We find the spectrum in maximal lexicographic order for quantum states ρ A B ∈ H A ⊗ H B \rho _{AB}\in \mathcal {H}_A\otimes \mathcal {H}_B with margins ρ A = 1 n I n \rho _A=\frac {1}{n}I_n and ρ B = 1 m I m \rho _B=\frac {1}{m}I_m and discuss the construction of ρ A B \rho _{AB} . By nonzero rectangular Kronecker coefficients, we give counterexamples for Klyachko’s conjecture which says that a quantum state with maximal lexicographical spectrum has minimal rank among all states with given margins. Moreover, we show that quantum states with the maximal lexicographical spectrum are extreme points.
We find the spectrum in maximal lexicographic order for quantum states ρ A B ∈ H A ⊗ H B \rho _{AB}\in \mathcal {H}_A\otimes \mathcal {H}_B with margins ρ A = 1 n I n \rho _A=\frac {1}{n}I_n and ρ B = 1 m I m \rho _B=\frac {1}{m}I_m and discuss the construction of ρ A B \rho _{AB} . By nonzero rectangular Kronecker coefficients, we give counterexamples for Klyachko’s conjecture which says that a quantum state with maximal lexicographical spectrum has minimal rank among all states with given margins. Moreover, we show that quantum states with the maximal lexicographical spectrum are extreme points.
Extremal Marginal States of Maximal Rank in (d,d+m)
We study the extreme points of the convex set C(ρ1,ρ2) of bipartite quantum states with fixed marginals ρ1 and ρ2. We construct extreme points in (d,d+m) dimension, of rank d+m, matching the highest possible value, for all d≥3, m>2d2−2d−2 (when d=2, m≥1). This proves the existence of extremal states with relatively large rank and also covers all the known examples. We further show that, in order to analyze the extreme points of C(ρ1,ρ2), it is sufficient to study the special case C(D1,D2), where the marginals are diagonal. Additionally, we observe that it is sufficient to consider d1≤d2. Thus, our results show that apart from possibly a few finite cases, for each d1, the maximal rank is achieved almost all times.
The existence of a maximally entangled pure state is a cornerstone result of entanglement theory that has paramount consequences in quantum information theory. A natural generalization of this property is to consider whether a notion of maximal entanglement is possible among all states with the same spectrum (where the aforementioned case of pure states corresponds to the particular choice in which the spectrum is a delta distribution, i.e., rank-1 states). Despite positive evidence in the past that such a notion might exist at least in the case of two-qubit states, it was recently shown in [Phys. Rev. Lett. 133, 050202 (2024)] that the answer to the above question is negative. This reference proved this for particular choices of the spectrum in the case of rank-2 two-qubit density matrices. While this settles the problem in general, it still leaves open whether there are other choices of the spectrum outside the case of pure states where a maximally entangled state for a fixed spectrum might exist. In this work we extend this impossibility result to all rank-2 and rank-3 two-qubit states as well as for a large class of eigenvalue distributions in the case where the rank equals four.
We study the convex set C(ρ1,ρ2) of all bipartite quantum states with fixed marginal states ρ1 and ρ2. The extremal states in this set have recently been characterized by Parthasarathy [Ann. Henri Poincaré (to appear), quant-ph/0307182]. Here we present an alternative necessary and sufficient condition for a state in C(ρ1,ρ2) to be extremal. Our approach is based on a canonical duality between bipartite states and a certain class of completely positive maps and has the advantage that it is easier to check and to construct explicit examples of extremal states. In dimension 2×2 we give a simple new proof for the fact that all extremal states in C(121,121) are precisely the projectors onto maximally entangled wave functions. We also prove that in higher dimension this does not hold and construct an explicit example of an extremal state in C(131,131) that is not maximally entangled. Generalizations of this result to higher dimensions are also discussed.
For m⊗n systems with n≥m≥3, we determine the exact maximum purity of absolutely positive partial transpose (APPT) states and the unique maximizing ordered spectrum when n≥2m2−4 for even m or n≥2m2−m−4 for odd m. Under these dimension assumptions, absolutely separable states have the same maximum purity, attained at the same unique ordered spectrum. The proof uses an outer polytope defined by two linear head--tail inequalities, each comparing a sum of the largest eigenvalues with a sum of the smallest.
Under explicit multiplicity assumptions, we derive an exact matrix criterion for APPT membership of full-rank spectra with three distinct eigenvalues. For every m≥10, this criterion gives explicit APPT boundary spectra at n=4m−2 and n=4m that disprove both cases of the maximum purity conjecture of Ahiable, Kothakonda, and Winter.
We also determine the exact completely absolutely separable (CAS) purity maximum and its unique maximizing ordered spectrum in every bipartite dimension. We prove that the inner APPT polytope consists entirely of absolutely separable spectra. The resulting linear sufficient condition for absolute separability strictly improves the reduction-map and eigenvalue-ratio tests. Finally, we compute the exact relative volumes of the CAS set and an outer polytope defined by a single head--tail inequality. Under the uniform measure on spectra, the CAS, absolutely separable, and APPT volumes have the same asymptotic order ne−κmn for every fixed m≥2, with explicit κm>0.
Entanglement is a resource under local operations assisted by classical communication (LOCC). Given a set of states S, if there is one state in S that can be transformed by LOCC into all other states in S, then this state is maximally entangled in S. It is a well-known result that the d-dimensional Bell state is the maximally entangled state in the set of all bipartite states of local dimension d. Since in practical applications noise renders every state mixed, it is interesting to study whether sets of mixed states of relevance enable the notion of a maximally entangled state. A natural choice is the set of all states with the same spectrum. In fact, for any given spectrum distribution on two-qubit states, previous work has shown that several entanglement measures are all maximized by one particular state in this set. This has led us to consider the possibility that this family of states could be the maximally entangled states in the set of all states with the same spectrum, which should then maximize all entanglement measures. In this work, I answer this question in the negative: There are no maximally entangled states for a fixed spectrum in general, i.e., for every possible choice of the spectrum. In order to do so, I consider the case of rank-2 states and show that for particular values of the eigenvalues there exists no state that can be transformed to all other isospectral states not only under LOCC but also under the larger class of nonentangling operations. This in particular implies that in these cases the state that maximizes a given entanglement measure among all states with the same spectrum depends on the choice of entanglement measure; i.e., it cannot be that the aforementioned family of states maximizes all entanglement measures.