Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1801.04362 · Physical Review A

Experimental investigation of measurement-induced disturbance and time symmetry in quantum physics

Davor Curic, M. C. Richardson, Guillaume Thekkadath, Jefferson Flórez, Lambert Giner, Jeff S. Lundeen

Published Apr 27, 2018• 14 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Unlike regular time evolution governed by the Schr\"odinger equation, standard quantum measurement appears to violate time-reversal symmetry. Measurement creates random disturbances (e.g., collapse) that prevent back-tracing the quantum state of the system. The effect of these disturbances is explicit in the results of subsequent measurements. In this way, the joint result of sequences of measurements depends on the order in time in which those measurements are performed. One might expect that if the disturbance could be eliminated this time-ordering dependence would vanish. Following a recent theoretical proposal [Bednorz, Franke, and Belzig, New J. Phys. 15, 023043 (2013)], we experimentally investigate this dependence for a kind of measurement that creates an arbitrarily small disturbance: weak measurement. We perform various sequences of a set of polarization weak measurements on photons. We experimentally demonstrate that, although the weak measurements are minimally disturbing, their time ordering affects the outcome of the measurement sequence for quantum systems.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.97.042128

Related papers

Noninvasiveness and time symmetry of weak measurements

Adam Bednorz, Kurt Franke, Wolfgang Belzig

Measurements in classical and quantum physics are described in fundamentally different ways. Nevertheless, one can formally define similar measurement procedures with respect to the disturbance they cause. Obviously, strong measurements, both classical and quantum, are invasive—they disturb the measured system. We show that it is possible to define general weak measurements, which are noninvasive: the disturbance becomes negligible as the measurement strength goes to zero. Classical intuition suggests that noninvasive measurements should be time symmetric (if the system dynamics is reversible) and we confirm that correlations are time-reversal symmetric in the classical case. However, quantum weak measurements—defined analogously to their classical counterparts—can be noninvasive but not time symmetric. We present a simple example of measurements on a two-level system which violates time symmetry and propose an experiment with quantum dots to measure the time-symmetry violation in a third-order current correlation function.

arXiv:1108.1305•New Journal of Physics•Feb 27, 2013•33 citations

Multitime measurements in quantum mechanics

M. S. Wang

The one-time and two-time measurements are studied by employing the idea of Aharonov et al. that the strength of a measurement depends on the state of the measuring device in the context of von Neumann measurement theory. A measurement is classified as either a strong or a weak measurement depending on whether the interaction between the system and the measuring device is infinitely large or negligibly small. A single strong measurement yields one of the eigenvalues of the operator while a single weak measurement, in addition to the eigenvalues, has infinite other possible outcomes. Nevertheless, the expectation values of the strong and the weak one-time measurements are the same. However, the expectation values of the two-time measurements depend on the strength of the first measurement. For the strong case the result is consistent with the conventional result without having to introduce the state collapsing. For the weak case the result is the real part of the expectation value of the time-ordered two-time operator. The fact that this expectation value cannot be factorized indicates that the entanglement between the system and the measuring device introduced by a weak measurement cannot be neglected.

Physical Review A•Jan 4, 2002•5 citations

Violation of Heisenberg’s Measurement-Disturbance Relationship by Weak Measurements

Lee A. Rozema, Ardavan Darabi, Dylan H. Mahler +3 more

While there is a rigorously proven relationship about uncertainties intrinsic to any quantum system, often referred to as "Heisenberg's uncertainty principle," Heisenberg originally formulated his ideas in terms of a relationship between the precision of a measurement and the disturbance it must create. Although this latter relationship is not rigorously proven, it is commonly believed (and taught) as an aspect of the broader uncertainty principle. Here, we experimentally observe a violation of Heisenberg's "measurement-disturbance relationship", using weak measurements to characterize a quantum system before and after it interacts with a measurement apparatus. Our experiment implements a 2010 proposal of Lund and Wiseman to confirm a revised measurement-disturbance relationship derived by Ozawa in 2003. Its results have broad implications for the foundations of quantum mechanics and for practical issues in quantum measurement.

arXiv:1208.0034•Physical Review Letters•Sep 6, 2012•310 citations

Probing the Limits of Time-Symmetry and the Projection Postulate in Sequential Quantum Measurements

Piechocinska, Barbara

This paper proposes two precise, platform-independent experiments that aim to test the foundational assumptions of quantum mechanics: namely, whether time-reversal symmetry holds exactly at the quantum level, and whether quantum measurements truly erase all information about unrealized possibilities. While inspired by larger theoretical ideas of generative wholeness, the experiments are intentionally designed in a model-agnostic way and can be implemented with current technologies such as trapped ions, superconducting qubits, or advanced photonic systems. The first experiment compares the statistical outcomes of a quantum system measured in one order with those when the same measurements are applied in reverse order. Under standard theory, no irreducible asymmetry should remain after all known disturbances are controlled. Detecting a residual asymmetry would signal a fundamental microscopic arrow of time. The second experiment examines whether a quantum system retains an intrinsic “memory” of measurements that were performed but whose results were ignored or not recorded. By comparing two sequences, one where an intermediate measurement is omitted entirely and another where it is performed but discarded, the design tests for subtle deviations from the standard projection rule. A confirmed deviation would indicate non-Markovian, intrinsic memory effects in quantum measurement itself. Both proposals are framed as “null tests”: if the orthodox theory is complete, the results should vanish within error bars. Any non-zero finding would open a doorway to new physics, probing the nature of time, measurement, and possibility in the quantum domain. Keywords: time asymmetry, projection postulate, quantum measurement, sequential measurements, intrinsic memory, non-Markovianity, trapped ions, superconducting qubits, photonics, foundational tests of quantum mechanics.

•Nov 14, 2025•0 citations

Determining complementary properties using weak-measurement: uncertainty, predictability, and disturbance

Guillaume Thekkadath, Felix Hufnagel, Jeff S. Lundeen

It is often said that measuring a system's position must disturb the complementary property, momentum, by some minimum amount due to the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. Using a 'weak-measurement', this disturbance can be reduced. One might expect this comes at the cost of also reducing the measurement's precision. However, it was recently demonstrated that a sequence consisting of a weak position measurement followed by a regular momentum measurement can probe a quantum system at a single point, with zero width, in position-momentum space. Here, we study this 'joint weak-measurement' and reconcile its compatibility with the uncertainty principle. While a single trial probes the system with a resolution that can saturate Heisenberg's limit, we show that averaging over many trials can be used to surpass this limit. The weak-measurement does not trade away precision, but rather another type of uncertainty called 'predictability' which quantifies the certainty of retrodicting the measurement's outcome.

arXiv:1809.05984•New Journal of Physics•Oct 31, 2018•12 citations

Weak measurements: From measuring incompatible observables and testing quantum contextuality to protective measurements

Fabrizio Piacentini, Alessio Avella, Rudi Lussana +9 more

Summary form only given. Measurements are the very basis of Physics, especially in Quantum Mechanics, where they assume even a more fundamental role because of wave function collapse after a “strong” (projective) measurement. Furthermore, measuring a quantum-mechanical observable completely erases the information on its conjugate one (e.g. measurement of position erases information on momentum, and vice-versa). Nevertheless, in Quantum Mechanics other kinds of measurement are possible. For example, wave function collapse can be overcome through Weak Measurements, i.e. measurements performed with an interaction sufficiently weak not to collapse the original state, featuring several interesting properties. An example of these are weak values [1-3], realised for the first time in [4-6], that have been used for addressing fundamental questions [7-12] as Contextuality and are also a tool for Quantum Metrology [13-19]. One of the most intriguing properties of Weak Measurements is that, since they are not affected by wave function collapse, they can allow gathering simultaneous information on non-commuting observables [20], impossible with the standard (projective) measurement protocols. A second example is offered by Protective Measurements [21], a new technique able to extract information on the expectation value of an observable even measuring a single particle. In this talk, after a general introduction to WMs, we present the first realisation of sequential weak value measurements [22], i.e. a joint measurement of the weak value of (incompatible) polarizations on a single photon. Then, we present an experiment addressed to explore the connection between anomalous weak values and Contextuality [23], showing a clear violation of the inequality proposed in [12] while satisfying all the additional theoretical requests, unequivocally demonstrating the contextual nature of weak values. Finally, we present and discuss the first implementation of Protective Measurements, showing unprecedented measurement capability and demonstrating how the expectation value of an observable can be obtained with a single measurement on a single particle.

Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics Europe & European Quantum Electronics Conference (CLEO/Europe-EQEC)•Jun 1, 2017•0 citations
Unlike regular time evolution governed by the Schr"odinger equation, standard quantum measurement appears to violate time-reversal symmetry. Measurement creates random disturbances (e.g., collapse) that prevent back-tracing the quantum state of the system. The effect of these disturbances is explicit in the results of subsequent measurements. In this way, the joint result of sequences of measurements depends on the order in time in which those measurements are performed. One might expect that if the disturbance could be eliminated this time-ordering dependence would vanish. Following a recent theoretical proposal [Bednorz, Franke, and Belzig, New J. Phys. 15, 023043 (2013)], we experimentally investigate this dependence for a kind of measurement that creates an arbitrarily small disturbance: weak measurement. We perform various sequences of a set of polarization weak measurements on photons. We experimentally demonstrate that, although the weak measurements are minimally disturbing, their time ordering affects the outcome of the measurement sequence for quantum systems.
Measurements in classical and quantum physics are described in fundamentally different ways. Nevertheless, one can formally define similar measurement procedures with respect to the disturbance they cause. Obviously, strong measurements, both classical and quantum, are invasive—they disturb the measured system. We show that it is possible to define general weak measurements, which are noninvasive: the disturbance becomes negligible as the measurement strength goes to zero. Classical intuition suggests that noninvasive measurements should be time symmetric (if the system dynamics is reversible) and we confirm that correlations are time-reversal symmetric in the classical case. However, quantum weak measurements—defined analogously to their classical counterparts—can be noninvasive but not time symmetric. We present a simple example of measurements on a two-level system which violates time symmetry and propose an experiment with quantum dots to measure the time-symmetry violation in a third-order current correlation function.
The one-time and two-time measurements are studied by employing the idea of Aharonov et al. that the strength of a measurement depends on the state of the measuring device in the context of von Neumann measurement theory. A measurement is classified as either a strong or a weak measurement depending on whether the interaction between the system and the measuring device is infinitely large or negligibly small. A single strong measurement yields one of the eigenvalues of the operator while a single weak measurement, in addition to the eigenvalues, has infinite other possible outcomes. Nevertheless, the expectation values of the strong and the weak one-time measurements are the same. However, the expectation values of the two-time measurements depend on the strength of the first measurement. For the strong case the result is consistent with the conventional result without having to introduce the state collapsing. For the weak case the result is the real part of the expectation value of the time-ordered two-time operator. The fact that this expectation value cannot be factorized indicates that the entanglement between the system and the measuring device introduced by a weak measurement cannot be neglected.
While there is a rigorously proven relationship about uncertainties intrinsic to any quantum system, often referred to as "Heisenberg's uncertainty principle," Heisenberg originally formulated his ideas in terms of a relationship between the precision of a measurement and the disturbance it must create. Although this latter relationship is not rigorously proven, it is commonly believed (and taught) as an aspect of the broader uncertainty principle. Here, we experimentally observe a violation of Heisenberg's "measurement-disturbance relationship", using weak measurements to characterize a quantum system before and after it interacts with a measurement apparatus. Our experiment implements a 2010 proposal of Lund and Wiseman to confirm a revised measurement-disturbance relationship derived by Ozawa in 2003. Its results have broad implications for the foundations of quantum mechanics and for practical issues in quantum measurement.
This paper proposes two precise, platform-independent experiments that aim to test the foundational assumptions of quantum mechanics: namely, whether time-reversal symmetry holds exactly at the quantum level, and whether quantum measurements truly erase all information about unrealized possibilities. While inspired by larger theoretical ideas of generative wholeness, the experiments are intentionally designed in a model-agnostic way and can be implemented with current technologies such as trapped ions, superconducting qubits, or advanced photonic systems. The first experiment compares the statistical outcomes of a quantum system measured in one order with those when the same measurements are applied in reverse order. Under standard theory, no irreducible asymmetry should remain after all known disturbances are controlled. Detecting a residual asymmetry would signal a fundamental microscopic arrow of time. The second experiment examines whether a quantum system retains an intrinsic “memory” of measurements that were performed but whose results were ignored or not recorded. By comparing two sequences, one where an intermediate measurement is omitted entirely and another where it is performed but discarded, the design tests for subtle deviations from the standard projection rule. A confirmed deviation would indicate non-Markovian, intrinsic memory effects in quantum measurement itself. Both proposals are framed as “null tests”: if the orthodox theory is complete, the results should vanish within error bars. Any non-zero finding would open a doorway to new physics, probing the nature of time, measurement, and possibility in the quantum domain. Keywords: time asymmetry, projection postulate, quantum measurement, sequential measurements, intrinsic memory, non-Markovianity, trapped ions, superconducting qubits, photonics, foundational tests of quantum mechanics.
It is often said that measuring a system's position must disturb the complementary property, momentum, by some minimum amount due to the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. Using a 'weak-measurement', this disturbance can be reduced. One might expect this comes at the cost of also reducing the measurement's precision. However, it was recently demonstrated that a sequence consisting of a weak position measurement followed by a regular momentum measurement can probe a quantum system at a single point, with zero width, in position-momentum space. Here, we study this 'joint weak-measurement' and reconcile its compatibility with the uncertainty principle. While a single trial probes the system with a resolution that can saturate Heisenberg's limit, we show that averaging over many trials can be used to surpass this limit. The weak-measurement does not trade away precision, but rather another type of uncertainty called 'predictability' which quantifies the certainty of retrodicting the measurement's outcome.
Summary form only given. Measurements are the very basis of Physics, especially in Quantum Mechanics, where they assume even a more fundamental role because of wave function collapse after a “strong” (projective) measurement. Furthermore, measuring a quantum-mechanical observable completely erases the information on its conjugate one (e.g. measurement of position erases information on momentum, and vice-versa). Nevertheless, in Quantum Mechanics other kinds of measurement are possible. For example, wave function collapse can be overcome through Weak Measurements, i.e. measurements performed with an interaction sufficiently weak not to collapse the original state, featuring several interesting properties. An example of these are weak values [1-3], realised for the first time in [4-6], that have been used for addressing fundamental questions [7-12] as Contextuality and are also a tool for Quantum Metrology [13-19]. One of the most intriguing properties of Weak Measurements is that, since they are not affected by wave function collapse, they can allow gathering simultaneous information on non-commuting observables [20], impossible with the standard (projective) measurement protocols. A second example is offered by Protective Measurements [21], a new technique able to extract information on the expectation value of an observable even measuring a single particle. In this talk, after a general introduction to WMs, we present the first realisation of sequential weak value measurements [22], i.e. a joint measurement of the weak value of (incompatible) polarizations on a single photon. Then, we present an experiment addressed to explore the connection between anomalous weak values and Contextuality [23], showing a clear violation of the inequality proposed in [12] while satisfying all the additional theoretical requests, unequivocally demonstrating the contextual nature of weak values. Finally, we present and discuss the first implementation of Protective Measurements, showing unprecedented measurement capability and demonstrating how the expectation value of an observable can be obtained with a single measurement on a single particle.