Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1809.06957 · Communications in Mathematical Physics

Approximate Unitary t-Designs by Short Random Quantum Circuits Using Nearest-Neighbor and Long-Range Gates

Aram W. Harrow, Saeed Adel Mehraban

Published May 4, 2023• 193 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract We prove that $${{\,\textrm{poly}\,}}(t) \cdot n^{1/D}$$ poly ( t ) · n 1 / D -depth local random quantum circuits with two qudit nearest-neighbor gates on a D -dimensional lattice with n qudits are approximate t -designs in various measures. These include the “monomial” measure, meaning that the monomials of a random circuit from this family have expectation close to the value that would result from the Haar measure. Previously, the best bound was $${{\,\textrm{poly}\,}}(t)\cdot n$$ poly ( t ) · n due to Brandão–Harrow–Horodecki (Commun Math Phys 346(2):397–434, 2016) for $$D=1$$ D = 1 . We also improve the “scrambling” and “decoupling” bounds for spatially local random circuits due to Brown and Fawzi (Scrambling speed of random quantum circuits, 2012). One consequence of our result is that assuming the polynomial hierarchy ( $${{\,\mathrm{\textsf{PH}}\,}}$$ PH ) is infinite and that certain counting problems are $$\#{\textsf{P}}$$ # P -hard “on average”, sampling within total variation distance from these circuits is hard for classical computers. Previously, exact sampling from the outputs of even constant-depth quantum circuits was known to be hard for classical computers under these assumptions. However the standard strategy for extending this hardness result to approximate sampling requires the quantum circuits to have a property called “anti-concentration”, meaning roughly that the output has near-maximal entropy. Unitary 2-designs have the desired anti-concentration property. Our result improves the required depth for this level of anti-concentration from linear depth to a sub-linear value, depending on the geometry of the interactions. This is relevant to a recent experiment by the Google Quantum AI group to perform such a sampling task with 53 qubits on a two-dimensional lattice (Arute in Nature 574(7779):505–510, 2019; Boixo et al. in Nate Phys 14(6):595–600, 2018) (and related experiments by USTC), and confirms their conjecture that $$O(\sqrt{n})$$ O ( n ) depth suffices for anti-concentration. The proof is based on a previous construction of t -designs by Brandão et al. (2016), an analysis of how approximate designs behave under composition, and an extension of the quasi-orthogonality of permutation operators developed by Brandão et al. (2016). Different versions of the approximate design condition correspond to different norms, and part of our contribution is to introduce the norm corresponding to anti-concentration and to establish equivalence between these various norms for low-depth circuits. For random circuits with long-range gates, we use different methods to show that anti-concentration happens at circuit size $$O(n\ln ^2 n)$$ O ( n ln 2 n ) corresponding to depth $$O(\ln ^3 n)$$ O ( ln 3 n ) . We also show a lower bound of $$\Omega (n \ln n)$$ Ω ( n ln n )

DOI
10.1007/s00220-023-04675-z

Related papers

Local random quantum circuits are approximate polynomial-designs: numerical results

Piotr Ćwikliński, Michał Horodecki, Marek Mozrzymas +2 more

We numerically investigate the statement that local random quantum circuits acting on n qubits composed of polynomially many nearest-neighbor two-qubit gates form an approximate unitary poly( n )-design (Brandão et al 2012 arXiv:1208.0692). Using a group theory formalism, spectral gaps that give a ratio of convergence to a given t -design are evaluated for a different number of qubits n (up to 20) and degrees t ( t = 2, 3, 4 and 5), improving previously known results for n = 2 in the case of t = 2 and 3. Their values lead to the conclusion that the previously used lower bound that bounds spectral gaps values may give very little information about the real situation and in most cases, only tells us that a gap is closed. We compare our results to another lower bounding technique, again showing that its results may not be tight.

arXiv:1212.2556•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Jul 5, 2013•18 citations

Random quantum circuits are approximate unitary t -designs in depth O(nt5+o(1))

Jonas Haferkamp

The applications of random quantum circuits range from quantum computing and quantum many-body systems to the physics of black holes. Many of these applications are related to the generation of quantum pseudorandomness: Random quantum circuits are known to approximate unitary t -designs. Unitary t -designs are probability distributions that mimic Haar randomness up to t th moments. In a seminal paper, Brandão, Harrow and Horodecki prove that random quantum circuits on qubits in a brickwork architecture of depth O(nt10.5) are approximate unitary t -designs. In this work, we revisit this argument, which lower bounds the spectral gap of moment operators for local random quantum circuits by Ω(n−1t−9.5) . We improve this lower bound to Ω(n−1t−4−o(1)) , where the o(1) term goes to 0 as t→∞ . A direct consequence of this scaling is that random quantum circuits generate approximate unitary t -designs in depth O(nt5+o(1)) . Our techniques involve Gao's quantum union bound and the unreasonable effectiveness of the Clifford group. As an auxiliary result, we prove fast convergence to the Haar measure for random Clifford unitaries interleaved with Haar random single qubit unitaries.

arXiv:2203.16571•Quantum•Sep 8, 2022•117 citations

Random Quantum Circuits Beyond Moment Matching

Shih-Han Hung

Random quantum circuits aim to efficiently reproduce the statistical properties of ideal random quantum evolution. One approach is to construct approximate unitary designs, which match the moments of Haar-random unitaries up to a prescribed order with controlled error. We establish quantitative guarantees for how accurately these designs reproduce the distribution of each output probability. We show that, for every strong $\varepsilon$-approximate unitary $k$-design on $n$ qubits, the distribution of each output probability is within $O(k^{-1/2}(1+k/2^n)^{-1/2}+\varepsilon)$ in Kolmogorov distance of the Porter-Thomas distribution, a beta distribution with parameters $1$ and $2^n-1$. This bound is optimal up to constant factors, implying that a substantially better uniform bound requires additional structure. We then show that a mild form of local invariance suffices. We prove that any such design that is invariant under unitary translations acting on a single qubit approximates Porter-Thomas to total variation distance $O(k^{-1/2}+\varepsilon)$. Every strong $\varepsilon$-approximate unitary $k$-design invariant on $\log k+O(1)$ qubits achieves error $2^{-Ω(k)}+O(\varepsilon)$ in Kolmogorov distance and $2^{-Ω(k)}+O(\varepsilon\log(2/\varepsilon))$ in total variation distance. These results identify the distributional accuracy guaranteed by moment matching and the structure that improves it. As an application, we show that the Shannon entropy of the output distribution of a strong $\varepsilon$-approximate $k$-design is concentrated around its Haar value $n-Θ(1)$: its mean differs from the Haar mean by $O(k^{-1/4}+\varepsilon^{1/2})$ and its standard deviation is $O(2^{-n/2}+k^{-1/8}+\varepsilon^{1/4})$. Consequently, a trusted device sampling such circuits generates $n-O(1)$ bits of entropy per sample, which makes them useful for random number generation.

quant-pharXiv:2610.02135•Oct 2, 2026•0 citations

Local random quantum circuits form approximate designs on arbitrary architectures

Shivan Mittal, Nicholas Hunter-Jones

We consider random quantum circuits (RQC) on arbitrary connected graphs whose edges determine the allowed $2$-qudit interactions. Prior work has established that such $n$-qudit circuits with local dimension $q$ on 1D, complete, and $D$-dimensional graphs form approximate unitary designs, that is, they generate unitaries from distributions close to the Haar measure on the unitary group $U(q^n)$ after polynomially many gates. Here, we extend those results by proving that RQCs comprised of $O(\mathrm{poly}(n,k))$ gates on a wide class of graphs form approximate unitary $k$-designs. We prove that RQCs on graphs with spanning trees of bounded degree and height form $k$-designs after $O(|E|n\,\mathrm{poly}(k))$ gates, where $|E|$ is the number of edges in the graph. Furthermore, we identify larger classes of graphs for which RQCs generate approximate designs in polynomial circuit size. For $k \leq 4$, we show that RQCs on graphs of certain maximum degrees form designs after $O(|E|n)$ gates, providing explicit constants. We determine our circuit size bounds from the spectral gaps of local Hamiltonians. To that end, we extend the finite-size (or Knabe) method for bounding gaps of frustration-free Hamiltonians on regular graphs to arbitrary connected graphs. We further introduce a new method based on the Detectability Lemma for determining the spectral gaps of Hamiltonians on arbitrary graphs. Our methods have wider applicability as the first method provides a succinct alternative proof of [Commun. Math. Phys. 291, 257 (2009)] and the second method proves that RQCs on any connected architecture form approximate designs in quasi-polynomial circuit size.

arXiv:2310.19355•Oct 30, 2023•29 citations

Anti-Concentration for the Unitary Haar Measure and Applications to Random Quantum Circuits

Bill Fefferman, Ghosh, Soumik, Zhan, Wei

We prove a Carbery-Wright style anti-concentration inequality for the unitary Haar measure, by showing that the probability of a polynomial in the entries of a random unitary falling into an $\varepsilon$ range is at most a polynomial in $\varepsilon$. Using it, we show that the scrambling speed of a random quantum circuit is lower bounded: Namely, every input qubit has an influence that is at least inverse exponential in depth, on any output qubit touched by its lightcone. Our result on scrambling speed works with high probability over the choice of a circuit from an ensemble, as opposed to just working in expectation. As an application, we give the first polynomial-time algorithm for learning log-depth random quantum circuits with Haar random gates up to polynomially small diamond distance, given oracle access to the circuit. Other applications of this new scrambling speed lower bound include: $\bullet$ An optimal $Ω(\log \varepsilon^{-1})$ depth lower bound for $\varepsilon$-approximate unitary designs on any circuit architecture; $\bullet$ A polynomial-time quantum algorithm that computes the depth of a bounded-depth circuit, given oracle access to the circuit. Our learning and depth-testing algorithms apply to architectures defined over any geometric dimension, and can be generalized to a wide class of architectures with good lightcone properties.

arXiv:2407.19561•Leibniz international proceedings in informatics•Jul 28, 2024•20 citations

Approximate Unitary k-Designs from Shallow, Low-Communication Circuits (Extended Abstract)

Nicholas D. LaRacuente, Felix Leditzky

Random unitaries are useful in quantum information and related fields but hard to generate with limited resources. An approximate unitary k-design is a measure over an ensemble of unitaries such that the average is close to a Haar (uniformly) random ensemble up to the first k moments. A strong notion of approximation bounds the distance from Haar randomness in relative error: the weighted twirl induced by an approximate design can be written as a convex combination involving that of an exact design and vice versa. The main focus of our work is on efficient constructions of approximate designs, in particular whether relative-error designs in sublinear depth are possible. We give a positive answer to this question as part of our main results: 1. Twirl-Swap-Twirl: Let A and B be systems of the same size. Consider a protocol that locally applies k-design unitaries to A^k and B^k respectively, then exchanges l qudits between each copy of A and B respectively, then again applies local k-design unitaries. This protocol yields an ε-approximate relative k-design when l = O(k log k + log(1/ε)). In particular, this bound is independent of the size of A and B as long as it is sufficiently large compared to k and 1/ε. 2. Twirl-Crosstwirl: Let A_1, … , A_P be subsystems of a multipartite system A. Consider the following protocol for k copies of A: (1) locally apply a k-design unitary to each A_p for p = 1, … , P; (2) apply a "crosstwirl" k-design unitary across a joint system combining l qudits from each A_p. Assuming each A_p’s dimension is sufficiently large compared to other parameters, one can choose l to be of the form 2 (Pk + 1) log_q k + log_q P + log_q(1/ε) + O(1) to achieve an ε-approximate relative k-design. As an intermediate step, we show that this protocol achieves a k-tensor-product-expander, in which the approximation error is in 2 → 2 norm, using communication logarithmic in k. 3. Recursive Crosstwirl: Consider an m-qudit system with connectivity given by a lattice in spatial dimension D. For every D = 1, 2, …, we give a construction of an ε-approximate relative k-design using unitaries of spatially local circuit depth O ((log m + log(1/ε) + k log k ) k polylog(k)). Moreover, across the boundaries of spatially contiguous sub-regions, unitaries used in the design ensemble require only area law communication up to corrections logarithmic in m. Hence they generate only that much entanglement on any product state input. These constructions use the alternating projection method to analyze overlapping Haar twirls, giving a bound on the convergence speed to the full twirl with respect to the 2-norm. Using von Neumann subalgebra indices to replace system dimension, the 2-norm distance converts to relative error without introducing system size. The Recursive Crosstwirl construction answers one variant of [Harrow and Mehraban, 2023, Open Problem 1], showing that with a specific, layered architecture, random circuits produce relative error k-designs in sublinear depth. Moreover, it addresses [Harrow and Mehraban, 2023, Open Problem 7], showing that structured circuits in spatial dimension D of depth << m^{1/D} may achieve approximate k-designs.

•Jan 1, 2025•2 citations
Abstract We prove that  poly (t)⋅n1/D{{\,\textrm{poly}\,}}(t) \cdot n^{1/D}poly(t)⋅n1/D poly ( t ) · n 1 / D -depth local random quantum circuits with two qudit nearest-neighbor gates on a D -dimensional lattice with n qudits are approximate t -designs in various measures. These include the “monomial” measure, meaning that the monomials of a random circuit from this family have expectation close to the value that would result from the Haar measure. Previously, the best bound was  poly (t)⋅n{{\,\textrm{poly}\,}}(t)\cdot npoly(t)⋅n poly ( t ) · n due to Brandão–Harrow–Horodecki (Commun Math Phys 346(2):397–434, 2016) for D=1D=1D=1 D = 1 . We also improve the “scrambling” and “decoupling” bounds for spatially local random circuits due to Brown and Fawzi (Scrambling speed of random quantum circuits, 2012). One consequence of our result is that assuming the polynomial hierarchy (  PH {{\,\mathrm{\textsf{PH}}\,}}PH PH ) is infinite and that certain counting problems are #P\#{\textsf{P}}#P # P -hard “on average”, sampling within total variation distance from these circuits is hard for classical computers. Previously, exact sampling from the outputs of even constant-depth quantum circuits was known to be hard for classical computers under these assumptions. However the standard strategy for extending this hardness result to approximate sampling requires the quantum circuits to have a property called “anti-concentration”, meaning roughly that the output has near-maximal entropy. Unitary 2-designs have the desired anti-concentration property. Our result improves the required depth for this level of anti-concentration from linear depth to a sub-linear value, depending on the geometry of the interactions. This is relevant to a recent experiment by the Google Quantum AI group to perform such a sampling task with 53 qubits on a two-dimensional lattice (Arute in Nature 574(7779):505–510, 2019; Boixo et al. in Nate Phys 14(6):595–600, 2018) (and related experiments by USTC), and confirms their conjecture that O(n)O(\sqrt{n})O(n​) O ( n ) depth suffices for anti-concentration. The proof is based on a previous construction of t -designs by Brandão et al. (2016), an analysis of how approximate designs behave under composition, and an extension of the quasi-orthogonality of permutation operators developed by Brandão et al. (2016). Different versions of the approximate design condition correspond to different norms, and part of our contribution is to introduce the norm corresponding to anti-concentration and to establish equivalence between these various norms for low-depth circuits. For random circuits with long-range gates, we use different methods to show that anti-concentration happens at circuit size O(nln⁡2n)O(n\ln ^2 n)O(nln2n) O ( n ln 2 n ) corresponding to depth O(ln⁡3n)O(\ln ^3 n)O(ln3n) O ( ln 3 n ) . We also show a lower bound of Ω(nln⁡n)\Omega (n \ln n)Ω(nlnn) Ω ( n ln n )
We numerically investigate the statement that local random quantum circuits acting on n qubits composed of polynomially many nearest-neighbor two-qubit gates form an approximate unitary poly( n )-design (Brandão et al 2012 arXiv:1208.0692). Using a group theory formalism, spectral gaps that give a ratio of convergence to a given t -design are evaluated for a different number of qubits n (up to 20) and degrees t ( t = 2, 3, 4 and 5), improving previously known results for n = 2 in the case of t = 2 and 3. Their values lead to the conclusion that the previously used lower bound that bounds spectral gaps values may give very little information about the real situation and in most cases, only tells us that a gap is closed. We compare our results to another lower bounding technique, again showing that its results may not be tight.
The applications of random quantum circuits range from quantum computing and quantum many-body systems to the physics of black holes. Many of these applications are related to the generation of quantum pseudorandomness: Random quantum circuits are known to approximate unitary t -designs. Unitary t -designs are probability distributions that mimic Haar randomness up to t th moments. In a seminal paper, Brandão, Harrow and Horodecki prove that random quantum circuits on qubits in a brickwork architecture of depth O(nt10.5) are approximate unitary t -designs. In this work, we revisit this argument, which lower bounds the spectral gap of moment operators for local random quantum circuits by Ω(n−1t−9.5) . We improve this lower bound to Ω(n−1t−4−o(1)) , where the o(1) term goes to 0 as t→∞ . A direct consequence of this scaling is that random quantum circuits generate approximate unitary t -designs in depth O(nt5+o(1)) . Our techniques involve Gao's quantum union bound and the unreasonable effectiveness of the Clifford group. As an auxiliary result, we prove fast convergence to the Haar measure for random Clifford unitaries interleaved with Haar random single qubit unitaries.
Random quantum circuits aim to efficiently reproduce the statistical properties of ideal random quantum evolution. One approach is to construct approximate unitary designs, which match the moments of Haar-random unitaries up to a prescribed order with controlled error. We establish quantitative guarantees for how accurately these designs reproduce the distribution of each output probability. We show that, for every strong ε\varepsilonε-approximate unitary kkk-design on nnn qubits, the distribution of each output probability is within O(k−1/2(1+k/2n)−1/2+ε)O(k^{-1/2}(1+k/2^n)^{-1/2}+\varepsilon)O(k−1/2(1+k/2n)−1/2+ε) in Kolmogorov distance of the Porter-Thomas distribution, a beta distribution with parameters 111 and 2n−12^n-12n−1. This bound is optimal up to constant factors, implying that a substantially better uniform bound requires additional structure. We then show that a mild form of local invariance suffices. We prove that any such design that is invariant under unitary translations acting on a single qubit approximates Porter-Thomas to total variation distance O(k−1/2+ε)O(k^{-1/2}+\varepsilon)O(k−1/2+ε). Every strong ε\varepsilonε-approximate unitary kkk-design invariant on log⁡k+O(1)\log k+O(1)logk+O(1) qubits achieves error 2−Ω(k)+O(ε)2^{-Ω(k)}+O(\varepsilon)2−Ω(k)+O(ε) in Kolmogorov distance and 2−Ω(k)+O(εlog⁡(2/ε))2^{-Ω(k)}+O(\varepsilon\log(2/\varepsilon))2−Ω(k)+O(εlog(2/ε)) in total variation distance. These results identify the distributional accuracy guaranteed by moment matching and the structure that improves it. As an application, we show that the Shannon entropy of the output distribution of a strong ε\varepsilonε-approximate kkk-design is concentrated around its Haar value n−Θ(1)n-Θ(1)n−Θ(1): its mean differs from the Haar mean by O(k−1/4+ε1/2)O(k^{-1/4}+\varepsilon^{1/2})O(k−1/4+ε1/2) and its standard deviation is O(2−n/2+k−1/8+ε1/4)O(2^{-n/2}+k^{-1/8}+\varepsilon^{1/4})O(2−n/2+k−1/8+ε1/4). Consequently, a trusted device sampling such circuits generates n−O(1)n-O(1)n−O(1) bits of entropy per sample, which makes them useful for random number generation.
We consider random quantum circuits (RQC) on arbitrary connected graphs whose edges determine the allowed 222-qudit interactions. Prior work has established that such nnn-qudit circuits with local dimension qqq on 1D, complete, and DDD-dimensional graphs form approximate unitary designs, that is, they generate unitaries from distributions close to the Haar measure on the unitary group U(qn)U(q^n)U(qn) after polynomially many gates. Here, we extend those results by proving that RQCs comprised of O(poly(n,k))O(\mathrm{poly}(n,k))O(poly(n,k)) gates on a wide class of graphs form approximate unitary kkk-designs. We prove that RQCs on graphs with spanning trees of bounded degree and height form kkk-designs after O(∣E∣n poly(k))O(|E|n\,\mathrm{poly}(k))O(∣E∣npoly(k)) gates, where ∣E∣|E|∣E∣ is the number of edges in the graph. Furthermore, we identify larger classes of graphs for which RQCs generate approximate designs in polynomial circuit size. For k≤4k \leq 4k≤4, we show that RQCs on graphs of certain maximum degrees form designs after O(∣E∣n)O(|E|n)O(∣E∣n) gates, providing explicit constants. We determine our circuit size bounds from the spectral gaps of local Hamiltonians. To that end, we extend the finite-size (or Knabe) method for bounding gaps of frustration-free Hamiltonians on regular graphs to arbitrary connected graphs. We further introduce a new method based on the Detectability Lemma for determining the spectral gaps of Hamiltonians on arbitrary graphs. Our methods have wider applicability as the first method provides a succinct alternative proof of [Commun. Math. Phys. 291, 257 (2009)] and the second method proves that RQCs on any connected architecture form approximate designs in quasi-polynomial circuit size.
We prove a Carbery-Wright style anti-concentration inequality for the unitary Haar measure, by showing that the probability of a polynomial in the entries of a random unitary falling into an ε\varepsilonε range is at most a polynomial in ε\varepsilonε. Using it, we show that the scrambling speed of a random quantum circuit is lower bounded: Namely, every input qubit has an influence that is at least inverse exponential in depth, on any output qubit touched by its lightcone. Our result on scrambling speed works with high probability over the choice of a circuit from an ensemble, as opposed to just working in expectation. As an application, we give the first polynomial-time algorithm for learning log-depth random quantum circuits with Haar random gates up to polynomially small diamond distance, given oracle access to the circuit. Other applications of this new scrambling speed lower bound include: ∙\bullet∙ An optimal Ω(log⁡ε−1)Ω(\log \varepsilon^{-1})Ω(logε−1) depth lower bound for ε\varepsilonε-approximate unitary designs on any circuit architecture; ∙\bullet∙ A polynomial-time quantum algorithm that computes the depth of a bounded-depth circuit, given oracle access to the circuit. Our learning and depth-testing algorithms apply to architectures defined over any geometric dimension, and can be generalized to a wide class of architectures with good lightcone properties.
Random unitaries are useful in quantum information and related fields but hard to generate with limited resources. An approximate unitary k-design is a measure over an ensemble of unitaries such that the average is close to a Haar (uniformly) random ensemble up to the first k moments. A strong notion of approximation bounds the distance from Haar randomness in relative error: the weighted twirl induced by an approximate design can be written as a convex combination involving that of an exact design and vice versa. The main focus of our work is on efficient constructions of approximate designs, in particular whether relative-error designs in sublinear depth are possible. We give a positive answer to this question as part of our main results: 1. Twirl-Swap-Twirl: Let A and B be systems of the same size. Consider a protocol that locally applies k-design unitaries to A^k and B^k respectively, then exchanges l qudits between each copy of A and B respectively, then again applies local k-design unitaries. This protocol yields an ε-approximate relative k-design when l = O(k log k + log(1/ε)). In particular, this bound is independent of the size of A and B as long as it is sufficiently large compared to k and 1/ε. 2. Twirl-Crosstwirl: Let A_1, … , A_P be subsystems of a multipartite system A. Consider the following protocol for k copies of A: (1) locally apply a k-design unitary to each A_p for p = 1, … , P; (2) apply a "crosstwirl" k-design unitary across a joint system combining l qudits from each A_p. Assuming each A_p’s dimension is sufficiently large compared to other parameters, one can choose l to be of the form 2 (Pk + 1) log_q k + log_q P + log_q(1/ε) + O(1) to achieve an ε-approximate relative k-design. As an intermediate step, we show that this protocol achieves a k-tensor-product-expander, in which the approximation error is in 2 → 2 norm, using communication logarithmic in k. 3. Recursive Crosstwirl: Consider an m-qudit system with connectivity given by a lattice in spatial dimension D. For every D = 1, 2, …, we give a construction of an ε-approximate relative k-design using unitaries of spatially local circuit depth O ((log m + log(1/ε) + k log k ) k polylog(k)). Moreover, across the boundaries of spatially contiguous sub-regions, unitaries used in the design ensemble require only area law communication up to corrections logarithmic in m. Hence they generate only that much entanglement on any product state input. These constructions use the alternating projection method to analyze overlapping Haar twirls, giving a bound on the convergence speed to the full twirl with respect to the 2-norm. Using von Neumann subalgebra indices to replace system dimension, the 2-norm distance converts to relative error without introducing system size. The Recursive Crosstwirl construction answers one variant of [Harrow and Mehraban, 2023, Open Problem 1], showing that with a specific, layered architecture, random circuits produce relative error k-designs in sublinear depth. Moreover, it addresses [Harrow and Mehraban, 2023, Open Problem 7], showing that structured circuits in spatial dimension D of depth << m^{1/D} may achieve approximate k-designs.