Although condensed matter systems usually do not have higher-form symmetries, we show that, unlike 0-form symmetry, higher-form symmetries can emerge as exact symmetries at low energies and long distances. In particular, emergent higher-form symmetries at zero temperature are robust to arbitrary local UV perturbations in the thermodynamic limit. This result is true for both invertible and noninvertible higher-form symmetries. Therefore emergent higher-form symmetries are exact emergent symmetries: they are not UV symmetries but constrain low-energy dynamics as if they were. Since phases of matter are defined in the thermodynamic limit, this implies that a UV theory without higher-form symmetries can have phases characterized by exact emergent higher-form symmetries. We demonstrate this in three lattice models, the quantum clock model and emergent
ZN and
U(1)p-gauge theory, finding regions of parameter space with exact emergent (anomalous) higher-form symmetries. Furthermore, we perform a generalized Landau analysis of a
2+1D lattice model that gives rise to
Z2 gauge theory. Using exact emergent 1-form symmetries accompanied by their own energy/length scales, we show that the transition between the deconfined and Higgs/confined phases is continuous and equivalent to the spontaneous symmetry-breaking transition of a
Z2 symmetry, even though the lattice model has no symmetry. Also, we show that this transition line must always contain two parts separated by multi-critical points or other phase transitions. We discuss the physical consequences of exact emergent higher-form symmetries and contrast them to emergent 0-form symmetries. Lastly, we show that emergent 1-form symmetries are no longer exact at finite temperatures, but emergent
p-form symmetries with $p\ensuremath{\ge}2$ are.
Two global symmetries are holoequivalent if their algebras of local symmetric operators are isomorphic. A holoequivalent class of global symmetries is described by a topological order (TO) in one higher dimension (called symmetry TO), which leads to a symmetry/topological-order (Symm/TO) correspondence. We establish that (1) for systems with a symmetry described by symmetry TO
M, their gapped and gapless states are classified by condensable algebras
A, formed by elementary excitations in
M with trivial self-/mutual statistics. These so-called
A states can describe symmetry breaking orders, symmetry protected topological orders, symmetry enriched topological orders, gapless critical points, etc. in a unified way. (2) The local low-energy properties of an
A state can be calculated from its reduced symmetry TO
M/A, using holographic modular bootstrap (holoMB) which takes
M/A as an input. Here
M/A is obtained from
M by condensing excitations in
A. Notably, an
A state must be gapless if
M/A is nontrivial. This provides a unified understanding of the emergence and symmetry protection of gaplessness that applies to symmetries that are anomalous, higher-form, and/or noninvertible. (3) The relations between condensable algebras constrain the structure of the global phase diagram. We find that, for $1+1\mathrm{D} {\mathbb{Z}}_{2}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ symmetry with mixed anomaly, there is a stable continuous transition (deconfined quantum critical point) between the
Z2-breaking-${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}^{\ensuremath{'}}$-symmetric phase and the
Z2-symmetric-${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}^{\ensuremath{'}}$-breaking phase. The critical point is the same as a
Z4 symmetry breaking critical point. (4)
1+1D bosonic systems with
S3 symmetry have four gapped phases with unbroken symmetries
S3,Z3,Z2, and
Z1. We find a duality between two transitions ${S}_{3}\ensuremath{\leftrightarrow}{\mathbb{Z}}_{1}$ and ${\mathbb{Z}}_{3}\ensuremath{\leftrightarrow}{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$: they are either both first order or both (stably) continuous, and in the latter case, they are described by the same conformal field theory (CFT). (5) The gapped and gapless states for
1+1D bosonic systems with anomalous
S3 symmetries are obtained as well. For example, anomalous
S3(1) and
S3(2) symmetries can have symmetry protected chiral gapless states with only symmetric irrelevant and marginal operators.
A global symmetry (0-symmetry) in an n-dimensional space acts on the whole space.A higher symmetry acts on closed submanifolds (i.e., loops and membranes, etc.), and those transformations form a higher group.In this paper, we introduce the notion of algebraic higher symmetry, which generalizes higher symmetry and is beyond higher group.We show that an algebraic higher symmetry in a bosonic system in n-dimensional space is characterized and classified by a local fusion n-category.We find that, when restricted to its symmetric sub-Hilbert space, an algebraic higher symmetry can be fully characterized by a noninvertible gravitational anomaly (i.e., a topological order in one higher dimension).Thus, we also refer to a noninvertible gravitational anomaly as categorical symmetry to stress its connection to symmetry.This provides a holographic and entanglement view of symmetries.For a system with a categorical symmetry, its gapped state must spontaneously break part (not all) of the symmetry, and the state with the full symmetry must be gapless.Using such a holographic point of view, we obtain (1) the gauging of the algebraic higher symmetry; (2) the classification of anomalies for an algebraic higher symmetry; (3) the equivalence between classes of systems, with different (potentially anomalous) algebraic higher symmetries or different sets of low-energy excitations, as long as they have the same categorical symmetry; and (4) the classification of gapped liquid phases for bosonic and/or fermionic systems with a categorical symmetry, as gapped boundaries of a topological order in one higher dimension (that corresponds to the categorical symmetry).This classification includes symmetry protected trivial (SPT) orders and symmetry enriched topological (SET) orders with an algebraic higher symmetry.
We study several aspects of the realization of global symmetries in highly entangled phases of quantum matter. Examples include gapped topological ordered phases, gapless quantum spin liquids, and non-Fermi liquid phases. An insightful window into such phases is provided by recent developments in the theory of short-ranged entangled symmetry protected topological (SPT) phases. First, they generate useful no-go constraints on how global symmetry may be implemented in a highly entangled phase. Possible symmetry implementation in gapped topological phases and some proposed gapless spin/Bose liquids are examined in this light. We show that some previously proposed spin liquid states for 2D quantum magnets do not in fact have consistent symmetry implementation unless they occur as the surface of a 3D SPT phase. A second SPT-based insight into highly entangled states is the development of a view point of such states as SPT phases of one of the emergent excitations. We describe this in the specific context of time-reversal symmetric 3D U(1) quantum spin liquids with an emergent photon. Different such spin liquids are shown to be equivalent to different SPT insulating phases of the emergent monopole excitation of such phases. The highly entangled states also in turn enrich our understanding of SPT phases. We use the insights obtained from our results to provide an explicit construction of bosonic SPT phases in 3D in a system of coupled layers. This includes construction of a time-reversal symmetric SPT state that is not currently part of the cohomology classification of such states.
We discuss physical constructions and the boundary properties of various symmetry-protected topological phases that involve 1-form symmetries from one spatial dimension to four spatial dimensions (
4d). For example, the prototype three-dimensional (
3d) boundary state of
4d SPT states involving 1-form symmetries can be either a gapless photon phase (quantum electrodynamics) or gapped topological order enriched by 1-form symmetries; that is, the loop excitations of these topological orders carry nontrivial 1-form symmetry charges. This study also serves the purpose of diagnosing anomalies of
3d states of matter. Connection between SPT states with 1-form symmetries and condensed-matter systems such as quantum dimer models at one lower dimension will also be discussed. Whether a quantum dimer model can have a trivial gapped phase depends on the nature of its corresponding bulk state in one higher dimension.
One problem of paramount importance in physics over various fields such as elementary particle physics, condensed matter physics, and statistical mechanics has been to make classification of phases of matter, including nontrivial structures of the vacuum. The triumphant history of theory on the phase classification and the phase transition can be traced back to Landau, which is based on the spontaneous breaking of symmetry. It is known, however, that other kinds of phases exist that cannot be characterized by conventional arguments of symmetry breaking, namely, topological phases. Topological phases are gapped phases at zero temperature without symmetry breaking. Examples of the topological phases include a quantum phase in a fractional quantum Hall system, where the ground state exhibits degeneracy, and an anyon, a quasi-particle with nontrivial statistical nature, neither boson nor fermion, emerges as a low-energy excitation. In contemporary physics of the 21st century, it has been revealed that, among various topological states, there exists a nontrivial ground state that does not have ground state degeneracy and yet can be distinguished from a trivial state. This nontrivial ground state, i.e., a topological insulator, has been recognized first in free electron systems [1–3] and later extended to more general quantum many-body systems with interactions including bosonic (spin) systems. Now, such a generalized situation is called a symmetry protected topological (SPT) phase [4–7]. From the point of a modern view of the SPT phase, nontrivial states, such as the Haldane state proposed in antiferromagnetic quantum spin systems in the 1980’s [8] and the ground state in the Affleck-Kennedy-Lieb-Tasaki model [9], belong to the SPT phase. A remarkable feature of the SPT phase is that, if the system has a surface, gapless surface states appear and they are stable against disturbances which do not break the symmetry. One way to understand these surface states is the quantum anomaly on the surface. That is, as long as the surface is concerned, the quantum anomaly arises, but the whole system has no quantum anomaly, and the symmetry is preserved due to cancellation from the bulk contribution. This canceling mechanism of the quantum anomaly has been long known as the anomaly inflow in elementary particle physics [10]. In fact, the classification of the SPT phases can be identified as the classification of the quantum anomaly through the bulk-boundary correspondence. This type of the quantum anomaly closely related to the SPT phase can provide us with a useful theoretical device to constrain phases that can or cannot be realized under the ’t Hooft anomaly matching condition [11–13]. It is quite difficult to scrutinize nonperturbatively interacting systems, but the ’t Hooft anomaly matching condition can be applied to those systems, and possible phases can be constrained. Nowadays, our understanding of the SPT phases has been so developed that applications of the anomaly matching condition can cover systems with finite groups and/or extending objects [14–16]. In this way, the concept of the topological phases has been essential by now in a wide range of physics, particularly in elementary particle physics, condensed matter physics, and statistical mechanics, as mentioned in the beginning. This special section is a collection of papers related to the topological aspects of physics including the topological phases. We would like to express our sincere gratitude to all the authors who made excellent contributions.