Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1809.09204 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Efficient prediction of time- and angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy measurements on a nonequilibrium BCS superconductor

Tianrui Xu, Takahiro Morimoto, Alessandra Lanzara, Joel E. Moore

Published Jan 9, 2019• 10 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study how time- and angle-resolved photoemission (tr-ARPES) reveals the dynamics of BCS-type, $s$-wave superconducting systems with time-varying order parameters. Approximate methods are discussed, based on previous approaches to either optical conductivity or quantum dot transport, to enable computationally efficient prediction of photoemission spectra. One use of such predictions is to enable extraction of the underlying order parameter dynamics from experimental data, which is topical given the rapidly growing use of tr-ARPES in studying unconventional superconductivity. The methods considered model the two-time lesser Green's functions with an approximated lesser self-energy that describes relaxation by coupling of the system to two types of baths. The approach primarily used here also takes into consideration the relaxation of the excited states into equilibrium by explicitly including the level-broadening of the retarded and advanced Green's functions. We present equilibrium and nonequilibrium calculations of tr-ARPES spectrum from our model and discuss the signatures of different types of superconducting dynamics.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.99.035117

Related papers

Momentum-resolved analysis of condensate dynamic and Higgs oscillations in quenched superconductors with time-resolved ARPES

Lukas Schwarz, Benedikt Fauseweh, Dirk Manske

Higgs oscillations in nonequilibrium superconductors provide a unique tool to obtain information about the underlying order parameter. Several properties like the absolute value, existence of multiple gaps, and the symmetry of the order parameter can be encoded in the Higgs oscillation spectrum. Studying Higgs oscillations with time-resolved angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES) has the advantage over optical measurements that a momentum-resolved analysis of the condensate dynamic is possible. In this paper, we investigate the time-resolved spectral function measured in ARPES for different quench protocols. We find that analyzing amplitude oscillations of the ARPES intensity in the whole Brillouin zone allows to understand how the condensate dynamic contributes to the emerging of collective Higgs oscillations. Furthermore, by evaluating the phase of these oscillations, the symmetry deformation dynamic of the condensate can be revealed, which gives insight about the ground state symmetry of the system. With such an analysis, time-resolved ARPES experiments might be used in the future as a powerful tool in the field of Higgs spectroscopy.

arXiv:2002.05904•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jun 18, 2020•16 citations

Spectral evolution of angle-resolved photoemission due to Holstein-type electron-phonon scattering within the adiabatic approximation

Jiaguang Han, Kai Ji, Zhiyuan Zhu +1 more

The angle-resolved photoemission spectra (ARPES) of the spin-1/2 Holstein model at non-half-filling are calculated by using the adiabatic approximation and the classical Monte Carlo method. It is found that in the metallic state, the spectra take broad Gaussians at the band bottom, while evolving to sharp Lorentzians near the Fermi level, commonly in one, two, and three dimensions. We justify that this evolution in ARPES is connected with an electronic state transition from quasi-localized ones to the extended ones due to the scattering of electrons with the static lattice distortion.

Physical Review B•Mar 22, 2006•2 citations

Spectroscopic probes of isolated nonequilibrium quantum matter: Quantum quenches, Floquet states, and distribution functions

Yunxiang Liao, Matthew S. Foster

We investigate radio-frequency (rf) spectroscopy, metal-to-superconductor tunneling, and angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES) as probes of isolated out-of-equilibrium quantum systems, and examine the crucial role played by the nonequilibrium distribution function. As an example, we focus on the induced topological time-periodic (Floquet) phase in a two-dimensional $p+ip$ superfluid, following an instantaneous quench of the coupling strength. The post-quench Cooper pairs occupy a linear combination of ``ground'' and ``excited'' Floquet states, with coefficients determined by the distribution function. While the Floquet band structure exhibits a single avoided crossing relative to the equilibrium case, the distribution function shows a population inversion of the Floquet bands at low energies. For a realization in ultracold atoms, these two features compensate, producing a bulk average rf signal that is well captured by a quasiequilibrium approximation. In particular, the rf spectrum shows a robust gap. The single crossing occurs because the quench-induced Floquet phase belongs to a particular class of soliton dynamics for the BCS equation. The population inversion is a consequence of this, and ensures the conservation of the pseudospin winding number. As a comparison, we compute the rf signal when only the lower Floquet band is occupied; in this case, the gap disappears for strong quenches. The tunneling signal in a solid-state realization is ignorant of the distribution function, and can show wildly different behaviors. We also examine rf, tunneling, and ARPES for weak quenches, such that the resulting topological steady state is characterized by a constant nonequilibrium order parameter. In a system with a boundary, tunneling reveals the Majorana edge states. However, the local rf signal due to the edge states is suppressed by a factor of the inverse system size, and is spatially deconfined throughout the bulk of the sample.

arXiv:1506.05833•Physical Review A•Nov 19, 2015•19 citations

Measuring correlated electron dynamics with time-resolved photoemission spectroscopy

Martin Eckstein, Marcus Kollar

Time-resolved photoemission experiments can reveal fascinating quantum dynamics of correlated electrons. However, the thermalization of the electronic system is typically so fast that very short probe pulses are necessary to resolve the time evolution of the quantum state, and this leads to poor energy resolution due to the energy-time uncertainty relation. Although the photoemission intensity can be calculated from the nonequilibrium electronic Green's functions, the converse procedure is therefore difficult. We analyze a hypothetical time-resolved photoemission experiment on a correlated electronic system, described by the Falicov-Kimball model in dynamical mean-field theory, which relaxes between metallic and insulating phases. We find that the real-time Green's function which describes the transient behavior during the buildup of the metallic state cannot be determined directly from the photoemission signal. On the other hand, the characteristic collapse-and-revival oscillations of an excited Mott insulator can be observed as oscillating weight in the center of the Mott gap in the time-dependent photoemission spectrum.

arXiv:0809.4282•Physical Review B•Dec 16, 2008•51 citations

Noise correlations in time- and angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy

Christopher Stahl, Martin Eckstein

In time-resolved photoemission experiments, more than one electron can be emitted from the solid by a single ultrashort pulse. We theoretically demonstrate how correlations between the momenta of outgoing electrons relate to time-dependent two-particle correlations in the solid. This can extend the scope of time- and angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy to probe superconducting and charge density fluctuations in systems without long-range order, and to reveal their dynamics independent of the electronic gap and thus unrestricted by the energy-time uncertainty. The proposal is illustrated for superconductivity in a BCS model. An impulsive perturbation can quench the gap on ultrafast timescales, while nonequilibrium pairing correlations persist much longer, even when electron-electron scattering beyond mean-field theory is taken into account. There is thus a clear distinction between a dephasing of the Cooper pairs and the thermalization into the normal state. While a measurement of the gap would be blind to such pairing correlations, they can be revealed by the angular correlations in photoemission.

arXiv:1812.09222•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jun 20, 2019•19 citations

Path-Integral Theory for Photoemission Specta of Electron-Phonon Coupled Systems

凱 吉, カイ ジ, Kai JI

It has been a long-standing question in solid state physics, how the electron-phonon (e-ph) interaction influences the electronic energy band structures, and finally determines a material to become an insulator, metal or superconductor. Since the photoemission spectrum can directly probe this structure of electronic energy bands and topology of Fermi surface, it has become one of the most important measurements for the experimental studies. In the angle resolved photoemission spectra (ARPES) , the binding energy can now be measured as a function of each given momentum. With the rapid progress of this high resolution ARPES, the electronic energy band structure can now be discerned in the scale of a few meV. Based on this technical development, quite a lot of new properties associated with e-ph interaction have been discovered in the normal metallic states as well as in the superconducting (SC) ones, signifying direct and clear evidences for the importance of the e-ph interactions. On the other hand, theoretical studies for this e-ph coupling already have a long history. In the case of a single electron coupled with phonons, it has been investigated in detail, by the ordinary perturbation theory, and also by the unitary transformation methods. As for the many-electron system coupled with phonons, the so-called Migdal-Eliashberg (ME) theory, and also adiabatic or mean field approximation are often used to clarify the energy band structures, in connection with various phase transition phenomena, such as the charge density wave (CDW) states and superconductor ones from metallic states. In some cases, systematic theoretical methods have already been devised to take into account high order corrections, which are not included in the ordinary perturbation theories. However, these existing theories seem to be not so useful to clarify the aforementioned ARPES, since it spans the whole momentum region from the Fermi level (≡EF ) to the bottom of the valence band. According to recent experimental results, it has become clear that the ARPES evolve quite drastically as the momentum changes from EF to the band bottom. This spectral evolution appears quite universal for a wide varieties of e-ph systems, especially the intermediately coupled metallic ones. However, its origin seems beyond the conventional approximation theories mentioned above. Thus, the problem how e-ph interaction dominates the spectral shape has now emerged as a new challenge for the theory of solid state physics. In this work, we present a new path-integral theory to calculate the ARPES of e=ph coupled systems. Our main purpose of this paper is to clarify the impact of e-ph interaction on the lineshape of ARPES. we consider a many-electron system coupled with Einstein phonons, which is often called Holstein model. This model has been studied extensivery, with various interests ranging from the competition between metallic, CDW and SC phases, to the energy gap opening, by perturbative and non-perturbative methods. In our numerical calculation, the path-integral is performed by the quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) simulation. Thus it is completely free from any other approximations. Give the QMC data of imaginary time Green's function, we reproduce the spectral function by the analytic continuation. By this means, we systematically study the spectral properties of the e-ph coupled systems based on the one-dimensional and two-dimensional (2D) Holstein models under various conditions. We find the band structure is greatly modified by the multiple scattering effect of electron with phonons, even if the whole system is still metallic and the e-ph coupling strength is intermediate. Around the band bottom, the spectrum takes a broad Gaussian, indicating the electron in this state is nearly localized and incoherent. While near the EF, the spectral shape is characterized by an asymmetric two-headed Lorentzian, which means the electron in this state is almost coherent with a plane wave nature, extending over all the crystal. There are also dimensionality effects on the phonon peaks, which make them most clearly observed in the 2D non-half-filled cases with no CDW gap. Our results qualitatively agree with recent experiments of high resolution ARPES on Be (0001) surface and Bi2Sr2CaCu2O8.

•Mar 24, 2004•0 citations
We study how time- and angle-resolved photoemission (tr-ARPES) reveals the dynamics of BCS-type, sss-wave superconducting systems with time-varying order parameters. Approximate methods are discussed, based on previous approaches to either optical conductivity or quantum dot transport, to enable computationally efficient prediction of photoemission spectra. One use of such predictions is to enable extraction of the underlying order parameter dynamics from experimental data, which is topical given the rapidly growing use of tr-ARPES in studying unconventional superconductivity. The methods considered model the two-time lesser Green's functions with an approximated lesser self-energy that describes relaxation by coupling of the system to two types of baths. The approach primarily used here also takes into consideration the relaxation of the excited states into equilibrium by explicitly including the level-broadening of the retarded and advanced Green's functions. We present equilibrium and nonequilibrium calculations of tr-ARPES spectrum from our model and discuss the signatures of different types of superconducting dynamics.
Higgs oscillations in nonequilibrium superconductors provide a unique tool to obtain information about the underlying order parameter. Several properties like the absolute value, existence of multiple gaps, and the symmetry of the order parameter can be encoded in the Higgs oscillation spectrum. Studying Higgs oscillations with time-resolved angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES) has the advantage over optical measurements that a momentum-resolved analysis of the condensate dynamic is possible. In this paper, we investigate the time-resolved spectral function measured in ARPES for different quench protocols. We find that analyzing amplitude oscillations of the ARPES intensity in the whole Brillouin zone allows to understand how the condensate dynamic contributes to the emerging of collective Higgs oscillations. Furthermore, by evaluating the phase of these oscillations, the symmetry deformation dynamic of the condensate can be revealed, which gives insight about the ground state symmetry of the system. With such an analysis, time-resolved ARPES experiments might be used in the future as a powerful tool in the field of Higgs spectroscopy.
The angle-resolved photoemission spectra (ARPES) of the spin-1/2 Holstein model at non-half-filling are calculated by using the adiabatic approximation and the classical Monte Carlo method. It is found that in the metallic state, the spectra take broad Gaussians at the band bottom, while evolving to sharp Lorentzians near the Fermi level, commonly in one, two, and three dimensions. We justify that this evolution in ARPES is connected with an electronic state transition from quasi-localized ones to the extended ones due to the scattering of electrons with the static lattice distortion.
We investigate radio-frequency (rf) spectroscopy, metal-to-superconductor tunneling, and angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES) as probes of isolated out-of-equilibrium quantum systems, and examine the crucial role played by the nonequilibrium distribution function. As an example, we focus on the induced topological time-periodic (Floquet) phase in a two-dimensional p+ipp+ipp+ip superfluid, following an instantaneous quench of the coupling strength. The post-quench Cooper pairs occupy a linear combination of ``ground'' and ``excited'' Floquet states, with coefficients determined by the distribution function. While the Floquet band structure exhibits a single avoided crossing relative to the equilibrium case, the distribution function shows a population inversion of the Floquet bands at low energies. For a realization in ultracold atoms, these two features compensate, producing a bulk average rf signal that is well captured by a quasiequilibrium approximation. In particular, the rf spectrum shows a robust gap. The single crossing occurs because the quench-induced Floquet phase belongs to a particular class of soliton dynamics for the BCS equation. The population inversion is a consequence of this, and ensures the conservation of the pseudospin winding number. As a comparison, we compute the rf signal when only the lower Floquet band is occupied; in this case, the gap disappears for strong quenches. The tunneling signal in a solid-state realization is ignorant of the distribution function, and can show wildly different behaviors. We also examine rf, tunneling, and ARPES for weak quenches, such that the resulting topological steady state is characterized by a constant nonequilibrium order parameter. In a system with a boundary, tunneling reveals the Majorana edge states. However, the local rf signal due to the edge states is suppressed by a factor of the inverse system size, and is spatially deconfined throughout the bulk of the sample.
Time-resolved photoemission experiments can reveal fascinating quantum dynamics of correlated electrons. However, the thermalization of the electronic system is typically so fast that very short probe pulses are necessary to resolve the time evolution of the quantum state, and this leads to poor energy resolution due to the energy-time uncertainty relation. Although the photoemission intensity can be calculated from the nonequilibrium electronic Green's functions, the converse procedure is therefore difficult. We analyze a hypothetical time-resolved photoemission experiment on a correlated electronic system, described by the Falicov-Kimball model in dynamical mean-field theory, which relaxes between metallic and insulating phases. We find that the real-time Green's function which describes the transient behavior during the buildup of the metallic state cannot be determined directly from the photoemission signal. On the other hand, the characteristic collapse-and-revival oscillations of an excited Mott insulator can be observed as oscillating weight in the center of the Mott gap in the time-dependent photoemission spectrum.
In time-resolved photoemission experiments, more than one electron can be emitted from the solid by a single ultrashort pulse. We theoretically demonstrate how correlations between the momenta of outgoing electrons relate to time-dependent two-particle correlations in the solid. This can extend the scope of time- and angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy to probe superconducting and charge density fluctuations in systems without long-range order, and to reveal their dynamics independent of the electronic gap and thus unrestricted by the energy-time uncertainty. The proposal is illustrated for superconductivity in a BCS model. An impulsive perturbation can quench the gap on ultrafast timescales, while nonequilibrium pairing correlations persist much longer, even when electron-electron scattering beyond mean-field theory is taken into account. There is thus a clear distinction between a dephasing of the Cooper pairs and the thermalization into the normal state. While a measurement of the gap would be blind to such pairing correlations, they can be revealed by the angular correlations in photoemission.
It has been a long-standing question in solid state physics, how the electron-phonon (e-ph) interaction influences the electronic energy band structures, and finally determines a material to become an insulator, metal or superconductor. Since the photoemission spectrum can directly probe this structure of electronic energy bands and topology of Fermi surface, it has become one of the most important measurements for the experimental studies. In the angle resolved photoemission spectra (ARPES) , the binding energy can now be measured as a function of each given momentum. With the rapid progress of this high resolution ARPES, the electronic energy band structure can now be discerned in the scale of a few meV. Based on this technical development, quite a lot of new properties associated with e-ph interaction have been discovered in the normal metallic states as well as in the superconducting (SC) ones, signifying direct and clear evidences for the importance of the e-ph interactions. On the other hand, theoretical studies for this e-ph coupling already have a long history. In the case of a single electron coupled with phonons, it has been investigated in detail, by the ordinary perturbation theory, and also by the unitary transformation methods. As for the many-electron system coupled with phonons, the so-called Migdal-Eliashberg (ME) theory, and also adiabatic or mean field approximation are often used to clarify the energy band structures, in connection with various phase transition phenomena, such as the charge density wave (CDW) states and superconductor ones from metallic states. In some cases, systematic theoretical methods have already been devised to take into account high order corrections, which are not included in the ordinary perturbation theories. However, these existing theories seem to be not so useful to clarify the aforementioned ARPES, since it spans the whole momentum region from the Fermi level (≡EF ) to the bottom of the valence band. According to recent experimental results, it has become clear that the ARPES evolve quite drastically as the momentum changes from EF to the band bottom. This spectral evolution appears quite universal for a wide varieties of e-ph systems, especially the intermediately coupled metallic ones. However, its origin seems beyond the conventional approximation theories mentioned above. Thus, the problem how e-ph interaction dominates the spectral shape has now emerged as a new challenge for the theory of solid state physics. In this work, we present a new path-integral theory to calculate the ARPES of e=ph coupled systems. Our main purpose of this paper is to clarify the impact of e-ph interaction on the lineshape of ARPES. we consider a many-electron system coupled with Einstein phonons, which is often called Holstein model. This model has been studied extensivery, with various interests ranging from the competition between metallic, CDW and SC phases, to the energy gap opening, by perturbative and non-perturbative methods. In our numerical calculation, the path-integral is performed by the quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) simulation. Thus it is completely free from any other approximations. Give the QMC data of imaginary time Green's function, we reproduce the spectral function by the analytic continuation. By this means, we systematically study the spectral properties of the e-ph coupled systems based on the one-dimensional and two-dimensional (2D) Holstein models under various conditions. We find the band structure is greatly modified by the multiple scattering effect of electron with phonons, even if the whole system is still metallic and the e-ph coupling strength is intermediate. Around the band bottom, the spectrum takes a broad Gaussian, indicating the electron in this state is nearly localized and incoherent. While near the EF, the spectral shape is characterized by an asymmetric two-headed Lorentzian, which means the electron in this state is almost coherent with a plane wave nature, extending over all the crystal. There are also dimensionality effects on the phonon peaks, which make them most clearly observed in the 2D non-half-filled cases with no CDW gap. Our results qualitatively agree with recent experiments of high resolution ARPES on Be (0001) surface and Bi2Sr2CaCu2O8.