Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1801.10196 · Journal of Physics Conference Series

An analysis of variational wave function for the pairing problem in strongly correlated system

Hsuan‐Hao Fan, E. Krotscheck

Published Jun 1, 2018• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We report a theoretical analysis of variational wave functions for the BCS pairing problem. Starting with a Jastrow-Feenberg (or, in a more recent language "fixed-node") wave function for the superfluid state, we develop the full optimized Fermi-Hypernetted Chain (FHNC-EL) equations which sum a local approximation of the parquet-diagrams. Close examination of the procedure reveals that it is essential to go beyond the usual Jastrow-Feenberg approximation to guarantee the correct stability range.

DOI
10.1088/1742-6596/1041/1/012010

Related papers

THEORY OF CORRELATED BASIS FUNCTIONS

E. Krotscheck

We describe the development of perturbation theory in a basis of correlated wave functions. The formulation of the basic theory is generic in the sense that it does not depend on a specific choice of correlation operator. We will, however, elaborate on the intricate relationships between cluster expansions for Jastrow–Feenberg wave functions on the one side, and perturbative expansions within the basis of Jastrow–Feenberg generated states. The first part of this lecture series sets the general scene of perturbation theroy in a non–orthogonal basis, as laid out by Feshbach, Feenberg, Clark, and others. We then turn to the calculation of effective interactions, which will require the same technical tools that were developed for the Fermi-Hypernetted-Chain theory of the ground state. We then look at the interpretation of these effective interactions from various points of view and draw the connections to phenomenological theories like Landau's Fermi liquid theory, or the BCS theory of superconductivity. We also demonstrate that Fermi–sea averages of the CBF effective interaction vanish for optimized correlation functions. Finally, we turn to cases where CBF theory to infinite order is necessary. Employing ideas of the coupled cluster theory, we develop a method for generating CBF perturbative corrections to infinite order by integral equations. Specializing to ring diagrams, we demonstrate that the "chain" diagrams of the FHNC theory are approximations for the ring diagrams of (CBF-)perturbation theory. The generalization of the time–dependent Hartree–Fock theory to correlated states will allow the formulation of a linear response theory for strongly interacting systems or, alternatively, provide the tools for mapping strong, bare interactions onto weak, effective interactions that can be used in phenomenological theories.

Series on advances in quantum many-body theory•Aug 1, 2002•9 citations

Fermi hypernetted-chain theory for correlated spin-density-wave states

X. Q. G. Wang, Stefano Fantoni, Erio Tosatti +1 more

The Fermi hypernetted-chain (FHNC) theory is applied to spin-density-wave states combined with a Jastrow-type correlation operator. The commonly used approximation scheme FHNC/n is found to be unsuitable for dealing with this class of correlated wave functions. A new scheme, named FHNC-n, is proposed, and numerically tested for the one-dimensional (1D) Hubbard model and the Gutzwiller correlation operator. The results obtained are in very good agreement with the available variational Monte Carlo calculation. This scheme can be used to study 2D and 3D Hubbard models and can easily be extended to treat more general correlation operators, which include triplet and quartet correlations.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Oct 1, 1992•6 citations

Gutzwiller approximation in the Fermi hypernetted-chain theory

Xiao-Qian Wang, C. E. Campbell

We present a general formalism for the variational calculation of the one-body density-matrix and correlation functions for strongly correlated lattice electrons in terms of the Fermi hypernetted-chain (FHNC) diagrammatic expansion. It is shown that, in the limit of infinite spatial dimensions, the local-field-approximate FHNC scheme yields the exact solution for the Gutzwiller wave function, which is equivalent to the result of the Gutzwiller approximation.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Jun 15, 1993•1 citation

Variational theory and parquet diagrams for nuclear systems: a comprehensive study of neutron matter

E. Krotscheck, Jia-Wei Wang

Abstract The main task of microscopic many-body theory is to provide an understanding and an explanation of properties of macroscopic systems from no other information than the properties of the underlying Hamiltonian, the particle statistics, and the macroscopic geometry of the system. Variational wave functions have been a very successful technique for examining the ground state and dynamic properties of dense quantum fluids. Specifically the “optimized (Fermi)-hypernetted chain” ((F)HNC-EL) hierarchy of approximations reproduces, for simple interactions like electrons and quantum fluids, the most basic features of a self-bound many-body system, namely binding, saturation, and spinodal decomposition. The relationships between Green’s functions based perturbation theory and variational wave functions have been clarified in much detail in the past. In the language of Feynman diagrams, a self-consistent summation of ring- and ladder-diagrams is the minimum requirement for a satisfactory microscopic description of these basic features. Realistic nucleon–nucleon interactions pose further problems: The most difficult aspect of the nuclear many-body problem is caused by the form of the microscopic nucleon–nucleon interaction which depends at least on the spin, isospin, the relative orientation and angular momentum of the interacting particles. Simple variational methods as used for electrons and quantum fluids are inadequate. Correlation functions that have the same structure as the interactions lead to so-called “commutator diagrams” that have, so far, been mostly neglected. We have shown in the past that these corrections can be very important if the two-body interactions are very different in different spin- or isospin channels. To deal with the problem of realistic nuclear interactions we have combined techniques of the Jastrow–Feenberg variational method and the local parquet-diagram theory. In the language of diagrammatic perturbation theory, “commutator diagrams” can be identified with non-parquet diagrams. We examine the physical processes described by these terms and include the relevant diagrams in a way that is suggested by the Jastrow–Feenberg approach. We show that the corrections from non-parquet contributions are, at short distances, larger than all other many-body effects. We examine here neutron matter as a prototype of systems with state-dependent interactions. Calculations are carried out for neutrons interacting via the so-called $$v_8$$ v 8 version of four popular interactions. We determine the structure and effective interactions and apply the method to the calculation of the energetics, structure and dynamic properties such as the single-particle self-energy and the dynamic response functions as well as BCS pairing in both singlet and triplet states. We find that many-body correlations lead to a strong reduction of the spin-orbit interaction, and, therefore, to a suppression of the $$^3\textrm{P}_2$$ 3 P 2 and $$^3\textrm{P}_2$$ 3 P 2 - $$^3\textrm{F}_2$$ 3 F 2 gaps. We also find pairing in $$^3\textrm{P}_0$$ 3 P 0 states; the strength of the pairing gap depends sensitively on the potential model employed.

arXiv:2507.03825•The European Physical Journal A•Apr 14, 2026•0 citations

Optimized correlations inspired by perturbation theory

Martin Panholzer, Raphael Hobbiger, Helga M. Böhm

We study the accuracy of analytical wave-function-based many-body methods derived by energy minimization of a Jastrow-Feenberg ansatz for electrons (the ``Fermi hypernetted chain/Euler Lagrange'' approach). Approximations to avoid the complexity of the fermion problem are chosen to parallel successful boson theories and to be computationally efficient. For the three-dimensional homogeneous electron gas, we calculate the correlation energy, the pair distribution function, and the static structure function in comparison with simulation results. We also present a variant of theory which is interpreted as an approximate, self-consistent sum of ladder and ring diagrams of perturbation theory. The theory performs particularly well in the highly dilute density regime.

arXiv:1807.04549•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•May 31, 2019•5 citations

Variational problem in Jastrow theory

E. Krotscheck

The ground-state wave function of an infinite system of fermions is approximated by the state-independent Jastrow ansatz. In order to optimize the pair correlation function, the Euler-Lagrange equations of the variational problem for the energy expectation value are derived. The short- and long-range behaviors of the optimum pair correlation function are discussed. Application of graphical techniques and use of rigorous results on the connection between the slope of the static structure function as $k\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$+ and long-range Jastrow correlations allow one to prove that the optimum pair correlation function behaves like $1+O({r}^{\ensuremath{-}2})$ as $r\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}$. A connection is derived between the weight of the long-range correlations and the Landau parameters. As simple examples the limit of Bose statistics and the electron-gas problem are considered. The consequences of these investigations on numerical calculations and their relation to alternative expansion methods are investigated.

Physical Review A•Jan 1, 1977•78 citations
We report a theoretical analysis of variational wave functions for the BCS pairing problem. Starting with a Jastrow-Feenberg (or, in a more recent language "fixed-node") wave function for the superfluid state, we develop the full optimized Fermi-Hypernetted Chain (FHNC-EL) equations which sum a local approximation of the parquet-diagrams. Close examination of the procedure reveals that it is essential to go beyond the usual Jastrow-Feenberg approximation to guarantee the correct stability range.
We describe the development of perturbation theory in a basis of correlated wave functions. The formulation of the basic theory is generic in the sense that it does not depend on a specific choice of correlation operator. We will, however, elaborate on the intricate relationships between cluster expansions for Jastrow–Feenberg wave functions on the one side, and perturbative expansions within the basis of Jastrow–Feenberg generated states. The first part of this lecture series sets the general scene of perturbation theroy in a non–orthogonal basis, as laid out by Feshbach, Feenberg, Clark, and others. We then turn to the calculation of effective interactions, which will require the same technical tools that were developed for the Fermi-Hypernetted-Chain theory of the ground state. We then look at the interpretation of these effective interactions from various points of view and draw the connections to phenomenological theories like Landau's Fermi liquid theory, or the BCS theory of superconductivity. We also demonstrate that Fermi–sea averages of the CBF effective interaction vanish for optimized correlation functions. Finally, we turn to cases where CBF theory to infinite order is necessary. Employing ideas of the coupled cluster theory, we develop a method for generating CBF perturbative corrections to infinite order by integral equations. Specializing to ring diagrams, we demonstrate that the "chain" diagrams of the FHNC theory are approximations for the ring diagrams of (CBF-)perturbation theory. The generalization of the time–dependent Hartree–Fock theory to correlated states will allow the formulation of a linear response theory for strongly interacting systems or, alternatively, provide the tools for mapping strong, bare interactions onto weak, effective interactions that can be used in phenomenological theories.
The Fermi hypernetted-chain (FHNC) theory is applied to spin-density-wave states combined with a Jastrow-type correlation operator. The commonly used approximation scheme FHNC/n is found to be unsuitable for dealing with this class of correlated wave functions. A new scheme, named FHNC-n, is proposed, and numerically tested for the one-dimensional (1D) Hubbard model and the Gutzwiller correlation operator. The results obtained are in very good agreement with the available variational Monte Carlo calculation. This scheme can be used to study 2D and 3D Hubbard models and can easily be extended to treat more general correlation operators, which include triplet and quartet correlations.
Abstract The main task of microscopic many-body theory is to provide an understanding and an explanation of properties of macroscopic systems from no other information than the properties of the underlying Hamiltonian, the particle statistics, and the macroscopic geometry of the system. Variational wave functions have been a very successful technique for examining the ground state and dynamic properties of dense quantum fluids. Specifically the “optimized (Fermi)-hypernetted chain” ((F)HNC-EL) hierarchy of approximations reproduces, for simple interactions like electrons and quantum fluids, the most basic features of a self-bound many-body system, namely binding, saturation, and spinodal decomposition. The relationships between Green’s functions based perturbation theory and variational wave functions have been clarified in much detail in the past. In the language of Feynman diagrams, a self-consistent summation of ring- and ladder-diagrams is the minimum requirement for a satisfactory microscopic description of these basic features. Realistic nucleon–nucleon interactions pose further problems: The most difficult aspect of the nuclear many-body problem is caused by the form of the microscopic nucleon–nucleon interaction which depends at least on the spin, isospin, the relative orientation and angular momentum of the interacting particles. Simple variational methods as used for electrons and quantum fluids are inadequate. Correlation functions that have the same structure as the interactions lead to so-called “commutator diagrams” that have, so far, been mostly neglected. We have shown in the past that these corrections can be very important if the two-body interactions are very different in different spin- or isospin channels. To deal with the problem of realistic nuclear interactions we have combined techniques of the Jastrow–Feenberg variational method and the local parquet-diagram theory. In the language of diagrammatic perturbation theory, “commutator diagrams” can be identified with non-parquet diagrams. We examine the physical processes described by these terms and include the relevant diagrams in a way that is suggested by the Jastrow–Feenberg approach. We show that the corrections from non-parquet contributions are, at short distances, larger than all other many-body effects. We examine here neutron matter as a prototype of systems with state-dependent interactions. Calculations are carried out for neutrons interacting via the so-called v8v_8v8​ v 8 version of four popular interactions. We determine the structure and effective interactions and apply the method to the calculation of the energetics, structure and dynamic properties such as the single-particle self-energy and the dynamic response functions as well as BCS pairing in both singlet and triplet states. We find that many-body correlations lead to a strong reduction of the spin-orbit interaction, and, therefore, to a suppression of the 3P2^3\textrm{P}_23P2​ 3 P 2 and 3P2^3\textrm{P}_23P2​ 3 P 2 - 3F2^3\textrm{F}_23F2​ 3 F 2 gaps. We also find pairing in 3P0^3\textrm{P}_03P0​ 3 P 0 states; the strength of the pairing gap depends sensitively on the potential model employed.
We study the accuracy of analytical wave-function-based many-body methods derived by energy minimization of a Jastrow-Feenberg ansatz for electrons (the ``Fermi hypernetted chain/Euler Lagrange'' approach). Approximations to avoid the complexity of the fermion problem are chosen to parallel successful boson theories and to be computationally efficient. For the three-dimensional homogeneous electron gas, we calculate the correlation energy, the pair distribution function, and the static structure function in comparison with simulation results. We also present a variant of theory which is interpreted as an approximate, self-consistent sum of ladder and ring diagrams of perturbation theory. The theory performs particularly well in the highly dilute density regime.
The ground-state wave function of an infinite system of fermions is approximated by the state-independent Jastrow ansatz. In order to optimize the pair correlation function, the Euler-Lagrange equations of the variational problem for the energy expectation value are derived. The short- and long-range behaviors of the optimum pair correlation function are discussed. Application of graphical techniques and use of rigorous results on the connection between the slope of the static structure function as $k\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$+ and long-range Jastrow correlations allow one to prove that the optimum pair correlation function behaves like $1+O({r}^{\ensuremath{-}2})$ as $r\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}$. A connection is derived between the weight of the long-range correlations and the Landau parameters. As simple examples the limit of Bose statistics and the electron-gas problem are considered. The consequences of these investigations on numerical calculations and their relation to alternative expansion methods are investigated.