Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1806.09958

Understanding quantum physics through simple experiments: from wave-particle duality to Bell's theorem

Ish Dhand, Adam D'Souza, Varun Narasimhachar, Neil E. Sinclair, Stephen C. Wein, Parisa Zarkeshian, Alireza Poostindouz, Christoph Simon

Published Jun 25, 2018• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum physics, which describes the strange behavior of light and matter at the smallest scales, is one of the most successful descriptions of reality, yet it is notoriously inaccessible. Here we provide an approachable explanation of quantum physics using simple thought experiments. We derive all relevant quantum predictions using minimal mathematics, without introducing the advanced calculations that are typically used to describe quantum physics. We focus on the two key surprises of quantum physics, namely wave-particle duality, a term that was introduced to capture the fact that single quantum particles in some respects behave like waves and in other respects like particles, and entanglement, which applies to two or more quantum particles and brings out the inherent contradiction between quantum physics and seemingly obvious assumptions regarding the nature of reality. Following arguments originally made by John Bell and Lucien Hardy, we show that the so-called local hidden variables are inadequate at explaining the behavior of entangled quantum particles. This means that one either has to give up on hidden variables, i.e., the idea that the outcomes of measurements on quantum particles are determined before an experiment is actually carried out, or one has to relinquish the principle of locality, which requires that no causal influences should be faster than the speed of light and is a cornerstone of Einstein's theory of relativity. Finally, we describe how these remarkable predictions of quantum physics have been confirmed in experiments. We have successfully used the present approach in a course that is open to all undergraduate students at the University of Calgary, without any prerequisites in mathematics or physics.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1806.09958

Related papers

Bell’s Theorem and Its Experiments

Alex Mo

Quantum mechanics makes surprising predictions that defy our classical understanding of the world.Experiments done on entangled particles-particles with linked properties-prove that actions on one particle can affect the other one no matter the distance.In response, physicists came up with local hidden variable theories in an attempt to understand this quantum phenomena through a classical lens.John Bell formulated a way to test whether nature is dictated by local hidden variable theories or quantum mechanics, and since then it has been the goal of numerous physicists to experimentally test the theorem and improve upon the results.This paper describes the history of these experiments, their pros and cons, their advancements, and the potential applications that they will enable.

•Aug 25, 2025•0 citations

Experimental test of nonlocal causality

Martin Ringbauer, Christina Giarmatzi, Rafael Chaves +3 more

Explaining observations in terms of cause-and-effect (causal) relations is central to empirical science. However, in his seminal 1964 work [1], John Bell showed that the correlations between entangled quantum systems cannot be explained in terms of, possibly hidden, cause and effect relations. After four decades of experimental effort, Bell's prediction has recently been confirmed in an unambiguous way by a series of loophole-free Bell-test experiments [2-4]. These experiments, however, cannot reveal where exactly quantum mechanics breaks with our classical notion of cause and effect. Specifically, Bell's theorem is based on the central assumptions of realism and local causality. Realism posits that physical systems have real, objective properties, independent of whether we observe them or not, and local causality assumes that causal influences cannot propagate faster than the speed of light.

Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics Europe & European Quantum Electronics Conference (CLEO/Europe-EQEC)•Jun 1, 2017•13 citations

On the wave nature of particles

Berat Tuğrul Uğurlu

The main goal of the present article is to elucidate the wave-particle duality problem by giving an unambiguous mathematical expression of the origin of the wave nature of particles. It is indicated that the wave nature of particles is originated from the multidimensional universe approach and under the one-dimensional universe assumption the wave nature vanishes. The one-dimensional universe assumption also gives a deterministic explanation for the double-slit experiment and answers how a single electron can interfere with itself. The locality paradox is also discussed. It is demonstrated that the same principle shows how a local measurement can determine the state of a distant system. The theoretical framework presented here may help us to understand various quantum physics phenomena. i.e., the superposition principle, wave function collapse, and entanglement.

Physics Essays•Jun 10, 2022•1 citation

Quantum Mechanics and Local Realism: Resolving the EPR Paradox via Decoherence

Everett X. Wang

Despite its remarkable success in describing microscopic phenomena, quantum mechanics continues to pose unresolved foundational questions concerning measurement, nonlocality, wavefunction collapse, and the nature of physical reality. These issues were highlighted by the EPR paradox. Quantum mechanics predicts that measuring one particle’s observable instantaneously determines the state of the other, seemingly violating special relativity’s prohibition of faster-than-light influences and suggesting an incomplete description of physical reality. However, Bell’s theorem has largely ruled out local hidden variable theories. In this paper, I critically examine the assumptions in deriving Bell’s theorem and demonstrate that the theorem does not apply strictly to quantum mechanics. By assuming measurement is always accompanied by uncontrollable environment interactions, I show that quantum theory can be local and realism with decoherence in EPR-like measurement. Specifically, I apply the quantum decoherence framework, pioneered by Zeh, Zurek and Leggett to analyze an EPR-like system using system-environment interactions as a measurement model. The results illustrate that measurement on one entangled particle does not instantaneously collapse the system's wavefunction. Instead, the local wavefunctions of the measured particle and its environment evolve dynamically, while the remote particle’s wavefunction remains unchanged. Environment-induced decoherence selects pointer states and rapidly suppresses quantum correlations through strictly local interactions, giving rise to the appearance of wavefunction collapse. These findings challenge the conventional interpretation of Bell’s theorem and suggest that quantum mechanics fundamentally respects locality and realism if the wavefunction is treated as an ontic entity. This work offers a potential path toward a locally realistic quantum theory in alignment with Einstein’s vision. It not only strengthens the conceptual foundations of quantum mechanics, but also carries tremendous implications for quantum information processing and computing.

•Aug 19, 2025•0 citations

Quantum Mechanics Plan B

Stefan G. Freundt

The Quantum mechanics works but is not yet well understood. The difficulty in understanding lies not so much in the already very sophisticated mathematical formulations, but are much more rooted in the question of how the objects do that? Starting with the double-slit experiment, we will first provide the viewpoint of quantum mechanics. This leads us to the wave-particle duality. Photons have both wave and particle properties. Then we see the exact opposite: photons, electrons... are neither wave nor particle and address the question: Can we find truth from falsity? Can quantum mechanics be wrong in their conditions and yet lead to so excellent results? We then address the question of how good the mathematical prerequisites in classical physics is and how well they are fulfilled in quantum physics. Finally, we look at some very basic experiments from the point of view of the objects.

•Apr 1, 2014•0 citations

Three peas, two children, one road – Quantum entanglement, Bell's theorem and Mendel's 75/25

Valerii Chernenko

Why is quantum entanglement “entangled”? Entanglement means that two particles (e.g., electrons or photons) cannot be described independently, even when they are far apart. Measuring one instantly determines the measurement outcome of the other – not because of a hidden signal, but because they share a single quantum state. This was the central point of the Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen (EPR) paradox (1935). Where was Einstein right? Einstein insisted on local realism: · Realism – physical properties exist before measurement (hidden variables).· Locality – no influence travels faster than light. He believed that quantum mechanics was incomplete because it could not account for those “pre‑existing” properties. In that narrow sense, he was right to question the theory, but wrong about nature: experiments show that local realism does not hold. Where was John Bell right? Bell (1964) derived inequalities that any local realistic theory must satisfy. He then proved that quantum mechanics violates these inequalities for certain measurement angles (e.g., 60°). Later experiments (Aspect, Zeilinger, Nobel 2022) confirmed the violation – nature is non‑local in the sense of irreducible quantum correlations. How can a non‑scientist understand the core idea? We propose a simple analogy: Two children watch cars on a road. First they count colours independently – no correlation. Then they change the rules: each counts a mixture of “colour AND size” (e.g., “red OR truck” vs “blue OR car”). Under the right conditions (viewing angle), the fraction of matches becomes 75% and mismatches 25% – exactly the numbers Mendel found in pea genetics (dominant vs recessive). This 75/25 pattern cannot be explained by local hidden “instructions” for each child; it requires a shared rule – like quantum entanglement. Mendel’s heterozygote Aa (one dominant allele, hidden recessive) is a biological analogue: one active unit determines the visible trait, while the recessive “hides” without duplicate information. The finitary number system (base φ, digits 0/1, prohibition of “11”) offers a deeper mathematical reason: nature forbids two independent active units (“11”). Entanglement is that single, non‑duplicable correlation – just as Aa (not AA) is the natural state of dominance. The number 137 (inverse fine‑structure constant) emerges as 4^2+11^2, and \sqrt{137} \approx 11.7 bits appears as the maximum quantum information that supports the 75/25 correlation. Target audience · Researchers in quantum foundations, history of physics, and complexity theory will find the connection between Bell’s theorem, Mendel’s genetics, and finarity.· Educators and students can use the car‑counting analogy and the pea‑dominance example to explain entanglement without mathematics.· General readers who have heard of “spooky action” but never understood why it’s real will find a step‑by‑step narrative with minimal equations. Final metaphor from the text: "Coherence is when two children look at the same car from different angles and see 'red truck' as a single image. Dysphasia is when they start counting each car separately. The transition is the moment they compare notes and find a 75% match. And coordinates and momentum are that very 'colour' and 'size' that cannot be mixed locally, otherwise the '11' ban would be violated and the number \sqrt{137} would vanish." Thus, your phrase fits perfectly into the narrative: coherence sustains the non‑local correlation, blocking its decay into two local variables (coordinate and momentum), and thereby makes the 'miraculous' transition to 75/25 possible.

•Jun 12, 2026•0 citations
Quantum physics, which describes the strange behavior of light and matter at the smallest scales, is one of the most successful descriptions of reality, yet it is notoriously inaccessible. Here we provide an approachable explanation of quantum physics using simple thought experiments. We derive all relevant quantum predictions using minimal mathematics, without introducing the advanced calculations that are typically used to describe quantum physics. We focus on the two key surprises of quantum physics, namely wave-particle duality, a term that was introduced to capture the fact that single quantum particles in some respects behave like waves and in other respects like particles, and entanglement, which applies to two or more quantum particles and brings out the inherent contradiction between quantum physics and seemingly obvious assumptions regarding the nature of reality. Following arguments originally made by John Bell and Lucien Hardy, we show that the so-called local hidden variables are inadequate at explaining the behavior of entangled quantum particles. This means that one either has to give up on hidden variables, i.e., the idea that the outcomes of measurements on quantum particles are determined before an experiment is actually carried out, or one has to relinquish the principle of locality, which requires that no causal influences should be faster than the speed of light and is a cornerstone of Einstein's theory of relativity. Finally, we describe how these remarkable predictions of quantum physics have been confirmed in experiments. We have successfully used the present approach in a course that is open to all undergraduate students at the University of Calgary, without any prerequisites in mathematics or physics.
Quantum mechanics makes surprising predictions that defy our classical understanding of the world.Experiments done on entangled particles-particles with linked properties-prove that actions on one particle can affect the other one no matter the distance.In response, physicists came up with local hidden variable theories in an attempt to understand this quantum phenomena through a classical lens.John Bell formulated a way to test whether nature is dictated by local hidden variable theories or quantum mechanics, and since then it has been the goal of numerous physicists to experimentally test the theorem and improve upon the results.This paper describes the history of these experiments, their pros and cons, their advancements, and the potential applications that they will enable.
Explaining observations in terms of cause-and-effect (causal) relations is central to empirical science. However, in his seminal 1964 work [1], John Bell showed that the correlations between entangled quantum systems cannot be explained in terms of, possibly hidden, cause and effect relations. After four decades of experimental effort, Bell's prediction has recently been confirmed in an unambiguous way by a series of loophole-free Bell-test experiments [2-4]. These experiments, however, cannot reveal where exactly quantum mechanics breaks with our classical notion of cause and effect. Specifically, Bell's theorem is based on the central assumptions of realism and local causality. Realism posits that physical systems have real, objective properties, independent of whether we observe them or not, and local causality assumes that causal influences cannot propagate faster than the speed of light.
The main goal of the present article is to elucidate the wave-particle duality problem by giving an unambiguous mathematical expression of the origin of the wave nature of particles. It is indicated that the wave nature of particles is originated from the multidimensional universe approach and under the one-dimensional universe assumption the wave nature vanishes. The one-dimensional universe assumption also gives a deterministic explanation for the double-slit experiment and answers how a single electron can interfere with itself. The locality paradox is also discussed. It is demonstrated that the same principle shows how a local measurement can determine the state of a distant system. The theoretical framework presented here may help us to understand various quantum physics phenomena. i.e., the superposition principle, wave function collapse, and entanglement.
Despite its remarkable success in describing microscopic phenomena, quantum mechanics continues to pose unresolved foundational questions concerning measurement, nonlocality, wavefunction collapse, and the nature of physical reality. These issues were highlighted by the EPR paradox. Quantum mechanics predicts that measuring one particle’s observable instantaneously determines the state of the other, seemingly violating special relativity’s prohibition of faster-than-light influences and suggesting an incomplete description of physical reality. However, Bell’s theorem has largely ruled out local hidden variable theories. In this paper, I critically examine the assumptions in deriving Bell’s theorem and demonstrate that the theorem does not apply strictly to quantum mechanics. By assuming measurement is always accompanied by uncontrollable environment interactions, I show that quantum theory can be local and realism with decoherence in EPR-like measurement. Specifically, I apply the quantum decoherence framework, pioneered by Zeh, Zurek and Leggett to analyze an EPR-like system using system-environment interactions as a measurement model. The results illustrate that measurement on one entangled particle does not instantaneously collapse the system's wavefunction. Instead, the local wavefunctions of the measured particle and its environment evolve dynamically, while the remote particle’s wavefunction remains unchanged. Environment-induced decoherence selects pointer states and rapidly suppresses quantum correlations through strictly local interactions, giving rise to the appearance of wavefunction collapse. These findings challenge the conventional interpretation of Bell’s theorem and suggest that quantum mechanics fundamentally respects locality and realism if the wavefunction is treated as an ontic entity. This work offers a potential path toward a locally realistic quantum theory in alignment with Einstein’s vision. It not only strengthens the conceptual foundations of quantum mechanics, but also carries tremendous implications for quantum information processing and computing.
The Quantum mechanics works but is not yet well understood. The difficulty in understanding lies not so much in the already very sophisticated mathematical formulations, but are much more rooted in the question of how the objects do that? Starting with the double-slit experiment, we will first provide the viewpoint of quantum mechanics. This leads us to the wave-particle duality. Photons have both wave and particle properties. Then we see the exact opposite: photons, electrons... are neither wave nor particle and address the question: Can we find truth from falsity? Can quantum mechanics be wrong in their conditions and yet lead to so excellent results? We then address the question of how good the mathematical prerequisites in classical physics is and how well they are fulfilled in quantum physics. Finally, we look at some very basic experiments from the point of view of the objects.
Why is quantum entanglement “entangled”? Entanglement means that two particles (e.g., electrons or photons) cannot be described independently, even when they are far apart. Measuring one instantly determines the measurement outcome of the other – not because of a hidden signal, but because they share a single quantum state. This was the central point of the Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen (EPR) paradox (1935). Where was Einstein right? Einstein insisted on local realism: · Realism – physical properties exist before measurement (hidden variables).· Locality – no influence travels faster than light. He believed that quantum mechanics was incomplete because it could not account for those “pre‑existing” properties. In that narrow sense, he was right to question the theory, but wrong about nature: experiments show that local realism does not hold. Where was John Bell right? Bell (1964) derived inequalities that any local realistic theory must satisfy. He then proved that quantum mechanics violates these inequalities for certain measurement angles (e.g., 60°). Later experiments (Aspect, Zeilinger, Nobel 2022) confirmed the violation – nature is non‑local in the sense of irreducible quantum correlations. How can a non‑scientist understand the core idea? We propose a simple analogy: Two children watch cars on a road. First they count colours independently – no correlation. Then they change the rules: each counts a mixture of “colour AND size” (e.g., “red OR truck” vs “blue OR car”). Under the right conditions (viewing angle), the fraction of matches becomes 75% and mismatches 25% – exactly the numbers Mendel found in pea genetics (dominant vs recessive). This 75/25 pattern cannot be explained by local hidden “instructions” for each child; it requires a shared rule – like quantum entanglement. Mendel’s heterozygote Aa (one dominant allele, hidden recessive) is a biological analogue: one active unit determines the visible trait, while the recessive “hides” without duplicate information. The finitary number system (base φ, digits 0/1, prohibition of “11”) offers a deeper mathematical reason: nature forbids two independent active units (“11”). Entanglement is that single, non‑duplicable correlation – just as Aa (not AA) is the natural state of dominance. The number 137 (inverse fine‑structure constant) emerges as 4^2+11^2, and \sqrt{137} \approx 11.7 bits appears as the maximum quantum information that supports the 75/25 correlation. Target audience · Researchers in quantum foundations, history of physics, and complexity theory will find the connection between Bell’s theorem, Mendel’s genetics, and finarity.· Educators and students can use the car‑counting analogy and the pea‑dominance example to explain entanglement without mathematics.· General readers who have heard of “spooky action” but never understood why it’s real will find a step‑by‑step narrative with minimal equations. Final metaphor from the text: "Coherence is when two children look at the same car from different angles and see 'red truck' as a single image. Dysphasia is when they start counting each car separately. The transition is the moment they compare notes and find a 75% match. And coordinates and momentum are that very 'colour' and 'size' that cannot be mixed locally, otherwise the '11' ban would be violated and the number \sqrt{137} would vanish." Thus, your phrase fits perfectly into the narrative: coherence sustains the non‑local correlation, blocking its decay into two local variables (coordinate and momentum), and thereby makes the 'miraculous' transition to 75/25 possible.