Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1803.08485 · Condensed Matter

Connecting Complex Electronic Pattern Formation to Critical Exponents

Shuo Liu, E. W. Carlson, Karin A. Dahmen

Published Nov 4, 2021• 7 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Scanning probes reveal complex, inhomogeneous patterns on the surface of many condensed matter systems. In some cases, the patterns form self-similar, fractal geometric clusters. In this paper, we advance the theory of criticality as it pertains to those geometric clusters (defined as connected sets of nearest-neighbor aligned spins) in the context of Ising models. We show how data from surface probes can be used to distinguish whether electronic patterns observed at the surface of a material are confined to the surface, or whether the patterns originate in the bulk. Whereas thermodynamic critical exponents are derived from the behavior of Fortuin–Kasteleyn (FK) clusters, critical exponents can be similarly defined for geometric clusters. We find that these geometric critical exponents are not only distinct numerically from the thermodynamic and uncorrelated percolation exponents, but that they separately satisfy scaling relations at the critical fixed points discussed in the text. We furthermore find that the two-dimensional (2D) cross-sections of geometric clusters in the three-dimensional (3D) Ising model display critical scaling behavior at the bulk phase transition temperature. In particular, we show that when considered on a 2D slice of a 3D system, the pair connectivity function familiar from percolation theory displays more robust critical behavior than the spin-spin correlation function, and we calculate the corresponding critical exponent. We discuss the implications of these two distinct length scales in Ising models. We also calculate the pair connectivity exponent in the clean 2D case. These results extend the theory of geometric criticality in the clean Ising universality classes, and facilitate the broad application of geometric cluster analysis techniques to maximize the information that can be extracted from scanning image probe data in condensed matter systems.

DOI
10.3390/condmat6040039

Related papers

Classifying Pattern Formation in Materials via Machine Learning

Lukasz Burzawa, Shuo Liu, E. W. Carlson

Scanning probe experiments such as scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) and atomic force microscopy (AFM) on strongly correlated materials often reveal complex pattern formation that occurs on multiple length scales. We have shown in two disparate correlated materials that the pattern formation is driven by proximity to a disorder-driven critical point. We developed new analysis concepts and techniques that relate the observed pattern formation to critical exponents by analyzing the geometry and statistics of clusters observed in these experiments and converting that information into critical exponents. Machine learning algorithms can be helpful correlating data from scanning probe experiments to theoretical models of pattern formation. We analyze the use of machine learning algorithms for the identification of critical behavior and universality underlying scanning probe data sets taken from correlated materials. This method has complementary strengths to the cluster analysis methods. The cluster techniques have a clear physical interpretation while machine learning algorithms require less expertise from the user and are faster to implement. The complementary nature of the two techniques further facilitates our understanding of correlated materials. The training of machine learning algorithms has been done through artificial neural networks. The neural net was trained using data from theoretical simulations of percolation and Ising models. The trained net had a 3.00% average classification error during testing. This proves that machine learning algorithms can successfully distinguish whether the complex pattern formation of a specific novel material is governed by uncorrelated percolation or by an interaction model fixed point.

•Jan 1, 2016•0 citations

Three-dimensional Ising model, percolation theory and conformal invariance

Abbas Ali Saberi, Hor Dashti-Naserabadi

The fractal structure and scaling properties of a 2d slice of the 3d Ising model is studied using Monte Carlo techniques. The percolation transition of geometric spin (GS) clusters is found to occur at the Curie point, reflecting the critical behavior of the 3d model. The fractal dimension and the winding angle statistics of the perimeter and external perimeter of the geometric spin clusters at the critical point suggest that, if conformally invariant in the scaling limit, they can be described by the theory of Schramm-Löwner evolution (SLE κ ) with diffusivity of κ=5 and 16/5, respectively, putting them in the same universality class as the interfaces in 2d tricritical Ising model. It is also found that the Fortuin-Kasteleyn (FK) clusters associated with the cross-sections undergo a nontrivial percolation transition, in the same universality class as the ordinary 2d critical percolation.

arXiv:1012.1485•Europhysics Letters (EPL)•Dec 1, 2010•26 citations

Critical behavior of the geometrical spin clusters and interfaces in the two-dimensional thermalized bond Ising model

S Davatolhagh, M Moshfeghian, A A Saberi

The fractal dimensions and the percolation exponents of geometrical spin clusters of like sign at criticality are obtained numerically for an Ising model with temperature dependent annealed bond dilution, also known as the thermalized bond Ising model (TBIM), in two dimensions. For this purpose, a modified Wolff single-cluster Monte Carlo simulation is used to generate equilibrium spin configurations on square lattices in the critical region. A tie-breaking rule is employed to identify nonintersecting spin cluster boundaries along the edges of the dual lattice. The values obtained for the fractal dimensions of the spanning geometrical clusters D c , and their interfaces D I , are in perfect agreement with those reported for the standard two-dimensional ferromagnetic Ising model. Furthermore, the variance of the winding angles results in a diffusivity κ = 3 for the two-dimensional thermalized bond Ising model, thus placing it in the universality class of the regular Ising model. A finite-size scaling analysis of the largest geometrical clusters results in a reliable estimation of the critical percolation exponents for the geometrical clusters in the limit of an infinite lattice size. The percolation exponents thus obtained are also found to be consistent with those reported for the regular Ising model. These consistencies are explained in terms of the Fisher renormalization relations, which express the thermodynamic critical exponents of systems with annealed bond dilution in terms of those of the regular model system.

arXiv:1202.6683•Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment•Feb 21, 2012•4 citations

Geometric Phase Transition of the Three-Dimensional Z 2 Lattice Gauge Model

Ramgopal Agrawal, Leticia F. Cugliandolo, Lara Faoro +2 more

After fifty years of lattice gauge theories (LGTs), the nature of the transition between their topological phases (confinement or deconfinement) remains challenging due to the absence of a local order parameter. In this work, we conduct a percolation analysis of Wegner's three-dimensional Z_{2} lattice gauge model using intensive Monte Carlo simulations and finite-size scaling, offering fresh insights into the topological phase transitions of gauge-invariant systems. We demonstrate that, regardless of the connection rules, geometrical loops, constructed by piercing excited plaquettes percolate precisely at the thermal critical point T_{c}, with critical exponents coinciding with those of the loop representation of the dual 3D Ising model. Further, we construct Fortuin-Kasteleyn (FK) clusters in a random-cluster representation, showing that they also percolate at T_{c}, enabling access to all thermal critical exponents. Strikingly, the Binder cumulants of the percolation order parameters for both loops and FK clusters reveal a pseudo-first-order transition. This work sheds new light on the critical behavior of pure LGTs, with potential implications for condensed matter systems and quantum error correction.

arXiv:2409.15123•Physical Review Letters•Aug 15, 2025•6 citations

Percolation in the two-dimensional Ising model

Tao Chen, Jinhong Zhu, Wei Zhong +2 more

The study of the Ising model from a percolation perspective has played a significant role in the modern theory of critical phenomena. We consider the celebrated square-lattice Ising model and construct percolation clusters by placing bonds, with probability p, between any pair of parallel spins within an extended range beyond nearest neighbors. At the Ising criticality, we observe two percolation transitions as p increases: starting from a disordered phase with only small clusters, the percolation system enters into a stable critical phase that persists over a wide range p_{c_{1}}<p<p_{c_{2}}, and then develops a long-ranged percolation order with giant clusters for both up and down spins. At p_{c1} and for the stable critical phase, the critical behaviors agree well with those for the Fortuin-Kasteleyn random clusters and the spin domains of the Ising model, respectively. At p_{c2}, the fractal dimension of clusters and the scaling exponent along p direction are estimated as y_{h2}=1.9580(6) and y_{p2}=0.552(9), of which the exact values remain unknown. These findings reveal interesting geometric properties of the two-dimensional Ising model that has been studied for more than 100 years.

arXiv:2504.18861•Physical review. E•Jul 22, 2025•2 citations

Geometric properties of the Fortuin-Kasteleyn representation of the Ising model

Pengcheng Hou, Sheng Fang, Junfeng Wang +2 more

We present a Monte Carlo study of the geometric properties of Fortuin-Kasteleyn (FK) clusters of the Ising model on square [two-dimensional (2D)] and simple-cubic [three-dimensional (3D)] lattices. The wrapping probability, a dimensionless quantity characterizing the topology of the FK clusters on a torus, is found to suffer from smaller finite-size corrections than the well-known Binder ratio and yields a high-precision critical coupling as ${K}_{c}(3\mathrm{D})=0.221\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}654\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}631(8)$. We then study other geometric properties of FK clusters at criticality. It is demonstrated that the distribution of the critical largest-cluster size ${C}_{1}$ follows a single-variable function as $P({C}_{1},L)\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}d{C}_{1}=\stackrel{\ifmmode \tilde{}\else \~{}\fi{}}{P}(x)\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}dx$ with $x\ensuremath{\equiv}{C}_{1}/{L}^{{d}_{\mathrm{F}}}$ ($L$ is the linear size), where the fractal dimension ${d}_{\mathrm{F}}$ is identical to the magnetic exponent. An interesting bimodal feature is observed in distribution $\stackrel{\ifmmode \tilde{}\else \~{}\fi{}}{P}(x)$ in three dimensions, and attributed to the different approaching behaviors for $K\ensuremath{\rightarrow}{K}_{c}+{0}^{\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}}$. To characterize the compactness of the FK clusters, we measure their graph distances and determine the shortest-path exponents as ${d}_{\mathrm{min}}(3\mathrm{D})=1.259\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}36(12)$ and ${d}_{\mathrm{min}}(2\mathrm{D})=1.094\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}0(2)$. Further, by excluding all the bridges from the occupied bonds, we obtain bridge-free configurations and determine the backbone exponents as ${d}_{\mathrm{B}}(3\mathrm{D})=2.167\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}3(15)$ and ${d}_{\mathrm{B}}(2\mathrm{D})=1.732\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}1(4)$. The estimates of the universal wrapping probabilities for the 3D Ising model and of the geometric critical exponents ${d}_{\mathrm{min}}$ and ${d}_{\mathrm{B}}$ either improve over the existing results or have not been reported yet. We believe that these numerical results would provide a testing ground in the development of further theoretical treatments of the 3D Ising model.

arXiv:1811.03358•Physical review. E•Apr 30, 2019•23 citations
Scanning probes reveal complex, inhomogeneous patterns on the surface of many condensed matter systems. In some cases, the patterns form self-similar, fractal geometric clusters. In this paper, we advance the theory of criticality as it pertains to those geometric clusters (defined as connected sets of nearest-neighbor aligned spins) in the context of Ising models. We show how data from surface probes can be used to distinguish whether electronic patterns observed at the surface of a material are confined to the surface, or whether the patterns originate in the bulk. Whereas thermodynamic critical exponents are derived from the behavior of Fortuin–Kasteleyn (FK) clusters, critical exponents can be similarly defined for geometric clusters. We find that these geometric critical exponents are not only distinct numerically from the thermodynamic and uncorrelated percolation exponents, but that they separately satisfy scaling relations at the critical fixed points discussed in the text. We furthermore find that the two-dimensional (2D) cross-sections of geometric clusters in the three-dimensional (3D) Ising model display critical scaling behavior at the bulk phase transition temperature. In particular, we show that when considered on a 2D slice of a 3D system, the pair connectivity function familiar from percolation theory displays more robust critical behavior than the spin-spin correlation function, and we calculate the corresponding critical exponent. We discuss the implications of these two distinct length scales in Ising models. We also calculate the pair connectivity exponent in the clean 2D case. These results extend the theory of geometric criticality in the clean Ising universality classes, and facilitate the broad application of geometric cluster analysis techniques to maximize the information that can be extracted from scanning image probe data in condensed matter systems.
Scanning probe experiments such as scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) and atomic force microscopy (AFM) on strongly correlated materials often reveal complex pattern formation that occurs on multiple length scales. We have shown in two disparate correlated materials that the pattern formation is driven by proximity to a disorder-driven critical point. We developed new analysis concepts and techniques that relate the observed pattern formation to critical exponents by analyzing the geometry and statistics of clusters observed in these experiments and converting that information into critical exponents. Machine learning algorithms can be helpful correlating data from scanning probe experiments to theoretical models of pattern formation. We analyze the use of machine learning algorithms for the identification of critical behavior and universality underlying scanning probe data sets taken from correlated materials. This method has complementary strengths to the cluster analysis methods. The cluster techniques have a clear physical interpretation while machine learning algorithms require less expertise from the user and are faster to implement. The complementary nature of the two techniques further facilitates our understanding of correlated materials. The training of machine learning algorithms has been done through artificial neural networks. The neural net was trained using data from theoretical simulations of percolation and Ising models. The trained net had a 3.00% average classification error during testing. This proves that machine learning algorithms can successfully distinguish whether the complex pattern formation of a specific novel material is governed by uncorrelated percolation or by an interaction model fixed point.
The fractal structure and scaling properties of a 2d slice of the 3d Ising model is studied using Monte Carlo techniques. The percolation transition of geometric spin (GS) clusters is found to occur at the Curie point, reflecting the critical behavior of the 3d model. The fractal dimension and the winding angle statistics of the perimeter and external perimeter of the geometric spin clusters at the critical point suggest that, if conformally invariant in the scaling limit, they can be described by the theory of Schramm-Löwner evolution (SLE κ ) with diffusivity of κ=5 and 16/5, respectively, putting them in the same universality class as the interfaces in 2d tricritical Ising model. It is also found that the Fortuin-Kasteleyn (FK) clusters associated with the cross-sections undergo a nontrivial percolation transition, in the same universality class as the ordinary 2d critical percolation.
The fractal dimensions and the percolation exponents of geometrical spin clusters of like sign at criticality are obtained numerically for an Ising model with temperature dependent annealed bond dilution, also known as the thermalized bond Ising model (TBIM), in two dimensions. For this purpose, a modified Wolff single-cluster Monte Carlo simulation is used to generate equilibrium spin configurations on square lattices in the critical region. A tie-breaking rule is employed to identify nonintersecting spin cluster boundaries along the edges of the dual lattice. The values obtained for the fractal dimensions of the spanning geometrical clusters D c , and their interfaces D I , are in perfect agreement with those reported for the standard two-dimensional ferromagnetic Ising model. Furthermore, the variance of the winding angles results in a diffusivity κ = 3 for the two-dimensional thermalized bond Ising model, thus placing it in the universality class of the regular Ising model. A finite-size scaling analysis of the largest geometrical clusters results in a reliable estimation of the critical percolation exponents for the geometrical clusters in the limit of an infinite lattice size. The percolation exponents thus obtained are also found to be consistent with those reported for the regular Ising model. These consistencies are explained in terms of the Fisher renormalization relations, which express the thermodynamic critical exponents of systems with annealed bond dilution in terms of those of the regular model system.
After fifty years of lattice gauge theories (LGTs), the nature of the transition between their topological phases (confinement or deconfinement) remains challenging due to the absence of a local order parameter. In this work, we conduct a percolation analysis of Wegner's three-dimensional Z_{2} lattice gauge model using intensive Monte Carlo simulations and finite-size scaling, offering fresh insights into the topological phase transitions of gauge-invariant systems. We demonstrate that, regardless of the connection rules, geometrical loops, constructed by piercing excited plaquettes percolate precisely at the thermal critical point T_{c}, with critical exponents coinciding with those of the loop representation of the dual 3D Ising model. Further, we construct Fortuin-Kasteleyn (FK) clusters in a random-cluster representation, showing that they also percolate at T_{c}, enabling access to all thermal critical exponents. Strikingly, the Binder cumulants of the percolation order parameters for both loops and FK clusters reveal a pseudo-first-order transition. This work sheds new light on the critical behavior of pure LGTs, with potential implications for condensed matter systems and quantum error correction.
The study of the Ising model from a percolation perspective has played a significant role in the modern theory of critical phenomena. We consider the celebrated square-lattice Ising model and construct percolation clusters by placing bonds, with probability p, between any pair of parallel spins within an extended range beyond nearest neighbors. At the Ising criticality, we observe two percolation transitions as p increases: starting from a disordered phase with only small clusters, the percolation system enters into a stable critical phase that persists over a wide range p_{c_{1}}<p<p_{c_{2}}, and then develops a long-ranged percolation order with giant clusters for both up and down spins. At p_{c1} and for the stable critical phase, the critical behaviors agree well with those for the Fortuin-Kasteleyn random clusters and the spin domains of the Ising model, respectively. At p_{c2}, the fractal dimension of clusters and the scaling exponent along p direction are estimated as y_{h2}=1.9580(6) and y_{p2}=0.552(9), of which the exact values remain unknown. These findings reveal interesting geometric properties of the two-dimensional Ising model that has been studied for more than 100 years.
We present a Monte Carlo study of the geometric properties of Fortuin-Kasteleyn (FK) clusters of the Ising model on square [two-dimensional (2D)] and simple-cubic [three-dimensional (3D)] lattices. The wrapping probability, a dimensionless quantity characterizing the topology of the FK clusters on a torus, is found to suffer from smaller finite-size corrections than the well-known Binder ratio and yields a high-precision critical coupling as Kc(3D)=0.221654631(8){K}_{c}(3\mathrm{D})=0.221\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}654\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}631(8)Kc​(3D)=0.221654631(8). We then study other geometric properties of FK clusters at criticality. It is demonstrated that the distribution of the critical largest-cluster size C1{C}_{1}C1​ follows a single-variable function as $P({C}_{1},L)\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}d{C}_{1}=\stackrel{\ifmmode \tilde{}\else \~{}\fi{}}{P}(x)\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}dx$ with $x\ensuremath{\equiv}{C}_{1}/{L}^{{d}_{\mathrm{F}}}$ (LLL is the linear size), where the fractal dimension dF{d}_{\mathrm{F}}dF​ is identical to the magnetic exponent. An interesting bimodal feature is observed in distribution $\stackrel{\ifmmode \tilde{}\else \~{}\fi{}}{P}(x)$ in three dimensions, and attributed to the different approaching behaviors for $K\ensuremath{\rightarrow}{K}_{c}+{0}^{\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}}$. To characterize the compactness of the FK clusters, we measure their graph distances and determine the shortest-path exponents as dmin(3D)=1.25936(12){d}_{\mathrm{min}}(3\mathrm{D})=1.259\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}36(12)dmin​(3D)=1.25936(12) and dmin(2D)=1.0940(2){d}_{\mathrm{min}}(2\mathrm{D})=1.094\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}0(2)dmin​(2D)=1.0940(2). Further, by excluding all the bridges from the occupied bonds, we obtain bridge-free configurations and determine the backbone exponents as dB(3D)=2.1673(15){d}_{\mathrm{B}}(3\mathrm{D})=2.167\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}3(15)dB​(3D)=2.1673(15) and dB(2D)=1.7321(4){d}_{\mathrm{B}}(2\mathrm{D})=1.732\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}1(4)dB​(2D)=1.7321(4). The estimates of the universal wrapping probabilities for the 3D Ising model and of the geometric critical exponents dmin{d}_{\mathrm{min}}dmin​ and dB{d}_{\mathrm{B}}dB​ either improve over the existing results or have not been reported yet. We believe that these numerical results would provide a testing ground in the development of further theoretical treatments of the 3D Ising model.