Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1805.02986

The meet of incommutable projection operators contradicts Burnside's theorem

Arkady Bolotin

Published May 8, 2018• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In contrast to conjunctions of commutable projection operators unambiguously represented by their meets, the mathematical representation of conjunctions of incommutable projection operators is a question that has yet to be solved. This question relates to another asking whether the set of the column spaces of the projection operators, commutable and incommutable alike, forms a lattice. As it is demonstrated in the paper, if the Hilbert space is finite, the column spaces of the incommutable projection operators cannot be elements of one partially ordered set in accordance with Burnside's theorem on matrix algebras.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1805.02986

Related papers

Latent Complete-Lattice Structure of Hilbert-Space Projectors

Fedor Herbut

To uncover the hidden complete-lattice structure of Hilbert-space projectors, which is not seen by the operator operations and relations (algebraically), resort is taken to the ranges of projectors (to subspaces—to geometry). Taking the range of a projector is completed into a bijection of all projectors onto all subspaces of any finite or countably infinite dimensional Hilbert space. As a second step, this basic bijection is upgraded into an isomorphism of partially ordered sets utilizing the sub-projector relation on the one hand, and the subspace relation on the other. As a third and final step, the basic bijection is further upgraded to isomorphism of complete lattices. The complete-lattice structure is derived for subspaces, then, using the basic bijection, it is transferred to the set of all projectors. Some consequences in the quantum-mechanical formalism are examined with particular attention to the infinite sums appearing in spectral decompositions of discrete self-adjoint operators with infinite spectra. Quanta 2019; 8: 1–10.

Quanta•Mar 1, 2019•0 citations

Finite Dimensional Spaces

Ravinder Rupchand Puri

In Chapter 2, we showed that the vectors in the Hilbert space can be represented by column vectors and the operators by n × n matrices. The algebra of operators in a finite dimensional space is thus equivalent with the algebra of finite dimensional matrices. In this chapter we summarize some results of relevance to us in matrix algebra. Matrix Algebra Consider the space of finite dimension n spanned by the orthonormal basis f﹛ | k ﹜. As discussed in Chapter 2, a vector j u i in the space is represented by the column vector u e constituted by as its elements, whereas its dual h u j is represented †. Similarly an operator A O is represented by the n × n matrix A Q constituted by as its elements. We restate below in matrix notation some notions of abstract operator algebra introduced in Chapter 2. 1. In terms of their representation by column vectors, the scalar or inner product h u jvi between j u i and is given by where ﹛ṵ﹜ and ﹛ṵ﹜ are the elements of ṵ and ṵ , respectively. It may be verified that the definition of the scalar product given above is in accordance with the axioms of the scalar product. Let ﹛u i ﹜ be an orthonormal basis spanning the given space. By virtue of (3.1) and (3.2), the completeness and the orthonormality relations,

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Apr 17, 2017•0 citations

Contextuality and the fundamental theorem of noncommutative algebra

Arkady Bolotin

In the paper it is shown that the Kochen-Specker theorem follows from Burnside's theorem on noncommutative algebras. Accordingly, contextuality (as an impossibility of assigning binary values to projection operators independently of their contexts) is merely an inference from Burnside's fundamental theorem of the algebra of linear transformations on a Hilbert space of finite dimension.

arXiv:1803.07463•Mar 20, 2018•1 citation

On the isomorphism of a quantum logic with the logic of the projections in a Hilbert space. II

Renzo Cirelli, Paolo Cotta-Ramusino, E. Novati

International Journal of Theoretical Physics•Oct 1, 1974•10 citations

A NOTE ON COMPLETENESS OF BOUNDED LATTICES POSTULATED IN SOME AXIOMATICS OF THE MATHEMATICAL FOUNDATIONS OF QUANTUM THEORY

M. K. MUKHERJEE

A NOTE ON COMPLETENESS OF BOUNDED LATTICES POSTULATED IN SOME AXIOMATICS OF THE MATHEMATICAL FOUNDATIONS OF QUANTUM THEORY

•Jan 1, 2015•0 citations

On the isomorphism of a ?quantum logic? with the logic of the projections in a hilbert space

Renzo Cirelli, Paolo Cotta-Ramusino

International Journal of Theoretical Physics•Jan 1, 1973•13 citations
In contrast to conjunctions of commutable projection operators unambiguously represented by their meets, the mathematical representation of conjunctions of incommutable projection operators is a question that has yet to be solved. This question relates to another asking whether the set of the column spaces of the projection operators, commutable and incommutable alike, forms a lattice. As it is demonstrated in the paper, if the Hilbert space is finite, the column spaces of the incommutable projection operators cannot be elements of one partially ordered set in accordance with Burnside's theorem on matrix algebras.
To uncover the hidden complete-lattice structure of Hilbert-space projectors, which is not seen by the operator operations and relations (algebraically), resort is taken to the ranges of projectors (to subspaces—to geometry). Taking the range of a projector is completed into a bijection of all projectors onto all subspaces of any finite or countably infinite dimensional Hilbert space. As a second step, this basic bijection is upgraded into an isomorphism of partially ordered sets utilizing the sub-projector relation on the one hand, and the subspace relation on the other. As a third and final step, the basic bijection is further upgraded to isomorphism of complete lattices. The complete-lattice structure is derived for subspaces, then, using the basic bijection, it is transferred to the set of all projectors. Some consequences in the quantum-mechanical formalism are examined with particular attention to the infinite sums appearing in spectral decompositions of discrete self-adjoint operators with infinite spectra. Quanta 2019; 8: 1–10.
In Chapter 2, we showed that the vectors in the Hilbert space can be represented by column vectors and the operators by n × n matrices. The algebra of operators in a finite dimensional space is thus equivalent with the algebra of finite dimensional matrices. In this chapter we summarize some results of relevance to us in matrix algebra. Matrix Algebra Consider the space of finite dimension n spanned by the orthonormal basis f﹛ | k ﹜. As discussed in Chapter 2, a vector j u i in the space is represented by the column vector u e constituted by as its elements, whereas its dual h u j is represented †. Similarly an operator A O is represented by the n × n matrix A Q constituted by as its elements. We restate below in matrix notation some notions of abstract operator algebra introduced in Chapter 2. 1. In terms of their representation by column vectors, the scalar or inner product h u jvi between j u i and is given by where ﹛ṵ﹜ and ﹛ṵ﹜ are the elements of ṵ and ṵ , respectively. It may be verified that the definition of the scalar product given above is in accordance with the axioms of the scalar product. Let ﹛u i ﹜ be an orthonormal basis spanning the given space. By virtue of (3.1) and (3.2), the completeness and the orthonormality relations,