Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1803.05977

The Pauli principle, normal modes and superfluidity: the emergence of collective organizational phenomena

D. K. Watson

Published Mar 15, 2018• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Understanding the emergence of collective organizational phenomena is a major goal in many fields of physics from condensed matter to cosmology. Using a recently introduced manybody perturbation formalism for fermions, we propose a mechanism for the emergence of collective behavior, specifically superfluidity, driven by quantum statistics and the enforcement of the Pauli principle through the selection of normal modes. The method, which is called symmetry invariant perturbation theory (SPT), uses group theory and graphical techniques to solve the manybody Schrodinger equation through first order exactly. The solution at first order defines collective coordinates in terms of five N-body normal modes, identified as breathing, center of mass, single particle angular excitation, single particle radial excitation and phonon. A correspondence is established "on paper" that enforces the Pauli principle through the assignment of specific normal mode quantum numbers. Applied in the unitary regime, this normal mode assignment yields occupation only in an extremely low frequency N-body phonon mode at ultralow temperatures. A single particle radial excitation mode at a much higher frequency creates a gap that stabilizes the superfluidity at low temperatures. Coupled with the corresponding values for the frequencies at unitarity obtained by this manybody calculation, we obtain good agreement with experimental thermodynamic results including the lambda transition in the specific heat. Our results suggest that the emergence of collective behavior in macroscopic systems is driven by the Pauli principle and its selection of the correct collective coordinates in the form of N-body normal modes.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1803.05977

Related papers

Universal thermodynamics of a trapped Fermi gas in the superfluid regime: the role of the Pauli principle

D. K. Watson

Abstract Understanding the universal behavior of strongly-interacting systems of particles has been a major goal in multiple fields of physics from atomic physics to cosmology. Using a recently introduced manybody perturbation formalism for fermions which uses group theoretic and graphical techniques to solve the N -body problem, I study the thermodynamic behavior of the unitary regime for a trapped Fermi gas and investigate the role of the Pauli principle in the emergence of collective behavior, specifically superfluidity at ultralow temperatures. The method, which is called symmetry invariant perturbation theory, has no adjustable parameters and currently offers a solution to the manybody Schrodinger equation through first order in inverse dimensionality exactly. The solution at first order defines collective coordinates in terms of five types of N -body normal modes, identified as symmetric stretch, symmetric bend, single particle angular excitation, single particle radial excitation and phonon. A correspondence is established ‘on paper’ that enforces the Pauli principle through the assignment of specific normal mode quantum numbers. Applied at ultracold temperatures, this normal mode assignment yields occupation only in an extremely low frequency N -body phonon mode. A single particle radial excitation mode at a much higher frequency creates a gap that stabilizes the superfluidity at low temperatures. This radial excitation involves excitation of a single particle out of the synced motion of the phonon mode, rather than the breaking of a fermion pair. Coupled with the corresponding values for the energies at unitarity obtained by this manybody calculation, I obtain good agreement with experimental thermodynamic results. In particular, the lambda transition in the specific heat is clearly seen. Based on these findings, I propose a mechanism for the emergence of superfluidity at ultralow temperatures in this unitary regime that is driven by quantum statistics and the enforcement of the Pauli principle through the selection of normal modes. My results for the calculated thermodynamic quantities suggest that the emergence of some collective behaviors in macroscopic systems is due to the Pauli principle producing manybody pairing and the resulting macroscopic occupation of an N -body phonon mode.

Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Aug 19, 2019•7 citations

Analytic-normal-mode frequencies for N identical particles: The microscopic dynamics underlying the emergence and stability of excitation gaps from BCS to unitarity

D. K. Watson

The frequencies of the analytic normal modes for $N$ identical particles are studied as a function of system parameters from the weakly interacting BCS regime to the strongly interacting unitary regime. The normal modes were obtained previously from a first-order $L=0$ group theoretic solution of a three-dimensional Hamiltonian with a general two-body interaction for confined identical particles. In a precursor to this study, the collective behavior of these normal modes was investigated as a function of $N$ from few-body systems to many-body systems analyzing the contribution of individual particles to the collective macroscopic motions. A specific case, the Hamiltonian for Fermi gases in the unitary regime, was studied in more detail. This regime is known to support collective behavior in the form of superfluidity and has previously been successfully described using normal modes. Two phenomena that could sustain the emergence and stability of superfluid behavior were revealed, including the behavior of the normal mode frequencies as $N$ increases. In this paper, I focus on a more detailed analysis of these analytic frequencies, extending my investigation to include Hamiltonians with a range of interparticle interaction strengths from the BCS regime to the unitary regime and analyzing the microscopic dynamics that lead to large gaps at unitarity. The results of the present study suggest that in regimes where higher-order effects are small, normal modes can be used to describe the physics of superfluidity from the weakly interacting BCS regime with the emergence of small excitation gaps to unitarity with its large gaps and can offer insight into a possible microscopic understanding of the behavior at unitarity. This approach could thus offer an alternative to the two-body pairing models commonly used to describe superfluidity along this transition.

arXiv:2105.10608•Physical Review A•Sep 27, 2021•5 citations

Reimagining and reinterpreting Cooper pairs, the Fermi sea, Pauli blocking and superfluidity: The Pauli principle in collective motion

D. K. Watson

Abstract Identifying possible microscopic mechanisms underlying superfluidity has been the goal of various studies since the introduction of the original BCS theory. Recently a series of papers have proposed microscopic dynamics based on normal modes to describe superfluidity without the use of real-space Cooper pairs. Multiple properties were determined with excellent agreement with experimental data. The group theoretic basis of this general N -body approach has allowed the microscopic behavior underlying these results to be analyzed in detail. This reimagination is now used to reinterpret several interrelated phenomena including Cooper pairs, the Fermi sea, and Pauli blocking. This approach adheres closely to the early tenets of superconductivity/superfluidity which assumed pairing only in momentum space, not in real space. The Pauli principle is used, in its recently revealed role in collective motion, to select the allowed normal modes. The expected properties of superfluidity including the rigidity of the wave function, interactions between the fermions in different pairs, convergence of the momentum and the gap in the excitation spectrum are discussed.

arXiv:2304.04696•Europhysics Letters (EPL)•Apr 29, 2024•1 citation

Many-body formalism for fermions: The partition function

D. K. Watson

The partition function, a fundamental tenet in statistical thermodynamics, contains in principle all thermodynamic information about a system. It encapsulates both microscopic information through the quantum energy levels and statistical information from the partitioning of the particles among the available energy levels. For identical particles, this statistical accounting is complicated by the symmetry requirements of the allowed quantum states. In particular, for Fermi systems, the enforcement of the Pauli principle is typically a numerically demanding task, responsible for much of the cost of the calculations. The interplay of these three elements---the structure of the many-body spectrum, the statistical partitioning of the $N$ particles among the available levels, and the enforcement of the Pauli principle---drives the behavior of mesoscopic and macroscopic Fermi systems. In this paper, we develop an approach for the determination of the partition function, a numerically difficult task, for systems of strongly interacting identical fermions and apply it to a model system of harmonically confined, harmonically interacting fermions. This approach uses a recently introduced many-body method that is an extension of the symmetry-invariant perturbation method (SPT) originally developed for bosons. It uses group theory and graphical techniques to avoid the heavy computational demands of conventional many-body methods which typically scale exponentially with the number of particles. The SPT application of the Pauli principle is trivial to implement since it is done ``on paper'' by imposing restrictions on the normal-mode quantum numbers at first order in the perturbation. The method is applied through first order and represents an extension of the SPT method to excited states. Our method of determining the partition function and various thermodynamic quantities is accurate and efficient and has the potential to yield interesting insight into the role played by the Pauli principle and the influence of large degeneracies on the emergence of the thermodynamic behavior of large-$N$ systems.

Physical Review A•Sep 1, 2017•7 citations

Many-body formalism for fermions: Enforcing the Pauli principle on paper

D. K. Watson

Confined quantum systems involving $N$ identical interacting fermions are found in many areas of physics, including condensed matter, atomic, nuclear, and chemical physics. In a previous series of papers, a many-body perturbation method that is applicable to both weakly and strongly interacting systems of bosons has been set forth by the author and coworkers. A symmetry-invariant perturbation theory was developed that uses group theory coupled with the dimension of space as the perturbation parameter to obtain an analytic correlated wave function through first order for a system under spherical confinement with a general two-body interaction. In the present paper, we extend this formalism to large systems of fermions, circumventing the numerical demands of applying the Pauli principle by enforcing the Pauli principle on paper. The method does not scale in complexity with $N$ and has minimal numerical cost. We apply the method to a unitary Fermi gas and compare to recent Monte Carlo values.

arXiv:1506.05122•Physical Review A•Jul 23, 2015•9 citations

Observing the emergence of a quantum phase transition shell by shell

Luca Bayha, Marvin Holten, Ralf Klemt +6 more

Many-body physics describes phenomena that cannot be understood by looking only at the constituents of a system1. Striking examples are broken symmetry, phase transitions and collective excitations2. To understand how such collective behaviour emerges as a system is gradually assembled from individual particles has been a goal in atomic, nuclear and solid-state physics for decades3–6. Here we observe the few-body precursor of a quantum phase transition from a normal to a superfluid phase. The transition is signalled by the softening of the mode associated with amplitude vibrations of the order parameter, usually referred to as a Higgs mode7. We achieve fine control over ultracold fermions confined to two-dimensional harmonic potentials and prepare closed-shell configurations of 2, 6 and 12 fermionic atoms in the ground state with high fidelity. Spectroscopy is then performed on our mesoscopic system while tuning the pair energy from zero to a value larger than the shell spacing. Using full atom counting statistics, we find the lowest resonance to consist of coherently excited pairs only. The distinct non-monotonic interaction dependence of this many-body excitation, combined with comparison with numerical calculations allows us to identify it as the precursor of the Higgs mode. Our atomic simulator provides a way to study the emergence of collective phenomena and the thermodynamic limit, particle by particle. An atomic simulator formed of a few ultracold fermionic atoms trapped in a two-dimensional harmonic potential exhibits precursors of a quantum phase transition, revealing the onset of collective quantum many-body phenomena in a few-body system.

arXiv:2004.14761•Nature•Nov 25, 2020•82 citations
Understanding the emergence of collective organizational phenomena is a major goal in many fields of physics from condensed matter to cosmology. Using a recently introduced manybody perturbation formalism for fermions, we propose a mechanism for the emergence of collective behavior, specifically superfluidity, driven by quantum statistics and the enforcement of the Pauli principle through the selection of normal modes. The method, which is called symmetry invariant perturbation theory (SPT), uses group theory and graphical techniques to solve the manybody Schrodinger equation through first order exactly. The solution at first order defines collective coordinates in terms of five N-body normal modes, identified as breathing, center of mass, single particle angular excitation, single particle radial excitation and phonon. A correspondence is established "on paper" that enforces the Pauli principle through the assignment of specific normal mode quantum numbers. Applied in the unitary regime, this normal mode assignment yields occupation only in an extremely low frequency N-body phonon mode at ultralow temperatures. A single particle radial excitation mode at a much higher frequency creates a gap that stabilizes the superfluidity at low temperatures. Coupled with the corresponding values for the frequencies at unitarity obtained by this manybody calculation, we obtain good agreement with experimental thermodynamic results including the lambda transition in the specific heat. Our results suggest that the emergence of collective behavior in macroscopic systems is driven by the Pauli principle and its selection of the correct collective coordinates in the form of N-body normal modes.
Abstract Understanding the universal behavior of strongly-interacting systems of particles has been a major goal in multiple fields of physics from atomic physics to cosmology. Using a recently introduced manybody perturbation formalism for fermions which uses group theoretic and graphical techniques to solve the N -body problem, I study the thermodynamic behavior of the unitary regime for a trapped Fermi gas and investigate the role of the Pauli principle in the emergence of collective behavior, specifically superfluidity at ultralow temperatures. The method, which is called symmetry invariant perturbation theory, has no adjustable parameters and currently offers a solution to the manybody Schrodinger equation through first order in inverse dimensionality exactly. The solution at first order defines collective coordinates in terms of five types of N -body normal modes, identified as symmetric stretch, symmetric bend, single particle angular excitation, single particle radial excitation and phonon. A correspondence is established ‘on paper’ that enforces the Pauli principle through the assignment of specific normal mode quantum numbers. Applied at ultracold temperatures, this normal mode assignment yields occupation only in an extremely low frequency N -body phonon mode. A single particle radial excitation mode at a much higher frequency creates a gap that stabilizes the superfluidity at low temperatures. This radial excitation involves excitation of a single particle out of the synced motion of the phonon mode, rather than the breaking of a fermion pair. Coupled with the corresponding values for the energies at unitarity obtained by this manybody calculation, I obtain good agreement with experimental thermodynamic results. In particular, the lambda transition in the specific heat is clearly seen. Based on these findings, I propose a mechanism for the emergence of superfluidity at ultralow temperatures in this unitary regime that is driven by quantum statistics and the enforcement of the Pauli principle through the selection of normal modes. My results for the calculated thermodynamic quantities suggest that the emergence of some collective behaviors in macroscopic systems is due to the Pauli principle producing manybody pairing and the resulting macroscopic occupation of an N -body phonon mode.
The frequencies of the analytic normal modes for NNN identical particles are studied as a function of system parameters from the weakly interacting BCS regime to the strongly interacting unitary regime. The normal modes were obtained previously from a first-order L=0L=0L=0 group theoretic solution of a three-dimensional Hamiltonian with a general two-body interaction for confined identical particles. In a precursor to this study, the collective behavior of these normal modes was investigated as a function of NNN from few-body systems to many-body systems analyzing the contribution of individual particles to the collective macroscopic motions. A specific case, the Hamiltonian for Fermi gases in the unitary regime, was studied in more detail. This regime is known to support collective behavior in the form of superfluidity and has previously been successfully described using normal modes. Two phenomena that could sustain the emergence and stability of superfluid behavior were revealed, including the behavior of the normal mode frequencies as NNN increases. In this paper, I focus on a more detailed analysis of these analytic frequencies, extending my investigation to include Hamiltonians with a range of interparticle interaction strengths from the BCS regime to the unitary regime and analyzing the microscopic dynamics that lead to large gaps at unitarity. The results of the present study suggest that in regimes where higher-order effects are small, normal modes can be used to describe the physics of superfluidity from the weakly interacting BCS regime with the emergence of small excitation gaps to unitarity with its large gaps and can offer insight into a possible microscopic understanding of the behavior at unitarity. This approach could thus offer an alternative to the two-body pairing models commonly used to describe superfluidity along this transition.
Abstract Identifying possible microscopic mechanisms underlying superfluidity has been the goal of various studies since the introduction of the original BCS theory. Recently a series of papers have proposed microscopic dynamics based on normal modes to describe superfluidity without the use of real-space Cooper pairs. Multiple properties were determined with excellent agreement with experimental data. The group theoretic basis of this general N -body approach has allowed the microscopic behavior underlying these results to be analyzed in detail. This reimagination is now used to reinterpret several interrelated phenomena including Cooper pairs, the Fermi sea, and Pauli blocking. This approach adheres closely to the early tenets of superconductivity/superfluidity which assumed pairing only in momentum space, not in real space. The Pauli principle is used, in its recently revealed role in collective motion, to select the allowed normal modes. The expected properties of superfluidity including the rigidity of the wave function, interactions between the fermions in different pairs, convergence of the momentum and the gap in the excitation spectrum are discussed.
The partition function, a fundamental tenet in statistical thermodynamics, contains in principle all thermodynamic information about a system. It encapsulates both microscopic information through the quantum energy levels and statistical information from the partitioning of the particles among the available energy levels. For identical particles, this statistical accounting is complicated by the symmetry requirements of the allowed quantum states. In particular, for Fermi systems, the enforcement of the Pauli principle is typically a numerically demanding task, responsible for much of the cost of the calculations. The interplay of these three elements---the structure of the many-body spectrum, the statistical partitioning of the NNN particles among the available levels, and the enforcement of the Pauli principle---drives the behavior of mesoscopic and macroscopic Fermi systems. In this paper, we develop an approach for the determination of the partition function, a numerically difficult task, for systems of strongly interacting identical fermions and apply it to a model system of harmonically confined, harmonically interacting fermions. This approach uses a recently introduced many-body method that is an extension of the symmetry-invariant perturbation method (SPT) originally developed for bosons. It uses group theory and graphical techniques to avoid the heavy computational demands of conventional many-body methods which typically scale exponentially with the number of particles. The SPT application of the Pauli principle is trivial to implement since it is done ``on paper'' by imposing restrictions on the normal-mode quantum numbers at first order in the perturbation. The method is applied through first order and represents an extension of the SPT method to excited states. Our method of determining the partition function and various thermodynamic quantities is accurate and efficient and has the potential to yield interesting insight into the role played by the Pauli principle and the influence of large degeneracies on the emergence of the thermodynamic behavior of large-NNN systems.
Confined quantum systems involving NNN identical interacting fermions are found in many areas of physics, including condensed matter, atomic, nuclear, and chemical physics. In a previous series of papers, a many-body perturbation method that is applicable to both weakly and strongly interacting systems of bosons has been set forth by the author and coworkers. A symmetry-invariant perturbation theory was developed that uses group theory coupled with the dimension of space as the perturbation parameter to obtain an analytic correlated wave function through first order for a system under spherical confinement with a general two-body interaction. In the present paper, we extend this formalism to large systems of fermions, circumventing the numerical demands of applying the Pauli principle by enforcing the Pauli principle on paper. The method does not scale in complexity with NNN and has minimal numerical cost. We apply the method to a unitary Fermi gas and compare to recent Monte Carlo values.
Many-body physics describes phenomena that cannot be understood by looking only at the constituents of a system1. Striking examples are broken symmetry, phase transitions and collective excitations2. To understand how such collective behaviour emerges as a system is gradually assembled from individual particles has been a goal in atomic, nuclear and solid-state physics for decades3–6. Here we observe the few-body precursor of a quantum phase transition from a normal to a superfluid phase. The transition is signalled by the softening of the mode associated with amplitude vibrations of the order parameter, usually referred to as a Higgs mode7. We achieve fine control over ultracold fermions confined to two-dimensional harmonic potentials and prepare closed-shell configurations of 2, 6 and 12 fermionic atoms in the ground state with high fidelity. Spectroscopy is then performed on our mesoscopic system while tuning the pair energy from zero to a value larger than the shell spacing. Using full atom counting statistics, we find the lowest resonance to consist of coherently excited pairs only. The distinct non-monotonic interaction dependence of this many-body excitation, combined with comparison with numerical calculations allows us to identify it as the precursor of the Higgs mode. Our atomic simulator provides a way to study the emergence of collective phenomena and the thermodynamic limit, particle by particle. An atomic simulator formed of a few ultracold fermionic atoms trapped in a two-dimensional harmonic potential exhibits precursors of a quantum phase transition, revealing the onset of collective quantum many-body phenomena in a few-body system.