Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1803.00578

Exotic $Z_2$ Symmetry Breaking Transitions in 2D Correlated Systems

Sangjin Lee, Jun Yeong Jung, Ara Go, Eun-Gook Moon

Published Mar 1, 2018• 8 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The Landau paradigm of phase transitions is one of the backbones in critical phenomena. With a $Z_2$ symmetry, it describes the Ising universality class whose central charge is one half (c = 1=2) in two spatial dimensions (2D). Recent experiments in strongly correlated systems, however, suggest intriguing possibilities beyond the Landau paradigm. We uncover an exotic universality class of a $Z_2$ symmetry breaking transition with c = 1. It is shown that fractionalization of discrete symmetry order parameters may realize the exotic class. In addition to novel critical exponents, we find that the onset of an order parameter may be super-linear in contrast to the sub-linear onset of the Ising class. We argue that a super-linear onset of a $Z_2$ order parameter without breaking a bigger symmetry than $Z_2$ is evidence of exotic phenomena, and our results are applied to recent experiments in phase transitions at pseudo-gap temperatures.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1803.00578

Related papers

Exotic thermal transitions with spontaneous symmetry breaking

Hanbit Oh, Eun-Gook Moon

We show that exotic spontaneous symmetry breaking appears in thermal topological phases by perturbing the exact solutions of quantum rotor models coupled to the three-dimensional toric code. The exotic Ising and XY transitions are shown to be in the same universality class, in drastic contrast to the conventional Wilson-Fisher classes without topological orders. Our results indicate that topological orders must be included to pin down the universality classes of thermal transitions in addition to order parameter symmetry and spatial dimension. We evaluate all the critical exponents and find that the exotic universality class is more stable under the couplings to acoustic phonons and disorder. Applying our results to experiments, we provide a plausible scenario in puzzlings of strongly correlated systems, including the absence of a specific heat anomaly in doped ${\mathrm{RbFe}}_{2}{\mathrm{As}}_{2}$.

arXiv:2111.09326•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Oct 17, 2022•0 citations

Deconfined Thermal Phase Transitions with $Z_2$ Gauge Structures

Eun-Gook Moon

Fathoming deconfined phases is one of the key issues in modern condensed matter. Striking many-body effects including massive quantum entanglement and coherence may be realized as manifested in quantum spin liquids and topological orders. Here, we demonstrate that deconfined phases even host exotic thermal phase transitions, dubbed deconfined thermal transitions. Constructing a $Z_2$ lattice gauge model with strong interactions between $Z_2$ gauge fluxes, we prove the existence of a thermal phase transition between deconfined and confined phases in two spatial dimensions in sharp contrast to its absence in the Wegner model. Incorporating deconfined fermions, it is shown that gapless excitations from Fermi surfaces endow line-tension to $Z_2$ gauge fluxes at zero temperature, and we argue that a deconfined thermal transition with deconfined fermions may be interpreted as a hidden order transition with thermal gap-opening in Fermi surfaces. Moreover, it is shown that symmetry breaking transitions in deconfined phases may be unconventional. Global $Z_2$ and $U(1)$ symmetry breaking transitions in deconfined phases may be in the same universality class, which is impossible under the conventional Landau-Ginzburg-Wilson paradigm. Characteristic signatures of the transitions in experiments and candidate strongly correlated systems such as Kitaev materials are also discussed.

arXiv:1812.05621•Dec 13, 2018•4 citations

Universal Symmetry-Breaking Dynamics at Continuous Phase Transitions: Evidence for a New Dynamical Critical Exponent

Tobias Wiener, Laurin Brunner, Markus Heyl

Uncovering and understanding universal dynamics in matter far from equilibrium remains a key challenge. In this work, we identify a so far unrecognized form of universal behavior that emerges after a sudden symmetry-breaking quench at continuous phase transitions. Our key observation is that the order-parameter fluctuations in Ising models exhibit a compelling temporal collapse across a wide range of system sizes and quench strengths, indicative of an emergent single-variable scaling form. This phenomenon can be explained by introducing a so far unknown dynamical critical exponent for the underlying continuous phase transition. We find evidence for a lower critical effective dimension of this universal regime: it is observed in the 2D quantum and 3D and 4D classical Ising models, but not in the 1D quantum or 2D classical cases. Our results suggest that our observed universal far-from-equilibrium scaling may extend beyond the Ising models studied here and could more broadly characterize systems with non-conserved order parameters, opening new avenues for exploring universal dynamics both theoretically and in current experimental platforms.

quant-pharXiv:2605.07753•May 11, 2026•1 citation

Boundary criticality of topological quantum phase transitions in two-dimensional systems

Xiao-Chuan Wu, Yichen Xu, Hao Geng +2 more

We discuss the boundary critical behaviors of two-dimensional (2D) quantum phase transitions with fractionalized degrees of freedom in the bulk, motivated by the fact that usually it is the one-dimensional boundary that is exposed and can be conveniently probed in many experimental platforms. In particular, we mainly discuss boundary criticality of two examples: (i) the quantum phase transition between a 2D ${Z}_{2}$ topological order and an ordered phase with spontaneous symmetry breaking; (ii) the continuous quantum phase transition between metal and a particular type of Mott insulator [$\mathrm{U}(1)$ spin liquid]. In particular, we obtain the critical exponents and scaling laws of these exotic quantum phase transitions when the systems are probed from the boundary in proposed experimental setup. These critical exponents obtained are significantly different from those one would see through bulk measurements. This theoretical study could be relevant to many purely 2D systems, where recent experiments have found correlated insulator, superconductor, and metal in the same phase diagram.

arXiv:2001.10550•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•May 5, 2020•9 citations

Quantum Phase Transition in the Coupled-Top Model: From Z2 to U(1) Symmetry Breaking

Wen-Jian Mao, Ye F. Tian, Liwei Duan +1 more

We investigate the coupled-top model, which describes two large spins interacting along both x and y directions. By tuning coupling strengths along distinct directions, the system exhibits different symmetries, ranging from a discrete Z2 to a continuous U(1) symmetry. The anisotropic coupled-top model displays a discrete Z2 symmetry, and the symmetry breaking induced by strong coupling drives a quantum phase transition from a disordered paramagnetic phase to an ordered ferromagnetic or antiferromagnetic phase. In particular, the isotropic coupled-top model possesses a continuous U(1) symmetry, whose breaking gives rise to the Goldstone mode. The phase boundary can be well captured by the mean-field approach, characterized by the distinct behaviors of the order parameter. Higher-order quantum effects beyond the mean-field contribution can be achieved by mapping the large spins to bosonic operators via the Holstein–Primakoff transformation. For the anisotropic coupled-top model with Z2 symmetry, the energy gap closes, and both quantum fluctuations and entanglement entropy diverge near the critical point, signaling the onset of second-order quantum phase transitions. Strikingly, when U(1) symmetry is broken, the energy gap vanishes beyond the critical point, yielding a novel critical exponent of 1, rather than 1/2 for Z2 symmetry breaking. The rich symmetry structure of the coupled-top model underpins its role as a paradigmatic model for studying quantum phase transitions and exploring associated physical phenomena.

arXiv:2502.09394•Entropy•Apr 27, 2025•0 citations

Z 2 gauge theory of electron fractionalization in strongly correlated systems

T. Senthil, Matthew P. A. Fisher

We develop a new theoretical framework for describing and analyzing exotic phases of strongly correlated electrons which support excitations with fractional quantum numbers. Starting with a class of microscopic models believed to capture much of the essential physics of the cuprate superconductors, we derive a new gauge theory---based upon a discrete Ising or ${Z}_{2}$ symmetry---which interpolates naturally between an antiferromagnetic Mott insulator and a conventional d-wave superconductor. We explore the intervening regime, and demonstrate the possible existence of an exotic fractionalized insulator, the nodal liquid, as well as various more conventional insulating phases exhibiting broken lattice symmetries. A crucial role is played by vortex configurations in the ${Z}_{2}$ gauge field. Fractionalization is obtained if they are uncondensed. Within the insulating phases, the dynamics of these ${Z}_{2}$ vortices in two dimensions is described, after a duality transformation, by an Ising model in a transverse field, the Ising spins representing the ${Z}_{2}$ vortices. The presence of an unusual Berry's phase term in the gauge theory leads to a doping-dependent ``frustration'' in the dual Ising model, being fully frustrated at half filling. The ${Z}_{2}$ gauge theory is readily generalized to a variety of different situations, in particular, it can also describe three-dimensional insulators with fractional quantum numbers. We point out that the mechanism of fractionalization for $d>1$ is distinct from the well-known one-dimensional spin--charge separation. Other interesting results include a description of an exotic fractionalized superconductor in two or higher dimensions.

arXiv:cond-mat/9910224•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Sep 15, 2000•676 citations
Exotic Z2Z_2Z2​ Symmetry Breaking Transitions in 2D Correlated Systems
The Landau paradigm of phase transitions is one of the backbones in critical phenomena. With a Z2Z_2Z2​ symmetry, it describes the Ising universality class whose central charge is one half (c = 1=2) in two spatial dimensions (2D). Recent experiments in strongly correlated systems, however, suggest intriguing possibilities beyond the Landau paradigm. We uncover an exotic universality class of a Z2Z_2Z2​ symmetry breaking transition with c = 1. It is shown that fractionalization of discrete symmetry order parameters may realize the exotic class. In addition to novel critical exponents, we find that the onset of an order parameter may be super-linear in contrast to the sub-linear onset of the Ising class. We argue that a super-linear onset of a Z2Z_2Z2​ order parameter without breaking a bigger symmetry than Z2Z_2Z2​ is evidence of exotic phenomena, and our results are applied to recent experiments in phase transitions at pseudo-gap temperatures.
We show that exotic spontaneous symmetry breaking appears in thermal topological phases by perturbing the exact solutions of quantum rotor models coupled to the three-dimensional toric code. The exotic Ising and XY transitions are shown to be in the same universality class, in drastic contrast to the conventional Wilson-Fisher classes without topological orders. Our results indicate that topological orders must be included to pin down the universality classes of thermal transitions in addition to order parameter symmetry and spatial dimension. We evaluate all the critical exponents and find that the exotic universality class is more stable under the couplings to acoustic phonons and disorder. Applying our results to experiments, we provide a plausible scenario in puzzlings of strongly correlated systems, including the absence of a specific heat anomaly in doped RbFe2As2{\mathrm{RbFe}}_{2}{\mathrm{As}}_{2}RbFe2​As2​.
Deconfined Thermal Phase Transitions with Z2Z_2Z2​ Gauge Structures
Fathoming deconfined phases is one of the key issues in modern condensed matter. Striking many-body effects including massive quantum entanglement and coherence may be realized as manifested in quantum spin liquids and topological orders. Here, we demonstrate that deconfined phases even host exotic thermal phase transitions, dubbed deconfined thermal transitions. Constructing a Z2Z_2Z2​ lattice gauge model with strong interactions between Z2Z_2Z2​ gauge fluxes, we prove the existence of a thermal phase transition between deconfined and confined phases in two spatial dimensions in sharp contrast to its absence in the Wegner model. Incorporating deconfined fermions, it is shown that gapless excitations from Fermi surfaces endow line-tension to Z2Z_2Z2​ gauge fluxes at zero temperature, and we argue that a deconfined thermal transition with deconfined fermions may be interpreted as a hidden order transition with thermal gap-opening in Fermi surfaces. Moreover, it is shown that symmetry breaking transitions in deconfined phases may be unconventional. Global Z2Z_2Z2​ and U(1)U(1)U(1) symmetry breaking transitions in deconfined phases may be in the same universality class, which is impossible under the conventional Landau-Ginzburg-Wilson paradigm. Characteristic signatures of the transitions in experiments and candidate strongly correlated systems such as Kitaev materials are also discussed.
Uncovering and understanding universal dynamics in matter far from equilibrium remains a key challenge. In this work, we identify a so far unrecognized form of universal behavior that emerges after a sudden symmetry-breaking quench at continuous phase transitions. Our key observation is that the order-parameter fluctuations in Ising models exhibit a compelling temporal collapse across a wide range of system sizes and quench strengths, indicative of an emergent single-variable scaling form. This phenomenon can be explained by introducing a so far unknown dynamical critical exponent for the underlying continuous phase transition. We find evidence for a lower critical effective dimension of this universal regime: it is observed in the 2D quantum and 3D and 4D classical Ising models, but not in the 1D quantum or 2D classical cases. Our results suggest that our observed universal far-from-equilibrium scaling may extend beyond the Ising models studied here and could more broadly characterize systems with non-conserved order parameters, opening new avenues for exploring universal dynamics both theoretically and in current experimental platforms.
We discuss the boundary critical behaviors of two-dimensional (2D) quantum phase transitions with fractionalized degrees of freedom in the bulk, motivated by the fact that usually it is the one-dimensional boundary that is exposed and can be conveniently probed in many experimental platforms. In particular, we mainly discuss boundary criticality of two examples: (i) the quantum phase transition between a 2D Z2{Z}_{2}Z2​ topological order and an ordered phase with spontaneous symmetry breaking; (ii) the continuous quantum phase transition between metal and a particular type of Mott insulator [U(1)\mathrm{U}(1)U(1) spin liquid]. In particular, we obtain the critical exponents and scaling laws of these exotic quantum phase transitions when the systems are probed from the boundary in proposed experimental setup. These critical exponents obtained are significantly different from those one would see through bulk measurements. This theoretical study could be relevant to many purely 2D systems, where recent experiments have found correlated insulator, superconductor, and metal in the same phase diagram.
We investigate the coupled-top model, which describes two large spins interacting along both x and y directions. By tuning coupling strengths along distinct directions, the system exhibits different symmetries, ranging from a discrete Z2 to a continuous U(1) symmetry. The anisotropic coupled-top model displays a discrete Z2 symmetry, and the symmetry breaking induced by strong coupling drives a quantum phase transition from a disordered paramagnetic phase to an ordered ferromagnetic or antiferromagnetic phase. In particular, the isotropic coupled-top model possesses a continuous U(1) symmetry, whose breaking gives rise to the Goldstone mode. The phase boundary can be well captured by the mean-field approach, characterized by the distinct behaviors of the order parameter. Higher-order quantum effects beyond the mean-field contribution can be achieved by mapping the large spins to bosonic operators via the Holstein–Primakoff transformation. For the anisotropic coupled-top model with Z2 symmetry, the energy gap closes, and both quantum fluctuations and entanglement entropy diverge near the critical point, signaling the onset of second-order quantum phase transitions. Strikingly, when U(1) symmetry is broken, the energy gap vanishes beyond the critical point, yielding a novel critical exponent of 1, rather than 1/2 for Z2 symmetry breaking. The rich symmetry structure of the coupled-top model underpins its role as a paradigmatic model for studying quantum phase transitions and exploring associated physical phenomena.
We develop a new theoretical framework for describing and analyzing exotic phases of strongly correlated electrons which support excitations with fractional quantum numbers. Starting with a class of microscopic models believed to capture much of the essential physics of the cuprate superconductors, we derive a new gauge theory---based upon a discrete Ising or Z2{Z}_{2}Z2​ symmetry---which interpolates naturally between an antiferromagnetic Mott insulator and a conventional d-wave superconductor. We explore the intervening regime, and demonstrate the possible existence of an exotic fractionalized insulator, the nodal liquid, as well as various more conventional insulating phases exhibiting broken lattice symmetries. A crucial role is played by vortex configurations in the Z2{Z}_{2}Z2​ gauge field. Fractionalization is obtained if they are uncondensed. Within the insulating phases, the dynamics of these Z2{Z}_{2}Z2​ vortices in two dimensions is described, after a duality transformation, by an Ising model in a transverse field, the Ising spins representing the Z2{Z}_{2}Z2​ vortices. The presence of an unusual Berry's phase term in the gauge theory leads to a doping-dependent ``frustration'' in the dual Ising model, being fully frustrated at half filling. The Z2{Z}_{2}Z2​ gauge theory is readily generalized to a variety of different situations, in particular, it can also describe three-dimensional insulators with fractional quantum numbers. We point out that the mechanism of fractionalization for d>1d>1d>1 is distinct from the well-known one-dimensional spin--charge separation. Other interesting results include a description of an exotic fractionalized superconductor in two or higher dimensions.