Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1808.04643 · Physical Review A

Time in quantum mechanics: A fresh look at the continuity equation

Axel Schild

Published Nov 12, 2018• 29 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The local conservation of a physical quantity whose distribution changes with time is mathematically described by the continuity equation. The corresponding time parameter, however, is defined with respect to an idealized classical clock. We consider what happens when this classical time is replaced by a nonrelativistic quantum-mechanical description of the clock. From the clock-dependent Schr\"odinger equation (as an analog of the time-dependent Schr\"odinger equation) we derive a continuity equation, where, instead of a time derivative, an operator occurs that depends on the flux (probability current) density of the clock. This clock-dependent continuity equation can be used to analyze the dynamics of a quantum system and to study degrees of freedom that may be used as internal clocks for an approximate description of the dynamics of the remaining degrees of freedom. As an illustration, we study a simple model for coupled electron-nuclear dynamics and interpret the nuclei as quantum clock for the electronic motion. We find that whenever the Born-Oppenheimer approximation is valid, the continuity equation shows that the nuclei are the only relevant clock for the electrons.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.98.052113

Related papers

Derivation of the non-stationary Schrödinger equation from the stationary one

Н.А. Винокуров

A derivation of the time-dependent Schrödinger equation from the time-independent one is considered. Instead of time, the coordinate of an additional degree of freedom, the clock, is introduced into the original time-independent Schrödinger equation. It is shown that the standard time-dependent Schrödinger equation can be obtained for the semiclassical clock only. For elucidation of the physical meaning of the equation obtained in this way, various types of clocks are discussed. In addition, the corresponding equation for the density matrix and formulas for the mean values of operators are derived.

arXiv:2307.13711•Siberian Journal of Physics•Feb 22, 2024•1 citation

Time in quantum mechanics: A fresh look on quantum hydrodynamics and quantum trajectories

Axel Schild

Quantum hydrodynamics is a formulation of quantum mechanics based on the probability density and flux (current) density of a quantum system. It can be used to define trajectories which allow for a particle-based interpretation of quantum mechanics, commonly known as Bohmian mechanics. However, quantum hydrodynamics rests on the usual time-dependent formulation of quantum mechanics where time appears as a parameter. This parameter describes the correlation of the state of the quantum system with an external system -- a clock -- which behaves according to classical mechanics. With the Exact Factorization of a quantum system into a marginal and a conditional system, quantum mechanics and hence quantum hydrodynamics can be generalized for quantum clocks. In this article, the theory is developed and it is shown that trajectories for the quantum system can still be defined, and that these trajectories depend conditionally on the trajectory of the clock. Such trajectories are not only interesting from a fundamental point of view, but they can also find practical applications whenever a dynamics relative to an external time parameter is composed of "fast" and "slow" degrees of freedom and the interest is in the fast ones, while quantum effects of the slow ones (like a branching of the wavepacket) cannot be neglected. As an illustration, time- and clock-dependent trajectories are calculated for a model system of a non-adiabatic dynamics, where an electron is the quantum system, a nucleus is the quantum clock, and an external time parameter is provided, e.g. via an interaction with a laser field that is not treated explicitly.

arXiv:1911.13033•Nov 29, 2019•1 citation

Internal clock formulation of quantum mechanics

Przemysław Małkiewicz, Artur Miroszewski

The basic tenet of the present work is the assumption of the lack of external and fixed time in the Universe. This assumption is best embodied by general relativity, which replaces the fixed space-time structure with the gravitational field, which is subject to dynamics. The lack of time does not imply the lack of evolution but rather brings to the forefront the role of internal clocks which are some largely arbitrary internal degrees of freedom with respect to which the evolution of timeless systems can be described. We take this idea seriously and try to understand what it implies for quantum mechanics when the fixed external time is replaced by an arbitrary internal clock. We put the issue in a solid, mathematically rigorous framework. We find that the dynamical interpretation of a quantum state of a timeless system depends on the employed internal clock. In particular, we find that the continuous spectra of well-known dynamical observables like the position of a free particle on the real line may turn discrete if measured in unusual clocks. We discuss the meaning of our result for attempts at quantization of global gravitational degrees of freedom.

arXiv:1706.00743•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Aug 7, 2017•17 citations

Unification of the conditional probability and semiclassical interpretations for the problem of time in quantum theory

J. C. Arce

We show that the time-dependent Schr\"odinger equation (TDSE) is the phenomenological dynamical law of evolution unraveled in the classical limit from a timeless formulation in terms of probability amplitudes conditioned by the values of suitably chosen internal clock variables, thereby unifying the conditional probability interpretation (CPI) and the semiclassical approach for the problem of time in quantum theory. Our formalism stems from an exact factorization of the Hamiltonian eigenfunction of the clock plus system composite, where the clock and system factors play the role of marginal and conditional probability amplitudes, respectively. Application of the Variation Principle leads to a pair of exact coupled pseudoeigenvalue equations for these amplitudes, whose solution requires an iterative self-consistent procedure. The equation for the conditional amplitude constitutes an effective ``equation of motion'' for the quantum state of the system with respect to the clock variables. These coupled equations also provide a convenient framework for treating the back-reaction of the system on the clock at various levels of approximation. At the lowest level, when the WKB approximation for the marginal amplitude is appropriate, in the classical limit of the clock variables the TDSE for the system emerges as a matter of course from the conditional equation. In this connection, we provide a discussion of the characteristics required by physical systems to serve as good clocks. This development is seen to be advantageous over the original CPI and semiclassical approach since it maintains the essence of the conventional formalism of quantum mechanics, admits a transparent interpretation, avoids the use of the Born-Oppenheimer approximation, and resolves various objections raised about them.

arXiv:1202.4638•Physical Review A•Apr 9, 2012•17 citations

The time-dependent Schrodinger equation for a closed quantum system

Hitoshi Kitada, J. Jeknić-Dugić, M. Arsenijević +1 more

Ever since Schrodinger, the time-dependent Schrodinger equation has been regarded as the fundamental physical law of the unitary-only quantum theory. However, while the origin of time for non-conservative systems can be traced back to the environmental influence, this procedure is inapplicable for the closed (conservative) quantum systems. Hence the question of the origin of time for closed systems. In addressing this issue, in order to avoid circularity of the standard universal (global) time as well as assumptions that could be additional to the standard postulates of quantum theory, we stick to the so-called quantum-mechanical local time. The problems that inevitably appear in such minimalist rejection of the standard role of time in physics are solved with mathematical rigor while leading to the emergent time for every, at least approximately, closed (conservative) system as well as to establishing the time-dependent Schrodinger law as the fundamental law of the unitary non-relativistic as well as relativistic-field quantum theory.

•Jun 15, 2016•0 citations

Estimation Of The Quantum Effects Of Nuclei in Large Molecular Systems

Bing Gu

Chemical dynamics, in principle, should be understood by solving the time-dependent Schrödinger equation for a molecular system, describing motion of the nuclei and electrons. However, the computational efforts to solve this partial second-order differential equation scales exponentially with the system size, which prevents us from getting exact numerical solutions for systems larger than 4-5 atoms. Thus, approximations simplifying the picture are necessary. The so-called Born-Oppenheimer approximation, separating motion of the electrons and nuclei is the central one: solution to the electronic Schrödinger equation defines the potential energy surface on which the nuclear motion unfolds, and there are standard quantum chemistry software packages for solving the electronic Schrödinger equation. For the nuclear Schrödinger equation, however, there are no widely applicable quantum-mechanical approaches, and most simulations are performed using classical Newtonian mechanics which is often adequate due to large nuclear masses. However, the nuclear quantum effects are significant for chemical processes involving light nuclei at low energies, and including these effects into simulation, even approximately, is highly desirable. In this dissertation, an approximate methodology of including quantum-mechanical effects within the quantum trajectory or the de Broglie-Bohm formulation of the Schrödinger equations is developed. Use of the trajectory framework makes the approach scalable to hundreds of degrees of freedom. The methodology is applied to study high-dimensional systems (solid He4 and others) relevant to chemistry.

•Jan 1, 2016•0 citations
The local conservation of a physical quantity whose distribution changes with time is mathematically described by the continuity equation. The corresponding time parameter, however, is defined with respect to an idealized classical clock. We consider what happens when this classical time is replaced by a nonrelativistic quantum-mechanical description of the clock. From the clock-dependent Schr"odinger equation (as an analog of the time-dependent Schr"odinger equation) we derive a continuity equation, where, instead of a time derivative, an operator occurs that depends on the flux (probability current) density of the clock. This clock-dependent continuity equation can be used to analyze the dynamics of a quantum system and to study degrees of freedom that may be used as internal clocks for an approximate description of the dynamics of the remaining degrees of freedom. As an illustration, we study a simple model for coupled electron-nuclear dynamics and interpret the nuclei as quantum clock for the electronic motion. We find that whenever the Born-Oppenheimer approximation is valid, the continuity equation shows that the nuclei are the only relevant clock for the electrons.
A derivation of the time-dependent Schrödinger equation from the time-independent one is considered. Instead of time, the coordinate of an additional degree of freedom, the clock, is introduced into the original time-independent Schrödinger equation. It is shown that the standard time-dependent Schrödinger equation can be obtained for the semiclassical clock only. For elucidation of the physical meaning of the equation obtained in this way, various types of clocks are discussed. In addition, the corresponding equation for the density matrix and formulas for the mean values of operators are derived.
Quantum hydrodynamics is a formulation of quantum mechanics based on the probability density and flux (current) density of a quantum system. It can be used to define trajectories which allow for a particle-based interpretation of quantum mechanics, commonly known as Bohmian mechanics. However, quantum hydrodynamics rests on the usual time-dependent formulation of quantum mechanics where time appears as a parameter. This parameter describes the correlation of the state of the quantum system with an external system -- a clock -- which behaves according to classical mechanics. With the Exact Factorization of a quantum system into a marginal and a conditional system, quantum mechanics and hence quantum hydrodynamics can be generalized for quantum clocks. In this article, the theory is developed and it is shown that trajectories for the quantum system can still be defined, and that these trajectories depend conditionally on the trajectory of the clock. Such trajectories are not only interesting from a fundamental point of view, but they can also find practical applications whenever a dynamics relative to an external time parameter is composed of "fast" and "slow" degrees of freedom and the interest is in the fast ones, while quantum effects of the slow ones (like a branching of the wavepacket) cannot be neglected. As an illustration, time- and clock-dependent trajectories are calculated for a model system of a non-adiabatic dynamics, where an electron is the quantum system, a nucleus is the quantum clock, and an external time parameter is provided, e.g. via an interaction with a laser field that is not treated explicitly.
The basic tenet of the present work is the assumption of the lack of external and fixed time in the Universe. This assumption is best embodied by general relativity, which replaces the fixed space-time structure with the gravitational field, which is subject to dynamics. The lack of time does not imply the lack of evolution but rather brings to the forefront the role of internal clocks which are some largely arbitrary internal degrees of freedom with respect to which the evolution of timeless systems can be described. We take this idea seriously and try to understand what it implies for quantum mechanics when the fixed external time is replaced by an arbitrary internal clock. We put the issue in a solid, mathematically rigorous framework. We find that the dynamical interpretation of a quantum state of a timeless system depends on the employed internal clock. In particular, we find that the continuous spectra of well-known dynamical observables like the position of a free particle on the real line may turn discrete if measured in unusual clocks. We discuss the meaning of our result for attempts at quantization of global gravitational degrees of freedom.
We show that the time-dependent Schr\"odinger equation (TDSE) is the phenomenological dynamical law of evolution unraveled in the classical limit from a timeless formulation in terms of probability amplitudes conditioned by the values of suitably chosen internal clock variables, thereby unifying the conditional probability interpretation (CPI) and the semiclassical approach for the problem of time in quantum theory. Our formalism stems from an exact factorization of the Hamiltonian eigenfunction of the clock plus system composite, where the clock and system factors play the role of marginal and conditional probability amplitudes, respectively. Application of the Variation Principle leads to a pair of exact coupled pseudoeigenvalue equations for these amplitudes, whose solution requires an iterative self-consistent procedure. The equation for the conditional amplitude constitutes an effective ``equation of motion'' for the quantum state of the system with respect to the clock variables. These coupled equations also provide a convenient framework for treating the back-reaction of the system on the clock at various levels of approximation. At the lowest level, when the WKB approximation for the marginal amplitude is appropriate, in the classical limit of the clock variables the TDSE for the system emerges as a matter of course from the conditional equation. In this connection, we provide a discussion of the characteristics required by physical systems to serve as good clocks. This development is seen to be advantageous over the original CPI and semiclassical approach since it maintains the essence of the conventional formalism of quantum mechanics, admits a transparent interpretation, avoids the use of the Born-Oppenheimer approximation, and resolves various objections raised about them.
Ever since Schrodinger, the time-dependent Schrodinger equation has been regarded as the fundamental physical law of the unitary-only quantum theory. However, while the origin of time for non-conservative systems can be traced back to the environmental influence, this procedure is inapplicable for the closed (conservative) quantum systems. Hence the question of the origin of time for closed systems. In addressing this issue, in order to avoid circularity of the standard universal (global) time as well as assumptions that could be additional to the standard postulates of quantum theory, we stick to the so-called quantum-mechanical local time. The problems that inevitably appear in such minimalist rejection of the standard role of time in physics are solved with mathematical rigor while leading to the emergent time for every, at least approximately, closed (conservative) system as well as to establishing the time-dependent Schrodinger law as the fundamental law of the unitary non-relativistic as well as relativistic-field quantum theory.
Chemical dynamics, in principle, should be understood by solving the time-dependent Schrödinger equation for a molecular system, describing motion of the nuclei and electrons. However, the computational efforts to solve this partial second-order differential equation scales exponentially with the system size, which prevents us from getting exact numerical solutions for systems larger than 4-5 atoms. Thus, approximations simplifying the picture are necessary. The so-called Born-Oppenheimer approximation, separating motion of the electrons and nuclei is the central one: solution to the electronic Schrödinger equation defines the potential energy surface on which the nuclear motion unfolds, and there are standard quantum chemistry software packages for solving the electronic Schrödinger equation. For the nuclear Schrödinger equation, however, there are no widely applicable quantum-mechanical approaches, and most simulations are performed using classical Newtonian mechanics which is often adequate due to large nuclear masses. However, the nuclear quantum effects are significant for chemical processes involving light nuclei at low energies, and including these effects into simulation, even approximately, is highly desirable. In this dissertation, an approximate methodology of including quantum-mechanical effects within the quantum trajectory or the de Broglie-Bohm formulation of the Schrödinger equations is developed. Use of the trajectory framework makes the approach scalable to hundreds of degrees of freedom. The methodology is applied to study high-dimensional systems (solid He4 and others) relevant to chemistry.