Abstract This paper is a rebuttal of the comment by Zhdanov (2018 J. Phys. A: Math. Theor .) with regard to our paper (Russell et al 2017 J. Phys. A: Math. Theor . 50 205302). Parts of the comment either misrepresent the original claims in Russell et al (2017 J. Phys. A: Math. Theor . 50 205302) or consider issues that go beyond the scope of Russell et al (2017 J. Phys. A: Math. Theor . 50 205302). We address all of these points in the rebuttal. A remaining item about the prospect of an accumulation of null sets was already considered in a prior work (Russell et al 2018 J. Phys. A: Math. Theor . 51 335103). Importantly, the comment fails to consider the vast and continually growing set of successful quantum control tests under well-defined conditions, which serves as foundational evidence for the results in Russell et al (2017 J. Phys. A: Math. Theor . 50 205302). In summary, the remarks in the comment either misconstrue the claims of Russell et al (2017 J. Phys. A: Math. Theor . 50 205302) or raise points that are irrelevant to the goal of the original work. Thus, we conclude that the primary claim of the original paper stands: almost all closed finite dimensional quantum systems are trap free given adequate control resources.
Abstract A proof is presented that almost all closed, finite dimensional quantum systems have trap free (i.e. free from local optima) landscapes for a large and physically general class of circumstances, which includes qubit evolutions in quantum computing. This result offers an explanation for why gradient-based methods succeed so frequently in quantum control. The role of singular controls is analyzed using geometric tools in the case of the control of the propagator, and thus in the case of observables as well. Singular controls have been implicated as a source of landscape traps. The conditions under which singular controls can introduce traps, and thus interrupt the progress of a control optimization, are discussed and a geometrical characterization of the issue is presented. It is shown that a control being singular is not sufficient to cause control optimization progress to halt, and sufficient conditions for a trap free landscape are presented. It is further shown that the local surjectivity (full rank) assumption of landscape analysis can be refined to the condition that the end-point map is transverse to each of the level sets of the fidelity function. This mild condition is shown to be sufficient for a quantum system’s landscape to be trap free. The control landscape is shown to be trap free for all but a null set of Hamiltonians using a geometric technique based on the parametric transversality theorem. Numerical evidence confirming this analysis is also presented. This new result is the analogue of the work of Altifini, wherein it was shown that controllability holds for all but a null set of quantum systems in the dipole approximation. These collective results indicate that the availability of adequate control resources remains the most physically relevant issue for achieving high fidelity control performance while also avoiding landscape traps.
Many quantum control problems are formulated as a search for an optimal field that maximizes a physical objective. This search is performed over a landscape defined as the objective as a function of the control field. A recent Letter [A. N. Pechen and D. J. Tannor, Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 120402 (2011)] asserts that the existence of special landscape critical points (CPs) with trapping characteristics is "contrary to recent claims in the literature" and "can have profound implications for both theoretical and experimental quantum control studies." We show here that these assertions are inaccurate and misleading.
Quantum control landscape theory was formulated to assess the ease of finding optimal control fields in simulations and in the laboratory. The landscape is the observable as a function of the controls, and a primary goal of the theory is the analysis of landscape features. In what is referred to as the kinematic picture of the landscape, prior work showed that the landscapes are generally free of traps that could halt the search for an optimal control at a suboptimal observable value. The present paper considers the dynamical picture of the landscape, seeking the existence of singular controls, especially of a nonkinematic nature along with an assessment of whether they correspond to traps. We analyze the necessary and sufficient conditions for singular controls to be kinematic or nonkinematic critical solutions and the likelihood of their being encountered while maximizing an observable. An algorithm is introduced to seek singular controls on the landscape in simulations along with an associated Hessian landscape analysis. Simulations are performed for a large number of model finite-level quantum systems, showing that all the numerically identified kinematic and nonkinematic singular critical controls are not traps, in support of the prior empirical observations on the ease of finding high-quality optimal control fields.
Optimization plays a central role in variational quantum algorithms, where the objective function typically takes the form
F(θ)=∑m=1Mfm(Tr[U(θ)ρmU†(θ)Om]), with
U(θ) being a parameterized quantum ansatz. Understanding the optimization landscape of such objective functions is crucial for assessing the trainability and performance of these algorithms. For the special case
M=1, it is known that under certain assumptions, the landscape is free of false traps (FTs), i.e., local optima that are not global. In this work, we investigate optimization landscapes of the general case
M≥1 and show that the landscape becomes intrinsically more complex. First, we establish a complete framework for analyzing critical features of the optimization landscape, by deriving necessary and sufficient conditions to identify and classify all critical points under some assumptions, which is also of practical importance in designing efficient algorithms independent of whether these assumptions are satisfied. Then, we show that FTs can still emerge on landscapes for
M>1, standing in stark contrast to the
M=1 case and further revealing that parameter sufficiency alone is not enough to guarantee a trap-free landscape. Moreover, we uncover a close connection that the emergence of FTs is necessarily attributed to the loss of distinguishability among the states and/or operators, and fundamentally, to the loss of compatibility of the spectral ordering governed by different objective terms. Our results provide a deeper understanding of the optimization complexity and practical guidance for both algorithmic and problem-setting designs.
There has been great interest in recent years in quantum control landscapes. Given an objective
J that depends on a control field $\ensuremath{\epsilon}$ the dynamical landscape is defined by the properties of the Hessian ${\ensuremath{\delta}}^{2}J/\ensuremath{\delta}{\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{2}$ at the critical points $\ensuremath{\delta}J/\ensuremath{\delta}\ensuremath{\epsilon}=0$. We show that contrary to recent claims in the literature the dynamical control landscape can exhibit trapping behavior due to the existence of special critical points and illustrate this finding with an example of a 3-level $\ensuremath{\Lambda}$ system. This observation can have profound implications for both theoretical and experimental quantum control studies.