In previous works, we introduced a geometric route to define our Ehrenfest statistical dynamics (ESD) and we proved that, for a simple toy model, the resulting ESD does not preserve purity. We now take a step further: we investigate decoherence and pointer basis in the ESD model by considering some uncertainty in the degrees of freedom of a simple but realistic molecular model, consisting of two classical cores and one quantum electron. The Ehrenfest model is sometimes discarded as a valid approximation to nonadiabatic coupled quantum-classical dynamics because it does not describe the decoherence in the quantum subsystem. However, any rigorous statistical analysis of the Ehrenfest dynamics, such as the described ESD formalism, proves that decoherence exists. In this article, decoherence in ESD is studied by measuring the change in the quantum subsystem purity and by analyzing the appearance of the pointer basis to which the system decoheres, which for our example is composed of the eigenstates of the electronic Hamiltonian.
In previous works, we introduced a geometric route to define our Ehrenfest statistical dynamics (ESD) and we proved that, for a simple toy model, the resulting ESD does not preserve purity. We now take a step further: we investigate decoherence and pointer basis in the ESD model by considering some uncertainty in the degrees of freedom of a simple but realistic molecular model, consisting of two classical cores and one quantum electron. The Ehrenfest model is sometimes discarded as a valid approximation to nonadiabatic coupled quantum-classical dynamics because it does not describe the decoherence in the quantum subsystem. However, any rigorous statistical analysis of the Ehrenfest dynamics, such as the described ESD formalism, proves that decoherence exists. In this article, decoherence in ESD is studied by measuring the change in the quantum subsystem purity and by analyzing the appearance of the pointer basis to which the system decoheres, which for our example is composed of the eigenstates of the electronic Hamiltonian.
We discuss the evolution of purity in mixed quantum/classical approaches to electronic nonadiabatic dynamics in the context of the Ehrenfest model. As it is impossible to exactly determine initial conditions for a realistic system, we choose to work in the statistical Ehrenfest formalism that we introduced in Alonso et al. [J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 44, 396004 (2011)]. From it, we develop a new framework to determine exactly the change in the purity of the quantum subsystem along with the evolution of a statistical Ehrenfest system. In a simple case, we verify how and to which extent Ehrenfest statistical dynamics makes a system with more than one classical trajectory, and an initial quantum pure state become a quantum mixed one. We prove this numerically showing how the evolution of purity depends on time, on the dimension of the quantum state space D, and on the number of classical trajectories N of the initial distribution. The results in this work open new perspectives for studying decoherence with Ehrenfest dynamics.
A hierarchy of measures of decoherence for many-electron systems that is based on the purity and the hierarchy of reduced electronic density matrices is presented. These reduced purities can be used to characterize electronic decoherence in the common case when the many-body electronic density matrix is not known and only reduced information about the electronic subsystem is available. Being defined from reduced electronic quantities, the interpretation of the reduced purities is more intricate than the usual (many-body) purity. This is because the nonidempotency of the r-body reduced electronic density matrix that is the basis of the reduced purity measures can arise due to decoherence or due to electronic correlations. To guide the interpretation, explicit expressions are provided for the one-body and two-body reduced purities for a general electronic state. Using them, the information content and structure of the one-body and two-body reduced purities is established, and limits on the changes that decoherence can induce are elucidated. The practical use of the reduced purities to understand decoherence dynamics in many-electron systems is exemplified through an analysis of the electronic decoherence dynamics in a model molecular system.
Decoherence is the tendency of a time-evolved reduced density matrix for a subsystem to assume a form corresponding to a statistical ensemble of states rather than a coherent combination of pure-state wave functions. When a molecular process involves changes in the electronic state and the coordinates of the nuclei, as in ultraviolet or visible light photochemistry or electronically inelastic collisions, the reduced density matrix of the electronic subsystem suffers decoherence, due to its interaction with the nuclear subsystem. We present the background necessary to conceptualize this decoherence; in particular, we discuss the density matrix description of pure states and mixed states, and we discuss pointer states and decoherence time. We then discuss how decoherence is treated in the coherent switching with decay of mixing algorithm and the trajectory surface hopping method for semiclassical calculations of electronically nonadiabatic processes.
Quantum decoherence is a physical process resulting from a system’s entanglement with an environment. This chapter examines the explanatory wealth of decoherence when brought to bear on foundational issues such as the question of why certain measurement bases seem to be preferred by nature – including the pointer basis of measuring apparatuses – the old familiar measurement problem, and the emergence of classicality. Decoherence satisfactorily explains the behavior of the ammonia molecule. Decoherence introduces no additional nonlinearity but “simply takes real, inevitable, interaction with external degrees of freedom to bear in the Hamiltonian”. The basis-specific nature of decoherence will allow for a satisfying explanation to one of quantum mechanics’ oldest mysteries: that of the pointer basis. The basis-specific nature of decoherence will allow for a satisfying explanation to one of quantum mechanics’ oldest mysteries: that of the pointer basis.
Based on the superposition principle, any two states of a quantum system may be coherently superposed to yield a novel state. Such a simple construction is at the heart of genuinely quantum phenomena such as interference of massive particles or quantum entanglement. Yet, these superpositions are susceptible to environmental influences, eventually leading to a complete disappearance of the system's quantum character. In principle, two distinct mechanisms responsible for this process of decoherence may be identified. In a classical decoherence setting, on the one hand, stochastic fluctuations of classical, ambient fields are the relevant source. This approach leads to a formulation in terms of stochastic Hamiltonians; the dynamics is unitary, yet stochastic. In a quantum decoherence scenario, on the other hand, the system is described in the language of open quantum systems. Here, the environmental degrees of freedom are to be treated quantum mechanically, too. The loss of coherence is then a direct consequence of growing correlations between system and environment. The purpose of the present thesis is to clarify the distinction between classical and quantum decoherence. It is known that there exist decoherence processes that are not reconcilable with the classical approach. We deem it desirable to have a simple, feasible model at hand of which it is known that it cannot be understood in terms of fluctuating fields. Indeed, we find such an example of true quantum decoherence. The calculation of the norm distance to the convex set of classical dynamics allows for a quantitative assessment of the results. In order to incorporate genuine irreversibility, we extend the original toy model by an additional bath. Here, the fragility of the true quantum nature of the dynamics under increasing coupling strength is evident. The geometric character of our findings offers remarkable insights into the geometry of the set of non-classical decoherence maps. We give a very intuitive geometrical measure---a volume---for the quantumness of dynamics. This enables us to identify the decoherence process of maximum quantumness, that is, having maximal distance to the convex set of dynamics consistent with the stochastic, classical approach. In addition, we observe a distinct correlation between the decoherence potential of a given dynamics and its achievable quantumness. In a last step, we study the notion of quantum decoherence in the context of a bipartite system which couples locally to the subsystems' respective environments. A simple argument shows that in the case of a separable environment the resulting dynamics is of classical nature. Based on a realistic experiment, we analyze the impact of entanglement between the local environments on the nature of the dynamics. Interestingly, despite the variety of entangled environmental states scrutinized, no single instance of true quantum decoherence is encountered. In part, the identification of the classical nature relies on numerical schemes. However, for a large class of dynamics, we are able to exclude analytically the true quantum nature.
Despite early developments on the foundations of quantum mechanics concern the wave function, quantum statistics has been developed with the density matrix formalism, leading to very important results in explaining molecular observations. Only recently, several authors argued a new interpretation by focusing on the wave function representing the quantum state of an isolated system, showing how a single wave function can exhibit statistical properties and generate the same results expected in the standard quantum statistical framework. Starting from these results, investigation on the foundations of quantum statistical mechanics has gained recently a renewed interest. As a matter of fact, the possibility of studying single molecule properties as well as the need of a better understanding of the effect of quantum dynamics, in order to develop new nanoscaled materials suitable to quantum computing tasks, have opened new intriguing questions leading to quantum statistical approaches far from being well understood and accepted. In this framework the behaviour of a single realization of quantum systems has gained a central role in the description of molecular systems. Furthermore, in recent years, an increasing number of studies has been presented on quantum dynamics through the numerical solution of the Schrödinger equation for systems of interacting components. These studies demonstrates that Quantum Dynamics Simulations could be a practicable route. In order to study phenomena such as dissipation, relaxation and thermalization, the focus has to be moved from isolated molecules to modular systems made of mutual interacting components, with model Hamiltonians possessing a sufficiently low dimensional representation. An important issue concerns the rules to be employed for the choice of the initial quantum state for the simulation of isolated systems. As long as one considers molecular degrees of freedom interacting with a (model) environment, there are no reasons to select a particular quantum state for the overall system and, therefore, a random choice has to be performed amongst a well defined statistical ensemble of pure states. Furthermore, one would like to operate a choice assuring that the simulation of the system is in a well defined thermal state with given temperature. This necessarily calls for a statistical description like for classical systems. A useful parametrization of the wave function will be presented in order to highlight the most appropriate variable for the statistical analysis. In particular some of them, called phases, retain all the dynamical information whereas the others, called populations, are the constants of motion. The latter, in particular are very important because they describe the equilibrium properties strictly related to the thermodynamic description. Since the dynamics of wave function does not supply any information about populations, the definition of a probability distribution on these variables is required. Different probability distributions on populations have been proposed, only on the bases of reasonable assumptions and they validation has been performed only with a posteriori considerations. In particular Fresch and Moro have demonstrated how the agreement with thermodynamics can be employed to discriminate different probability distributions on pure states. This had led the uniform ensembles to be, up to now, the most self-consistent models for quantum pure states. However, in this thesis I will highlight a drawback of the uniform distribution ensemble that can be described as follow: if we bring into contact two systems, even through a perturbative interaction, we are not able to describe the equilibrium properties after the interaction within the uniform distribution statistics, since the uniform character is lost. It represents a severe shortcoming of the statistical ensemble from a methodological point of view, since closed systems can be always considered as the result of interaction among previously isolated systems. On the other hand this drawback introduces a further requirement of a different nature that can be used for the definition of a new statistical ensemble. In this work I intend to find and characterize a statistical ensemble for populations that overcomes the drawbacks of the uniform distribution of pure states. The invariance of the thermal state in the coupling of identical systems will be used as a guideline in the definition af a new probability distribution on populations. Such an ensemble for pure states, called Thermalization Resilient Ensemble, provides a convenient framework for treating the interactions between quantum systems, as long as the structure of the statistical distribution is preserved and the identification of thermodynamic properties is assured. In perspective it should be the privileged statistical ensemble to implement Quantum Dynamics Simulations. Once the average properties of the Thermalization Resilient Ensemble have been introduced, I will obtain a probability distribution on pure states with the use of a geometrical analysis on the Hilbert space. The surface elements of an ellipsoidal manifold will be related to the probability density on populations. As a matter of fact the explicit form of the probability distribution is a prerequisite in order to perform Quantum Dynamical Simulations. However the results obtained through the geometrical analysis cannot be easily extended to systems with unbounded energy spectrum and an alternative strategy has been developed. A scaling algorithm on the basis of the uniform statistical ensemble will be described and this allows a well defined sampling of a probability distribution with desired averages. In this framework I demonstrate the emergence of thermodynamic behavior in the limit of macroscopic systems. In the last part of the thesis I consider the dynamical features of the thermalization experiment. Two identical systems, initially at different temperature, will be brought in interaction and the analysis of the final equilibrium state will be performed for two different generic forms of the interaction Hamiltonian, highlighting how the statistical approach can be very useful in the definition of the equilibrium in complex quantum systems.