Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1805.09359 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Pairing and superconductivity in the flat band: Creutz lattice

Rubem Mondaini, G. G. Batrouni, Benoît Grémaud

Published Oct 25, 2018• 68 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We use unbiased numerical methods to study the onset of pair superfluidity in a system that displays flat bands in the noninteracting regime. This is achieved by using a known example of flat band systems, namely, the Creutz lattice, where we investigate the role of local attractive interactions in the $U<0$ Hubbard model. Going beyond the standard approach used in these systems where weak interactions are considered, we map the superfluid behavior for a wide range of interaction strengths and exhibit a crossover between BCS and tightly bound bosonic fermion pairs. We further contrast these results with a standard two-leg fermionic ladder, showing that the pair correlations, although displaying algebraic decay in both cases, are longer ranged in the Creutz lattice, signifying the robustness of pairing in this system.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.98.155142

Related papers

Disorder and the Robustness of Superconductivity on the Flat Band

Si Min Chan, Benoît Grémaud, G. G. Batrouni

We study the interplay between on-site disorder and fermion pairing on the quasi one-dimensional flat band Creutz lattice. Both disorder and flat bands localize particles, but an attractive interaction results in pair formation and delocalization giving rise to superconductivity. In this work, we examine the attractive Hubbard model on the Creutz lattice to study the competition between these two effects and elucidate the properties of the superconducting phase and the localization quantum phase transition as the disorder strength is increased. Our main result is that flat band superconductivity is robust against disorder: The critical disorder strength, $W_c$, required to localize the fermion pairs and destroy superconductivity, is finite at any interaction strength, $U$, and is proportional to the superconducting weight, $D_s$, of the clean system. Using large scale density matrix renormalization group computations, we show that this transition is of the BKT form. In addition, even at very small interaction strength, the localization is not due to single fermion localization but to pair localization. For completeness, we briefly study this disorder-induced localization with mean field theory and show that $W_c$ can be accurately determined by using an appropriate scaling function.

arXiv:2506.07095•Jun 8, 2025•4 citations

Pairing and superconductivity in quasi-one-dimensional flat-band systems: Creutz and sawtooth lattices

Si Min Chan, Benoît Grémaud, G. G. Batrouni

We study the pairing and superconducting properties of the attractive Hubbard model in two quasi-one-dimensional topological lattices---the Creutz and sawtooth lattices---which share two peculiar properties: each of their band structures exhibits a flat band with a nontrivial winding number. The difference, however, is that only the Creutz lattice is genuinely topological, due to a chiral (sublattice) symmetry, resulting in a quantized winding number and zero energy edge modes for open boundary conditions. We use a multiband mean field and exact density matrix renormalization group in our work. Our three main results are as follows: (a) For both lattice systems, the superconducting weight, ${D}_{s}$, is linear in the coupling strength, $U$, for low values of $U$. (b) For small $U, {D}_{s}$ is proportional to the quantum metric for the Creutz system but not for the sawtooth system because its sublattices are not equivalent. We have therefore extended the approach to this more complex situation and found an excellent agreement with the numerical results. (c) At moderate and large $U$, the conventional BCS mean field is no longer appropriate for such systems with inequivalent sublattices. We show that, for a wide range of densities and coupling strengths, these systems are very well described by a full multiband mean-field method where the pairing parameters and the local particle densities on the inequivalent sublattices are variational mean-field parameters.

arXiv:2105.12761•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jan 5, 2022•41 citations

Numerically Exact Study of Flat-Band Superconductivity

I. S. Tupitsyn, B. Currie, Boris V. Svistunov +2 more

Current theories of high-temperature superconductivity in flat-band systems predict a linear dependence of the transition temperature on the attractive interaction, $T_c(U) = c|U|$. However, the value of $c$ and the full nonlinear $T_c(U)$ curve---with a maximum at large $|U|$---are known beyond mean-field and quantum geometry estimates only for systems with isolated flat bands. Using a controlled diagrammatic Monte Carlo technique, we trace the onset of superfluid response in the Lieb lattice with attractive Hubbard interaction. Focusing on the half-filled flat-band case, where the ordering mechanism differs fundamentally from both BCS and BEC (preformed Cooper pair) scenarios, we find that the pairing response diverges linearly with decreasing temperature over a broad range of $U$, leading to a sharp crossover to long-range correlations at a characteristic temperature $T_*$, which provides a controlled upper bound on $T_c$. The highest $T_*$ occurs when all three bands touch at a single momentum point, potentially corresponding to high $T_c$ values.

arXiv:2604.05997•Apr 7, 2026•4 citations

Superconducting pairing from repulsive interactions of fermions in a flat-band system

Iman Mahyaeh, Thomas Köhler, Annica M. Black‐Schaffer +1 more

Fermion systems with flat bands can boost superconductivity by enhancing the density of states at the Fermi level. We use quasiexact numerical methods to show that repulsive interactions between spinless fermions in a one-dimensional (1D) flat-band system, the Creutz ladder, give a finite pairing energy that increases with repulsion, though charge quasiorder remains dominant. Adding an attractive component shifts the balance in favor of superconductivity and the interplay of two flat bands further yields a remarkable enhancement of superconductivity, well outside of known paradigms for 1D fermions.

arXiv:2111.03321•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Sep 30, 2022•7 citations

Coexistence of antiferromagnetism and unconventional superconductivity in a quasi-one-dimensional flat-band system: Creutz lattice

Feng 峰 Xu 徐, Lei 磊 Zhang 张

We study the coexistence of antiferromagnetism and unconventional superconductivity on the Creutz lattice which shows strictly flat bands in the noninteracting regime. The famous renormalized mean-field theory is used to deal with strong electron–electron repulsive Hubbard interaction in the effective low-energy t–J model, the superfluid weight of the unconventional superconducting state has been calculated via the linear response theory. An unconventional superconducting state with both spin-singlet and staggered spin-triplet pairs emerges beyond a critical antiferromagnetic coupling interaction, while antiferromagnetism accompanies this state. The superconducting state with only spin-singlet pairs is dominant with paramagnetic phase. The A phase is analogous to the pseudogap phase, which shows that electrons go to form pairs but do not cause a supercurrent. We also show the superfluid behavior of the unconventional superconducting state and its critical temperature. It is proven directly that the flat band can effectively raise the critical temperature of superconductivity. It is implementable to simulate and control strongly-correlated electrons’ behavior on the Creutz lattice in the ultracold atoms experiment or other artificial structures. Our results may help the understanding of the interplay between unconventional superconductivity and magnetism.

Chinese Physics B•Sep 1, 2023•1 citation

Fermions with attractive interactions on optical lattices and implications for correlated systems

Chih-Chun Chien, Qijin Chen, Kathryn Levin

In this paper we address the behavior of the superfluid transition temperature ${T}_{c}$ in the attractive Hubbard model. The attractive Hubbard model can be regarded as the generalization of the BCS to Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC) crossover to a lattice and, as such, may have implications for future optical lattice studies. Nevertheless, the BEC limit of the Hubbard model is very different from that of the better-studied Fermi gases, owing to the strong intersite repulsion between pairs. Here we address systematically the effects of pairing fluctuations for all filling fractions over the entire range of attractive interaction strength. A central conclusion of our work is that in a lattice, around half filling, the smooth evolution from the BCS to the BEC limits is interrupted: ${T}_{c}$ vanishes when the system approaches the bosonic regime with increasing interaction strength. We suggest that this interruption of crossover may signal a quantum critical transition to another form of superfluid not continuously connected to a BCS-like phase. A simple variational ansatz for an alternate ground state in this more strongly coupled superfluid is presented. A generalization of the ($s$-wave) Hubbard model to $d$-wave pairing allows us to address issues of relevance to high-${T}_{c}$ superconductivity. The phase diagram (representing the pairing or pseudogap onset temperature ${T}^{*}$ and ${T}_{c}$) shows that here too one observes a vanishing of ${T}_{c}$ when ${T}^{*}$ becomes sufficiently large. Given this predicted breakdown of the crossover, and given the striking similarity to features of the cuprate phase diagram, we suggest that future experiments on ultracold fermions in optical lattices should not be exclusively limited to the repulsive Hubbard model, but should address the attractive model in order to elucidate features of high-temperature superconductivity.

arXiv:0808.1900•Physical Review A•Oct 23, 2008•19 citations
We use unbiased numerical methods to study the onset of pair superfluidity in a system that displays flat bands in the noninteracting regime. This is achieved by using a known example of flat band systems, namely, the Creutz lattice, where we investigate the role of local attractive interactions in the U<0U<0U<0 Hubbard model. Going beyond the standard approach used in these systems where weak interactions are considered, we map the superfluid behavior for a wide range of interaction strengths and exhibit a crossover between BCS and tightly bound bosonic fermion pairs. We further contrast these results with a standard two-leg fermionic ladder, showing that the pair correlations, although displaying algebraic decay in both cases, are longer ranged in the Creutz lattice, signifying the robustness of pairing in this system.
We study the interplay between on-site disorder and fermion pairing on the quasi one-dimensional flat band Creutz lattice. Both disorder and flat bands localize particles, but an attractive interaction results in pair formation and delocalization giving rise to superconductivity. In this work, we examine the attractive Hubbard model on the Creutz lattice to study the competition between these two effects and elucidate the properties of the superconducting phase and the localization quantum phase transition as the disorder strength is increased. Our main result is that flat band superconductivity is robust against disorder: The critical disorder strength, WcW_cWc​, required to localize the fermion pairs and destroy superconductivity, is finite at any interaction strength, UUU, and is proportional to the superconducting weight, DsD_sDs​, of the clean system. Using large scale density matrix renormalization group computations, we show that this transition is of the BKT form. In addition, even at very small interaction strength, the localization is not due to single fermion localization but to pair localization. For completeness, we briefly study this disorder-induced localization with mean field theory and show that WcW_cWc​ can be accurately determined by using an appropriate scaling function.
We study the pairing and superconducting properties of the attractive Hubbard model in two quasi-one-dimensional topological lattices---the Creutz and sawtooth lattices---which share two peculiar properties: each of their band structures exhibits a flat band with a nontrivial winding number. The difference, however, is that only the Creutz lattice is genuinely topological, due to a chiral (sublattice) symmetry, resulting in a quantized winding number and zero energy edge modes for open boundary conditions. We use a multiband mean field and exact density matrix renormalization group in our work. Our three main results are as follows: (a) For both lattice systems, the superconducting weight, Ds{D}_{s}Ds​, is linear in the coupling strength, UUU, for low values of UUU. (b) For small U,DsU, {D}_{s}U,Ds​ is proportional to the quantum metric for the Creutz system but not for the sawtooth system because its sublattices are not equivalent. We have therefore extended the approach to this more complex situation and found an excellent agreement with the numerical results. (c) At moderate and large UUU, the conventional BCS mean field is no longer appropriate for such systems with inequivalent sublattices. We show that, for a wide range of densities and coupling strengths, these systems are very well described by a full multiband mean-field method where the pairing parameters and the local particle densities on the inequivalent sublattices are variational mean-field parameters.
Current theories of high-temperature superconductivity in flat-band systems predict a linear dependence of the transition temperature on the attractive interaction, Tc(U)=c∣U∣T_c(U) = c|U|Tc​(U)=c∣U∣. However, the value of ccc and the full nonlinear Tc(U)T_c(U)Tc​(U) curve---with a maximum at large ∣U∣|U|∣U∣---are known beyond mean-field and quantum geometry estimates only for systems with isolated flat bands. Using a controlled diagrammatic Monte Carlo technique, we trace the onset of superfluid response in the Lieb lattice with attractive Hubbard interaction. Focusing on the half-filled flat-band case, where the ordering mechanism differs fundamentally from both BCS and BEC (preformed Cooper pair) scenarios, we find that the pairing response diverges linearly with decreasing temperature over a broad range of UUU, leading to a sharp crossover to long-range correlations at a characteristic temperature T∗T_*T∗​, which provides a controlled upper bound on TcT_cTc​. The highest T∗T_*T∗​ occurs when all three bands touch at a single momentum point, potentially corresponding to high TcT_cTc​ values.
Fermion systems with flat bands can boost superconductivity by enhancing the density of states at the Fermi level. We use quasiexact numerical methods to show that repulsive interactions between spinless fermions in a one-dimensional (1D) flat-band system, the Creutz ladder, give a finite pairing energy that increases with repulsion, though charge quasiorder remains dominant. Adding an attractive component shifts the balance in favor of superconductivity and the interplay of two flat bands further yields a remarkable enhancement of superconductivity, well outside of known paradigms for 1D fermions.
We study the coexistence of antiferromagnetism and unconventional superconductivity on the Creutz lattice which shows strictly flat bands in the noninteracting regime. The famous renormalized mean-field theory is used to deal with strong electron–electron repulsive Hubbard interaction in the effective low-energy t–J model, the superfluid weight of the unconventional superconducting state has been calculated via the linear response theory. An unconventional superconducting state with both spin-singlet and staggered spin-triplet pairs emerges beyond a critical antiferromagnetic coupling interaction, while antiferromagnetism accompanies this state. The superconducting state with only spin-singlet pairs is dominant with paramagnetic phase. The A phase is analogous to the pseudogap phase, which shows that electrons go to form pairs but do not cause a supercurrent. We also show the superfluid behavior of the unconventional superconducting state and its critical temperature. It is proven directly that the flat band can effectively raise the critical temperature of superconductivity. It is implementable to simulate and control strongly-correlated electrons’ behavior on the Creutz lattice in the ultracold atoms experiment or other artificial structures. Our results may help the understanding of the interplay between unconventional superconductivity and magnetism.
In this paper we address the behavior of the superfluid transition temperature Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ in the attractive Hubbard model. The attractive Hubbard model can be regarded as the generalization of the BCS to Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC) crossover to a lattice and, as such, may have implications for future optical lattice studies. Nevertheless, the BEC limit of the Hubbard model is very different from that of the better-studied Fermi gases, owing to the strong intersite repulsion between pairs. Here we address systematically the effects of pairing fluctuations for all filling fractions over the entire range of attractive interaction strength. A central conclusion of our work is that in a lattice, around half filling, the smooth evolution from the BCS to the BEC limits is interrupted: Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ vanishes when the system approaches the bosonic regime with increasing interaction strength. We suggest that this interruption of crossover may signal a quantum critical transition to another form of superfluid not continuously connected to a BCS-like phase. A simple variational ansatz for an alternate ground state in this more strongly coupled superfluid is presented. A generalization of the (sss-wave) Hubbard model to ddd-wave pairing allows us to address issues of relevance to high-Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ superconductivity. The phase diagram (representing the pairing or pseudogap onset temperature T∗{T}^{*}T∗ and Tc{T}_{c}Tc​) shows that here too one observes a vanishing of Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ when T∗{T}^{*}T∗ becomes sufficiently large. Given this predicted breakdown of the crossover, and given the striking similarity to features of the cuprate phase diagram, we suggest that future experiments on ultracold fermions in optical lattices should not be exclusively limited to the repulsive Hubbard model, but should address the attractive model in order to elucidate features of high-temperature superconductivity.