Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1805.11493

On Geometric Paradox in Quantization of Natural Dynamical Systems

Эрнест Ахмеджанович Тагиров

Published May 29, 2018• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The Schrodinger variational approach (1926) to quantization of the natural Hamilton mechanics in $2n$-dimensional phase space is revised in the modern paradigm of quantum mechanics in application to the system the Hamilton function of which is a positive-definite quadratic form of the n momenta with the coefficients depending on coordinates in the generic configuration space $V_n$. The quantum Hamilonian thus obtained has a paradoxical potential term depending on choice of coordinates in $V_n$, which was discovered first by B. DeWitt in 1952 in the framework of canonical quantization of the system by a particular ordering of the operators of observables of momenta and coordinates. It is shown that the Schrodinger approach in the standard paradigm of quantum mechanics determines uniquely the ordering selected by DeWitt among a continuum of other possibilties to determine the quantum Hamiltonian. Two particular classes of observables of localization in $V_n$ are considered in detail. It is shown that, in general, the quantum-mechanical potential does not vanish even in the Euclidean configuration space $V_n$ except the case when Cartesian coordinates are taken as the observables of localization of the system. It is noted also that, in the quasi-classical approach to the quantization considered by DeWitt in 1957, the quantum Green function (propagator) is also non-unique and depends on the choice of a line in $V_n$ connecting these points. All three formalisms have the same local asymtotics of the quantum Hamiltonian if the normal Riemannian cordinates are used, at least implicitly, to localize the system in $V_n$. Keywords: Hamilton function; Quantization; Quantum-Mechanical Potential; Observables of Localization; Quantum Anomaly of (non-relativistic) General Covariance.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1805.11493

Related papers

Unfinished history and paradoxes of quantum potential. I. Non-relativistic origin, history and paradoxes

Эрнест Ахмеджанович Тагиров

This is the first of two related papers analyzing and explaining the origin, manifestations and parodoxical features of the quantum potential (QP) from the non-relativistic and relativistic points of view. The QP arises in the quantum Hamiltonian under various procedures of quantization of natural systems, i.e., those whose Hamilton functions are positive-definite quadratic forms in momenta with coefficients depending on the coordinates in (n-dimensional) configurational space V n thus endowed with a Riemannian structure. The result of quantization may be considered as quantum mechanics (QM) of a particle in V n in the normal Gaussian coordinate system in the globally static space-time V 1,n . Contradiction of the QP to the General Covariance and Equivalence principles is discussed. It is found that actually the historically first Hilbert space-based quantization by E. Schrödinger (1926), after revision in the modern framework of QM, also leads to a QP in the form that B. DeWitt found 26 years later. Efforts to avoid the QP or to reduce its drawbacks are discussed. The general conclusion is that some form of QP and a violation of the principles of general relativity which it induces are inevitable in the non-relativistic quantum Hamiltonian. It is also shown that Feynman (path-integral) quantization of natural systems singles out two versions of the QP, which both determine two bi-scalar (independent of a choice of coordinates) propagators fixing two different algorithms of path integral calculation. The accompanying paper under the same general title and the subtitle “The Relativistic Point of View” (published in the same issue of the journal and referred to as Paper II) considers a relation of the nonrelativistic QP to the quantum theory of a scalar field non-minimally coupled to the curved space-time metric.

arXiv:1201.2664•Gravitation and Cosmology•Jan 1, 2013•2 citations

Unfinished history and paradoxes of quantum potential. II. Relativistic point of view

Эрнест Ахмеджанович Тагиров

This is the second of the two related papers analyzing the origins and possible explanations of a paradoxical phenomenon of the quantum potential (QP). It arises in quantum mechanics (QM) of a particle in a Riemannian n-dimensional configurational space obtained by various procedures of quantization of non-relativistic natural Hamilton systems. Now, two questions are investigated: 1) Does a QP appear in non-relativistic QM generated by the quantum theory of a scalar field (QFT) non-minimally coupled to the space-time metric? 2) To which extent is it in accord with quantization of natural systems? To this end, the asymptotic non-relativistic equation for particle-interpretable wave functions and operators of canonical observables are obtained from the primary QFT objects. It is shown that, in globally static space-time, the Hamilton operators coincide at the origin of the quasi-Euclidean space coordinates in both alternative approaches for any non-minimality constant $$\tilde \xi$$ , but a certain requirement of the Equivalence Principle to the quantum field propagator distinguishes the unique value $$\tilde \xi = 1/6$$ = 1/6. Just the same value had the constant ζ in the quantum Hamiltonians arising from the traditional quantizations of natural systems: the DeWitt canonical, Pauli-DeWitt quasiclassical, geometric and Feynman ones, as well as in the revised Schrödinger variational quantization. Thus, the QP generated by mechanics is tightly related to non-minimality of the quantum scalar field. Meanwhile, an essential discrepancy exists between the non-relativistic QMs derived from the two alternative approaches: QFT generates a scalar QP, whereas various quantizations of natural mechanics lead to QPs depending on the choice of space coordinates as physical observables and nonvanishing even in flat space if the coordinates are curvilinear.

arXiv:1201.5806•Gravitation and Cosmology•Jan 1, 2013•2 citations

Quantization of Hamiltonian and non-Hamiltonian systems

Sergey A. Rashkovskiy

The quantization process was always tightly connected to the Hamiltonian formulation of classical mechanics. For non-Hamiltonian systems, traditional quantization algorithms turn out to be unsuitable. Numerous attempts to quantize non-Hamiltonian systems have shown that this problem is nontrivial and requires the development of new approaches. In this paper, we present the quantization methods that do not depend upon the Hamiltonian formulation of classical mechanics. Two approaches to the quantization of mechanical systems are considered: axiomatic and hydrodynamic. It is shown that the formal application of these approaches to the classical Hamilton-Jacobi theory allows obtaining the wave equation for the corresponding quantum system in natural way. Examples are considered that show the effectiveness of the proposed approaches, both for Hamiltonian and non-Hamiltonian systems. The spinor form of the relativistic Hamilton-Jacobi theory for classical particles is considered. It is shown that it naturally leads to the Dirac equation for the corresponding quantum particle and to its non-Hamiltonian generalization, the bispinor relativistic Kostin equation.

Communications in Analysis and Mechanics•Jan 1, 2023•2 citations

LANDAU LEVELS AND GEOMETRIC QUANTIZATION

John R. Klauder, E. Onofri

The geometrical approach to phase-space quantization introduced by Klauder [KQ] is interpreted in terms of a universal magnetic field acting on a free particle moving in a higher dimensional configuration space; quantization corresponds to freezing the particle to its first Landau level. The Geometric Quantization [GQ] scheme appears as the natural technique to define the interaction with the magnetic field for a particle on a general Riemannian manifold. The freedom of redefining the operators' ordering makes it possible to select that particular definition of the Hamiltonian which is adapted to a specific polarization; in this way the first Landau level acquires the expected degeneracy. This unification with GQ makes it clear how algebraic relations between classical observables are or are not preserved under quantization. From this point of view all quantum systems appear as the low energy sector of a generalized theory in which all classical observables have a uniquely assigned quantum counterpart such that Poisson bracket relations are isomorphic to the commutation relations.

International Journal of Modern Physics A•Sep 1, 1989•43 citations

Quantum theory is classical mechanics with non-local existence

John J. Hegseth

I propose a new and direct connection between classical mechanics and quantum mechanics where I derive the quantum mechanical propagator from a variational principle. This variational principle is Hamilton's modified principle generalized to allow many paths due to the non-local existence of particles in phase space. This principle allows a physical system to evolve non-locally in phase space while still allowing a representation that uses many classical paths. Whereas a point in phase space represents a classical system's state, I represent the state of a non-local system by a mixed trajectory. This formulation naturally leads to the transactional interpretation for resolving the paradoxes of the measurement problem. This principle also suggests a more flexible framework for formulating theories based on invariant actions and provides a single conceptual framework for discussing many areas of science.

arXiv:0912.2474•Dec 13, 2009•0 citations

Hamiltonian systems on manifolds of second-order tensors

Jan Jerzy Sławianowski, Vasyl Kovalchuk

Considered is the Schrödinger equation in a finite-dimensional space as an equation of mathematical physics derivable from the variational principle and treatable in terms of the Lagrange-Hamilton formalism. It provides an interesting example of ”mechanics ” with singular Lagrangians, effectively treatable within the framework of Dirac formalism. We discuss also some modified ”Schrödinger ” equations involving second-order time derivatives and introduce a kind of non-direct, non-perturbative, geometrically-motivated nonlinearity based on making the scalar product a dynamical quantity. There are some reasons to expect that this might be a new way of describing open dynamical systems and explaining some quantum ”paradoxes”.

•Dec 30, 2008•0 citations
The Schrodinger variational approach (1926) to quantization of the natural Hamilton mechanics in 2n2n2n-dimensional phase space is revised in the modern paradigm of quantum mechanics in application to the system the Hamilton function of which is a positive-definite quadratic form of the n momenta with the coefficients depending on coordinates in the generic configuration space VnV_nVn​. The quantum Hamilonian thus obtained has a paradoxical potential term depending on choice of coordinates in VnV_nVn​, which was discovered first by B. DeWitt in 1952 in the framework of canonical quantization of the system by a particular ordering of the operators of observables of momenta and coordinates. It is shown that the Schrodinger approach in the standard paradigm of quantum mechanics determines uniquely the ordering selected by DeWitt among a continuum of other possibilties to determine the quantum Hamiltonian. Two particular classes of observables of localization in VnV_nVn​ are considered in detail. It is shown that, in general, the quantum-mechanical potential does not vanish even in the Euclidean configuration space VnV_nVn​ except the case when Cartesian coordinates are taken as the observables of localization of the system. It is noted also that, in the quasi-classical approach to the quantization considered by DeWitt in 1957, the quantum Green function (propagator) is also non-unique and depends on the choice of a line in VnV_nVn​ connecting these points. All three formalisms have the same local asymtotics of the quantum Hamiltonian if the normal Riemannian cordinates are used, at least implicitly, to localize the system in VnV_nVn​. Keywords: Hamilton function; Quantization; Quantum-Mechanical Potential; Observables of Localization; Quantum Anomaly of (non-relativistic) General Covariance.
This is the first of two related papers analyzing and explaining the origin, manifestations and parodoxical features of the quantum potential (QP) from the non-relativistic and relativistic points of view. The QP arises in the quantum Hamiltonian under various procedures of quantization of natural systems, i.e., those whose Hamilton functions are positive-definite quadratic forms in momenta with coefficients depending on the coordinates in (n-dimensional) configurational space V n thus endowed with a Riemannian structure. The result of quantization may be considered as quantum mechanics (QM) of a particle in V n in the normal Gaussian coordinate system in the globally static space-time V 1,n . Contradiction of the QP to the General Covariance and Equivalence principles is discussed. It is found that actually the historically first Hilbert space-based quantization by E. Schrödinger (1926), after revision in the modern framework of QM, also leads to a QP in the form that B. DeWitt found 26 years later. Efforts to avoid the QP or to reduce its drawbacks are discussed. The general conclusion is that some form of QP and a violation of the principles of general relativity which it induces are inevitable in the non-relativistic quantum Hamiltonian. It is also shown that Feynman (path-integral) quantization of natural systems singles out two versions of the QP, which both determine two bi-scalar (independent of a choice of coordinates) propagators fixing two different algorithms of path integral calculation. The accompanying paper under the same general title and the subtitle “The Relativistic Point of View” (published in the same issue of the journal and referred to as Paper II) considers a relation of the nonrelativistic QP to the quantum theory of a scalar field non-minimally coupled to the curved space-time metric.
This is the second of the two related papers analyzing the origins and possible explanations of a paradoxical phenomenon of the quantum potential (QP). It arises in quantum mechanics (QM) of a particle in a Riemannian n-dimensional configurational space obtained by various procedures of quantization of non-relativistic natural Hamilton systems. Now, two questions are investigated: 1) Does a QP appear in non-relativistic QM generated by the quantum theory of a scalar field (QFT) non-minimally coupled to the space-time metric? 2) To which extent is it in accord with quantization of natural systems? To this end, the asymptotic non-relativistic equation for particle-interpretable wave functions and operators of canonical observables are obtained from the primary QFT objects. It is shown that, in globally static space-time, the Hamilton operators coincide at the origin of the quasi-Euclidean space coordinates in both alternative approaches for any non-minimality constant ξ~\tilde \xiξ~​ , but a certain requirement of the Equivalence Principle to the quantum field propagator distinguishes the unique value ξ~=1/6\tilde \xi = 1/6ξ~​=1/6 = 1/6. Just the same value had the constant ζ in the quantum Hamiltonians arising from the traditional quantizations of natural systems: the DeWitt canonical, Pauli-DeWitt quasiclassical, geometric and Feynman ones, as well as in the revised Schrödinger variational quantization. Thus, the QP generated by mechanics is tightly related to non-minimality of the quantum scalar field. Meanwhile, an essential discrepancy exists between the non-relativistic QMs derived from the two alternative approaches: QFT generates a scalar QP, whereas various quantizations of natural mechanics lead to QPs depending on the choice of space coordinates as physical observables and nonvanishing even in flat space if the coordinates are curvilinear.
The quantization process was always tightly connected to the Hamiltonian formulation of classical mechanics. For non-Hamiltonian systems, traditional quantization algorithms turn out to be unsuitable. Numerous attempts to quantize non-Hamiltonian systems have shown that this problem is nontrivial and requires the development of new approaches. In this paper, we present the quantization methods that do not depend upon the Hamiltonian formulation of classical mechanics. Two approaches to the quantization of mechanical systems are considered: axiomatic and hydrodynamic. It is shown that the formal application of these approaches to the classical Hamilton-Jacobi theory allows obtaining the wave equation for the corresponding quantum system in natural way. Examples are considered that show the effectiveness of the proposed approaches, both for Hamiltonian and non-Hamiltonian systems. The spinor form of the relativistic Hamilton-Jacobi theory for classical particles is considered. It is shown that it naturally leads to the Dirac equation for the corresponding quantum particle and to its non-Hamiltonian generalization, the bispinor relativistic Kostin equation.
The geometrical approach to phase-space quantization introduced by Klauder [KQ] is interpreted in terms of a universal magnetic field acting on a free particle moving in a higher dimensional configuration space; quantization corresponds to freezing the particle to its first Landau level. The Geometric Quantization [GQ] scheme appears as the natural technique to define the interaction with the magnetic field for a particle on a general Riemannian manifold. The freedom of redefining the operators' ordering makes it possible to select that particular definition of the Hamiltonian which is adapted to a specific polarization; in this way the first Landau level acquires the expected degeneracy. This unification with GQ makes it clear how algebraic relations between classical observables are or are not preserved under quantization. From this point of view all quantum systems appear as the low energy sector of a generalized theory in which all classical observables have a uniquely assigned quantum counterpart such that Poisson bracket relations are isomorphic to the commutation relations.
I propose a new and direct connection between classical mechanics and quantum mechanics where I derive the quantum mechanical propagator from a variational principle. This variational principle is Hamilton's modified principle generalized to allow many paths due to the non-local existence of particles in phase space. This principle allows a physical system to evolve non-locally in phase space while still allowing a representation that uses many classical paths. Whereas a point in phase space represents a classical system's state, I represent the state of a non-local system by a mixed trajectory. This formulation naturally leads to the transactional interpretation for resolving the paradoxes of the measurement problem. This principle also suggests a more flexible framework for formulating theories based on invariant actions and provides a single conceptual framework for discussing many areas of science.
Considered is the Schrödinger equation in a finite-dimensional space as an equation of mathematical physics derivable from the variational principle and treatable in terms of the Lagrange-Hamilton formalism. It provides an interesting example of ”mechanics ” with singular Lagrangians, effectively treatable within the framework of Dirac formalism. We discuss also some modified ”Schrödinger ” equations involving second-order time derivatives and introduce a kind of non-direct, non-perturbative, geometrically-motivated nonlinearity based on making the scalar product a dynamical quantity. There are some reasons to expect that this might be a new way of describing open dynamical systems and explaining some quantum ”paradoxes”.