Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1809.04447

Richardson-Gaudin models and broken integrability

Pieter W. Claeys

Published Sep 11, 2018• 22 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

This thesis presents an introduction to the class of Richardson-Gaudin integrable models, with special focus on the Bethe ansatz wave function, and investigates ways of applying the properties of Richardson-Gaudin models both in and out of integrability. A framework is outlined for the numerical and theoretical treatment of these systems, exposing a duality allowing the Bethe equations to be solved numerically. This is extended to the calculation of inner products and correlation functions. Using this framework, the influence of particle exchange on the Bethe ansatz is discussed, after which it is shown how the Bethe ansatz is able to accurately model wave functions of non-integrable models in two different settings. First, a variational approach is outlined for stationary models where integrability-breaking perturbations are explicitly introduced. Second, an alternative way of breaking integrability is through the introduction of dynamics and periodic driving, where it is shown how integrability can be used to model the resulting Floquet many-body resonances. Throughout this work, it is shown how the clear-cut structure and relatively large freedom in Richardson-Gaudin models makes them ideal for an investigation of the general principles of integrability, as well as being a perfect testing ground for the development of new quantum many-body techniques beyond integrability.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1809.04447

Related papers

Richardson-Gaudin integrable systems (and beyond) for strongly correlated quantum many-body systems

Stijn De Baerdemacker, Paul W. Ayers, Patrick Bultinck +4 more

Integrable systems take a special niche in quantum many-body systems. Due to the underlying algebraic structure, it is possible to capture all the quantum correlations exactly within a Bethe Ansatz wavefunction at a favourably scaling computational cost. Richardson [1] and Gaudin [2] have shown that the reduced Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer (BCS) Hamiltonian of superconductivity [3] is integrable and that the Bethe Ansatz state corresponds to a product wave function of generalized Cooper pairs [4]. In this formulation, the Bethe ansatz state is equivalent to a non-orthogonal geminal, which is widely used in quantum chemistry to describe electron pair correlations in atoms and molecules [5]. Inspired by Richardson-Gaudin integrable systems, it is possible to construct classes of non-orthogonal geminals, allowing for an accurate description of realistic and non-integrable strongly correlated atoms and molecules, while retaining the favorable computational scaling [6, 7]. In this contribution, I will discuss Richardson-Gaudin integrability and why it is useful for strongly correlated systems.

•Jan 1, 2013•0 citations

Eigenvalue-based method and form-factor determinant representations for integrable XXZ Richardson-Gaudin models

Pieter W. Claeys, Stijn De Baerdemacker, Mario Van Raemdonck +1 more

We propose an extension of the numerical approach for integrable Richardson-Gaudin models based on a new set of eigenvalue-based variables [A. Faribault et al., Phys. Rev. B 83, 235124 (2011); O. El Araby et al., Phys. Rev. B 85, 115130 (2012)]. Starting solely from the Gaudin algebra, the approach is generalized towards the full class of XXZ Richardson-Gaudin models. This allows for a fast and robust numerical determination of the spectral properties of these models, avoiding the singularities usually arising at the so-called singular points. We also provide different determinant expressions for the normalization of the Bethe ansatz states and form factors of local spin operators, opening up possibilities for the study of larger systems, both integrable and nonintegrable. These expressions can be written in terms of the new set of variables and generalize the results previously obtained for rational Richardson-Gaudin models [A. Faribault and D. Schuricht, J. Phys. A 45, 485202 (2012)] and Dicke-Jaynes-Cummings-Gaudin models [H. Tschirhart and A. Faribault, J. Phys. A 47, 405204 (2014)]. Remarkably, these results are independent of the explicit parametrization of the Gaudin algebra, exposing a universality in the properties of Richardson-Gaudin integrable systems deeply linked to the underlying algebraic structure.

arXiv:1501.05827•Physical Review B•Apr 3, 2015•74 citations

Variational method for integrability-breaking Richardson-Gaudin models

Pieter W. Claeys, Jean-Sébastien Caux, Dimitri Van Neck +1 more

We present a variational method for approximating the ground state of spin models close to (Richardson-Gaudin) integrability. This is done by variationally optimizing eigenstates of integrable Richardson-Gaudin models, where the toolbox of integrability allows for an efficient evaluation and minimization of the energy functional. The method is shown to return exact results for integrable models and improve substantially on perturbation theory for models close to integrability. For large integrability-breaking interactions, it is shown how (avoided) level crossings necessitate the use of excited states of integrable Hamiltonians in order to accurately describe the ground states of general nonintegrable models.

arXiv:1707.06793•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Oct 30, 2017•14 citations

A primer on the study of one dimensional systems, Bethe ansatz and integrability.

Daniel Pérez Cruz

In this work we will be introducing important concepts, techniques and procedures related to the study of one dimensional quantum many body systems. The study of this kind of systems started shortly after Schr¨odinger’s seminal paper (1926) with the work of Hans Bethe (1931). He introduced a novel technique, the Bethe ansatz, that would stay unrecognized until the paradigmatic work of Lieb and Liniger (1963). They were able to solve, without any approximation, a many body quantum system analytically, both for a finite system of bosons as well as in the thermodynamic limit. This opened a new research field that has helped to understand the physics of strongly correlated quantum systems as well as the dynamics of dilute gases. Moreover, the recent experimental realization of systems of this kind has fueled not just intense experimental efforts to reproduce more diverse one dimensional systems but also theoretical ones. The importance of dealing with one dimensional systems is that they exhibit exotic phenomena that are not present in 2D and 3D systems, as we shall see, in the process of fermionization. Moreover, one dimensional systems are more prone to admit an analytical solution, making it easier to understand the dynamics of the system. Another topic that we will be covering is integrability. Coming from the theory of classical Hamiltonian systems it has been an elusive topic for physicists, and some advances have been done with more mathematically-oriented purposes. Bethe’s method and its generalizations (Nested, Thermodynamic, Algebraic, Coordinate Bethe Ansatz) allow us to determine whether a system is integrable or not, because solvability by the ansatz is a clear signature of the system being integrable. The study of integrability in quantum systems has become a topic of great interest because of the deep implications it has in quantum statistical mechanics. The relation between integrability and thermalization is yet under study and the mechanisms that enable one or the other are to be discovered, although some hypothesis, as the Eigenstate thermalization hypothesis, have been proposed. The main motivation of this work is to serve as an introduction to this vast topic. We begin with a brief review of scattering theory, introducing some useful results and how these can be used to solve one dimensional problems. The next step is an overview of the problem of thermalization: when should one expect a system to thermalize? Which mechanisms are responsible? The link between integrability, thermalization and quantum collisions is established here, qualitatively. Our following task is to study Bethe’s method, initially giving a general description and why it being a solution implies that the system is integrable. Then, we solve the problem of a system of N bosons in a ring with delta interaction [1], both for finite N and in the thermodynamic limit. We study the spectrum of this model and find some relations between the distribution of Bethe’s rapidities and the spectrum of random matrices, which serve us to introduce the concept of level repulsion and distribution of level spacing. After some calculations we proceed to study a slightly modified model for a system of three bosons, where we substitute the delta potential by a Gaussian. We repeat the same analysis as for the Lieb-Liniger model and analyze the similarities and differences between them. Theoretical research on this topic has found that the system is integrable for certain regimes. We study the statistics of the energy spectrum for different values of the parameters of the system, comparing the results with the integrable or non integrable expected results.

Scientia Insularum Revista de Ciencias Naturales en islas•Jan 1, 2022•0 citations

The Roaming Bethe Roots: An Effective Bethe Ansatz Beyond Integrability

Wenlong Zhao, Yunfeng Jiang, Rui-Dong Zhu

Abstract We propose an effective Bethe ansatz (EBA) for solving quantum many-body systems near an integrable point. Our approach retains the functional form of the Bethe wave function while renormalizing the Bethe roots to account for integrability-breaking interactions. These effective roots are determined by minimizing physically motivated cost functions. The resulting off-shell Bethe states serve as approximate eigenstates of the non-integrable models. We assess the quality of the approximation using various physical observables, including the energy eigenvalue, state fidelity, and bipartite entanglement entropy. Our tests show that for models with weak integrability-breaking, the EBA provides a high-quality approximation to the exact eigenstates over a wide range of deformation parameters. In contrast, for models with strong integrability-breaking interactions, the efficacy of EBA degrades relatively quickly as the deformation parameter increases. The efficacy of the method thus offers a useful probe for characterizing the strength of integrability breaking. Within its regime of accuracy, it also provides a new representation of the eigenstates of nearly integrable models, enabling one to exploit the algebraic structure inherited from integrability.

arXiv:2604.04627•Chinese Physics Letters•Aug 28, 2026•2 citations

Kaleidoscope Yang-Baxter Equation for Gaudin's Kaleidoscope models

Wen-Jie Qiu, Xi-Wen Guan, Yi-Cong Yu

Recently, researchers have proposed the Asymmetric Bethe ansatz method - a theoretical tool that extends the scope of Bethe ansatz-solvable models by "breaking" partial mirror symmetry via the introduction of a fully reflecting boundary. Within this framework, the integrability conditions which were originally put forward by Gaudin have been further generalized. In this work, building on Gaudin's generalized kaleidoscope model, we present a detailed investigation of the relationship between DN symmetry and its integrability. We demonstrate that the mathematical essence of integrability in this class of models is characterized by a newly proposed Kaleidoscope Yang-Baxter Equation. Furthermore, we show that the solvability of a model via the coordinate Bethe ansatz depends not only on the consistency relations satisfied by scattering matrices, but also on the model's boundary conditions and the symmetry of the subspace where solutions are sought. Through finite element method based numerical studies, we further confirm that Bethe ansatz integrability arises in a specific symmetry sector. Finally, by analyzing the algebraic structure of the Kaleidoscope Yang-Baxter Equation, we derive a series of novel quantum algebraic identities within the framework of quantum torus algebra.

nlin.SICross-listedarXiv:2601.13596•SciPost Physics Core•Jan 21, 2026•1 citation
This thesis presents an introduction to the class of Richardson-Gaudin integrable models, with special focus on the Bethe ansatz wave function, and investigates ways of applying the properties of Richardson-Gaudin models both in and out of integrability. A framework is outlined for the numerical and theoretical treatment of these systems, exposing a duality allowing the Bethe equations to be solved numerically. This is extended to the calculation of inner products and correlation functions. Using this framework, the influence of particle exchange on the Bethe ansatz is discussed, after which it is shown how the Bethe ansatz is able to accurately model wave functions of non-integrable models in two different settings. First, a variational approach is outlined for stationary models where integrability-breaking perturbations are explicitly introduced. Second, an alternative way of breaking integrability is through the introduction of dynamics and periodic driving, where it is shown how integrability can be used to model the resulting Floquet many-body resonances. Throughout this work, it is shown how the clear-cut structure and relatively large freedom in Richardson-Gaudin models makes them ideal for an investigation of the general principles of integrability, as well as being a perfect testing ground for the development of new quantum many-body techniques beyond integrability.
Integrable systems take a special niche in quantum many-body systems. Due to the underlying algebraic structure, it is possible to capture all the quantum correlations exactly within a Bethe Ansatz wavefunction at a favourably scaling computational cost. Richardson [1] and Gaudin [2] have shown that the reduced Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer (BCS) Hamiltonian of superconductivity [3] is integrable and that the Bethe Ansatz state corresponds to a product wave function of generalized Cooper pairs [4]. In this formulation, the Bethe ansatz state is equivalent to a non-orthogonal geminal, which is widely used in quantum chemistry to describe electron pair correlations in atoms and molecules [5]. Inspired by Richardson-Gaudin integrable systems, it is possible to construct classes of non-orthogonal geminals, allowing for an accurate description of realistic and non-integrable strongly correlated atoms and molecules, while retaining the favorable computational scaling [6, 7]. In this contribution, I will discuss Richardson-Gaudin integrability and why it is useful for strongly correlated systems.
We propose an extension of the numerical approach for integrable Richardson-Gaudin models based on a new set of eigenvalue-based variables [A. Faribault et al., Phys. Rev. B 83, 235124 (2011); O. El Araby et al., Phys. Rev. B 85, 115130 (2012)]. Starting solely from the Gaudin algebra, the approach is generalized towards the full class of XXZ Richardson-Gaudin models. This allows for a fast and robust numerical determination of the spectral properties of these models, avoiding the singularities usually arising at the so-called singular points. We also provide different determinant expressions for the normalization of the Bethe ansatz states and form factors of local spin operators, opening up possibilities for the study of larger systems, both integrable and nonintegrable. These expressions can be written in terms of the new set of variables and generalize the results previously obtained for rational Richardson-Gaudin models [A. Faribault and D. Schuricht, J. Phys. A 45, 485202 (2012)] and Dicke-Jaynes-Cummings-Gaudin models [H. Tschirhart and A. Faribault, J. Phys. A 47, 405204 (2014)]. Remarkably, these results are independent of the explicit parametrization of the Gaudin algebra, exposing a universality in the properties of Richardson-Gaudin integrable systems deeply linked to the underlying algebraic structure.
We present a variational method for approximating the ground state of spin models close to (Richardson-Gaudin) integrability. This is done by variationally optimizing eigenstates of integrable Richardson-Gaudin models, where the toolbox of integrability allows for an efficient evaluation and minimization of the energy functional. The method is shown to return exact results for integrable models and improve substantially on perturbation theory for models close to integrability. For large integrability-breaking interactions, it is shown how (avoided) level crossings necessitate the use of excited states of integrable Hamiltonians in order to accurately describe the ground states of general nonintegrable models.
In this work we will be introducing important concepts, techniques and procedures related to the study of one dimensional quantum many body systems. The study of this kind of systems started shortly after Schr¨odinger’s seminal paper (1926) with the work of Hans Bethe (1931). He introduced a novel technique, the Bethe ansatz, that would stay unrecognized until the paradigmatic work of Lieb and Liniger (1963). They were able to solve, without any approximation, a many body quantum system analytically, both for a finite system of bosons as well as in the thermodynamic limit. This opened a new research field that has helped to understand the physics of strongly correlated quantum systems as well as the dynamics of dilute gases. Moreover, the recent experimental realization of systems of this kind has fueled not just intense experimental efforts to reproduce more diverse one dimensional systems but also theoretical ones. The importance of dealing with one dimensional systems is that they exhibit exotic phenomena that are not present in 2D and 3D systems, as we shall see, in the process of fermionization. Moreover, one dimensional systems are more prone to admit an analytical solution, making it easier to understand the dynamics of the system. Another topic that we will be covering is integrability. Coming from the theory of classical Hamiltonian systems it has been an elusive topic for physicists, and some advances have been done with more mathematically-oriented purposes. Bethe’s method and its generalizations (Nested, Thermodynamic, Algebraic, Coordinate Bethe Ansatz) allow us to determine whether a system is integrable or not, because solvability by the ansatz is a clear signature of the system being integrable. The study of integrability in quantum systems has become a topic of great interest because of the deep implications it has in quantum statistical mechanics. The relation between integrability and thermalization is yet under study and the mechanisms that enable one or the other are to be discovered, although some hypothesis, as the Eigenstate thermalization hypothesis, have been proposed. The main motivation of this work is to serve as an introduction to this vast topic. We begin with a brief review of scattering theory, introducing some useful results and how these can be used to solve one dimensional problems. The next step is an overview of the problem of thermalization: when should one expect a system to thermalize? Which mechanisms are responsible? The link between integrability, thermalization and quantum collisions is established here, qualitatively. Our following task is to study Bethe’s method, initially giving a general description and why it being a solution implies that the system is integrable. Then, we solve the problem of a system of N bosons in a ring with delta interaction [1], both for finite N and in the thermodynamic limit. We study the spectrum of this model and find some relations between the distribution of Bethe’s rapidities and the spectrum of random matrices, which serve us to introduce the concept of level repulsion and distribution of level spacing. After some calculations we proceed to study a slightly modified model for a system of three bosons, where we substitute the delta potential by a Gaussian. We repeat the same analysis as for the Lieb-Liniger model and analyze the similarities and differences between them. Theoretical research on this topic has found that the system is integrable for certain regimes. We study the statistics of the energy spectrum for different values of the parameters of the system, comparing the results with the integrable or non integrable expected results.
Abstract We propose an effective Bethe ansatz (EBA) for solving quantum many-body systems near an integrable point. Our approach retains the functional form of the Bethe wave function while renormalizing the Bethe roots to account for integrability-breaking interactions. These effective roots are determined by minimizing physically motivated cost functions. The resulting off-shell Bethe states serve as approximate eigenstates of the non-integrable models. We assess the quality of the approximation using various physical observables, including the energy eigenvalue, state fidelity, and bipartite entanglement entropy. Our tests show that for models with weak integrability-breaking, the EBA provides a high-quality approximation to the exact eigenstates over a wide range of deformation parameters. In contrast, for models with strong integrability-breaking interactions, the efficacy of EBA degrades relatively quickly as the deformation parameter increases. The efficacy of the method thus offers a useful probe for characterizing the strength of integrability breaking. Within its regime of accuracy, it also provides a new representation of the eigenstates of nearly integrable models, enabling one to exploit the algebraic structure inherited from integrability.
Recently, researchers have proposed the Asymmetric Bethe ansatz method - a theoretical tool that extends the scope of Bethe ansatz-solvable models by "breaking" partial mirror symmetry via the introduction of a fully reflecting boundary. Within this framework, the integrability conditions which were originally put forward by Gaudin have been further generalized. In this work, building on Gaudin's generalized kaleidoscope model, we present a detailed investigation of the relationship between DN symmetry and its integrability. We demonstrate that the mathematical essence of integrability in this class of models is characterized by a newly proposed Kaleidoscope Yang-Baxter Equation. Furthermore, we show that the solvability of a model via the coordinate Bethe ansatz depends not only on the consistency relations satisfied by scattering matrices, but also on the model's boundary conditions and the symmetry of the subspace where solutions are sought. Through finite element method based numerical studies, we further confirm that Bethe ansatz integrability arises in a specific symmetry sector. Finally, by analyzing the algebraic structure of the Kaleidoscope Yang-Baxter Equation, we derive a series of novel quantum algebraic identities within the framework of quantum torus algebra.