Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1806.10931 · Physics Letters B

Bogoliubov many-body perturbation theory for open-shell nuclei

A. Tichai, P. Arthuis, T. Duguet, H. Hergert, V. Somà, Robert Roth

Published Sep 25, 2018• 96 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A Rayleigh–Schrödinger many-body perturbation theory (MBPT) approach is introduced by making use of a particle-number-breaking Bogoliubov reference state to tackle (near-)degenerate open-shell fermionic systems. By choosing a reference state that solves the Hartree–Fock–Bogoliubov variational problem, the approach reduces to the well-tested Møller–Plesset, i.e., Hartree–Fock based, MBPT when applied to closed-shell systems. Due to its algorithmic simplicity, the newly developed framework provides a computationally simple yet accurate alternative to state-of-the-art non-perturbative many-body approaches. At the price of working in the quasi-particle basis associated with a single-particle basis of sufficient size, the computational scaling of the method is independent of the particle number. This paper presents the first realistic applications of the method ranging from the oxygen to the nickel isotopic chains on the basis of a modern nuclear Hamiltonian derived from chiral effective field theory.

DOI
10.1016/j.physletb.2018.09.044

Related papers

Many-Body Perturbation Theory for Ab Initio Nuclear Structure

A. Tichai

The solution of the quantum many-body problem for medium-mass nuclei using realistic nuclear interactions poses a superbe challenge for nuclear structure research. Because an exact solution can only be provided for the lightest nuclei, one has to rely on approximate solutions when proceeding to heavier systems. Over the past years, tremendous progress has been made in the development and application of systematically improvable expansion methods and an accurate description of nuclear observables has become viable up to mass number $A \approx 100$. While closed-shell systems are consistently described via a plethora of different many-body methods, the extension to genuine open-shell systems still remains a major challenge and up to now there is no \textit{ab initio} many-body method which applies equally well to systems with even and odd mass numbers. The goal of this thesis is the development and implementation of innovative perturbative approaches with genuine open-shell capabilities. This requires the extension of well-known single-reference approaches to more general vacua. In this work we choose two complementary routes for the usage of generalized reference states. First, we derive a new \emph{ab initio} approach based on multi-configurational reference states that are conveniently derived from a prior no-core shell model calculation. Perturbative corrections are derived via second-order many-body perturbation theory, thus, merging configuration interaction and many-body perturbation theory. The generality of this ansatz enables for a treatment of medium-mass systems with arbitrary mass number, as well as the extension to low-lying excited states such that ground and excited states are treated on an equal footing. In a complementary approach, we use reference states that break a symmetry of the underlying Hamiltonian. In the simplest case this corresponds to the expansion around a particle-number-broken Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov vacuum which is obtained from a mean-field calculation. Pairing correlations are already absorbed in the reference state. The mild scaling allows for investigations up to tin isotopic chains. All benchmarks were performed using state-of-the-art chiral two- plus three-nucleon interactions thus allowing for a universal description of nuclear observables in the medium-mass regime.

•Jan 1, 2017•1 citation

Ab initioBogoliubov coupled cluster theory for open-shell nuclei

A. Signoracci, T. Duguet, G. Hagen +1 more

Background: Ab initio many-body methods have been developed over the past 10 yr to address closed-shell nuclei up to mass $A\ensuremath{\approx}130$ on the basis of realistic two- and three-nucleon interactions. A current frontier relates to the extension of those many-body methods to the description of open-shell nuclei. Several routes to address open-shell nuclei are currently under investigation, including ideas that exploit spontaneous symmetry breaking.Purpose: Singly open-shell nuclei can be efficiently described via the sole breaking of U(1) gauge symmetry associated with particle-number conservation as a way to account for their superfluid character. While this route was recently followed within the framework of self-consistent Green's function theory, the goal of the present work is to formulate a similar extension within the framework of coupled cluster theory.Methods: We formulate and apply Bogoliubov coupled cluster (BCC) theory, which consists of representing the exact ground-state wave function of the system as the exponential of a quasiparticle excitation cluster operator acting on a Bogoliubov reference state. Equations for the ground-state energy and the cluster amplitudes are derived at the singles and doubles level (BCCSD) both algebraically and diagrammatically. The formalism includes three-nucleon forces at the normal-ordered two-body level. The first BCC code is implemented in $m$ scheme, which will permit the treatment of doubly open-shell nuclei via the further breaking of SU(2) symmetry associated with angular momentum conservation.Results: Proof-of-principle calculations in an ${N}_{\text{max}}=6$ spherical harmonic oscillator basis for $^{16,18}\mathrm{O}$ and $^{18}\mathrm{Ne}$ in the BCCD approximation are in good agreement with standard coupled cluster results with the same chiral two-nucleon interaction, while $^{20}\mathrm{O}$ and $^{20}\mathrm{Mg}$ display underbinding relative to experiment. The breaking of U(1) symmetry, monitored by computing the variance associated with the particle-number operator, is relatively constant for all five nuclei, in both the Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov and BCCD approximations.Conclusions: The newly developed many-body formalism increases the potential span of ab initio calculations based on single-reference coupled cluster techniques tremendously, i.e., potentially to reach several hundred additional midmass nuclei. The new formalism offers a wealth of potential applications and further extensions dedicated to the description of ground and excited states of open-shell nuclei. Short-term goals include the implementation of three-nucleon forces at the normal-ordered two-body level. Midterm extensions include the approximate treatment of triples corrections and the development of the equation-of-motion methodology to treat both excited states and odd nuclei. Long-term extensions include exact restoration of U(1) and SU(2) symmetries.

arXiv:1412.2696•Physical Review C•Jun 29, 2015•95 citations

Zero-pairing limit of Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov reference states

T. Duguet, B. Bally, A. Tichai

Background: The variational Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov (HFB) mean-field theory is the starting point of various (ab initio) many-body methods dedicated to superfluid systems. In this context, pairing correlations may be driven towards zero either on purpose via HFB calculations constrained on, e.g., the particle-number variance or simply because internucleon interactions cannot sustain pairing correlations in the first place in, e.g., closed-shell systems. While taking this limit constitutes a text-book problem when the system is of closed-shell character, it is typically, although wrongly, thought to be ill-defined whenever the naive filling of single-particle levels corresponds to an open-shell system.Purpose: The present work demonstrates that the zero-pairing limit of an HFB state is well-defined independently of the average particle number $\mathrm{A}$ it is constrained to. Still, the nature of the limit state is shown to depend on the regime, i.e., on whether the nucleus characterizes as a closed-shell or an open-shell system when taking the limit. Finally, the consequences of the zero-pairing limit on Bogoliubov many-body perturbation theory (BMBPT) calculations performed on top of the HFB reference state are illustrated.Methods: The zero-pairing limit of a HFB state constrained to carry an arbitrary (integer) number of particles $\mathrm{A}$ on average is worked out analytically and realized numerically using a two-nucleon interaction derived within the frame of chiral effective field theory.Results: The zero-pairing limit of the HFB state is mathematically well-defined, independently of the closed- or open-shell character of the system in the limit. Still, the nature of the limit state strongly depends on the underlying shell structure and on the associated naive filling reached in the zero-pairing limit for the particle number $\mathrm{A}$ of interest. First, the textbook situation is recovered for closed-shell systems, i.e., the limit state is reached for a finite value of the pairing strength (the well-known BardeenCooperSchrieffer (BCS) collapse) and takes the form of a single Slater determinant displaying (i) zero pairing energy, (ii) nondegenerate elementary excitations, and (iii) zero particle-number variance. Contrarily, a nonstandard situation is obtained for open-shell systems, i.e., the limit state is only reached for a zero value of the pairing interaction (no BCS collapse) and takes the form of a specific finite linear combination of Slater determinants displaying (a) a nonzero pairing energy, (b) degenerate elementary excitations, and (c) a nonzero particle-number variance for which an analytical formula is derived. This nonzero particle-number variance acts as a lower bound that depends in a specific way on the number of valence nucleons and on the degeneracy of the valence shell. All these findings are confirmed and illustrated numerically. Last but not least, BMBPT calculations of closed-shell (open-shell) nuclei are shown to be well-defined (ill-defined) in the zero-pairing limit.Conclusions: While HFB theory has been intensively scrutinized formally and numerically over the last decades, it still uncovers unknown and somewhat unexpected features. In the present paper, the zero-pairing limit of a HFB state carrying an arbitrary number of particles has been worked out and shown to lead to drastic differences and consequences depending on the closed-shell or open-shell nature of the system in that limit. From a general perspective, the present analysis demonstrates that HFB theory does not reduce to HF theory when the pairing field is driven to zero in the HFB Hamiltonian matrix.

arXiv:2006.02871•Physical Review C•Nov 13, 2020•21 citations

Improved quasiparticle nuclear Hamiltonians for quantum computing

Emanuele Costa, Javier Menendez

Quantum computing is increasingly offering concrete solutions toward the simulation of nuclear structure, with the potential to overcome the exponential scaling that limits classical diagonalization methods in large spaces. A particularly efficient encoding scheme, based on collective like-nucleon pairing modes, reduces the qubit requirements by half and avoids the non-local operator strings of standard fermion-to-qubit mappings. While this quasiparticle framework provides accurate results for semimagic nuclei, it does not adequately describe open-shell systems where proton-neutron correlations become important. In this work, we apply Brillouin-Wigner perturbation theory to systematically improve the quasiparticle description of open-shell nuclei in the $sd$ shell, reaching an energy relative error below $0.2\%$ compared to the nuclear shell model. Furthermore, to make the effective Hamiltonian suitable for quantum simulation, we introduce a mean-field Hartree-Fock approximation of the non-quasiparticle resolvent, achieving ground-state energies typically within $2\%$ of the exact shell-model result. This represents a systematic improvement over the bare quasiparticle Hamiltonian while remaining within the reach of near-term quantum devices.

nucl-thCross-listedarXiv:2604.11381•Physical Review C•Apr 14, 2026•0 citations

Ab initio Rayleigh-Schrödinger perturbation calculation including three-body force

B. S. Hu, T. Li, F. R. Xu

We first derive the Rayleigh-Schrödinger many-body perturbation theory up to third order (RSPT3) for Hamiltonians with three-body interaction. The structure of closed-shell nuclei in a wide mass range from 4He to 48Ca has been investigated by the RSPT3 with explicit NN+3N Hamiltonian. The RSPT3 calculations are performed within Hartree-Fock bases. The perturbative contribution of antisymmetrized Goldstone diagrams (diagrammatic expansion for RSPT) with normal-ordered interaction has been analyzed. We demonstrate that the normal-ordered two-body level (NO2B) approximation which neglects the residual three-body term can catch the main effect of full three-body force in RSPT calculation. We also present rigorous benchmarks for RSPT3 with non-perturbative coupled cluster and in-medium similarity renormalization group using the same chiral NNLOsat NO2B interaction. The three methods are in good agreement with each other for binding energies and radii. However, the RSPT3 provides an alternative that is computationally inexpensive but comparable in accuracy to state-of-the-art non-perturbative many-body methods.

arXiv:1810.08804•Oct 20, 2018•3 citations

Multi-reference many-body perturbation theory for nuclei I -- Novel PGCM-PT formalism

Mikaël Frosini, T. Duguet, J.-P. Ebran +1 more

Perturbative and non-perturbative expansion methods already constitute a tool of choice to perform ab initio calculations over a significant part of the nuclear chart. In this context, the categories of accessible nuclei directly reflect the class of unperturbed state employed in the formulation of the expansion. The present work generalizes to the nuclear many-body context the versatile method of Ref. \cite{burton20a} by formulating a perturbative expansion on top of a multi-reference unperturbed state mixing deformed non-orthogonal Bogoliubov vacua, i.e. a state obtained from the projected generator coordinate method (PGCM). Particular attention is paid to the part of the mixing taking care of the symmetry restoration, showing that it can be exactly contracted throughout the expansion, thus reducing significantly the dimensionality of the linear problem to be solved to extract perturbative corrections. While the novel expansion method, coined as PGCM-PT, reduces to the PGCM at lowest order, it reduces to single-reference perturbation theories in appropriate limits. Based on a PGCM unperturbed state capturing (strong) static correlations in a versatile and efficient fashion, PGCM-PT is indistinctly applicable to doubly closed-shell, singly open-shell and doubly open-shell nuclei. The remaining (weak) dynamical correlations are brought consistently through perturbative corrections. This symmetry-conserving multi-reference perturbation theory is state-specific and applies to both ground and excited PGCM unperturbed states, thus correcting each state belonging to the low-lying spectrum of the system under study.

arXiv:2110.15737•Oct 29, 2021•25 citations
A Rayleigh–Schrödinger many-body perturbation theory (MBPT) approach is introduced by making use of a particle-number-breaking Bogoliubov reference state to tackle (near-)degenerate open-shell fermionic systems. By choosing a reference state that solves the Hartree–Fock–Bogoliubov variational problem, the approach reduces to the well-tested Møller–Plesset, i.e., Hartree–Fock based, MBPT when applied to closed-shell systems. Due to its algorithmic simplicity, the newly developed framework provides a computationally simple yet accurate alternative to state-of-the-art non-perturbative many-body approaches. At the price of working in the quasi-particle basis associated with a single-particle basis of sufficient size, the computational scaling of the method is independent of the particle number. This paper presents the first realistic applications of the method ranging from the oxygen to the nickel isotopic chains on the basis of a modern nuclear Hamiltonian derived from chiral effective field theory.
The solution of the quantum many-body problem for medium-mass nuclei using realistic nuclear interactions poses a superbe challenge for nuclear structure research. Because an exact solution can only be provided for the lightest nuclei, one has to rely on approximate solutions when proceeding to heavier systems. Over the past years, tremendous progress has been made in the development and application of systematically improvable expansion methods and an accurate description of nuclear observables has become viable up to mass number A≈100A \approx 100A≈100. While closed-shell systems are consistently described via a plethora of different many-body methods, the extension to genuine open-shell systems still remains a major challenge and up to now there is no \textit{ab initio} many-body method which applies equally well to systems with even and odd mass numbers. The goal of this thesis is the development and implementation of innovative perturbative approaches with genuine open-shell capabilities. This requires the extension of well-known single-reference approaches to more general vacua. In this work we choose two complementary routes for the usage of generalized reference states. First, we derive a new \emph{ab initio} approach based on multi-configurational reference states that are conveniently derived from a prior no-core shell model calculation. Perturbative corrections are derived via second-order many-body perturbation theory, thus, merging configuration interaction and many-body perturbation theory. The generality of this ansatz enables for a treatment of medium-mass systems with arbitrary mass number, as well as the extension to low-lying excited states such that ground and excited states are treated on an equal footing. In a complementary approach, we use reference states that break a symmetry of the underlying Hamiltonian. In the simplest case this corresponds to the expansion around a particle-number-broken Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov vacuum which is obtained from a mean-field calculation. Pairing correlations are already absorbed in the reference state. The mild scaling allows for investigations up to tin isotopic chains. All benchmarks were performed using state-of-the-art chiral two- plus three-nucleon interactions thus allowing for a universal description of nuclear observables in the medium-mass regime.
Background: Ab initio many-body methods have been developed over the past 10 yr to address closed-shell nuclei up to mass $A\ensuremath{\approx}130$ on the basis of realistic two- and three-nucleon interactions. A current frontier relates to the extension of those many-body methods to the description of open-shell nuclei. Several routes to address open-shell nuclei are currently under investigation, including ideas that exploit spontaneous symmetry breaking.Purpose: Singly open-shell nuclei can be efficiently described via the sole breaking of U(1) gauge symmetry associated with particle-number conservation as a way to account for their superfluid character. While this route was recently followed within the framework of self-consistent Green's function theory, the goal of the present work is to formulate a similar extension within the framework of coupled cluster theory.Methods: We formulate and apply Bogoliubov coupled cluster (BCC) theory, which consists of representing the exact ground-state wave function of the system as the exponential of a quasiparticle excitation cluster operator acting on a Bogoliubov reference state. Equations for the ground-state energy and the cluster amplitudes are derived at the singles and doubles level (BCCSD) both algebraically and diagrammatically. The formalism includes three-nucleon forces at the normal-ordered two-body level. The first BCC code is implemented in mmm scheme, which will permit the treatment of doubly open-shell nuclei via the further breaking of SU(2) symmetry associated with angular momentum conservation.Results: Proof-of-principle calculations in an Nmax=6{N}_{\text{max}}=6Nmax​=6 spherical harmonic oscillator basis for 16,18O^{16,18}\mathrm{O}16,18O and 18Ne^{18}\mathrm{Ne}18Ne in the BCCD approximation are in good agreement with standard coupled cluster results with the same chiral two-nucleon interaction, while 20O^{20}\mathrm{O}20O and 20Mg^{20}\mathrm{Mg}20Mg display underbinding relative to experiment. The breaking of U(1) symmetry, monitored by computing the variance associated with the particle-number operator, is relatively constant for all five nuclei, in both the Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov and BCCD approximations.Conclusions: The newly developed many-body formalism increases the potential span of ab initio calculations based on single-reference coupled cluster techniques tremendously, i.e., potentially to reach several hundred additional midmass nuclei. The new formalism offers a wealth of potential applications and further extensions dedicated to the description of ground and excited states of open-shell nuclei. Short-term goals include the implementation of three-nucleon forces at the normal-ordered two-body level. Midterm extensions include the approximate treatment of triples corrections and the development of the equation-of-motion methodology to treat both excited states and odd nuclei. Long-term extensions include exact restoration of U(1) and SU(2) symmetries.
Background: The variational Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov (HFB) mean-field theory is the starting point of various (ab initio) many-body methods dedicated to superfluid systems. In this context, pairing correlations may be driven towards zero either on purpose via HFB calculations constrained on, e.g., the particle-number variance or simply because internucleon interactions cannot sustain pairing correlations in the first place in, e.g., closed-shell systems. While taking this limit constitutes a text-book problem when the system is of closed-shell character, it is typically, although wrongly, thought to be ill-defined whenever the naive filling of single-particle levels corresponds to an open-shell system.Purpose: The present work demonstrates that the zero-pairing limit of an HFB state is well-defined independently of the average particle number A\mathrm{A}A it is constrained to. Still, the nature of the limit state is shown to depend on the regime, i.e., on whether the nucleus characterizes as a closed-shell or an open-shell system when taking the limit. Finally, the consequences of the zero-pairing limit on Bogoliubov many-body perturbation theory (BMBPT) calculations performed on top of the HFB reference state are illustrated.Methods: The zero-pairing limit of a HFB state constrained to carry an arbitrary (integer) number of particles A\mathrm{A}A on average is worked out analytically and realized numerically using a two-nucleon interaction derived within the frame of chiral effective field theory.Results: The zero-pairing limit of the HFB state is mathematically well-defined, independently of the closed- or open-shell character of the system in the limit. Still, the nature of the limit state strongly depends on the underlying shell structure and on the associated naive filling reached in the zero-pairing limit for the particle number A\mathrm{A}A of interest. First, the textbook situation is recovered for closed-shell systems, i.e., the limit state is reached for a finite value of the pairing strength (the well-known BardeenCooperSchrieffer (BCS) collapse) and takes the form of a single Slater determinant displaying (i) zero pairing energy, (ii) nondegenerate elementary excitations, and (iii) zero particle-number variance. Contrarily, a nonstandard situation is obtained for open-shell systems, i.e., the limit state is only reached for a zero value of the pairing interaction (no BCS collapse) and takes the form of a specific finite linear combination of Slater determinants displaying (a) a nonzero pairing energy, (b) degenerate elementary excitations, and (c) a nonzero particle-number variance for which an analytical formula is derived. This nonzero particle-number variance acts as a lower bound that depends in a specific way on the number of valence nucleons and on the degeneracy of the valence shell. All these findings are confirmed and illustrated numerically. Last but not least, BMBPT calculations of closed-shell (open-shell) nuclei are shown to be well-defined (ill-defined) in the zero-pairing limit.Conclusions: While HFB theory has been intensively scrutinized formally and numerically over the last decades, it still uncovers unknown and somewhat unexpected features. In the present paper, the zero-pairing limit of a HFB state carrying an arbitrary number of particles has been worked out and shown to lead to drastic differences and consequences depending on the closed-shell or open-shell nature of the system in that limit. From a general perspective, the present analysis demonstrates that HFB theory does not reduce to HF theory when the pairing field is driven to zero in the HFB Hamiltonian matrix.
Quantum computing is increasingly offering concrete solutions toward the simulation of nuclear structure, with the potential to overcome the exponential scaling that limits classical diagonalization methods in large spaces. A particularly efficient encoding scheme, based on collective like-nucleon pairing modes, reduces the qubit requirements by half and avoids the non-local operator strings of standard fermion-to-qubit mappings. While this quasiparticle framework provides accurate results for semimagic nuclei, it does not adequately describe open-shell systems where proton-neutron correlations become important. In this work, we apply Brillouin-Wigner perturbation theory to systematically improve the quasiparticle description of open-shell nuclei in the sdsdsd shell, reaching an energy relative error below 0.2%0.2\%0.2% compared to the nuclear shell model. Furthermore, to make the effective Hamiltonian suitable for quantum simulation, we introduce a mean-field Hartree-Fock approximation of the non-quasiparticle resolvent, achieving ground-state energies typically within 2%2\%2% of the exact shell-model result. This represents a systematic improvement over the bare quasiparticle Hamiltonian while remaining within the reach of near-term quantum devices.
We first derive the Rayleigh-Schrödinger many-body perturbation theory up to third order (RSPT3) for Hamiltonians with three-body interaction. The structure of closed-shell nuclei in a wide mass range from 4He to 48Ca has been investigated by the RSPT3 with explicit NN+3N Hamiltonian. The RSPT3 calculations are performed within Hartree-Fock bases. The perturbative contribution of antisymmetrized Goldstone diagrams (diagrammatic expansion for RSPT) with normal-ordered interaction has been analyzed. We demonstrate that the normal-ordered two-body level (NO2B) approximation which neglects the residual three-body term can catch the main effect of full three-body force in RSPT calculation. We also present rigorous benchmarks for RSPT3 with non-perturbative coupled cluster and in-medium similarity renormalization group using the same chiral NNLOsat NO2B interaction. The three methods are in good agreement with each other for binding energies and radii. However, the RSPT3 provides an alternative that is computationally inexpensive but comparable in accuracy to state-of-the-art non-perturbative many-body methods.
Perturbative and non-perturbative expansion methods already constitute a tool of choice to perform ab initio calculations over a significant part of the nuclear chart. In this context, the categories of accessible nuclei directly reflect the class of unperturbed state employed in the formulation of the expansion. The present work generalizes to the nuclear many-body context the versatile method of Ref. \cite{burton20a} by formulating a perturbative expansion on top of a multi-reference unperturbed state mixing deformed non-orthogonal Bogoliubov vacua, i.e. a state obtained from the projected generator coordinate method (PGCM). Particular attention is paid to the part of the mixing taking care of the symmetry restoration, showing that it can be exactly contracted throughout the expansion, thus reducing significantly the dimensionality of the linear problem to be solved to extract perturbative corrections. While the novel expansion method, coined as PGCM-PT, reduces to the PGCM at lowest order, it reduces to single-reference perturbation theories in appropriate limits. Based on a PGCM unperturbed state capturing (strong) static correlations in a versatile and efficient fashion, PGCM-PT is indistinctly applicable to doubly closed-shell, singly open-shell and doubly open-shell nuclei. The remaining (weak) dynamical correlations are brought consistently through perturbative corrections. This symmetry-conserving multi-reference perturbation theory is state-specific and applies to both ground and excited PGCM unperturbed states, thus correcting each state belonging to the low-lying spectrum of the system under study.