψ1​+ψ2​, but with ψ1′=ψ1+ψ22 eıπ4≠ψ1ψ'_{1} = {ψ_{1} +ψ_{2}\over{\sqrt{2}}} \,e^{\imath {π\over{4}}} \neq ψ_{1}ψ1′​=2​ψ1​+ψ2​​e4π​=ψ1​ and ψ2′=ψ1+ψ22 e−ıπ4≠ψ2ψ'_{2} = {ψ_{1} +ψ_{2}\over{\sqrt{2}}}\,e^{-\imath {π\over{4}}}\neq ψ_{2}ψ2′​=2​ψ1​+ψ2​​e−4π​=ψ2​. Here ψ1′ψ'_{1}ψ1′​ and ψ2′ψ'_{2}ψ2′​ are the correct contributions from the slits to the total wave function ψ1′+ψ2′ψ'_{1} + ψ'_{2}ψ1′​+ψ2′​. We have then $p = |ψ'_{1} + ψ'_{2}|^{2} = |ψ'_{1}|^{2} + |ψ'_{2}|^{2} = p_{1}+p_{2} $ such that the paradox that quantum mechanics (QM) would not follow the traditional rules of probability calculus disappears.