Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1812.11060 · Physical review. D/Physical review. D.

Impact of irrelevant deformations on thermodynamics and transport in holographic quantum critical states

Richard A. Davison, Simon A. Gentle, Blaise Goutéraux

Published Oct 29, 2019• 28 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study thermodynamic and transport observables of quantum critical states that arise in the infrared limit of holographic renormalization group flows. Although these observables are expected to exhibit quantum critical scaling, there are a number of cases in which their frequency and temperature dependences are in apparent contradiction with scaling theories. We study two different classes of examples and show in both cases that the apparent breakdown of scaling is a consequence of the dependence of observables on an irrelevant deformation of the quantum critical state. By assigning scaling dimensions to the near-horizon observables, we formulate improved scaling theories that are completely consistent with all explicit holographic results once the dependence on the dangerously irrelevant coupling is properly accounted for. In addition to governing thermodynamic and transport phenomena in these states, we show that the dangerously irrelevant coupling also controls late-time equilibration, which occurs at a rate parametrically slower than the temperature $1/{\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}\ensuremath{\ll}T$. At very late times, transport is diffusion-dominated, with a diffusivity that can be written simply in terms of ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}$ and the butterfly velocity, $D\ensuremath{\sim}{v}_{B}^{2}{\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}$. We conjecture that in such cases there exists a long-lived, propagating collective mode with velocity ${v}_{s}$, and in this case the relation $D={v}_{s}^{2}{\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}$ holds exactly in the limit ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}T\ensuremath{\gg}1$.

DOI
10.1103/physrevd.100.086020

Related papers

Slow Relaxation and Diffusion in Holographic Quantum Critical Phases

Richard A. Davison, Simon A. Gentle, Blaise Goutéraux

The dissipative dynamics of strongly interacting systems are often characterized by the timescale set by the inverse temperature ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{P}\ensuremath{\sim}\ensuremath{\hbar}/({k}_{B}T)$. We show that near a class of strongly interacting quantum critical points that arise in the infrared limit of translationally invariant holographic theories, there is a collective excitation (a quasinormal mode of the dual black hole spacetime) whose lifetime ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}$ is parametrically longer than ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{P}$: ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}\ensuremath{\gg}{T}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$. The lifetime is enhanced due to its dependence on a dangerously irrelevant coupling that breaks the particle-hole symmetry and the invariance under Lorentz boosts of the quantum critical point. The thermal diffusivity (in units of the butterfly velocity) is anomalously large near the quantum critical point and is governed by ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}$ rather than ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{P}$. We conjecture that there exists a long-lived, propagating collective mode with velocity ${v}_{s}$, and in this case the relation $D={v}_{s}^{2}{\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}$ holds exactly in the limit $T{\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}\ensuremath{\gg}1$. While scale invariance is broken, a generalized scaling theory still holds provided that the dependence of observables on the dangerously irrelevant coupling is incorporated. Our work further underlines the connection between dangerously irrelevant deformations and slow equilibration.

arXiv:1808.05659•Physical Review Letters•Oct 4, 2019•41 citations

Hydrodynamic Diffusion and Its Breakdown near AdS2 Quantum Critical Points

Daniel Areán, Richard A. Davison, Blaise Goutéraux +1 more

Hydrodynamics provides a universal description of interacting quantum field theories at sufficiently long times and wavelengths, but breaks down at scales dependent on microscopic details of the theory.In the vicinity of a quantum critical point, it is expected that some aspects of the dynamics are universal and dictated by properties of the critical point.We use gauge-gravity duality to investigate the breakdown of diffusive hydrodynamics in two low-temperature states dual to black holes with AdS 2 horizons, which exhibit quantum critical dynamics with an emergent scaling symmetry in time.We find that the breakdown is characterized by a collision between the diffusive pole of the retarded Green's function with a pole associated to the AdS 2 region of the geometry, such that the local equilibration time is set by infrared properties of the theory.The absolute values of the frequency and wave vector at the collision (ω eq and k eq ) provide a natural characterization of all the low-temperature diffusivities D of the states via D ¼ ω eq =k 2 eq , where ω eq ¼ 2πΔT is set by the temperature T and the scaling dimension Δ of an operator of the infrared quantum critical theory.We confirm that these relations are also satisfied in a Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev chain model in the limit of strong interactions.Our work paves the way toward a deeper understanding of transport in quantum critical phases.

arXiv:2011.12301•Physical Review X•Jul 29, 2021•55 citations

Holographic butterfly effect and diffusion in quantum critical region

Yi Ling, Zhuo-Yu Xian

We investigate the butterfly effect and charge diffusion near the quantum phase transition in holographic approach. We argue that their criticality is controlled by the holographic scaling geometry with deformations induced by a relevant operator at finite temperature. Specifically, in the quantum critical region controlled by a single fixed point, the butterfly velocity decreases when deviating from the critical point. While, in the non-critical region, the behavior of the butterfly velocity depends on the specific phase at low temperature. Moreover, in the holographic Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless transition, the universal behavior of the butterfly velocity is absent. Finally, the tendency of our holographic results matches with the numerical results of Bose-Hubbard model. A comparison between our result and that in the O(N ) nonlinear sigma model is also given.

arXiv:1707.02843•Journal of High Energy Physics•Sep 1, 2017•30 citations

Holography and strongly correlated systems

Nabil Iqbal

In this thesis we apply techniques arising from string theory - gauge-gravity/duality, or holography - to problems associated with strongly coupled quantum field theories under extreme conditions such as finite temperature or density. We first study a strongly coupled field theory at finite temperature. We demonstrate that its low frequency limit is determined by the horizon geometry of its gravity dual, i.e. by the "membrane paradigm" fluid of classical black hole mechanics. Thus generic boundary theory transport coefficients can be expressed in terms of geometric quantities evaluated at the horizon, providing a simple understanding of results such as the universality of the shear viscosity in theories with gravity duals. Away from the low frequency limit we find a nontrivial radial flow from the black hole horizon to the boundary of the spacetime; we derive equations governing this flow and demonstrate their use in the simple examples of charge and momentum diffusion. Next, we turn to the study of strongly coupled theories with a finite density of a U(1) charge. The near-horizon geometry of the gravity dual of such a state has an AdS 2 factor, indicating the existence of a nontrivial emergent conformal symmetry in the infrared with nontrivial scaling only in the time direction. We review earlier work indicating that fermionic perturbations of such a state reveal non-Fermi-liquid behavior, i.e. gapless fermionic excitations that are not those of Fermi liquid theory. We perform a one-loop calculation in the bulk to compute the contribution from these Fermi surfaces to the conductivity of the full system. Interestingly, within this class of non-Fermi liquids we find examples whose single-particle spectral function and transport behavior both resemble those of strange metals, i.e. the anomalous metallic state existing in the real-life high Tc cuprates above their superconducting transition temperature. In particular, for these examples the contribution to the conductivity is inversely proportional to temperature. In our treatment these properties can be understood as being controlled by the scaling dimension of the fermion operator in the emergent IR fixed point. We then turn to models of symmetry breaking in holographic models at finite density. We observe that the presence of the AdS₂ factor can result in the condensation of a neutral scalar operator. This can be used to model an "antiferromagnetic" phase in which a global SU(2) symmetry is broken down to U(1). We study the collective modes of the ordered phase and recover the expected spin waves from a gravitational treatment. We then note that the phase transition can be driven to zero temperature by tuning various bulk couplings, resulting in a quantum phase transition of the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless type. We study this transition in detail, revealing novel critical behavior, including locally quantum critical dynamics and the existence of an infinite tower of excited states related by a discrete subgroup of the original emergent conformal symmetry. Throughout this thesis we focus on how the novel viewpoint provided by holography can help us gain new insights into the physics of strongly correlated systems.

•Jan 1, 2011•1 citation

Thermal diffusivity and butterfly velocity in anisotropic Q-lattice models

Hyun-Sik Jeong, Yongjun Ahn, Dujin Ahn +3 more

We study a relation between the thermal diffusivity (D T ) and two quantum chaotic properties, Lyapunov time (τ L ) and butterfly velocity (v B ) in strongly correlated systems by using a holographic method. Recently, it was shown that $$ {\mathbb{E}}_i:={D}_{T,i}/\left({v}_{{}^{B,i}}^2{\tau}_L\right)\left(i=x,y\right) $$ is universal in the sense that it is determined only by some scaling exponents of the IR metric in the low temperature limit regardless of the matter fields and ultraviolet data. Inspired by this observation, by analyzing the anisotropic IR scaling geometry carefully, we find the concrete expressions for $$ {\mathbb{E}}_i $$ in terms of the critical dynamical exponents z i in each direction, $$ {\mathbb{E}}_i={z}_i/2\left({z}_i-1\right) $$ . Furthermore, we find the lower bound of $$ {\mathbb{E}}_i $$ is always 1/2, which is not affected by anisotropy, contrary to the η/s case. However, there may be an upper bound determined by given fixed anisotropy.

arXiv:1708.08822•Journal of High Energy Physics•Jan 1, 2018•56 citations

Universal Charge Diffusion and the Butterfly Effect in Holographic Theories

Mike Blake

We study charge diffusion in holographic scaling theories with a particle-hole symmetry. We show that these theories have a universal regime in which the diffusion constant is given by D_{c}=Cv_{B}^{2}/(2πT), where v_{B} is the velocity of the butterfly effect. The constant of proportionality C depends only on the scaling exponents of the infrared theory. Our results suggest an unexpected connection between transport at strong coupling and quantum chaos.

arXiv:1603.08510•Physical Review Letters•Aug 23, 2016•240 citations
We study thermodynamic and transport observables of quantum critical states that arise in the infrared limit of holographic renormalization group flows. Although these observables are expected to exhibit quantum critical scaling, there are a number of cases in which their frequency and temperature dependences are in apparent contradiction with scaling theories. We study two different classes of examples and show in both cases that the apparent breakdown of scaling is a consequence of the dependence of observables on an irrelevant deformation of the quantum critical state. By assigning scaling dimensions to the near-horizon observables, we formulate improved scaling theories that are completely consistent with all explicit holographic results once the dependence on the dangerously irrelevant coupling is properly accounted for. In addition to governing thermodynamic and transport phenomena in these states, we show that the dangerously irrelevant coupling also controls late-time equilibration, which occurs at a rate parametrically slower than the temperature 1/\ensuremathτeq\ensuremath≪T1/{\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}\ensuremath{\ll}T1/\ensuremathτeq​\ensuremath≪T. At very late times, transport is diffusion-dominated, with a diffusivity that can be written simply in terms of \ensuremathτeq{\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}\ensuremathτeq​ and the butterfly velocity, D\ensuremath∼vB2\ensuremathτeqD\ensuremath{\sim}{v}_{B}^{2}{\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}D\ensuremath∼vB2​\ensuremathτeq​. We conjecture that in such cases there exists a long-lived, propagating collective mode with velocity vs{v}_{s}vs​, and in this case the relation D=vs2\ensuremathτeqD={v}_{s}^{2}{\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}D=vs2​\ensuremathτeq​ holds exactly in the limit \ensuremathτeqT\ensuremath≫1{\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}T\ensuremath{\gg}1\ensuremathτeq​T\ensuremath≫1.
The dissipative dynamics of strongly interacting systems are often characterized by the timescale set by the inverse temperature ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{P}\ensuremath{\sim}\ensuremath{\hbar}/({k}_{B}T)$. We show that near a class of strongly interacting quantum critical points that arise in the infrared limit of translationally invariant holographic theories, there is a collective excitation (a quasinormal mode of the dual black hole spacetime) whose lifetime ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}$ is parametrically longer than ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{P}$: ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}\ensuremath{\gg}{T}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$. The lifetime is enhanced due to its dependence on a dangerously irrelevant coupling that breaks the particle-hole symmetry and the invariance under Lorentz boosts of the quantum critical point. The thermal diffusivity (in units of the butterfly velocity) is anomalously large near the quantum critical point and is governed by ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}$ rather than ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{P}$. We conjecture that there exists a long-lived, propagating collective mode with velocity vs{v}_{s}vs​, and in this case the relation $D={v}_{s}^{2}{\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}$ holds exactly in the limit $T{\ensuremath{\tau}}_{\mathrm{eq}}\ensuremath{\gg}1$. While scale invariance is broken, a generalized scaling theory still holds provided that the dependence of observables on the dangerously irrelevant coupling is incorporated. Our work further underlines the connection between dangerously irrelevant deformations and slow equilibration.
Hydrodynamics provides a universal description of interacting quantum field theories at sufficiently long times and wavelengths, but breaks down at scales dependent on microscopic details of the theory.In the vicinity of a quantum critical point, it is expected that some aspects of the dynamics are universal and dictated by properties of the critical point.We use gauge-gravity duality to investigate the breakdown of diffusive hydrodynamics in two low-temperature states dual to black holes with AdS 2 horizons, which exhibit quantum critical dynamics with an emergent scaling symmetry in time.We find that the breakdown is characterized by a collision between the diffusive pole of the retarded Green's function with a pole associated to the AdS 2 region of the geometry, such that the local equilibration time is set by infrared properties of the theory.The absolute values of the frequency and wave vector at the collision (ω eq and k eq ) provide a natural characterization of all the low-temperature diffusivities D of the states via D ¼ ω eq =k 2 eq , where ω eq ¼ 2πΔT is set by the temperature T and the scaling dimension Δ of an operator of the infrared quantum critical theory.We confirm that these relations are also satisfied in a Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev chain model in the limit of strong interactions.Our work paves the way toward a deeper understanding of transport in quantum critical phases.
We investigate the butterfly effect and charge diffusion near the quantum phase transition in holographic approach. We argue that their criticality is controlled by the holographic scaling geometry with deformations induced by a relevant operator at finite temperature. Specifically, in the quantum critical region controlled by a single fixed point, the butterfly velocity decreases when deviating from the critical point. While, in the non-critical region, the behavior of the butterfly velocity depends on the specific phase at low temperature. Moreover, in the holographic Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless transition, the universal behavior of the butterfly velocity is absent. Finally, the tendency of our holographic results matches with the numerical results of Bose-Hubbard model. A comparison between our result and that in the O(N ) nonlinear sigma model is also given.
In this thesis we apply techniques arising from string theory - gauge-gravity/duality, or holography - to problems associated with strongly coupled quantum field theories under extreme conditions such as finite temperature or density. We first study a strongly coupled field theory at finite temperature. We demonstrate that its low frequency limit is determined by the horizon geometry of its gravity dual, i.e. by the "membrane paradigm" fluid of classical black hole mechanics. Thus generic boundary theory transport coefficients can be expressed in terms of geometric quantities evaluated at the horizon, providing a simple understanding of results such as the universality of the shear viscosity in theories with gravity duals. Away from the low frequency limit we find a nontrivial radial flow from the black hole horizon to the boundary of the spacetime; we derive equations governing this flow and demonstrate their use in the simple examples of charge and momentum diffusion. Next, we turn to the study of strongly coupled theories with a finite density of a U(1) charge. The near-horizon geometry of the gravity dual of such a state has an AdS 2 factor, indicating the existence of a nontrivial emergent conformal symmetry in the infrared with nontrivial scaling only in the time direction. We review earlier work indicating that fermionic perturbations of such a state reveal non-Fermi-liquid behavior, i.e. gapless fermionic excitations that are not those of Fermi liquid theory. We perform a one-loop calculation in the bulk to compute the contribution from these Fermi surfaces to the conductivity of the full system. Interestingly, within this class of non-Fermi liquids we find examples whose single-particle spectral function and transport behavior both resemble those of strange metals, i.e. the anomalous metallic state existing in the real-life high Tc cuprates above their superconducting transition temperature. In particular, for these examples the contribution to the conductivity is inversely proportional to temperature. In our treatment these properties can be understood as being controlled by the scaling dimension of the fermion operator in the emergent IR fixed point. We then turn to models of symmetry breaking in holographic models at finite density. We observe that the presence of the AdS₂ factor can result in the condensation of a neutral scalar operator. This can be used to model an "antiferromagnetic" phase in which a global SU(2) symmetry is broken down to U(1). We study the collective modes of the ordered phase and recover the expected spin waves from a gravitational treatment. We then note that the phase transition can be driven to zero temperature by tuning various bulk couplings, resulting in a quantum phase transition of the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless type. We study this transition in detail, revealing novel critical behavior, including locally quantum critical dynamics and the existence of an infinite tower of excited states related by a discrete subgroup of the original emergent conformal symmetry. Throughout this thesis we focus on how the novel viewpoint provided by holography can help us gain new insights into the physics of strongly correlated systems.
We study a relation between the thermal diffusivity (D T ) and two quantum chaotic properties, Lyapunov time (τ L ) and butterfly velocity (v B ) in strongly correlated systems by using a holographic method. Recently, it was shown that Ei:=DT,i/(vB,i2τL)(i=x,y) {\mathbb{E}}_i:={D}_{T,i}/\left({v}_{{}^{B,i}}^2{\tau}_L\right)\left(i=x,y\right) Ei​:=DT,i​/(vB,i2​τL​)(i=x,y) is universal in the sense that it is determined only by some scaling exponents of the IR metric in the low temperature limit regardless of the matter fields and ultraviolet data. Inspired by this observation, by analyzing the anisotropic IR scaling geometry carefully, we find the concrete expressions for Ei {\mathbb{E}}_i Ei​ in terms of the critical dynamical exponents z i in each direction, Ei=zi/2(zi−1) {\mathbb{E}}_i={z}_i/2\left({z}_i-1\right) Ei​=zi​/2(zi​−1) . Furthermore, we find the lower bound of Ei {\mathbb{E}}_i Ei​ is always 1/2, which is not affected by anisotropy, contrary to the η/s case. However, there may be an upper bound determined by given fixed anisotropy.