Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1806.03200 · Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences

Quantum advantage of unitary Clifford circuits with magic state inputs

Mithuna Yoganathan, Richard Jozsa, Sergii Strelchuk

Published May 1, 2019• 57 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study the computational power of unitary Clifford circuits with solely magic state inputs (CM circuits), supplemented by classical efficient computation. We show that CM circuits are hard to classically simulate up to multiplicative error (assuming polynomial hierarchy non-collapse), and also up to additive error under plausible average-case hardness conjectures. Unlike other such known classes, a broad variety of possible conjectures apply. Along the way, we give an extension of the Gottesman-Knill theorem that applies to universal computation, showing that for Clifford circuits with joint stabilizer and non-stabilizer inputs, the stabilizer part can be eliminated in favour of classical simulation, leaving a Clifford circuit on only the non-stabilizer part. Finally, we discuss implementational advantages of CM circuits.

DOI
10.1098/rspa.2018.0427

Related papers

The power of restricted quantum computational models

Mithuna Yoganathan

Restricted models of quantum computation are ones that have less power than a universal quantum computer. We studied the consequences of removing particular properties from a universal quantum computer to discover whether those resources were important.In the first part of the thesis we studied universal quantum computers which are implemented using Clifford gates, adaptive measurements, and magic states. The Gottesman–Knill theorem shows that circuits in this form which do not use magic states can be simulated by a classical computer. We extended this result to show that all circuits in this form can be partially simulated; the same computation can be implemented using a smaller quantum computer with the assistance of some polynomial time classical computation. We also identified a subclass of these computations that can be shown to not be entirely classically simulated by any method, given certain complexity theoretic assumptions are true.In the next part of the thesis we examine the role of entanglement in noisy quantum computations. Entanglement is necessary for noiseless quantum computers to have any quantum advantage, but it is not known whether the same is true for mixed state quantum computers. We show that entanglement, unexpectedly, does play a crucial role in the most well known mixed state computer: the one clean qubit model.Finally, we investigate how closely classical simulation is related to another idea of classicality.This notion captures how easily the final state of a computation can be learnt, given samples of measurements from it. We find an extra condition under which a circuit that is classically simulable is also efficiently learnable.

•Jan 5, 2021•1 citation

Classical simulation complexity of extended Clifford circuits

Richard Jozsa, M. Van den Nest

Clifford gates are a winsome class of quantum operations combining mathematical elegance with physical significance. The Gottesman-Knill theorem asserts that Clifford computations can be classically efficiently simulated but this is true only in a suitably restricted setting. Here we consider Clifford computations with a variety of additional ingredients: (a) strong vs. weak simulation, (b) inputs being computational basis states vs. general product states, (c) adaptive vs. non-adaptive choices of gates for circuits involving intermediate measurements, (d) single line outputs vs. multi-line outputs. We consider the classical simulation complexity of all combinations of these ingredients and show that many are not classically efficiently simulatable (subject to common complexity assumptions such as P not equal to NP). Our results reveal a surprising proximity of classical to quantum computing power viz. a class of classically simulatable quantum circuits which yields universal quantum computation if extended by a purely classical additional ingredient that does not extend the class of quantum processes occurring.

arXiv:1305.6190•Quantum Information and Computation•May 1, 2014•97 citations

Classical simulation of quantum computation, the gottesman-Knill theorem, and slightly beyond

M. Van den Nest

We study classical simulation of quantum computation, taking the Gottesman-Knill theorem as a starting point. We show how each Clifford circuit can be reduced to an equivalent, manifestly simulatable circuit (normal form). This provides a simple proof of the Gottesman-Knill theorem without resorting to stabilizer techniques. The normal form highlights why Clifford circuits have such limited computational power in spite of their high entangling power. At the same time, the normal form shows how the classical simulation of Clifford circuits fits into the standard way of embedding classical computation into the quantum circuit model. This leads to simple extensions of Clifford circuits which are classically simulatable. These circuits can be efficiently simulated by classical sampling (``weak simulation'') even though the problem of exactly computing the outcomes of measurements for these circuits (``strong simulation'') is proved to be $\#\mathbf{P}$-complete---thus showing that there is a separation between weak and strong classical simulation of quantum computation.

arXiv:0811.0898•Quantum Information and Computation•Mar 1, 2010•169 citations

Clifford circuits over non-cyclic abelian groups

Milo Moses, Jacek Horecki, Konrad Deka +1 more

We present a discussion of the generalized Clifford group over non-cyclic finite abelian groups. These Clifford groups appear naturally in the theory of topological error correction and abelian anyon models. We demonstrate a generalized Gottesman-Knill theorem, stating that every Clifford circuit can be efficiently classically simulated. We additionally provide circuits for a universal quantum computing scheme based on local two-qudit Clifford gates and magic states.

arXiv:2402.13994•Feb 21, 2024•2 citations

On stabiliser techniques and their application to simulation and certification of quantum devices

Markus Heinrich

The stabiliser formalism is a widely used and successful subtheory of quantum mechanics consisting of stabiliser states, Clifford unitaries and Pauli measurements. The power of the formalism comes from the description of its elements via simple group theory. Although the origins of the formalism lie in quantum error correction and fault-tolerant quantum computing, the utility of the formalism goes beyond that. The Gottesman-Knill theorem states that the dynamics of stabiliser states under Clifford unitaries and Pauli measurements can be efficiently simulated on a classical computer. This algorithm can be extended to arbitrary states and unitaries in multiple ways at the cost of an increased runtime. This runtime can be seen as a quantification of the non-stabiliser resources needed to implement a quantum circuit. Moreover, as non-stabiliser elements are necessary for universal quantum computing, the runtime provides a way to measure the “non-classicality” of a computation. This is particularly pronounced in the magic state model of quantum computing where the only non-stabiliser elements are given by magic states. Hence, in the resource theory of magic, resources are measured through magic monotones which are operationally linked to runtimes of classical simulation algorithms. In this thesis, I discuss different aspects of the resource theory of magic. The mentioned classical simulation algorithms require the computation of magic monotones which is in general a computationally intractable problem. However, I show that the computational complexity can be exponentially reduced for certain classes of symmetric states, such as copies of magic states. To this end, the symmetries of the convex hull of stabiliser states are characterised and linked to their properties as so-called designs. In addition, I study the recently introduced class of completely stabiliser-preserving channels (CSP), which is the class of quantum channels unable to generate magic resources. It is shown that this class is strictly larger than the class of stabiliser operations, composed of Clifford unitaries and Pauli measurements. This finding could have several interesting consequences. First, it implies that there is a class of efficiently simulable quantum channels beyond the Gottesman-Knill theorem. Second, it is possible that optimal magic state distillation rates cannot be achieved via stabiliser operations and this gap is in fact significant. Further applications of the stabiliser formalism come through design theory. A unitary t-design is an ensemble of unitaries which reproduce the first t moments of the Haar measure on the unitary group. Randomness in the form of Haar-random unitaries is an essential building block in many quantum information protocols. Implementing such Haar-random unitaries is however often impractical. Here, designs can exhibit considerably lower resource requirements while still being random enough for most applications. Some of the most prominent examples of such protocols concern the certification and characterisation of quantum systems, such as randomised benchmarking. Interestingly, the group of Clifford unitaries forms a unitary 3-design and is often the prime choice thanks to efficient group operations. In this thesis, I summarise my recent results obtained with collaborators in constructing approximate unitary t-designs from the Clifford group supplemented by only few non-Clifford gates. Intriguingly, this construction uses only O(t^4) single qubit non-Clifford gates and is independent of the number of qubits n. Overall, this yields a gate count which is a significant improvement over for the Brandao-Harrow- Horodecki construction based on local random circuits. To provide context for this result, I review the representation theory of the Clifford group and define the Clifford semigroup. In an attempt to generalise approximations results for the unitary group to the Clifford group, the Clifford semigroup is investigated for suitable approximations of the Clifford twirl.

•Jan 1, 2021•4 citations

Complexity Classification of Conjugated Clifford Circuits

Adam Bouland, Joseph F. Fitzsimons, Dax Enshan Koh

Clifford circuits - i.e. circuits composed of only CNOT, Hadamard, and pi/4 phase gates - play a central role in the study of quantum computation. However, their computational power is limited: a well-known result of Gottesman and Knill states that Clifford circuits are efficiently classically simulable. We show that in contrast, "conjugated Clifford circuits" (CCCs) - where one additionally conjugates every qubit by the same one-qubit gate U - can perform hard sampling tasks. In particular, we fully classify the computational power of CCCs by showing that essentially any non-Clifford conjugating unitary U can give rise to sampling tasks which cannot be efficiently classically simulated to constant multiplicative error, unless the polynomial hierarchy collapses. Furthermore, by standard techniques, this hardness result can be extended to allow for the more realistic model of constant additive error, under a plausible complexity-theoretic conjecture. This work can be seen as progress towards classifying the computational power of all restricted quantum gate sets.

arXiv:1709.01805•Leibniz international proceedings in informatics•Sep 6, 2017•43 citations
We study the computational power of unitary Clifford circuits with solely magic state inputs (CM circuits), supplemented by classical efficient computation. We show that CM circuits are hard to classically simulate up to multiplicative error (assuming polynomial hierarchy non-collapse), and also up to additive error under plausible average-case hardness conjectures. Unlike other such known classes, a broad variety of possible conjectures apply. Along the way, we give an extension of the Gottesman-Knill theorem that applies to universal computation, showing that for Clifford circuits with joint stabilizer and non-stabilizer inputs, the stabilizer part can be eliminated in favour of classical simulation, leaving a Clifford circuit on only the non-stabilizer part. Finally, we discuss implementational advantages of CM circuits.
Restricted models of quantum computation are ones that have less power than a universal quantum computer. We studied the consequences of removing particular properties from a universal quantum computer to discover whether those resources were important.In the first part of the thesis we studied universal quantum computers which are implemented using Clifford gates, adaptive measurements, and magic states. The Gottesman–Knill theorem shows that circuits in this form which do not use magic states can be simulated by a classical computer. We extended this result to show that all circuits in this form can be partially simulated; the same computation can be implemented using a smaller quantum computer with the assistance of some polynomial time classical computation. We also identified a subclass of these computations that can be shown to not be entirely classically simulated by any method, given certain complexity theoretic assumptions are true.In the next part of the thesis we examine the role of entanglement in noisy quantum computations. Entanglement is necessary for noiseless quantum computers to have any quantum advantage, but it is not known whether the same is true for mixed state quantum computers. We show that entanglement, unexpectedly, does play a crucial role in the most well known mixed state computer: the one clean qubit model.Finally, we investigate how closely classical simulation is related to another idea of classicality.This notion captures how easily the final state of a computation can be learnt, given samples of measurements from it. We find an extra condition under which a circuit that is classically simulable is also efficiently learnable.
Clifford gates are a winsome class of quantum operations combining mathematical elegance with physical significance. The Gottesman-Knill theorem asserts that Clifford computations can be classically efficiently simulated but this is true only in a suitably restricted setting. Here we consider Clifford computations with a variety of additional ingredients: (a) strong vs. weak simulation, (b) inputs being computational basis states vs. general product states, (c) adaptive vs. non-adaptive choices of gates for circuits involving intermediate measurements, (d) single line outputs vs. multi-line outputs. We consider the classical simulation complexity of all combinations of these ingredients and show that many are not classically efficiently simulatable (subject to common complexity assumptions such as P not equal to NP). Our results reveal a surprising proximity of classical to quantum computing power viz. a class of classically simulatable quantum circuits which yields universal quantum computation if extended by a purely classical additional ingredient that does not extend the class of quantum processes occurring.
We study classical simulation of quantum computation, taking the Gottesman-Knill theorem as a starting point. We show how each Clifford circuit can be reduced to an equivalent, manifestly simulatable circuit (normal form). This provides a simple proof of the Gottesman-Knill theorem without resorting to stabilizer techniques. The normal form highlights why Clifford circuits have such limited computational power in spite of their high entangling power. At the same time, the normal form shows how the classical simulation of Clifford circuits fits into the standard way of embedding classical computation into the quantum circuit model. This leads to simple extensions of Clifford circuits which are classically simulatable. These circuits can be efficiently simulated by classical sampling (``weak simulation'') even though the problem of exactly computing the outcomes of measurements for these circuits (``strong simulation'') is proved to be #P\#\mathbf{P}#P-complete---thus showing that there is a separation between weak and strong classical simulation of quantum computation.
The stabiliser formalism is a widely used and successful subtheory of quantum mechanics consisting of stabiliser states, Clifford unitaries and Pauli measurements. The power of the formalism comes from the description of its elements via simple group theory. Although the origins of the formalism lie in quantum error correction and fault-tolerant quantum computing, the utility of the formalism goes beyond that. The Gottesman-Knill theorem states that the dynamics of stabiliser states under Clifford unitaries and Pauli measurements can be efficiently simulated on a classical computer. This algorithm can be extended to arbitrary states and unitaries in multiple ways at the cost of an increased runtime. This runtime can be seen as a quantification of the non-stabiliser resources needed to implement a quantum circuit. Moreover, as non-stabiliser elements are necessary for universal quantum computing, the runtime provides a way to measure the “non-classicality” of a computation. This is particularly pronounced in the magic state model of quantum computing where the only non-stabiliser elements are given by magic states. Hence, in the resource theory of magic, resources are measured through magic monotones which are operationally linked to runtimes of classical simulation algorithms. In this thesis, I discuss different aspects of the resource theory of magic. The mentioned classical simulation algorithms require the computation of magic monotones which is in general a computationally intractable problem. However, I show that the computational complexity can be exponentially reduced for certain classes of symmetric states, such as copies of magic states. To this end, the symmetries of the convex hull of stabiliser states are characterised and linked to their properties as so-called designs. In addition, I study the recently introduced class of completely stabiliser-preserving channels (CSP), which is the class of quantum channels unable to generate magic resources. It is shown that this class is strictly larger than the class of stabiliser operations, composed of Clifford unitaries and Pauli measurements. This finding could have several interesting consequences. First, it implies that there is a class of efficiently simulable quantum channels beyond the Gottesman-Knill theorem. Second, it is possible that optimal magic state distillation rates cannot be achieved via stabiliser operations and this gap is in fact significant. Further applications of the stabiliser formalism come through design theory. A unitary t-design is an ensemble of unitaries which reproduce the first t moments of the Haar measure on the unitary group. Randomness in the form of Haar-random unitaries is an essential building block in many quantum information protocols. Implementing such Haar-random unitaries is however often impractical. Here, designs can exhibit considerably lower resource requirements while still being random enough for most applications. Some of the most prominent examples of such protocols concern the certification and characterisation of quantum systems, such as randomised benchmarking. Interestingly, the group of Clifford unitaries forms a unitary 3-design and is often the prime choice thanks to efficient group operations. In this thesis, I summarise my recent results obtained with collaborators in constructing approximate unitary t-designs from the Clifford group supplemented by only few non-Clifford gates. Intriguingly, this construction uses only O(t^4) single qubit non-Clifford gates and is independent of the number of qubits n. Overall, this yields a gate count which is a significant improvement over for the Brandao-Harrow- Horodecki construction based on local random circuits. To provide context for this result, I review the representation theory of the Clifford group and define the Clifford semigroup. In an attempt to generalise approximations results for the unitary group to the Clifford group, the Clifford semigroup is investigated for suitable approximations of the Clifford twirl.
Clifford circuits - i.e. circuits composed of only CNOT, Hadamard, and pi/4 phase gates - play a central role in the study of quantum computation. However, their computational power is limited: a well-known result of Gottesman and Knill states that Clifford circuits are efficiently classically simulable. We show that in contrast, "conjugated Clifford circuits" (CCCs) - where one additionally conjugates every qubit by the same one-qubit gate U - can perform hard sampling tasks. In particular, we fully classify the computational power of CCCs by showing that essentially any non-Clifford conjugating unitary U can give rise to sampling tasks which cannot be efficiently classically simulated to constant multiplicative error, unless the polynomial hierarchy collapses. Furthermore, by standard techniques, this hardness result can be extended to allow for the more realistic model of constant additive error, under a plausible complexity-theoretic conjecture. This work can be seen as progress towards classifying the computational power of all restricted quantum gate sets.