Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1901.02387 · Applied Physics Letters

Mitigation of cosmic ray effect on microwave kinetic inductance detector arrays

K. Karatsu, Akira Endo, Juan Bueno, Pieter de Visser, R. Barends, David Johannes Thoen, Vignesh Murugesan, N. Tomita, J. J. A. Baselmans

Published Jan 21, 2019• 63 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

For space observatories, the glitches caused by high energy phonons created by the interaction of cosmic ray particles with a detector substrate lead to dead time during observation. Mitigating the impact of cosmic rays is therefore an important requirement for detectors to be used in future space missions. In order to investigate possible solutions, we carry out a systematic study by testing four large arrays of Microwave Kinetic Inductance Detectors (MKIDs), each consisting of ∼960 pixels and fabricated on monolithic 55 mm × 55 mm × 0.35 mm Si substrates. We compare the response to cosmic ray interactions in our laboratory for different detector arrays: A standard array with only the MKID array as reference, an array with a low Tc superconducting film as a phonon absorber on the opposite side of the substrate, and arrays with MKIDs on membranes. The idea is that the low Tc layer down converts the phonon energy to values below the pair breaking threshold of the MKIDs, and the membranes isolate the sensitive part of the MKIDs from phonons created in the substrate. We find that the dead time can be reduced up to a factor of 40 when compared to the reference array. Simulations show that the dead time can be reduced to below 1% for the tested detector arrays when operated in a spacecraft in an L2 or a similar far-Earth orbit. The technique described here is also applicable and important for large superconducting qubit arrays for future quantum computers.

DOI
10.1063/1.5052419

Related papers

Ultra High Kinetic Inductance Detectors

Stefan Verheul

Microwave Kinetic Inductance Detectors (MKIDs) are extremely sensitive radiation detectors based on superconducting resonators that can be combined in large arrays on a single readout line within a limited frequency bandwidth. This makes MKIDs ideal detectors for the ultimate far-infrared observatory: a future space-based actively cooled telescope with its performance solely limited by the low universe background radiation. However, to reach these detector requirements, state-of-the-art MKIDs still need a order of magnitude improvement in device sensitivity. In this work, the MKID sensitivity is improved by reducing the aluminium volume that absorbs pair-breaking radiation into quasiparticle excitations, while making sure all radiation is still absorbed. Furthermore, a key requirement is sufficient reduction of excess noise as to keep the device intrinsically limited by thermally driven random fluctuations in the number of quasiparticles in absence of radiation, or Generation-Recombination (G-R) noise. To this end, a model is developed that describes the noise contributions as function of device geometry, readout power, material properties and radiation power. Subsequently, a realistic MKID design is presented and tested that reduces excess noise and maximises the sensitivity, expressed as Noise Equivalent Power (NEP). At high temperatures, good overall agreement is found between the measured noise spectra and the model. At low temperature T = 120 mK, the measurement results give an optical NEP similar to current state-of-the-art MKIDs. The NEP is not as low as expected due to short quasiparticle lifetimes, an unexpected decrease in the G-R noise level and a very high excess noise attributed to Two-Level Systems (TLS) noise that starts to dominate the already low G-R noise spectrum at low temperatures. Possibly, the quick quasiparticle lifetime saturation and noise level drop are caused by a strong readout power effect, as the readout power is known to create excess quasiparticles and to cause a strongly non-thermal electron energy distribution in the aluminium strip of the MKID. However, the exact microscopic details of these effects are unknown and not studied in this project. Based on the current chip design, a straightforward way to improve device performance and study the readout power effect in more detail is a reduction of the high TLS noise levels, which is possibly fabrication related. This would allow an unobstructed view of the G-R noise spectrum at low temperatures, thereby allowing both a study of the readout power effect on the quasiparticle system, and ultimately achieving the improvement in NEP needed reach the detector requirements for the ultimate space-based far-infrared observatory.

•Jan 1, 2019•0 citations

Study of Superconducting Bilayer for Microwave Kinetic Inductance Detectors for Astrophysics

Agnès Dominjon, Masakazu Sekine, K. Karatsu +5 more

Due to their multiplexing capability and their good sensitivity to radiation from submillimeter to X-ray wavelengths, microwave kinetic inductance detectors (MKIDs) are increasingly used in the field of astrophysics. The Advanced Technology Center of the National Astronomical Observatory of Japan is developing MKIDs for astronomical observations such as CMB B-mode search with LiteBIRD. MKIDs are made of superconductors whose energy gap determines the detector frequency range. The energy gap depends on Tc, the critical temperature of the superconductor. It is thus important to be able to adjust Tc in order to choose the suitable frequency range. When using a single-layer MKID, the Tc is fixed by the superconducting gap energy of the unique component and cannot be changed. One possibility is to make a bilayer MKID using the proximity effect to adjust its critical temperature. This paper presents our new study on MKIDs made of superconductor/metal bilayers. We investigated niobium and copper bilayers (Nb/Cu) and fabricated different bilayers in our clean room. The critical temperature of each of them has been measured. We show that the Tc depends on the ratio between Nb and Cu thicknesses and that we are able to control it. Then, we characterized one of these Nb/Cu bilayers (Nb = 8 nm and Cu = 22 nm) once integrated in a MKID. We measured the temperature dependence of the resonant frequency, and we achieved quality factors as high as 2 × 104. The measurement of the noise spectrum provided a lower limit equal to -85 dBc/Hz, and the calculation of the noise equivalent power has shown that the sensitivity of the Nb/Cu bilayer MKID is not very far from that of an Al monolayer MKID.

IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity•Feb 19, 2016•17 citations

Die separation for mitigation of phonon bursts in superconducting circuits

Guy Moshel, Omer Rabinowitz, Eliya Blumenthal +1 more

Cosmic rays and background radioactive decay can deposit significant energy into superconducting quantum circuits on planar chips. This energy converts into pair-breaking phonons that travel across the substrate and generate quasiparticles, leading to correlated energy and phase errors in nearby qubits. To mitigate this, we fabricated two separate dies and placed them adjacently without a galvanic connection between them. This blocks phonon propagation from one die to the other. Using microwave kinetic inductance detectors on both dies, we detected high-energy bursts and demonstrated the blocking effect. However, we also observed simultaneous events in both dies, likely originating from a single cosmic particle traversing both dies.

arXiv:2505.16272•Applied Physics Letters•Aug 4, 2025•0 citations

Antenna-coupled Microwave Kinetic Inductance detectors (MKIDs) for mm and submm imaging arrays

Anastasios Vayonakis, James A. Schlaerth, S. Kumar +9 more

We present results from completely lithographic antenna-coupled Microwave Kinetic Inductance detectors (MKIDs). MKIDs are superconducting resonators with resonant frequency and quality-factor which are highly sensitive to changes in the density of the quasiparticle population which occurs when photons above the superconducting gap energy are absorbed. The resonators are coupled to submm light through on-chip phased-array slot antennas. Each planar antenna consists of an array of N long slots which are fed along their length at M points. The resulting N*M feed points are combined in-phase using a binary summing tree made of low-loss superconducting microstrip lines. Due to its large size, the resulting planar antenna produces a narrow beam pattern and can therefore be used without additional optical coupling elements such as feedhorns or substrate lenses. The output of the antenna is a single superconducting thin-film microstrip line which can be efficiently coupled to one (or more) kinetic inductance coplanar waveguide resonators to produce a single (or multi-color) pixel in an imaging focal plane array, using in-line lumped element lithographic band-pass filters. Such highly integrated architectures can be easily fabricated on a single substrate, and many detectors can be frequency multiplexed through coupling to a single feedline. Microwave readout provides a lot of bandwidth per detector, allowing a large number of pixels to be read using a single cryogenic microwave amplifier and warm readout electronics.

Softwaretechnik-Trends•Apr 1, 2008•1 citation

Three-dimensional microwave kinetic inductance detectors

Nicholas F. Cothard, Thomas R. Stevenson, Christine A. Jhabvala +1 more

We present the design and optical characterization of a novel highly compact three-dimensional microwave kinetic inductance detector (3D-MKID). At short wavelengths, such as the far- and mid-infrared, the pixel density of MKID arrays is often limited by the size and geometry of each resonator’s capacitor. Sending the non-optically active component of the resonator into the third dimension minimizes the footprint of each pixel, allowing much higher array densities to be achieved. In our 3D-MKID design, we compactify the resonator by conformally coating deep-etched holes in the silicon substrate with superconducting films formed by atomic layer deposition. The resulting geometry consists of three-dimensional coaxial transmission lines, which are then connected to a meandered absorber on the substrate surface. An array of these resonators are capacitively coupled to a microstrip feedline. We present the characterization of a prototype 3D-MKID array and compare it to simulate resonator properties. We additionally describe the detector sensitivity performance when illuminated by a far-infrared blackbody source.

Millimeter, Submillimeter, and Far-Infrared Detectors and Instrumentation for Astronomy XI•Aug 16, 2024•0 citations

Superconducting Microwave Resonator Arrays for Submillimeter/Far-infrared Imaging

Omid Noroozian

Superconducting microwave resonators have the potential to revolutionize submillimeter and far-infrared astronomy, and with it our understanding of the universe. The field of low-temperature detector technology has reached a point where extremely sensitive devices like transition-edge sensors are now capable of detecting radiation limited by the background noise of the universe. However, the size of these detector arrays are limited to only a few thousand pixels. This is because of the cost and complexity of fabricating large-scale arrays of these detectors that can reach up to 10 lithographic levels on chip, and the complicated SQUID-based multiplexing circuitry and wiring for readout of each detector. In order to make substantial progress, next- generation ground-based telescopes such as CCAT or future space telescopes require focal planes with large-scale detector arrays of 104–106 pixels. Arrays using microwave kinetic inductance detectors (MKID) are a potential solution. These arrays can be easily made with a single layer of superconducting metal film deposited on a silicon substrate and pattered using conventional optical lithography. Furthermore, MKIDs are inherently multiplexable in the frequency domain, allowing ∼ 103 detectors to be read out using a single coaxial transmission line and cryogenic amplifier, drastically reducing cost and complexity. An MKID uses the change in the microwave surface impedance of a superconducting thin-film microresonator to detect photons. Absorption of photons in the superconductor breaks Cooper pairs into quasiparticles, changing the complex surface impedance, which results in a perturbation of resonator frequency and quality factor. For excitation and readout, the resonator is weakly coupled to a transmission line. The complex amplitude of a microwave probe signal tuned on-resonance and transmitted on the feedline past the resonator is perturbed as photons are absorbed in the superconductor. The perturbation can be detected using a cryogenic amplifier and subsequent homodyne mixing at room temperature. In an array of MKIDs, all the resonators are coupled to a shared feedline and are tuned to slightly different frequencies. They can be read out simultaneously using a comb of frequencies generated and measured using digital techniques. This thesis documents an effort to demonstrate the basic operation of ∼ 256 pixel arrays of lumped-element MKIDs made from superconducting TiNx on silicon. The resonators are designed and simulated for optimum operation. Various properties of the resonators and arrays are measured and compared to theoretical expectations. A particularly exciting observation is the extremely high quality factors (∼ 3 × 107) of our TiNx resonators which is essential for ultra-high sensitivity. The arrays are tightly packed both in space and in frequency which is desirable for larger full-size arrays. However, this can cause a serious problem in terms of microwave crosstalk between neighboring pixels. We show that by properly designing the resonator geometry, crosstalk can be eliminated; this is supported by our measurement results. We also tackle the problem of excess frequency noise in MKIDs. Intrinsic noise in the form of an excess resonance frequency jitter exists in planar superconducting resonators that are made on dielectric substrates. We conclusively show that this noise is due to fluctuations of the resonator capacitance. In turn, the capacitance fluctuations are thought to be driven by two-level system (TLS) fluctuators in a thin layer on the surface of the device. With a modified resonator design we demonstrate with measurements that this noise can be substantially reduced. An optimized version of this resonator was designed for the multiwavelength submillimeter kinetic inductance camera (MUSIC) instrument for the Caltech Submillimeter Observatory.

•Jun 12, 2012•14 citations
For space observatories, the glitches caused by high energy phonons created by the interaction of cosmic ray particles with a detector substrate lead to dead time during observation. Mitigating the impact of cosmic rays is therefore an important requirement for detectors to be used in future space missions. In order to investigate possible solutions, we carry out a systematic study by testing four large arrays of Microwave Kinetic Inductance Detectors (MKIDs), each consisting of ∼960 pixels and fabricated on monolithic 55 mm × 55 mm × 0.35 mm Si substrates. We compare the response to cosmic ray interactions in our laboratory for different detector arrays: A standard array with only the MKID array as reference, an array with a low Tc superconducting film as a phonon absorber on the opposite side of the substrate, and arrays with MKIDs on membranes. The idea is that the low Tc layer down converts the phonon energy to values below the pair breaking threshold of the MKIDs, and the membranes isolate the sensitive part of the MKIDs from phonons created in the substrate. We find that the dead time can be reduced up to a factor of 40 when compared to the reference array. Simulations show that the dead time can be reduced to below 1% for the tested detector arrays when operated in a spacecraft in an L2 or a similar far-Earth orbit. The technique described here is also applicable and important for large superconducting qubit arrays for future quantum computers.
Microwave Kinetic Inductance Detectors (MKIDs) are extremely sensitive radiation detectors based on superconducting resonators that can be combined in large arrays on a single readout line within a limited frequency bandwidth. This makes MKIDs ideal detectors for the ultimate far-infrared observatory: a future space-based actively cooled telescope with its performance solely limited by the low universe background radiation. However, to reach these detector requirements, state-of-the-art MKIDs still need a order of magnitude improvement in device sensitivity. In this work, the MKID sensitivity is improved by reducing the aluminium volume that absorbs pair-breaking radiation into quasiparticle excitations, while making sure all radiation is still absorbed. Furthermore, a key requirement is sufficient reduction of excess noise as to keep the device intrinsically limited by thermally driven random fluctuations in the number of quasiparticles in absence of radiation, or Generation-Recombination (G-R) noise. To this end, a model is developed that describes the noise contributions as function of device geometry, readout power, material properties and radiation power. Subsequently, a realistic MKID design is presented and tested that reduces excess noise and maximises the sensitivity, expressed as Noise Equivalent Power (NEP). At high temperatures, good overall agreement is found between the measured noise spectra and the model. At low temperature T = 120 mK, the measurement results give an optical NEP similar to current state-of-the-art MKIDs. The NEP is not as low as expected due to short quasiparticle lifetimes, an unexpected decrease in the G-R noise level and a very high excess noise attributed to Two-Level Systems (TLS) noise that starts to dominate the already low G-R noise spectrum at low temperatures. Possibly, the quick quasiparticle lifetime saturation and noise level drop are caused by a strong readout power effect, as the readout power is known to create excess quasiparticles and to cause a strongly non-thermal electron energy distribution in the aluminium strip of the MKID. However, the exact microscopic details of these effects are unknown and not studied in this project. Based on the current chip design, a straightforward way to improve device performance and study the readout power effect in more detail is a reduction of the high TLS noise levels, which is possibly fabrication related. This would allow an unobstructed view of the G-R noise spectrum at low temperatures, thereby allowing both a study of the readout power effect on the quasiparticle system, and ultimately achieving the improvement in NEP needed reach the detector requirements for the ultimate space-based far-infrared observatory.
Due to their multiplexing capability and their good sensitivity to radiation from submillimeter to X-ray wavelengths, microwave kinetic inductance detectors (MKIDs) are increasingly used in the field of astrophysics. The Advanced Technology Center of the National Astronomical Observatory of Japan is developing MKIDs for astronomical observations such as CMB B-mode search with LiteBIRD. MKIDs are made of superconductors whose energy gap determines the detector frequency range. The energy gap depends on Tc, the critical temperature of the superconductor. It is thus important to be able to adjust Tc in order to choose the suitable frequency range. When using a single-layer MKID, the Tc is fixed by the superconducting gap energy of the unique component and cannot be changed. One possibility is to make a bilayer MKID using the proximity effect to adjust its critical temperature. This paper presents our new study on MKIDs made of superconductor/metal bilayers. We investigated niobium and copper bilayers (Nb/Cu) and fabricated different bilayers in our clean room. The critical temperature of each of them has been measured. We show that the Tc depends on the ratio between Nb and Cu thicknesses and that we are able to control it. Then, we characterized one of these Nb/Cu bilayers (Nb = 8 nm and Cu = 22 nm) once integrated in a MKID. We measured the temperature dependence of the resonant frequency, and we achieved quality factors as high as 2 × 104. The measurement of the noise spectrum provided a lower limit equal to -85 dBc/Hz, and the calculation of the noise equivalent power has shown that the sensitivity of the Nb/Cu bilayer MKID is not very far from that of an Al monolayer MKID.
Cosmic rays and background radioactive decay can deposit significant energy into superconducting quantum circuits on planar chips. This energy converts into pair-breaking phonons that travel across the substrate and generate quasiparticles, leading to correlated energy and phase errors in nearby qubits. To mitigate this, we fabricated two separate dies and placed them adjacently without a galvanic connection between them. This blocks phonon propagation from one die to the other. Using microwave kinetic inductance detectors on both dies, we detected high-energy bursts and demonstrated the blocking effect. However, we also observed simultaneous events in both dies, likely originating from a single cosmic particle traversing both dies.
We present results from completely lithographic antenna-coupled Microwave Kinetic Inductance detectors (MKIDs). MKIDs are superconducting resonators with resonant frequency and quality-factor which are highly sensitive to changes in the density of the quasiparticle population which occurs when photons above the superconducting gap energy are absorbed. The resonators are coupled to submm light through on-chip phased-array slot antennas. Each planar antenna consists of an array of N long slots which are fed along their length at M points. The resulting N*M feed points are combined in-phase using a binary summing tree made of low-loss superconducting microstrip lines. Due to its large size, the resulting planar antenna produces a narrow beam pattern and can therefore be used without additional optical coupling elements such as feedhorns or substrate lenses. The output of the antenna is a single superconducting thin-film microstrip line which can be efficiently coupled to one (or more) kinetic inductance coplanar waveguide resonators to produce a single (or multi-color) pixel in an imaging focal plane array, using in-line lumped element lithographic band-pass filters. Such highly integrated architectures can be easily fabricated on a single substrate, and many detectors can be frequency multiplexed through coupling to a single feedline. Microwave readout provides a lot of bandwidth per detector, allowing a large number of pixels to be read using a single cryogenic microwave amplifier and warm readout electronics.
We present the design and optical characterization of a novel highly compact three-dimensional microwave kinetic inductance detector (3D-MKID). At short wavelengths, such as the far- and mid-infrared, the pixel density of MKID arrays is often limited by the size and geometry of each resonator’s capacitor. Sending the non-optically active component of the resonator into the third dimension minimizes the footprint of each pixel, allowing much higher array densities to be achieved. In our 3D-MKID design, we compactify the resonator by conformally coating deep-etched holes in the silicon substrate with superconducting films formed by atomic layer deposition. The resulting geometry consists of three-dimensional coaxial transmission lines, which are then connected to a meandered absorber on the substrate surface. An array of these resonators are capacitively coupled to a microstrip feedline. We present the characterization of a prototype 3D-MKID array and compare it to simulate resonator properties. We additionally describe the detector sensitivity performance when illuminated by a far-infrared blackbody source.
Superconducting microwave resonators have the potential to revolutionize submillimeter and far-infrared astronomy, and with it our understanding of the universe. The field of low-temperature detector technology has reached a point where extremely sensitive devices like transition-edge sensors are now capable of detecting radiation limited by the background noise of the universe. However, the size of these detector arrays are limited to only a few thousand pixels. This is because of the cost and complexity of fabricating large-scale arrays of these detectors that can reach up to 10 lithographic levels on chip, and the complicated SQUID-based multiplexing circuitry and wiring for readout of each detector. In order to make substantial progress, next- generation ground-based telescopes such as CCAT or future space telescopes require focal planes with large-scale detector arrays of 104–106 pixels. Arrays using microwave kinetic inductance detectors (MKID) are a potential solution. These arrays can be easily made with a single layer of superconducting metal film deposited on a silicon substrate and pattered using conventional optical lithography. Furthermore, MKIDs are inherently multiplexable in the frequency domain, allowing ∼ 103 detectors to be read out using a single coaxial transmission line and cryogenic amplifier, drastically reducing cost and complexity. An MKID uses the change in the microwave surface impedance of a superconducting thin-film microresonator to detect photons. Absorption of photons in the superconductor breaks Cooper pairs into quasiparticles, changing the complex surface impedance, which results in a perturbation of resonator frequency and quality factor. For excitation and readout, the resonator is weakly coupled to a transmission line. The complex amplitude of a microwave probe signal tuned on-resonance and transmitted on the feedline past the resonator is perturbed as photons are absorbed in the superconductor. The perturbation can be detected using a cryogenic amplifier and subsequent homodyne mixing at room temperature. In an array of MKIDs, all the resonators are coupled to a shared feedline and are tuned to slightly different frequencies. They can be read out simultaneously using a comb of frequencies generated and measured using digital techniques. This thesis documents an effort to demonstrate the basic operation of ∼ 256 pixel arrays of lumped-element MKIDs made from superconducting TiNx on silicon. The resonators are designed and simulated for optimum operation. Various properties of the resonators and arrays are measured and compared to theoretical expectations. A particularly exciting observation is the extremely high quality factors (∼ 3 × 107) of our TiNx resonators which is essential for ultra-high sensitivity. The arrays are tightly packed both in space and in frequency which is desirable for larger full-size arrays. However, this can cause a serious problem in terms of microwave crosstalk between neighboring pixels. We show that by properly designing the resonator geometry, crosstalk can be eliminated; this is supported by our measurement results. We also tackle the problem of excess frequency noise in MKIDs. Intrinsic noise in the form of an excess resonance frequency jitter exists in planar superconducting resonators that are made on dielectric substrates. We conclusively show that this noise is due to fluctuations of the resonator capacitance. In turn, the capacitance fluctuations are thought to be driven by two-level system (TLS) fluctuators in a thin layer on the surface of the device. With a modified resonator design we demonstrate with measurements that this noise can be substantially reduced. An optimized version of this resonator was designed for the multiwavelength submillimeter kinetic inductance camera (MUSIC) instrument for the Caltech Submillimeter Observatory.