We investigate the security against the intercept/resend and translucent attacks on the quantum key distribution protocol based on the pre- and post-selection effect. In 2001, Bub proposed the quantum cryptography scheme, which was an application of the so-called mean king’s problem. We evaluate a probability that legitimate users cannot detect eavesdropper’s malicious acts for Bub’s protocol. We also estimate a probability that the eavesdropper guesses right at the random secret key one of the legitimate users tries to share with the other one. From rigorous mathematical and numerical analyses, we conclude that Bub’s protocol is weaker than the Bennett–Brassard protocol of 1984 (BB84) against both the intercept/resend and translucent attacks. Because Bub’s protocol uses a two-way quantum channel, the analyses of its security are tough to accomplish. We refer to their technical points accurately in the current paper. For example, we impose some constraints upon the eavesdropper’s strategies in order to let their degrees of freedom be small.
We investigate the security against the intercept/resend and translucent attacks on the quantum key distribution protocol based on the pre- and post-selection effect. In 2001, Bub proposed the quantum cryptography scheme, which was an application of the so-called mean king’s problem. We evaluate a probability that legitimate users cannot detect eavesdropper’s malicious acts for Bub’s protocol. We also estimate a probability that the eavesdropper guesses right at the random secret key one of the legitimate users tries to share with the other one. From rigorous mathematical and numerical analyses, we conclude that Bub’s protocol is weaker than the Bennett–Brassard protocol of 1984 (BB84) against both the intercept/resend and translucent attacks. Because Bub’s protocol uses a two-way quantum channel, the analyses of its security are tough to accomplish. We refer to their technical points accurately in the current paper. For example, we impose some constraints upon the eavesdropper’s strategies in order to let their degrees of freedom be small.
It is anticipated that quantum key distribution enable us to share a secret key while guaranteeing unconditionally security. In this paper, we discuss the quantum key distribution using the Mean King Problem which was proposed by J. Bub in 2001. While this two-way quantum protocol is essentially different from the other one-way protocols like the BB84, it has been shown that Eve cannot gain any information without being detected even in this protocol. Assuming two attack scenarios in this protocol, we derive two trade-off inequalities showing that the larger Eve's information gain is, the higher the detectability becomes. These quantitative inequalities enables the legitimate users to estimate Eve's information gain.
In this paper, we discuss security of the six-state quantum key distribution protocol against intercept/resend attacks and collective attacks. For the intercept/resend attacks, we evaluate a probability that the legitimate users, Alice and Bob, do not notice interference caused by the eavesdropper Eve and a probability that Eve obtains a secret bit sent by Alice. For the collective attacks, we estimate not only the above two probabilities but also Eve's Shannon information. In the assessment of the security against the collective attacks, imposing looser constraints upon Eve's strategies than Bechmann-Pasquinucci and Gisin, we reach substantially the same result as their study. In other words, although we let Eve's strategies satisfy lower symmetry than Bechmann-Pasquinucci and Gisin, both their work and ours attain the same conclusion, i.e. the identical, unique, and optimum strategy. This implies that we obtain Eve's best tactic by applying simpler conditions to it than Bechmann-Pasquinucci and Gisin, so that this result is novel. Finally, we consider a relation between the six-state protocol and the E91 scheme. We show that the intercept/resend attacks can always be described by hidden variable models. In contrast, we demonstrate that we cannot regard the collective attacks as the hidden variable theories if the disturbance is smaller than 1/3.
We present and analyze a quantum key distribution protocol based on sending entangled N-qubit states instead of single-qubit ones as in the trail-blazing scheme by Bennett and Brassard 1984 (BB84). Since the qubits are sent and acknowledged individually, an eavesdropper is limited to accessing them one by one. In an intercept-resend attack, this fundamental restriction allows one to make the eavesdropper's information on the transmitted key vanish if even one of the qubits is not intercepted. The implied upper bound 1∕(2N) for this information is further shown not to be the lowest, as the information can be reduced to less than 30% of that in the BB84 scheme in the case N=2. In general, the protocol is at least as secure as BB84.
In 2001, Jefferey Bub proposed a quantum key distribution protocol using the Mean King problem. In the protocol, King chooses one of the observables σ x or σ z , while Alice is required to measure an observable that solves the Mean King problem for three observables σ x , σ y and σ z . The observable employed by Alice is thus rather complicated. In this paper, we give other simple solutions of the Mean King problem for two observables and examine the quantum key distribution protocols using them. Our result shows that not all the solutions of the Mean King problem are available to construct a secure protocol. In addition, we consider a protocol that is tolerant with three attack scenarios and derive a trade-off inequality between Eve's information gain and error probability observed by the legitimate users.
In this paper, we introduce the extended mean king's problem and its solutions. Also, we show a quantum key distribution (QKD) using the extended mean king's problem. By using the quantum key distribution, a sender can share a secret key with each of receivers. Besides, we consider the tolerance to an eavesdropper who makes intercept-resend attacks. As a result, in the case of two receivers, we indicate that the quantum key distribution is robust against the intercept-resend attacks by showing that the error occurs between the secret keys of a sender and receivers.
The security analysis of the Ekert 1991 (E91), Bennett 1992 (B92), six-state protocol, Scarani–Acín–Ribordy–Gisin 2004 (SARG04) quantum key distribution (QKD) protocols, and their variants have been studied in the presence of collective-rotation noise channels. However, besides the Bennett–Brassard 1984 (BB84) being the first proposed, extensively studied, and essential protocol, its security proof under collective-rotation noise is still missing. Thus, we aim to close this gap in the literature. Consequently, we investigate how collective-rotation noise channels affect the security of the BB84 protocol. Mainly, we study scenarios where the eavesdropper, Eve, conducts an intercept-resend attack on the transmitted photons sent via a quantum communication channel shared by Alice and Bob. Notably, we distinguish the impact of collective-rotation noise and that of the eavesdropper. To achieve this, we provide rigorous, yet straightforward numerical calculations. First, we derive a model for the collective-rotation noise for the BB84 protocol and parametrize the mutual information shared between Alice and Eve. This is followed by deriving the quantum bit error rate (QBER) for two intercept-resend attack scenarios. In particular, we demonstrate that, for small rotation angles, one can extract a secure secret key under a collective-rotation noise channel when there is no eavesdropping. We observe that noise induced by rotation of 0.35 radians of the prepared quantum state results in a QBER of 11%, which corresponds to the lower bound on the tolerable error rate for the BB84 QKD protocol against general attacks. Moreover, a rotational angle of 0.53 radians yields a 25% QBER, which corresponds to the error rate bound due to the intercept-resend attack. Finally, we conclude that the BB84 protocol is robust against intercept-resend attacks on collective-rotation noise channels when the rotation angle is varied arbitrarily within particular bounds.