Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1804.09925 · Physical Review A

Detecting nondecomposability of time evolution via extreme gain of correlations

Tanjung Krisnanda, Ray Ganardi, Su‐Yong Lee, Jaewan Kim, Tomasz Paterek

Published Nov 16, 2018• 15 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Noncommutativity is one of the most elementary nonclassical features of quantum observables. Here we propose a method to detect noncommutativity of interaction Hamiltonians of two probe objects coupled via a mediator. If these objects are open to their local environments, our method reveals nondecomposability of temporal evolution into a sequence of interactions between each probe and the mediator. The Hamiltonians or Lindblad operators can remain unknown throughout the assessment, we only require knowledge of the dimension of the mediator. Furthermore, no operations on the mediator are necessary. Technically, under the assumption of decomposable evolution, we derive upper bounds on correlations between the probes and then demonstrate that these bounds can be violated with correlation dynamics generated by non-commuting Hamiltonians, e.g., Jaynes-Cummings coupling. An intuitive explanation is provided in terms of multiple exchanges of a virtual particle which lead to the excessive accumulation of correlations. A plethora of correlation quantifiers are helpful in our method, e.g., quantum entanglement, discord, mutual information, and even classical correlation. Finally, we discuss exemplary applications of the method in quantum information: the distribution of correlations and witnessing dimension of an object.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.98.052321

Related papers

Quantitative Nonclassicality of Mediated Interactions

Ray Ganardi, Ekta Panwar, Mahasweta Pandit +2 more

In a plethora of physical situations, one can distinguish a mediator—a system that couples other, noninteracting, systems. Often, the mediator itself is not directly accessible to experimentation, yet it is interesting and sometimes crucial to understand if it admits nonclassical properties. An example of this sort that has recently been enjoying considerable attention is that of two quantum masses coupled via a gravitational field. It has been argued that the gain of quantum entanglement between the masses indicates nonclassicality of the states of the whole tripartite system. Here, we focus on the nonclassical properties of the involved interactions rather than the states. We derive inequalities the violation of which indicates noncommutativity and nondecomposability (open-system generalization of noncommuting unitaries) of interactions through the mediators. The derivations are based on properties of general quantum formalism and make minimalistic assumptions about the studied systems; in particular, the interactions can remain uncharacterized throughout the assessment. Furthermore, we also present conditions that solely use correlations between the coupled systems, excluding the need to measure the mediator. Next, we show that the amount of violation places a lower bound on suitably defined degree of nondecomposability. This makes the methods quantitative and at the same time experiment ready. We give applications of these techniques in two different fields: for detecting the nonclassicality of gravitational interaction and in bounding the Trotter error in quantum simulations. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2303.12428•PRX Quantum•Feb 6, 2024•3 citations

Revealing Nonclassicality of Inaccessible Objects

Tanjung Krisnanda, Margherita Zuppardo, Mauro Paternostro +1 more

Some physical objects are hardly accessible to direct experimentation. It is then desirable to infer their properties based solely on the interactions they have with systems over which we have control. In this spirit, here we introduce schemes for assessing the nonclassicality of the inaccessible objects as characterized by quantum discord. We consider two probes individually interacting with the inaccessible object but not with each other. The schemes are based on monitoring entanglement dynamics between the probes. Our method is robust and experimentally friendly, as it allows the probes and the object to be open systems and makes no assumptions about the initial state, dimensionality of involved Hilbert spaces, and details of the probe-object Hamiltonian. We apply our scheme to a membrane-in-the-middle optomechanical system, to detect system-environment correlations in open system dynamics as well as nonclassicality of the environment, and we foresee potential benefits for the inference of the nonclassical nature of gravity.

arXiv:1607.01140•Physical Review Letters•Sep 21, 2017•88 citations

Role of nonclassicality in mediated spatial quantum correlations

Salvatore Raia, Giuseppe Di Pietra, Chiara Marletto

The study of nonclassicality is essential to understand the quantum-to-classical transition in physical systems. Recently, a witness of nonclassicality has been proposed, linking the ability of a system (the mediator) to create quantum correlations between two quantum probes with its nonclassicality, intended as the existence of at least two noncommuting variables. Here we propose an inequality that quantitatively links the increase in quantum correlations between the probes to a function of the noncommutativity of the mediator's observables. We test the inequality for various degrees of nonclassicality of the mediator, from fully quantum to fully classical. This quantum-to-classical transition is simulated via a phase-flip channel applied to the mediator, inducing an effective reduction of the noncommutativity of its variables. Our results provide a general framework for witnessing nonclassicality, assessing the nonclassicality of a system via its intrinsic properties, independently of the specific chosen interaction dynamics.

arXiv:2410.00824•Physical Review A•Mar 30, 2026•4 citations

Information-theoretical witnesses of non-classicality in hybrid systems

G Di Pietra

Quantum theory is one of the most successful theories in modern physics. It has been extensively tested in the microscopic domain, always with remarkable success. Yet, these tests do not currently extend in a conclusive way to all physical systems and across all scales. This leaves open the question of whether quantum theory provides a truly universal description of reality, especially in regimes where direct experimental access is limited, such as the gravitational field or complex macroscopic biological systems. This Thesis addresses this question through the study of hybrid systems, where a well-controlled quantum sector interacts with an unknown sector whose underlying description may or may not be quantum. It contributes to the emerging framework of information-theoretical witnesses of non-classicality, where the quantum sector is used as a probe to test the nature of the unknown system under minimal assumptions. We first examine spatial entanglement-based witnesses, in which the ability of an unknown system to mediate entanglement between two quantum probes by local means provides a sufficient condition for its non-classicality. We extend this framework by quantitatively showing that locally mediated quantum correlations lower bound the non-commutativity of the observables of the mediator, within quantum theory. We then introduce a novel class of single-probe temporal witnesses, where non-classicality is inferred from the temporal evolution of a probe under a global conservation law. We prove that quantum coherent evolution under such a constraint can only be mediated by a non-classical system, and propose an application to light-harvesting processes in photosynthetic complexes. Finally, we develop a temporal entanglement-based witness. Here, the sufficient condition for the non-classicality of the unknown system is the ability to mediate temporal entanglement relative to the probe's local conserved quantity and a non-commuting observable. This result provides a temporal extension of the spatial entanglement-based witness, representing a promising route for the development of the next generation of tests to probe the universality of quantum theory in previously inaccessible fields such as gravity and biology.

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Experimental localisation of quantum entanglement through monitored classical mediator

Soham Pal, Priya Batra, Tanjung Krisnanda +2 more

Quantum entanglement is a form of correlation between quantum particles that cannot be increased via local operations and classical communication. It has therefore been proposed that an increment of quantum entanglement between probes that are interacting solely via a mediator implies non-classicality of the mediator. Indeed, under certain assumptions regarding the initial state, entanglement gain between the probes indicates quantum coherence in the mediator. Going beyond such assumptions, there exist other initial states which produce entanglement between the probes via only local interactions with a classical mediator. In this process the initial entanglement between any probe and the rest of the system "flows through" the classical mediator and gets localised between the probes. Here we theoretically characterise maximal entanglement gain via classical mediator and experimentally demonstrate, using liquid-state NMR spectroscopy, the optimal growth of quantum correlations between two nuclear spin qubits interacting through a mediator qubit in a classical state. We additionally monitor, i.e., dephase, the mediator in order to emphasise its classical character. Our results indicate the necessity of verifying features of the initial state if entanglement gain between the probes is used as a figure of merit for witnessing non-classical mediator. Such methods were proposed to have exemplary applications in quantum optomechanics, quantum biology and quantum gravity.

arXiv:1909.11030•Quantum•Jun 17, 2021•46 citations

Temporal witnesses of non-classicality and conservation laws

Giuseppe Di Pietra, Chiara Marletto

Abstract A general entanglement-based witness of non-classicality has recently been proposed, which can be applied to testing quantum effects in gravity. This witness is based on generating entanglement between two quantum probes via a mediator. In this paper we provide a ‘temporal’ variant of this witness, using a single quantum probe to assess the non-classicality of the mediator. Within the formalism of quantum theory, we show that if a system M is capable of inducing a coherent dynamical evolution of a quantum system Q, in the presence of a conservation law, then M must be non-classical. This argument supports witnesses of non-classicality relying on a single quantum probe, which can be applied to a number of open issues, notably in quantum gravity or quantum biology.

arXiv:2205.00198•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•May 31, 2023•12 citations
Noncommutativity is one of the most elementary nonclassical features of quantum observables. Here we propose a method to detect noncommutativity of interaction Hamiltonians of two probe objects coupled via a mediator. If these objects are open to their local environments, our method reveals nondecomposability of temporal evolution into a sequence of interactions between each probe and the mediator. The Hamiltonians or Lindblad operators can remain unknown throughout the assessment, we only require knowledge of the dimension of the mediator. Furthermore, no operations on the mediator are necessary. Technically, under the assumption of decomposable evolution, we derive upper bounds on correlations between the probes and then demonstrate that these bounds can be violated with correlation dynamics generated by non-commuting Hamiltonians, e.g., Jaynes-Cummings coupling. An intuitive explanation is provided in terms of multiple exchanges of a virtual particle which lead to the excessive accumulation of correlations. A plethora of correlation quantifiers are helpful in our method, e.g., quantum entanglement, discord, mutual information, and even classical correlation. Finally, we discuss exemplary applications of the method in quantum information: the distribution of correlations and witnessing dimension of an object.
In a plethora of physical situations, one can distinguish a mediator—a system that couples other, noninteracting, systems. Often, the mediator itself is not directly accessible to experimentation, yet it is interesting and sometimes crucial to understand if it admits nonclassical properties. An example of this sort that has recently been enjoying considerable attention is that of two quantum masses coupled via a gravitational field. It has been argued that the gain of quantum entanglement between the masses indicates nonclassicality of the states of the whole tripartite system. Here, we focus on the nonclassical properties of the involved interactions rather than the states. We derive inequalities the violation of which indicates noncommutativity and nondecomposability (open-system generalization of noncommuting unitaries) of interactions through the mediators. The derivations are based on properties of general quantum formalism and make minimalistic assumptions about the studied systems; in particular, the interactions can remain uncharacterized throughout the assessment. Furthermore, we also present conditions that solely use correlations between the coupled systems, excluding the need to measure the mediator. Next, we show that the amount of violation places a lower bound on suitably defined degree of nondecomposability. This makes the methods quantitative and at the same time experiment ready. We give applications of these techniques in two different fields: for detecting the nonclassicality of gravitational interaction and in bounding the Trotter error in quantum simulations. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
Some physical objects are hardly accessible to direct experimentation. It is then desirable to infer their properties based solely on the interactions they have with systems over which we have control. In this spirit, here we introduce schemes for assessing the nonclassicality of the inaccessible objects as characterized by quantum discord. We consider two probes individually interacting with the inaccessible object but not with each other. The schemes are based on monitoring entanglement dynamics between the probes. Our method is robust and experimentally friendly, as it allows the probes and the object to be open systems and makes no assumptions about the initial state, dimensionality of involved Hilbert spaces, and details of the probe-object Hamiltonian. We apply our scheme to a membrane-in-the-middle optomechanical system, to detect system-environment correlations in open system dynamics as well as nonclassicality of the environment, and we foresee potential benefits for the inference of the nonclassical nature of gravity.
The study of nonclassicality is essential to understand the quantum-to-classical transition in physical systems. Recently, a witness of nonclassicality has been proposed, linking the ability of a system (the mediator) to create quantum correlations between two quantum probes with its nonclassicality, intended as the existence of at least two noncommuting variables. Here we propose an inequality that quantitatively links the increase in quantum correlations between the probes to a function of the noncommutativity of the mediator's observables. We test the inequality for various degrees of nonclassicality of the mediator, from fully quantum to fully classical. This quantum-to-classical transition is simulated via a phase-flip channel applied to the mediator, inducing an effective reduction of the noncommutativity of its variables. Our results provide a general framework for witnessing nonclassicality, assessing the nonclassicality of a system via its intrinsic properties, independently of the specific chosen interaction dynamics.
Quantum theory is one of the most successful theories in modern physics. It has been extensively tested in the microscopic domain, always with remarkable success. Yet, these tests do not currently extend in a conclusive way to all physical systems and across all scales. This leaves open the question of whether quantum theory provides a truly universal description of reality, especially in regimes where direct experimental access is limited, such as the gravitational field or complex macroscopic biological systems. This Thesis addresses this question through the study of hybrid systems, where a well-controlled quantum sector interacts with an unknown sector whose underlying description may or may not be quantum. It contributes to the emerging framework of information-theoretical witnesses of non-classicality, where the quantum sector is used as a probe to test the nature of the unknown system under minimal assumptions. We first examine spatial entanglement-based witnesses, in which the ability of an unknown system to mediate entanglement between two quantum probes by local means provides a sufficient condition for its non-classicality. We extend this framework by quantitatively showing that locally mediated quantum correlations lower bound the non-commutativity of the observables of the mediator, within quantum theory. We then introduce a novel class of single-probe temporal witnesses, where non-classicality is inferred from the temporal evolution of a probe under a global conservation law. We prove that quantum coherent evolution under such a constraint can only be mediated by a non-classical system, and propose an application to light-harvesting processes in photosynthetic complexes. Finally, we develop a temporal entanglement-based witness. Here, the sufficient condition for the non-classicality of the unknown system is the ability to mediate temporal entanglement relative to the probe's local conserved quantity and a non-commuting observable. This result provides a temporal extension of the spatial entanglement-based witness, representing a promising route for the development of the next generation of tests to probe the universality of quantum theory in previously inaccessible fields such as gravity and biology.
Quantum entanglement is a form of correlation between quantum particles that cannot be increased via local operations and classical communication. It has therefore been proposed that an increment of quantum entanglement between probes that are interacting solely via a mediator implies non-classicality of the mediator. Indeed, under certain assumptions regarding the initial state, entanglement gain between the probes indicates quantum coherence in the mediator. Going beyond such assumptions, there exist other initial states which produce entanglement between the probes via only local interactions with a classical mediator. In this process the initial entanglement between any probe and the rest of the system "flows through" the classical mediator and gets localised between the probes. Here we theoretically characterise maximal entanglement gain via classical mediator and experimentally demonstrate, using liquid-state NMR spectroscopy, the optimal growth of quantum correlations between two nuclear spin qubits interacting through a mediator qubit in a classical state. We additionally monitor, i.e., dephase, the mediator in order to emphasise its classical character. Our results indicate the necessity of verifying features of the initial state if entanglement gain between the probes is used as a figure of merit for witnessing non-classical mediator. Such methods were proposed to have exemplary applications in quantum optomechanics, quantum biology and quantum gravity.
Abstract A general entanglement-based witness of non-classicality has recently been proposed, which can be applied to testing quantum effects in gravity. This witness is based on generating entanglement between two quantum probes via a mediator. In this paper we provide a ‘temporal’ variant of this witness, using a single quantum probe to assess the non-classicality of the mediator. Within the formalism of quantum theory, we show that if a system M is capable of inducing a coherent dynamical evolution of a quantum system Q, in the presence of a conservation law, then M must be non-classical. This argument supports witnesses of non-classicality relying on a single quantum probe, which can be applied to a number of open issues, notably in quantum gravity or quantum biology.