Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1806.10134

Modeling Position and Momentum in Finite-Dimensional Hilbert Spaces via Generalized Pauli Operators

Ashmeet Singh, Sean M. Carroll

Published Jun 26, 2018• 34 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The finite entropy of black holes suggests that local regions of spacetime are described by finite-dimensional factors of Hilbert space, in contrast with the infinite-dimensional Hilbert spaces of quantum field theory. With this in mind, we explore how to cast finite-dimensional quantum mechanics in a form that matches naturally onto the smooth case, especially the recovery of conjugate position/momentum variables, in the limit of large Hilbert-space dimension. A natural tool for this task are the Generalized Pauli operators (GPO). Based on an exponential form of Heisenberg's canonical commutation relation, the GPO offers a finite-dimensional generalization of conjugate variables without relying on any a priori structure on Hilbert space. We highlight some features of the GPO, its importance in studying concepts such as spread induced by operators, and point out departures from infinite-dimensional results (possibly with a cutoff) that might play a crucial role in our understanding of quantum gravity. We introduce the concept of "Operator Collimation," which characterizes how the action of an operator spreads a quantum state along conjugate directions. We illustrate these concepts with a worked example of a finite-dimensional harmonic oscillator, demonstrating how the energy spectrum deviates from the familiar infinite-dimensional case.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1806.10134

Related papers

Modeling Position and Momentum in Finite-Dimensional Hilbert Spaces via Generalized Clifford Algebra

Ashmeet Singh, Sean M. Carroll

The finite entropy of black holes suggests that local regions of spacetime \nare described by finite-dimensional factors of Hilbert space, in contrast with \nthe infinite-dimensional Hilbert spaces of quantum field theory. With this in \nmind, we explore how to cast finite-dimensional quantum mechanics in a form \nthat matches naturally onto the smooth case, especially the recovery of \nconjugate position/momentum variables, in the limit of large Hilbert-space \ndimension. A natural tool for this task is the generalized Clifford algebra \n(GCA). Based on an exponential form of Heisenberg's canonical commutation \nrelation, the GCA offers a finite-dimensional generalization of conjugate \nvariables without relying on any a priori structure on Hilbert space. We \nhighlight some features of the GCA, its importance in studying concepts such as \nlocality of operators, and point out departures from infinite-dimensional \nresults (possibly with a cutoff) that might play a crucial role in our \nunderstanding of quantum gravity. We introduce the concept of "Schwinger \nlocality," which characterizes how the action of an operator spreads a quantum \nstate along conjugate directions. We illustrate these concepts with a worked \nexample of a finite-dimensional harmonic oscillator, demonstrating how the \nenergy spectrum deviates from the familiar infinite-dimensional case.

•Jun 25, 2018•9 citations

Quantum Mechanical Vistas on the Road to Quantum Gravity

Ashmeet Singh

In this thesis, we lay out the goal, and a broad outline, for a program that takes quantum mechanics in its minimal form to be the fundamental ontology of the universe. Everything else, including features like space-time, matter and gravity associated with classical reality, are emergent from these minimal quantum elements. We argue that the Hilbert space of quantum gravity is locally finite-dimensional, in sharp contrast to that of conventional field theory, which could have observable consequences for gravity. We also treat time and space on an equal footing in Hilbert space in a reparametrization invariant setting and show how symmetry transformations, both global and local, can be treated as unitary basis changes. Motivated by the finite-dimensional context, we use Generalized Pauli Operators as finite-dimensional conjugate variables and define a purely Hilbert space notion of locality based on the spread induced by conjugate operators which we call "Operator Collimation." We study deviations in the spectrum of physical theories, particularly the quantum harmonic oscillator, induced by finite-dimensional effects, and show that by including a black hole-based bound in a lattice field theory, the quantum contribution to the vacuum energy can be suppressed by multiple orders of magnitude. We then show how one can recover subsystem structure in Hilbert space which exhibits emergent quasi-classical dynamics. We explicitly connect classical features (such as pointer states of the system being relatively robust to entanglement production under environmental monitoring and the existence of approximately classical trajectories) with features of the Hamiltonian. We develop an in-principle algorithm based on extremization of an entropic quantity that can sift through different factorizations of Hilbert space to pick out the one with manifest classical dynamics. This discussion is then extended to include direct sum decompositions and their compatibility with Hamiltonian evolution. Following this, we study quantum coarse-graining and state-reduction maps in a broad context. In addition to developing a first-principle quantum coarse-graining algorithm based on principle component analysis, we construct more general state-reduction maps specified by a restricted set of observables which do not span the full algebra (as could be the case of limited access in a laboratory or in various situations in quantum gravity). We also present a general, not inherently numeric, algorithm for finding irreducible representations of matrix algebras. Throughout the thesis, we discuss implications of our work in the broader goal of understanding quantum gravity from minimal elements in quantum mechanics.

•Jun 1, 2020•0 citations

The discrete Fourier transform and the quantum-mechanical oscillator in a finite-dimensional Hilbert space

Thalanayar S. Santhanam, Balu Santhanam

Quantum mechanics of a linear harmonic oscillator in a finite-dimensional Hilbert space satisfying the correct equations of motion is studied. The connections to Weyl's formulation of the algebra of bounded unitary operators in finite space as well as to a truncated quantized linear harmonic oscillator are discussed. It is pointed out that the discrete Fourier transformation (DFT) plays a central role in determining the actual form of the position, the momentum, the number and the Hamiltonian operators. The explicit form of these operators in different bases is exhibited for some low values of the dimension of the Hilbert space. In this formulation, it is shown that the Hamiltonian is indeed the logarithm of the DFT and that by modifying Weyl's framework to include position and momentum operators with non-uniformly spaced spectra the equations of motion are satisfied.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Apr 28, 2009•5 citations

Generalized momentum operators from Fourier transform correspondence

Siddharth Dwivedi

In this work we take a closer look at the algebraic-operator correspondence between the momentum space and the position space which defines the form of the canonical momentum operator in position space in Quantum Mechanics (QM). Starting from the Fourier transform (FT) relationship, we present a Hermitian generalization of the canonical momentum operator in position space. The action of the generalized operator is found to generate a local flow accompanied by position-dependent rescaling, rather than a global translation. Explicit eigenfunctions are obtained for representative cases and are shown to possess a well-defined limit to the plane-wave solution in QM. As an illustration, the infinite square well problem is solved using the generalized operator, yielding a deformed spectrum that has a smooth limit to the standard QM result.

arXiv:2506.10950•Jun 12, 2025•0 citations

Mathematics of quantum mechanics II: infinite dimension

Michel Le Bellac

In Chapter 4 we saw that the canonical commutation relations force us to use a space of states of infinite dimension, in which rigor would require the use of advanced mathematical tools. Fortunately, physicists generally need only to carry the results for finite dimension over to infinite dimension with some simple modifications which we shall indicate here, without embarking on sophisticated mathematics. Nevertheless, it is useful to be aware of the lapses in rigor which are customarily made in physics in order to avoid possible unpleasant surprises. The objective of this chapter is, on the one hand, to present some concrete examples illustrating the new features which arise in infinite dimension and, on the other, to give the rules for practical calculations, in particular to write down the spectral decomposition of Hermitian and unitary operators. The mathematics we use is a bit more detailed than commonly found in most quantum mechanics textbooks. The reader interested purely in the practical aspects can proceed directly to Section 7.3, where the results essential for later on are summarized. Hilbert spaces Definitions The space of states of quantum mechanics is a Hilbert space ℌ, which in general is of infinite dimension. The axiomatic definition of a Hilbert space is the following. It is a vector space which, for the needs of quantum mechanics, is defined on complex numbers. The vectors of this space are denoted |ϕ〉. […]

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Mar 23, 2006•0 citations

Quantum-optical Phase and Canonical Conjugation

David Thomas Pegg, Joan A. Vaccaro, Stephen Mark Barnett

We use a new limiting procedure, developed to study quantum-optical phase, to examine canonically conjugate operators in general. We find that Dirac's assumption that photon number and phase should be canonically conjugate variables, similar to momentum and position, is essentially correct. The difficulties with Dirac's approach are shown to arise through use of a form of the canonical commutator which, although the only possible form in the usual infinite Hilbert space approach, is not sufficiently general to be used as a model for a number-phase commutator. The approach in this paper unifies the theory of conjugate operators, which include photon number and phase, angular momentum and angle, and momentum and position as particular cases. The usual position-momentum commutator is regained from a more generally applicable expression by means of a domain restriction which cannot be used for the phase-number commutator.

Journal of Modern Optics•Nov 1, 1990•71 citations
The finite entropy of black holes suggests that local regions of spacetime are described by finite-dimensional factors of Hilbert space, in contrast with the infinite-dimensional Hilbert spaces of quantum field theory. With this in mind, we explore how to cast finite-dimensional quantum mechanics in a form that matches naturally onto the smooth case, especially the recovery of conjugate position/momentum variables, in the limit of large Hilbert-space dimension. A natural tool for this task are the Generalized Pauli operators (GPO). Based on an exponential form of Heisenberg's canonical commutation relation, the GPO offers a finite-dimensional generalization of conjugate variables without relying on any a priori structure on Hilbert space. We highlight some features of the GPO, its importance in studying concepts such as spread induced by operators, and point out departures from infinite-dimensional results (possibly with a cutoff) that might play a crucial role in our understanding of quantum gravity. We introduce the concept of "Operator Collimation," which characterizes how the action of an operator spreads a quantum state along conjugate directions. We illustrate these concepts with a worked example of a finite-dimensional harmonic oscillator, demonstrating how the energy spectrum deviates from the familiar infinite-dimensional case.
The finite entropy of black holes suggests that local regions of spacetime \nare described by finite-dimensional factors of Hilbert space, in contrast with \nthe infinite-dimensional Hilbert spaces of quantum field theory. With this in \nmind, we explore how to cast finite-dimensional quantum mechanics in a form \nthat matches naturally onto the smooth case, especially the recovery of \nconjugate position/momentum variables, in the limit of large Hilbert-space \ndimension. A natural tool for this task is the generalized Clifford algebra \n(GCA). Based on an exponential form of Heisenberg's canonical commutation \nrelation, the GCA offers a finite-dimensional generalization of conjugate \nvariables without relying on any a priori structure on Hilbert space. We \nhighlight some features of the GCA, its importance in studying concepts such as \nlocality of operators, and point out departures from infinite-dimensional \nresults (possibly with a cutoff) that might play a crucial role in our \nunderstanding of quantum gravity. We introduce the concept of "Schwinger \nlocality," which characterizes how the action of an operator spreads a quantum \nstate along conjugate directions. We illustrate these concepts with a worked \nexample of a finite-dimensional harmonic oscillator, demonstrating how the \nenergy spectrum deviates from the familiar infinite-dimensional case.
In this thesis, we lay out the goal, and a broad outline, for a program that takes quantum mechanics in its minimal form to be the fundamental ontology of the universe. Everything else, including features like space-time, matter and gravity associated with classical reality, are emergent from these minimal quantum elements. We argue that the Hilbert space of quantum gravity is locally finite-dimensional, in sharp contrast to that of conventional field theory, which could have observable consequences for gravity. We also treat time and space on an equal footing in Hilbert space in a reparametrization invariant setting and show how symmetry transformations, both global and local, can be treated as unitary basis changes. Motivated by the finite-dimensional context, we use Generalized Pauli Operators as finite-dimensional conjugate variables and define a purely Hilbert space notion of locality based on the spread induced by conjugate operators which we call "Operator Collimation." We study deviations in the spectrum of physical theories, particularly the quantum harmonic oscillator, induced by finite-dimensional effects, and show that by including a black hole-based bound in a lattice field theory, the quantum contribution to the vacuum energy can be suppressed by multiple orders of magnitude. We then show how one can recover subsystem structure in Hilbert space which exhibits emergent quasi-classical dynamics. We explicitly connect classical features (such as pointer states of the system being relatively robust to entanglement production under environmental monitoring and the existence of approximately classical trajectories) with features of the Hamiltonian. We develop an in-principle algorithm based on extremization of an entropic quantity that can sift through different factorizations of Hilbert space to pick out the one with manifest classical dynamics. This discussion is then extended to include direct sum decompositions and their compatibility with Hamiltonian evolution. Following this, we study quantum coarse-graining and state-reduction maps in a broad context. In addition to developing a first-principle quantum coarse-graining algorithm based on principle component analysis, we construct more general state-reduction maps specified by a restricted set of observables which do not span the full algebra (as could be the case of limited access in a laboratory or in various situations in quantum gravity). We also present a general, not inherently numeric, algorithm for finding irreducible representations of matrix algebras. Throughout the thesis, we discuss implications of our work in the broader goal of understanding quantum gravity from minimal elements in quantum mechanics.
Quantum mechanics of a linear harmonic oscillator in a finite-dimensional Hilbert space satisfying the correct equations of motion is studied. The connections to Weyl's formulation of the algebra of bounded unitary operators in finite space as well as to a truncated quantized linear harmonic oscillator are discussed. It is pointed out that the discrete Fourier transformation (DFT) plays a central role in determining the actual form of the position, the momentum, the number and the Hamiltonian operators. The explicit form of these operators in different bases is exhibited for some low values of the dimension of the Hilbert space. In this formulation, it is shown that the Hamiltonian is indeed the logarithm of the DFT and that by modifying Weyl's framework to include position and momentum operators with non-uniformly spaced spectra the equations of motion are satisfied.
In this work we take a closer look at the algebraic-operator correspondence between the momentum space and the position space which defines the form of the canonical momentum operator in position space in Quantum Mechanics (QM). Starting from the Fourier transform (FT) relationship, we present a Hermitian generalization of the canonical momentum operator in position space. The action of the generalized operator is found to generate a local flow accompanied by position-dependent rescaling, rather than a global translation. Explicit eigenfunctions are obtained for representative cases and are shown to possess a well-defined limit to the plane-wave solution in QM. As an illustration, the infinite square well problem is solved using the generalized operator, yielding a deformed spectrum that has a smooth limit to the standard QM result.
In Chapter 4 we saw that the canonical commutation relations force us to use a space of states of infinite dimension, in which rigor would require the use of advanced mathematical tools. Fortunately, physicists generally need only to carry the results for finite dimension over to infinite dimension with some simple modifications which we shall indicate here, without embarking on sophisticated mathematics. Nevertheless, it is useful to be aware of the lapses in rigor which are customarily made in physics in order to avoid possible unpleasant surprises. The objective of this chapter is, on the one hand, to present some concrete examples illustrating the new features which arise in infinite dimension and, on the other, to give the rules for practical calculations, in particular to write down the spectral decomposition of Hermitian and unitary operators. The mathematics we use is a bit more detailed than commonly found in most quantum mechanics textbooks. The reader interested purely in the practical aspects can proceed directly to Section 7.3, where the results essential for later on are summarized. Hilbert spaces Definitions The space of states of quantum mechanics is a Hilbert space ℌ, which in general is of infinite dimension. The axiomatic definition of a Hilbert space is the following. It is a vector space which, for the needs of quantum mechanics, is defined on complex numbers. The vectors of this space are denoted |ϕ〉. […]
We use a new limiting procedure, developed to study quantum-optical phase, to examine canonically conjugate operators in general. We find that Dirac's assumption that photon number and phase should be canonically conjugate variables, similar to momentum and position, is essentially correct. The difficulties with Dirac's approach are shown to arise through use of a form of the canonical commutator which, although the only possible form in the usual infinite Hilbert space approach, is not sufficiently general to be used as a model for a number-phase commutator. The approach in this paper unifies the theory of conjugate operators, which include photon number and phase, angular momentum and angle, and momentum and position as particular cases. The usual position-momentum commutator is regained from a more generally applicable expression by means of a domain restriction which cannot be used for the phase-number commutator.