Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1811.06551 · Physical Review A

Fundamental limitations on photoisomerization from thermodynamic resource theories

Nicole Yunger Halpern, David T. Limmer

Published Apr 17, 2020• 41 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum information theory is used to investigate molecular switches. A resource-theory model for thermodynamics is applied to upper bound the probability of photoisomerization, or molecular switching, opening the door to a better understanding of the roles played by information, energy, and coherence in natural and artificial materials.
DOI
10.1103/physreva.101.042116

Related papers

Correlated dynamics as a resource in molecular switches

Daniel Siciliano, Rudi B. P. Pietsch, Giovanni Spaventa +2 more

Photoisomerization, a photochemical process underlying many biological mechanisms, has been modeled recently within the quantum resource theory of thermodynamics. This approach has emerged as a promising tool for studying fundamental limitations to nanoscale processes independently of the microscopic details governing their dynamics. On the other hand, correlations between physical systems have been shown to play a crucial role in quantum thermodynamics by lowering the work cost of certain operations. Here we explore quantitatively how correlations between multiple photoswitches can enhance the efficiency of photoisomerization beyond that attainable for single molecules. Furthermore, our analysis provides insights into the interplay between quantum and classical correlations in these transformations.

arXiv:2504.12202•Physical Review A•Sep 5, 2025•2 citations

Boosting biomolecular switch efficiency with quantum coherence

Mattheus Burkhard, Onur Pusuluk, Tristan Farrow

The resource theory of quantum thermodynamics has emerged as a powerful tool for exploring the out-of-equilibrium dynamics of microscopic and highly correlated systems. Recently, it has been employed in photoisomerization, a mechanism facilitating vision through the isomerism of the photoreceptor protein rhodopsin, to elucidate the fundamental limits of efficiency inherent in this physical process. Limited attention has been given to the impact of energetic quantum coherences in this process, as these coherences do not influence the energy-level populations within an individual molecule subjected to thermal operations. However, a specific type of energetic quantum coherences can impact the energy-level populations in the scenario involving two or more molecules. In this study, we examine the case of two molecules undergoing photoisomerization to show that energetic quantum coherence can function as a resource that amplifies the efficiency of photoisomerization. These insights offer evidence for the role of energetic quantum coherence as a key resource in the realm of quantum thermodynamics at mesoscopic scales. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2310.17585•Physical Review A•Jul 1, 2024•6 citations

Quantum-resource-theoretical analysis of the role of vibrational structure in photoisomerization

Siddharth Tiwary, Giovanni Spaventa, Susana F. Huelga +1 more

Thermodynamical systems at the nanoscale, such as single molecules interacting with highly structured vibrational environments, typically undergo nonequilibrium physical processes that lack precise microscopic descriptions. Photoisomerization is such an example, which has emerged as a platform on which to study single-molecule ultrafast photochemical processes from a quantum resource theoretic perspective. However, the upper bounds on its efficiency have only been obtained under significant simplifications that make the mathematics of the resource-theoretical treatment manageable. Here we generalize previous models for the photoisomers, while retaining the full vibrational structure, and still obtain analytical bounds on the efficiency of photoisomerization. We quantify the impact of such a vibrational structure on the optimal photoisomerization quantum yield both when the vibrational coordinate has no dynamics of its own and when we take into account the vibrational dynamics. This work serves as an example of how to bridge the gap between the abstract language of quantum resource theories and the open system formulation of nanoscale processes.

arXiv:2409.18710•Physical Review A•Aug 26, 2025•6 citations

The use of quantum resource theories in the study of nanoscale systems

Giovanni Spaventa

The thermodynamical behavior of quantum systems at the nanoscale is often very difficult to capture via standard frameworks of thermodynamics. The latter is, in fact, an equilibrium theory whose predictions are typically only valid on average, and in regimes where systems are composed of a very large number of constituents. In reality, the thermodynamical behavior of nanoscale systems can be much more constrained that what is predicted by macroscopic thermodynamics, due to the unavoidable impact of fluctuations. As a result, the fundamental limitations to a system's dynamics induced by macroscopic thermodynamics might turn out to be considerably less stringent than what can actually be observed at those scales. The theory of open quantum systems is certainly a powerful tool in this context, and can provide solutions which go beyond equilibrium treatments, but solving the dynamics of an open system requires detailed information about its microscopic structure (e.g. system-environment interactions and coupling strengths). In other words, one of the great advantages of macroscopic thermodynamics, i.e. its universality and independence of microscopic details, might be essentially lost if we can only infer thermodynamical results once we specify the full microscopic structure of our system-environment interaction. This highlights the necessity for a framework of thermodynamics that is well suited for studying the behavior of small quantum systems far from equilibrium, but can still be applied to physical systems in a universal way, i.e., without having to specify full microscopic information. Quantum Resource Theories (QRTs), and in particular the formulations of quantum thermodynamics that have emerged from them, constitute a promising tool in this direction. However, these models of thermodynamics have not yet been extensively applied to realistic physical platform, and their consequences on known thermodynamical processes are still unexplored. Furthermore, going beyond a purely thermodynamical context, a case can be made for the use of general QRTs as benchmarking tools for the certification of certain quantum resources. In other words, QRTs could be used to find fundamental bounds to physical quantities or impossibility results (in the form of no-go theorems) that, when compared to experimental data, can be used to falsify specific hypotheses. In this thesis, both these directions will be explored, by considering resource-theoretical questions that are relevant for different physical platforms. These will include the photochemical process of photoisomerization, heat transport in harmonic systems, and tabletop tests of quantum gravity.

•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

Quantum Resource Theories for Thermodynamics, Reference Frames, and Uncertainty

Varun Narasimhachar

Quantum information science is at the interface of physics and information theory, with applications including quantum computing and communication. Within this science, a resource theory is a detailed study of a particular class of physical processes, under which the possible state transitions are restricted. Given any initial physical state, the possible final states are also restricted. Initial states with a wealth of possible final states can then be considered more valuable than less versatile initial states, leading to a notion of "resourcefulness" of states. The broad goals of a resource theory include (1) to identify, characterize, and quantify resources; (2) to find an efficient way to determine whether an arbitrary instance of resource conversion is possible; and (3) to relate practical applications to resource conversion. In this thesis, we will take the resource-theoretic approach to understanding thermodynamics. The mathematical methods used in this work will enable us to also develop resource theories for measurement uncertainty and reference frames; in fact, the resource-theoretic treatment of thermodynamics is a combination of these two. Our approach is based on a model called thermal operations, applicable on individual quantum-mechanical systems out of thermal equilibrium. We study this model in detail, resulting in a better understanding of the resource of thermal inequilibrium. In a simplified version of the model where quantum coherence is neglected, we find that the conditions for state transitions are already more complex than the classical second law of thermodynamics. We extend the model to quantum systems controlled by classical circuitry. We also extend it to incorporate quantum coherence in the low-temperature limit. Measurement uncertainty is an important element in quantum mechanics. But its current understanding is through particular measures of uncertainty, such as the variance. We apply the resource theory approach to develop a measure-independent formalism for uncertainty, even in the case where the measurement is on part of a composite system with quantum correlations. Under physical processes restricted by some symmetry (e.g. rotational symmetry), asymmetric states act as resourceful reference frames. In this resource theory, we find the rate at which large quantities of resources can be interconverted through measurements.

•Jan 1, 2016•1 citation

Approaching Resource-Theoretic Optimal Performance with Structured Environments

Lea Lautenbacher, Giovanni Spaventa, Susana F. Huelga +1 more

Resource-theoretic approaches to thermodynamics provide powerful, model-independent bounds on the efficiency of physical processes, because they do not rely on microscopic details of the environment. Whether such bounds can be approached by realistic dynamics generated by explicit system-environment interactions remains an open question. Photoisomerization, a fundamental molecular photoreaction, offers a concrete setting to examine this issue. We introduce a tunable microscopic model of a molecular photoswitch coupled to a structured vibrational environment, which interpolates continuously between Markovian and non-Markovian regimes. Resource-theoretic analysis predicts in particular that Markovian Thermal Operations achieve strictly lower yields than general Thermal Operations. We show that environmental memory lifts dynamical restrictions associated with Markovian thermal evolutions, thereby enlarging the set of transformations accessible to the microscopic dynamics. Approaching the thermal operation bound, however, depends on the microscopic coupling structure that generates this memory and directs the resulting dynamics towards the target transformation.

quant-pharXiv:2608.28488•Aug 31, 2026•0 citations
Photoisomerization, a photochemical process underlying many biological mechanisms, has been modeled recently within the quantum resource theory of thermodynamics. This approach has emerged as a promising tool for studying fundamental limitations to nanoscale processes independently of the microscopic details governing their dynamics. On the other hand, correlations between physical systems have been shown to play a crucial role in quantum thermodynamics by lowering the work cost of certain operations. Here we explore quantitatively how correlations between multiple photoswitches can enhance the efficiency of photoisomerization beyond that attainable for single molecules. Furthermore, our analysis provides insights into the interplay between quantum and classical correlations in these transformations.
The resource theory of quantum thermodynamics has emerged as a powerful tool for exploring the out-of-equilibrium dynamics of microscopic and highly correlated systems. Recently, it has been employed in photoisomerization, a mechanism facilitating vision through the isomerism of the photoreceptor protein rhodopsin, to elucidate the fundamental limits of efficiency inherent in this physical process. Limited attention has been given to the impact of energetic quantum coherences in this process, as these coherences do not influence the energy-level populations within an individual molecule subjected to thermal operations. However, a specific type of energetic quantum coherences can impact the energy-level populations in the scenario involving two or more molecules. In this study, we examine the case of two molecules undergoing photoisomerization to show that energetic quantum coherence can function as a resource that amplifies the efficiency of photoisomerization. These insights offer evidence for the role of energetic quantum coherence as a key resource in the realm of quantum thermodynamics at mesoscopic scales. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
Thermodynamical systems at the nanoscale, such as single molecules interacting with highly structured vibrational environments, typically undergo nonequilibrium physical processes that lack precise microscopic descriptions. Photoisomerization is such an example, which has emerged as a platform on which to study single-molecule ultrafast photochemical processes from a quantum resource theoretic perspective. However, the upper bounds on its efficiency have only been obtained under significant simplifications that make the mathematics of the resource-theoretical treatment manageable. Here we generalize previous models for the photoisomers, while retaining the full vibrational structure, and still obtain analytical bounds on the efficiency of photoisomerization. We quantify the impact of such a vibrational structure on the optimal photoisomerization quantum yield both when the vibrational coordinate has no dynamics of its own and when we take into account the vibrational dynamics. This work serves as an example of how to bridge the gap between the abstract language of quantum resource theories and the open system formulation of nanoscale processes.
The thermodynamical behavior of quantum systems at the nanoscale is often very difficult to capture via standard frameworks of thermodynamics. The latter is, in fact, an equilibrium theory whose predictions are typically only valid on average, and in regimes where systems are composed of a very large number of constituents. In reality, the thermodynamical behavior of nanoscale systems can be much more constrained that what is predicted by macroscopic thermodynamics, due to the unavoidable impact of fluctuations. As a result, the fundamental limitations to a system's dynamics induced by macroscopic thermodynamics might turn out to be considerably less stringent than what can actually be observed at those scales. The theory of open quantum systems is certainly a powerful tool in this context, and can provide solutions which go beyond equilibrium treatments, but solving the dynamics of an open system requires detailed information about its microscopic structure (e.g. system-environment interactions and coupling strengths). In other words, one of the great advantages of macroscopic thermodynamics, i.e. its universality and independence of microscopic details, might be essentially lost if we can only infer thermodynamical results once we specify the full microscopic structure of our system-environment interaction. This highlights the necessity for a framework of thermodynamics that is well suited for studying the behavior of small quantum systems far from equilibrium, but can still be applied to physical systems in a universal way, i.e., without having to specify full microscopic information. Quantum Resource Theories (QRTs), and in particular the formulations of quantum thermodynamics that have emerged from them, constitute a promising tool in this direction. However, these models of thermodynamics have not yet been extensively applied to realistic physical platform, and their consequences on known thermodynamical processes are still unexplored. Furthermore, going beyond a purely thermodynamical context, a case can be made for the use of general QRTs as benchmarking tools for the certification of certain quantum resources. In other words, QRTs could be used to find fundamental bounds to physical quantities or impossibility results (in the form of no-go theorems) that, when compared to experimental data, can be used to falsify specific hypotheses. In this thesis, both these directions will be explored, by considering resource-theoretical questions that are relevant for different physical platforms. These will include the photochemical process of photoisomerization, heat transport in harmonic systems, and tabletop tests of quantum gravity.
Quantum information science is at the interface of physics and information theory, with applications including quantum computing and communication. Within this science, a resource theory is a detailed study of a particular class of physical processes, under which the possible state transitions are restricted. Given any initial physical state, the possible final states are also restricted. Initial states with a wealth of possible final states can then be considered more valuable than less versatile initial states, leading to a notion of "resourcefulness" of states. The broad goals of a resource theory include (1) to identify, characterize, and quantify resources; (2) to find an efficient way to determine whether an arbitrary instance of resource conversion is possible; and (3) to relate practical applications to resource conversion. In this thesis, we will take the resource-theoretic approach to understanding thermodynamics. The mathematical methods used in this work will enable us to also develop resource theories for measurement uncertainty and reference frames; in fact, the resource-theoretic treatment of thermodynamics is a combination of these two. Our approach is based on a model called thermal operations, applicable on individual quantum-mechanical systems out of thermal equilibrium. We study this model in detail, resulting in a better understanding of the resource of thermal inequilibrium. In a simplified version of the model where quantum coherence is neglected, we find that the conditions for state transitions are already more complex than the classical second law of thermodynamics. We extend the model to quantum systems controlled by classical circuitry. We also extend it to incorporate quantum coherence in the low-temperature limit. Measurement uncertainty is an important element in quantum mechanics. But its current understanding is through particular measures of uncertainty, such as the variance. We apply the resource theory approach to develop a measure-independent formalism for uncertainty, even in the case where the measurement is on part of a composite system with quantum correlations. Under physical processes restricted by some symmetry (e.g. rotational symmetry), asymmetric states act as resourceful reference frames. In this resource theory, we find the rate at which large quantities of resources can be interconverted through measurements.
Resource-theoretic approaches to thermodynamics provide powerful, model-independent bounds on the efficiency of physical processes, because they do not rely on microscopic details of the environment. Whether such bounds can be approached by realistic dynamics generated by explicit system-environment interactions remains an open question. Photoisomerization, a fundamental molecular photoreaction, offers a concrete setting to examine this issue. We introduce a tunable microscopic model of a molecular photoswitch coupled to a structured vibrational environment, which interpolates continuously between Markovian and non-Markovian regimes. Resource-theoretic analysis predicts in particular that Markovian Thermal Operations achieve strictly lower yields than general Thermal Operations. We show that environmental memory lifts dynamical restrictions associated with Markovian thermal evolutions, thereby enlarging the set of transformations accessible to the microscopic dynamics. Approaching the thermal operation bound, however, depends on the microscopic coupling structure that generates this memory and directs the resulting dynamics towards the target transformation.