Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1805.01115 · IEEE Transactions on Information Theory

Upper Bounds via Lamination on the Constrained Secrecy Capacity of Hypergraphical Sources

Chung Chan, Manuj Mukherjee, Navin Kashyap, Qiaoqiao Zhou

Published Feb 4, 2019• 12 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Hypergraphical sources are a natural class of sources for secret key generation, within which different subsets of terminals sharing secrets are allowed to discuss publicly in order to agree upon a global secret key. While their secrecy capacity, i.e., the maximum rate of a secret key that can be agreed upon by the entire set of terminals, is well-understood, what remains open is the maximum rate of a secret key that can be generated when there is a restriction on the overall rate of public discussion allowed. In this paper, we obtain a family of explicitly computable upper bounds on the number of bits of secret key that can be generated per bit of public discussion. These upper bounds are derived using a lamination technique based on the submodularity of the entropy function. In particular, a specific instance of these upper bounds, called the edge-partition bound, is shown to be tight for the pairwise independent network model, a special case of the hypergraphical source when the hypergraph is a graph. The secret key generation scheme achieving this upper bound is the tree-packing protocol of Nitinawarat et al., thereby resolving in the affirmative the discussion rate optimality of the tree-packing protocol.

DOI
10.1109/tit.2019.2897129

Related papers

Secret key agreement for hypergraphical sources with limited total discussion

Chung Chan

This work considers the problem of multiterminal secret key agreement by limited total public discussion under the hypergraphical source model. The secrecy capacity as a function of the total discussion rate is completely characterized by a polynomial-time computable linear program. Compared to the existing solution for a particular hypergraphical source model called the pairwise independent network (PIN) model, the current result is a non-trivial extension as it applies to a strictly larger class of sources and a more general scenario involving helpers and wiretapper's side information. In particular, while the existing solution by tree-packing can be strictly suboptimal for the PIN model with helpers and the hypergraphical source model in general, we can show that decremental secret key agreement and linear network coding is optimal, resolving a previous conjecture in the affirmative. The converse is established by a single-letter upper bound on the secrecy capacity for discrete memoryless multiple sources and individual discussion rate constraints. The minimax optimization involved in the bound can be relaxed to give the best existing upper bounds on secrecy capacities such as the lamination bounds for hypergraphical sources, helper-set bound for general sources, the bound at asymptotically zero discussion rate via the multivariate Gác--Körner common information, and the lower bound on communication complexity via a multivariate extension of the Wyner common information. These reductions unify existing bounding techniques and reveal surprising connections between seemingly different information-theoretic notions. Further challenges are posed in this work along with a simple example of finite linear source where the current converse techniques fail even though the proposed achieving scheme remains optimal.

arXiv:1910.01894•Oct 4, 2019•2 citations

Perfect Secret Key Generation for a Class of Hypergraphical Sources

Manuj Mukherjee, Sagnik Chatterjee, Alhad Sethi

Nitinawarat and Narayan proposed a perfect secret key generation scheme for the so-called \emph{pairwise independent network (PIN) model} by exploiting the combinatorial properties of the underlying graph, namely the spanning tree packing rate. This work considers a generalization of the PIN model where the underlying graph is replaced with a hypergraph, and makes progress towards designing similar perfect secret key generation schemes by exploiting the combinatorial properties of the hypergraph. Our contributions are two-fold. We first provide a capacity achieving scheme for a complete $t$-uniform hypergraph on $m$ vertices by leveraging a packing of the complete $t$-uniform hypergraphs by what we refer to as star hypergraphs, and designing a scheme that gives $\binom{m-2}{t-2}$ bits of perfect secret key per star graph. Our second contribution is a 2-bit perfect secret key generation scheme for 3-uniform star hypergraphs whose projections are cycles. This scheme is then extended to a perfect secret key generation scheme for generic 3-uniform hypergraphs by exploiting star graph packing of 3-uniform hypergraphs and Hamiltonian packings of graphs. The scheme is then shown to be capacity achieving for certain classes of hypergraphs.

arXiv:2601.10697•IEEE International Symposium on Information Theory (ISIT)•Jun 1, 2026•0 citations

Secret Key Generation for a Pairwise Independent Network Model

Sirin Nitinawarat, Chunxuan Ye, Alexander Barg +2 more

We consider secret key generation for a “pairwise independent network” model in which every pair of terminals observes correlated sources that are independent of sources observed by all other pairs of terminals. The terminals are then allowed to communicate publicly with all such communication being observed by all the terminals. The objective is to generate a secret key shared by a given subset of terminals at the largest rate possible, with the cooperation of any remaining terminals. Secrecy is required from an eavesdropper that has access to the public interterminal communication. A (single-letter) formula for secret key capacity brings out a natural connection between the problem of secret key generation and a combinatorial problem of maximal packing of Steiner trees in an associated multigraph. An explicit algorithm is proposed for secret key generation based on a maximal packing of Steiner trees in a multigraph; the corresponding maximum rate of Steiner tree packing is thus a lower bound for the secret key capacity. When only two of the terminals or when all the terminals seek to share a secret key, the mentioned algorithm achieves secret key capacity in which case the bound is tight.

arXiv:1007.3518•IEEE Transactions on Information Theory•Nov 30, 2010•82 citations

Secret Key Generation for Minimally Connected Hypergraphical Sources

Qiaoqiao Zhou, Chung Chan

This paper investigates the secret key generation in the multiterminal source model, where users observing correlated sources discuss interactively under limited rates to agree on a secret key. We focus on a class of sources representable by minimally connected hypergraphs. For such sources, we give a single-letter explicit characterization of the region of achievable secret key rate and public discussion rate tuple. This is the first result that completely characterizes the achievable rate region for a multiterminal source model, which is beyond the PIN model on a tree. We also obtain an explicit formula for the maximum achievable secret key rate, called the constrained secrecy capacity, as a function of the total discussion rate.

arXiv:1805.03110•IEEE Transactions on Information Theory•Feb 12, 2020•11 citations

Secret key generation for a pairwise independent network model

Sirin Nitinawarat, Chunxuan Ye, Alexander Barg +2 more

We investigate secret key generation for a ldquopair-wise independent networkrdquo model in which every pair of terminals observes correlated sources which are independent of sources observed by all other pairs of terminals. The terminals are then allowed to communicate interactively in multiple rounds over a public noiseless channel of unlimited capacity, with all such communication being observed by all the terminals. The objective is to generate a secret key shared by a given subset of terminals at the largest rate possible. All the terminals cooperate in generating the secret key, with secrecy being required from an eavesdropper which has access to the public interterminal communication. We provide a (single-letter) formula for the secrecy capacity for this model, and show a natural connection between the problem of secret key generation and the combinatorial problem of maximal packing of Steiner trees in an associated multigraph. In particular, we show that the maximum number of Steiner tree packings in the multigraph is always a lower bound for the secrecy capacity. The bound is tight for the case when all the terminals seek to share a secret key; the mentioned connection yields an explicit capacity-achieving algorithm. This algorithm, which can be executed in polynomial time, extracts a group-wide secret key of the optimum rate from the collection of optimum and mutually independent secret keys for pairs of terminals.

IEEE International Symposium on Information Theory (ISIT)•Jul 1, 2008•20 citations

Secret key agreement under discussion rate constraints

Chung Chan, Manuj Mukherjee, Navin Kashyap +1 more

For the multiterminal secret key agreement problem, new single-letter lower bounds are obtained on the minimum public discussion rate required to achieve any given secret key rate below the secrecy capacity. The results apply to the general source model without helpers or wiretapper's side information, but can be strengthened for hypergraphical sources. In particular, for the pairwise independent network, our results yield a complete characterization of the maximum secret key rate achievable under a constraint on the total discussion rate.

arXiv:1701.05008•IEEE International Symposium on Information Theory (ISIT)•Jun 1, 2017•16 citations
Hypergraphical sources are a natural class of sources for secret key generation, within which different subsets of terminals sharing secrets are allowed to discuss publicly in order to agree upon a global secret key. While their secrecy capacity, i.e., the maximum rate of a secret key that can be agreed upon by the entire set of terminals, is well-understood, what remains open is the maximum rate of a secret key that can be generated when there is a restriction on the overall rate of public discussion allowed. In this paper, we obtain a family of explicitly computable upper bounds on the number of bits of secret key that can be generated per bit of public discussion. These upper bounds are derived using a lamination technique based on the submodularity of the entropy function. In particular, a specific instance of these upper bounds, called the edge-partition bound, is shown to be tight for the pairwise independent network model, a special case of the hypergraphical source when the hypergraph is a graph. The secret key generation scheme achieving this upper bound is the tree-packing protocol of Nitinawarat et al., thereby resolving in the affirmative the discussion rate optimality of the tree-packing protocol.
This work considers the problem of multiterminal secret key agreement by limited total public discussion under the hypergraphical source model. The secrecy capacity as a function of the total discussion rate is completely characterized by a polynomial-time computable linear program. Compared to the existing solution for a particular hypergraphical source model called the pairwise independent network (PIN) model, the current result is a non-trivial extension as it applies to a strictly larger class of sources and a more general scenario involving helpers and wiretapper's side information. In particular, while the existing solution by tree-packing can be strictly suboptimal for the PIN model with helpers and the hypergraphical source model in general, we can show that decremental secret key agreement and linear network coding is optimal, resolving a previous conjecture in the affirmative. The converse is established by a single-letter upper bound on the secrecy capacity for discrete memoryless multiple sources and individual discussion rate constraints. The minimax optimization involved in the bound can be relaxed to give the best existing upper bounds on secrecy capacities such as the lamination bounds for hypergraphical sources, helper-set bound for general sources, the bound at asymptotically zero discussion rate via the multivariate Gác--Körner common information, and the lower bound on communication complexity via a multivariate extension of the Wyner common information. These reductions unify existing bounding techniques and reveal surprising connections between seemingly different information-theoretic notions. Further challenges are posed in this work along with a simple example of finite linear source where the current converse techniques fail even though the proposed achieving scheme remains optimal.
Nitinawarat and Narayan proposed a perfect secret key generation scheme for the so-called \emph{pairwise independent network (PIN) model} by exploiting the combinatorial properties of the underlying graph, namely the spanning tree packing rate. This work considers a generalization of the PIN model where the underlying graph is replaced with a hypergraph, and makes progress towards designing similar perfect secret key generation schemes by exploiting the combinatorial properties of the hypergraph. Our contributions are two-fold. We first provide a capacity achieving scheme for a complete ttt-uniform hypergraph on mmm vertices by leveraging a packing of the complete ttt-uniform hypergraphs by what we refer to as star hypergraphs, and designing a scheme that gives (m−2t−2)\binom{m-2}{t-2}(t−2m−2​) bits of perfect secret key per star graph. Our second contribution is a 2-bit perfect secret key generation scheme for 3-uniform star hypergraphs whose projections are cycles. This scheme is then extended to a perfect secret key generation scheme for generic 3-uniform hypergraphs by exploiting star graph packing of 3-uniform hypergraphs and Hamiltonian packings of graphs. The scheme is then shown to be capacity achieving for certain classes of hypergraphs.
We consider secret key generation for a “pairwise independent network” model in which every pair of terminals observes correlated sources that are independent of sources observed by all other pairs of terminals. The terminals are then allowed to communicate publicly with all such communication being observed by all the terminals. The objective is to generate a secret key shared by a given subset of terminals at the largest rate possible, with the cooperation of any remaining terminals. Secrecy is required from an eavesdropper that has access to the public interterminal communication. A (single-letter) formula for secret key capacity brings out a natural connection between the problem of secret key generation and a combinatorial problem of maximal packing of Steiner trees in an associated multigraph. An explicit algorithm is proposed for secret key generation based on a maximal packing of Steiner trees in a multigraph; the corresponding maximum rate of Steiner tree packing is thus a lower bound for the secret key capacity. When only two of the terminals or when all the terminals seek to share a secret key, the mentioned algorithm achieves secret key capacity in which case the bound is tight.
This paper investigates the secret key generation in the multiterminal source model, where users observing correlated sources discuss interactively under limited rates to agree on a secret key. We focus on a class of sources representable by minimally connected hypergraphs. For such sources, we give a single-letter explicit characterization of the region of achievable secret key rate and public discussion rate tuple. This is the first result that completely characterizes the achievable rate region for a multiterminal source model, which is beyond the PIN model on a tree. We also obtain an explicit formula for the maximum achievable secret key rate, called the constrained secrecy capacity, as a function of the total discussion rate.
We investigate secret key generation for a ldquopair-wise independent networkrdquo model in which every pair of terminals observes correlated sources which are independent of sources observed by all other pairs of terminals. The terminals are then allowed to communicate interactively in multiple rounds over a public noiseless channel of unlimited capacity, with all such communication being observed by all the terminals. The objective is to generate a secret key shared by a given subset of terminals at the largest rate possible. All the terminals cooperate in generating the secret key, with secrecy being required from an eavesdropper which has access to the public interterminal communication. We provide a (single-letter) formula for the secrecy capacity for this model, and show a natural connection between the problem of secret key generation and the combinatorial problem of maximal packing of Steiner trees in an associated multigraph. In particular, we show that the maximum number of Steiner tree packings in the multigraph is always a lower bound for the secrecy capacity. The bound is tight for the case when all the terminals seek to share a secret key; the mentioned connection yields an explicit capacity-achieving algorithm. This algorithm, which can be executed in polynomial time, extracts a group-wide secret key of the optimum rate from the collection of optimum and mutually independent secret keys for pairs of terminals.
For the multiterminal secret key agreement problem, new single-letter lower bounds are obtained on the minimum public discussion rate required to achieve any given secret key rate below the secrecy capacity. The results apply to the general source model without helpers or wiretapper's side information, but can be strengthened for hypergraphical sources. In particular, for the pairwise independent network, our results yield a complete characterization of the maximum secret key rate achievable under a constraint on the total discussion rate.