Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1812.00425 · Physical Review A

Qubit positive-operator-valued measurements by destructive weak measurements

Yi‐Hsiang Chen, Todd A. Brun

Published Jun 28, 2019• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Many quantum measurements, such as photodetection, can be destructive. In photodetection, when the detector ``clicks'' a photon has been absorbed and destroyed. Yet the lack of a click also gives information about the presence or absence of a photon. In monitoring the emission of photons from a source, one decomposes the strong measurement into a series of weak measurements, which describe the evolution of the state during the measurement process. Motivated by this example of destructive photon detection, a simple model of destructive weak measurements using qubits was studied in earlier work by the authors. It has shown that the model can achieve any positive-operator-valued measurement (POVM) with commuting POVM elements including projective measurements. In this paper, we use a different approach for decomposing any POVM into a series of weak measurements. The process involves three steps: randomly choose, with certain probabilities, a set of linearly independent POVM elements; perform that POVM by a series of destructive weak measurements; and output the result of the series of weak measurements with certain probabilities. The probabilities of the outcomes from this process agree with those from the original POVM, and hence this model of destructive weak measurements can perform any qubit POVM.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.99.062121

Related papers

Decomposing qubit positive-operator-valued measurements into continuous destructive weak measurements

Yi‐Hsiang Chen, Todd A. Brun

It has been shown that any generalized measurement can be decomposed into a sequence of weak measurements corresponding to a stochastic process. However, the weak measurements may require almost arbitrary unitaries, which are unlikely to be realized by any real measurement device. Furthermore, many measurement processes are destructive, like photon counting procedures that terminate once all photons are consumed. One cannot expect to have full control of the evolution of a state under such destructive measurements, and the possible unitaries allow only a limited set of weak measurements. In this paper, we consider a qubit model of destructive weak measurements, which is a toy version of an optical cavity, in which the state of an electromagnetic field mode inside the cavity leaks out and is measured destructively while the vacuum state $|0\ensuremath{\rangle}$ leaks into the cavity. At long times, the state of the qubit inevitably evolves to be $|0\ensuremath{\rangle}$, and the only available control is the choice of measurement on the external ancilla system. Surprisingly, this very limited model can still perform an arbitrary projective measurement on the qubit in any basis, where the probability of getting an outcome satisfies the usual Born rule. Combining this method with probabilistic postprocessing, the result can be extended to any generalized measurement with commuting positive-operator-valued measurement (POVM) elements. This implies, among other results, that any two-outcome POVM on a qubit can be decomposed into a sequence of destructive weak measurements by this restricted measurement device.

arXiv:1804.03354•Physical Review A•Dec 18, 2018•2 citations

Positive operator valued measure in quantum information processing

Howard E. Brandt

The positive operator valued measure (POVM), also known as the probability operator valued measure, is useful in quantum information processing. The POVM consists of a set of non-negative quantum-mechanical Hermitian operators that add up to the identity. The probability that a quantum system is in a particular state is given by the expectation value of the POVM operator corresponding to that state. Following a brief review of the mathematics and history of POVMs in quantum theory, and a pedagogical discussion of the quantum mechanics of photonic qubits, a particular implementation of a POVM for use in the measurement of photonic qubits is reviewed.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Jul 6, 1998•1 citation

Positive operator valued measure in quantum information processing

Howard E. Brandt

The positive operator valued measure (POVM), also known as the probability operator valued measure, is useful in quantum information processing. The POVM consists of a set of non-negative quantum-mechanical Hermitian operators that add up to the identity. The probability that a quantum system is in a particular state is given by the expectation value of the POVM operator corresponding to that state. Following a brief review of the mathematics and history of POVMs in quantum theory, and an expository discussion of the quantum mechanics of photonic qubits, a particular implementation of a POVM for use in the measurement of photonic qubits is reviewed.

American Journal of Physics•May 1, 1999•67 citations

Fundamental Limits to Single-Photon Detection

Tzula B. Propp

Quantum mechanics cements the intimate relationship between the nature of light and its detection. Historically, quantum theories of photodetection have generally fallen into two categories: the first tries to determine what quantum field observable is measured when photoelectrons are detected, laying the theoretical groundwork for photodetection being possible. The second type are phenomenological theories, which take great care to model the details of specific photodetectors. In this dissertation, we fill in the gap between these two models in the modern literature on photodetection by constructing a fully quantum-mechanical and sufficiently realistic model that includes all stages of the photodetection process. We accomplish this within the framework of quantum information theory using the language of positive operator valued measures (POVMs). \n\nA POVM provides the most general description of a quantum measurement. In the context of single-photon detection, the photodetector POVM provides a complete characterization of the single-photon detector (SPD) from which all figures of merit can be calculated. Each element of the POVM is comprised of a weighted sum over single-photon state projectors. To construct SPD POVMs, we identify the states projected onto by a measurement and the associated weights. We first accomplish this for a simple time-dependent system, laying out how to efficiently project onto arbitrary single-photon states. Then, we describe the three stages of a realistic SPD: transmission, amplification, and measurement.\n\nIn the transmission stage of photodetection a photon enters a network of discrete energy levels, its energy propagating through that network and finally exiting into another output continuum of modes, a process entirely described by a single complex function. In the amplification stage of photodetection, a single excitation is amplified into a macroscopic signal via a nonlinear amplification mechanism. In the final stage, an inefficient ``classical'' measurement is made on the macroscopic signal. By combining these three stages we form a chain of inference from the final ``click'' to the input photon and construct a POVM projecting onto the input Hilbert space. Lastly, we discuss limits and tradeoffs that arise at each stage and implications for photodetection applications.\n\nThis dissertation contains previously published and unpublished material.

•Dec 8, 2020•0 citations

Decomposing positive operator valued measurements on qubits into destructive weak measurements

Yi‐Hsiang Chen, Todd A. Brun

Bulletin of the American Physical Society•Mar 5, 2018•0 citations

Phase transitions in sequential weak measurements

Wen-Long Ma, Ping Wang, Weng-Hang Leong +1 more

Quantum measurement can be strong or weak, the former being important in readout and initialization of quantum objects and the latter being useful for monitoring and maneuvering quantum evolution. However, the boundary between weak and strong measurement is unclear. Here we show that a phase transition occurs in sequential quantum measurement, which unambiguously separates the weak and strong measurement by a critical value of measurement strength or duration. We formulate the probability distribution of the output of a sequence of quantum measurements as the Boltzmann distribution of an interacting spin model. The measurement results present phase transitions similar to those in the spin model. In particular the sequential commuting positive operator-valued measurement is mapped to a long-range Ising model, and a projective measurement emerges from sequential weak measurements when the strength or the number of measurements becomes above certain critical values, corresponding to the ferromagnetic phase transition of the spin model. This finding sheds insights on sequential quantum measurement, and also provides the theoretical foundation for constructing projective measurements from sequential weak measurements, which have applications in steering the quantum evolution and initializing quantum systems where strong measurement in a single shot is often not possible.

arXiv:1711.02482•Physical Review A•Jul 13, 2018•25 citations
Many quantum measurements, such as photodetection, can be destructive. In photodetection, when the detector ``clicks'' a photon has been absorbed and destroyed. Yet the lack of a click also gives information about the presence or absence of a photon. In monitoring the emission of photons from a source, one decomposes the strong measurement into a series of weak measurements, which describe the evolution of the state during the measurement process. Motivated by this example of destructive photon detection, a simple model of destructive weak measurements using qubits was studied in earlier work by the authors. It has shown that the model can achieve any positive-operator-valued measurement (POVM) with commuting POVM elements including projective measurements. In this paper, we use a different approach for decomposing any POVM into a series of weak measurements. The process involves three steps: randomly choose, with certain probabilities, a set of linearly independent POVM elements; perform that POVM by a series of destructive weak measurements; and output the result of the series of weak measurements with certain probabilities. The probabilities of the outcomes from this process agree with those from the original POVM, and hence this model of destructive weak measurements can perform any qubit POVM.
It has been shown that any generalized measurement can be decomposed into a sequence of weak measurements corresponding to a stochastic process. However, the weak measurements may require almost arbitrary unitaries, which are unlikely to be realized by any real measurement device. Furthermore, many measurement processes are destructive, like photon counting procedures that terminate once all photons are consumed. One cannot expect to have full control of the evolution of a state under such destructive measurements, and the possible unitaries allow only a limited set of weak measurements. In this paper, we consider a qubit model of destructive weak measurements, which is a toy version of an optical cavity, in which the state of an electromagnetic field mode inside the cavity leaks out and is measured destructively while the vacuum state $|0\ensuremath{\rangle}$ leaks into the cavity. At long times, the state of the qubit inevitably evolves to be $|0\ensuremath{\rangle}$, and the only available control is the choice of measurement on the external ancilla system. Surprisingly, this very limited model can still perform an arbitrary projective measurement on the qubit in any basis, where the probability of getting an outcome satisfies the usual Born rule. Combining this method with probabilistic postprocessing, the result can be extended to any generalized measurement with commuting positive-operator-valued measurement (POVM) elements. This implies, among other results, that any two-outcome POVM on a qubit can be decomposed into a sequence of destructive weak measurements by this restricted measurement device.
The positive operator valued measure (POVM), also known as the probability operator valued measure, is useful in quantum information processing. The POVM consists of a set of non-negative quantum-mechanical Hermitian operators that add up to the identity. The probability that a quantum system is in a particular state is given by the expectation value of the POVM operator corresponding to that state. Following a brief review of the mathematics and history of POVMs in quantum theory, and a pedagogical discussion of the quantum mechanics of photonic qubits, a particular implementation of a POVM for use in the measurement of photonic qubits is reviewed.
The positive operator valued measure (POVM), also known as the probability operator valued measure, is useful in quantum information processing. The POVM consists of a set of non-negative quantum-mechanical Hermitian operators that add up to the identity. The probability that a quantum system is in a particular state is given by the expectation value of the POVM operator corresponding to that state. Following a brief review of the mathematics and history of POVMs in quantum theory, and an expository discussion of the quantum mechanics of photonic qubits, a particular implementation of a POVM for use in the measurement of photonic qubits is reviewed.
Quantum mechanics cements the intimate relationship between the nature of light and its detection. Historically, quantum theories of photodetection have generally fallen into two categories: the first tries to determine what quantum field observable is measured when photoelectrons are detected, laying the theoretical groundwork for photodetection being possible. The second type are phenomenological theories, which take great care to model the details of specific photodetectors. In this dissertation, we fill in the gap between these two models in the modern literature on photodetection by constructing a fully quantum-mechanical and sufficiently realistic model that includes all stages of the photodetection process. We accomplish this within the framework of quantum information theory using the language of positive operator valued measures (POVMs). \n\nA POVM provides the most general description of a quantum measurement. In the context of single-photon detection, the photodetector POVM provides a complete characterization of the single-photon detector (SPD) from which all figures of merit can be calculated. Each element of the POVM is comprised of a weighted sum over single-photon state projectors. To construct SPD POVMs, we identify the states projected onto by a measurement and the associated weights. We first accomplish this for a simple time-dependent system, laying out how to efficiently project onto arbitrary single-photon states. Then, we describe the three stages of a realistic SPD: transmission, amplification, and measurement.\n\nIn the transmission stage of photodetection a photon enters a network of discrete energy levels, its energy propagating through that network and finally exiting into another output continuum of modes, a process entirely described by a single complex function. In the amplification stage of photodetection, a single excitation is amplified into a macroscopic signal via a nonlinear amplification mechanism. In the final stage, an inefficient ``classical'' measurement is made on the macroscopic signal. By combining these three stages we form a chain of inference from the final ``click'' to the input photon and construct a POVM projecting onto the input Hilbert space. Lastly, we discuss limits and tradeoffs that arise at each stage and implications for photodetection applications.\n\nThis dissertation contains previously published and unpublished material.
Quantum measurement can be strong or weak, the former being important in readout and initialization of quantum objects and the latter being useful for monitoring and maneuvering quantum evolution. However, the boundary between weak and strong measurement is unclear. Here we show that a phase transition occurs in sequential quantum measurement, which unambiguously separates the weak and strong measurement by a critical value of measurement strength or duration. We formulate the probability distribution of the output of a sequence of quantum measurements as the Boltzmann distribution of an interacting spin model. The measurement results present phase transitions similar to those in the spin model. In particular the sequential commuting positive operator-valued measurement is mapped to a long-range Ising model, and a projective measurement emerges from sequential weak measurements when the strength or the number of measurements becomes above certain critical values, corresponding to the ferromagnetic phase transition of the spin model. This finding sheds insights on sequential quantum measurement, and also provides the theoretical foundation for constructing projective measurements from sequential weak measurements, which have applications in steering the quantum evolution and initializing quantum systems where strong measurement in a single shot is often not possible.