Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1712.07259 · Physical Review A

Optical nonclassicality test based on third-order intensity correlations

L. Rigovacca, W. Steven Kolthammer, C. Di Franco, M. S. Kim

Published Mar 9, 2018• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We develop a nonclassicality criterion for the interference of three delayed, but otherwise identical, light fields in a three-mode Bell interferometer. We do so by comparing the prediction of quantum mechanics with those of a classical framework in which independent sources emit electric fields with random phases. In particular, we evaluate third-order correlations among output intensities as a function of the delays, and show how the presence of a correlation revival for small delays cannot be explained by the classical model of light. The observation of a revival is thus a nonclassicality signature, which can be achieved only by sources with a photon-number statistics that is highly sub-Poissonian. Our analysis provides strong evidence for the nonclassicality of the experiment discussed by Menssen et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 118, 153603 (2017)], and shows how a collective ``triad'' phase affects the interference of any three or more light fields, irrespective of their quantum or classical character.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.97.033809

Related papers

Nonclassicality Criteria in Multiport Interferometry

L. Rigovacca, Carlo D. Franco, B. J. Metcalf +2 more

Interference lies at the heart of the behavior of classical and quantum light. It is thus crucial to understand the boundaries between which interference patterns can be explained by a classical electromagnetic description of light and which, on the other hand, can only be understood with a proper quantum mechanical approach. While the case of two-mode interference has received a lot of attention, the multimode case has not yet been fully explored. Here we study a general scenario of intensity interferometry: we derive a bound on the average correlations between pairs of output intensities for the classical wavelike model of light, and we show how it can be violated in a quantum framework. As a consequence, this violation acts as a nonclassicality witness, able to detect the presence of sources with sub-Poissonian photon-number statistics. We also develop a criterion that can certify the impossibility of dividing a given interferometer into two independent subblocks.

arXiv:1604.07588•Physical Review Letters•Nov 16, 2016•23 citations

Enhanced Nonclassical Third‐Order Spatial Intensity Correlations in Three‐Beam Interferences<

Th. Richter

Abstract The joint probability of detecting simultaneously three photons at two and three points in the superposition field of three independent plane waves with the same frequency but random phases is calculated and compared with the results of a classical wave theory. Significant differences occur for sufficiently weak fields. We find that the differences between the quantum mechanical and classical predictions concerning the third order intensity correlation functions are more pronounced in a three‐beam than in a two‐beam interference experiment.

Annalen der Physik•Jan 1, 1991•0 citations

Multi-Photon Interferences of Independent Light Sources

Steffen Oppel

In this thesis we discuss an extension of the historical Hanbury Brown and Twiss experiment and investigate spatial intensity correlations of higher-orders in the radiation field of statistically independent light sources. The light sources can be non-classical like single-photon emitters or classical, obeying thermal or coherent statistics. Although the light sources are assumed to emit the photons in an incoherent manner, we find spatial photon correlations in the far field which can be explained by the quantum mechanical concept of multi-photon interferences. We demonstrate that spatial correlation measurements between indistinguishable photons based on linear optical detection techniques can be used to overcome the resolution limit of classical optics (Abbe/Rayleigh limit) and also to manipulate the spatial radiation characteristic of the light sources. Both remarkable properties of higher-order intensity correlations have been experimentally verified using statistically independent pseudothermal light sources. Due to the fact that the reported correlation measurements require neither special quantum tailoring of light nor N-photon absorbing media, they are of particular interest for the field of quantum imaging and quantum information processing. The thesis is divided into three main parts: In the first part (Chapter 2 and 3) we introduce a quantum path formalism which allows to describe multi-photon interferences arising in both classical and nonclassical light fields. This quantum path approach explains the origin of the underlying interference mechanism of the higher-order spatial intensity correlation functions in a transparent and simple manner. Moreover, it enables us to compare the multi-photon interferences obtained by nonclassical single-photon emitters with those generated by classical light sources. In the course of this discussion it appears that Dirac's famous statement “Each photon interferes only with itself. Interference between two different photons never occurs.” should better read “A multi-photon state of independent photons only interferes with itself. Interference between different multi-photon states never occurs.” This general statement summarizes the physics behind all multi-photon interference phenomena investigated in this thesis. In the second part of the thesis (Chapter 4) we investigate particular multi-photon interference measurements of independent light sources in the context of quantum imaging. We demonstrate that the Nth-order spatial intensity correlation functions display at specific ‘magic’ detector positions the ability to filter sub-wavelength information out of the light fields arising from N incoherently radiating light sources. These multi-photon interference patterns achieve a higher resolution for N>2 than the classical Abbe/Rayleigh limit for imaging the light source. In case of N single-photon emitters we theoretically show that the super-resolving interference patterns obtained for the ‘magic’ detector positions are identical to the ones generated by NOON states with N-1 photons. Quite unexpected, the same is true for N thermal light sources, except for a reduced visibility. Experimental results with up to eight independent thermal light sources confirm this approach to improve the spatial resolution in imaging. In the last part of this thesis (Chapter 5) we finally demonstrate that multi-photon detections can lead to a strong angular focussing of incoherent photons emitted again by either uncorrelated single-photon sources or statistically independent classical light sources. For this effect the sources can be far away from each other and do not interact. The mth-order intensity correlation measurement causes source correlations which produce a heralded peaked emission pattern for the initially uncorrelated light sources. In particular, we show that if m-1 photons have been detected in a particular direction, the conditional probability to detect the mth photon in the same direction can be as high as 100 %. Owing to the great flexibility of detector positions for the correlation measurement, a wide variety of additional detection schemes exists which produces similar directional photon emission patterns. This theoretically predicted measurement-induced focussing was experimentally confirmed with up to eight pseudothermal light sources for three particular detection schemes.

•Jan 1, 2012•0 citations

Classical visibility limit for three-photon interference

I. N. Agafonov, T. Sh. Iskhakov, Alexander N. Penin +1 more

It is shown theoretically and experimentally that the third-order interference of intensities, which is studied in many works performed in the last decade and is usually attributed to three-photon entanglement, can also be observed for classical light with a high visibility up to 81.8%. The calculations show that classical sources ensure an even higher visibility of the interference pattern up to 94.4% for fourth order intensity interference. Thus, a large visibility of the interference pattern of the third and higher orders cannot be considered an attribute of the nonclassical character of the effect.

Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics Letters•Jun 1, 2007•4 citations

Coherence Properties of Optical Fields II Study of Experiments Described by Fourth-Order Coherence Functions

Etienne Boileau, B. Picinbono

The higher-order coherence functions of optical fields involving phase fluctuations have not yet been studied extensively. We discuss here an experiment which can in principle yield the fourth-order coherence function. This experiment is a study of the correlation function of the irradiance fluctuations obtained in some interference experiments. Two kinds of delay are then used: optical delays in the interferometer and electrical delays with suitable variations in the correlator.The results of the experiment are calculated theoretically with a particular statistical model of laser light. The possibility of using a spectrum analyzer instead of a correlator is discussed.

Journal of the Optical Society of America•Sep 1, 1968•3 citations

Experimental characterization of multi-photon entanglement with intensity correlation functions

I. N. Agafonov, Maria V. Chekhova, T. Sh. Iskhakov

We consider possible ways to recognize multi-photon entangled states in experiment. A commonly used technique is to measure higher-order multi-photon correlation functions and their dependence on certain phase delays (multi-photon interference). Theoretically and experimentally, we show that multi-photon interference can have very high visibility for classical sources: up to 81.8% in the three-photon case and up to 94.4% in the four-photon one. Therefore, the visibility of multi-photon interference should not be used as a criterion of multi-photon entangled states generation. Instead, we suggest to characterize multi-photon entanglement by the photon-number dependence of the normalized correlation functions.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Jun 15, 2007•0 citations
We develop a nonclassicality criterion for the interference of three delayed, but otherwise identical, light fields in a three-mode Bell interferometer. We do so by comparing the prediction of quantum mechanics with those of a classical framework in which independent sources emit electric fields with random phases. In particular, we evaluate third-order correlations among output intensities as a function of the delays, and show how the presence of a correlation revival for small delays cannot be explained by the classical model of light. The observation of a revival is thus a nonclassicality signature, which can be achieved only by sources with a photon-number statistics that is highly sub-Poissonian. Our analysis provides strong evidence for the nonclassicality of the experiment discussed by Menssen et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 118, 153603 (2017)], and shows how a collective ``triad'' phase affects the interference of any three or more light fields, irrespective of their quantum or classical character.
Interference lies at the heart of the behavior of classical and quantum light. It is thus crucial to understand the boundaries between which interference patterns can be explained by a classical electromagnetic description of light and which, on the other hand, can only be understood with a proper quantum mechanical approach. While the case of two-mode interference has received a lot of attention, the multimode case has not yet been fully explored. Here we study a general scenario of intensity interferometry: we derive a bound on the average correlations between pairs of output intensities for the classical wavelike model of light, and we show how it can be violated in a quantum framework. As a consequence, this violation acts as a nonclassicality witness, able to detect the presence of sources with sub-Poissonian photon-number statistics. We also develop a criterion that can certify the impossibility of dividing a given interferometer into two independent subblocks.
Abstract The joint probability of detecting simultaneously three photons at two and three points in the superposition field of three independent plane waves with the same frequency but random phases is calculated and compared with the results of a classical wave theory. Significant differences occur for sufficiently weak fields. We find that the differences between the quantum mechanical and classical predictions concerning the third order intensity correlation functions are more pronounced in a three‐beam than in a two‐beam interference experiment.
In this thesis we discuss an extension of the historical Hanbury Brown and Twiss experiment and investigate spatial intensity correlations of higher-orders in the radiation field of statistically independent light sources. The light sources can be non-classical like single-photon emitters or classical, obeying thermal or coherent statistics. Although the light sources are assumed to emit the photons in an incoherent manner, we find spatial photon correlations in the far field which can be explained by the quantum mechanical concept of multi-photon interferences. We demonstrate that spatial correlation measurements between indistinguishable photons based on linear optical detection techniques can be used to overcome the resolution limit of classical optics (Abbe/Rayleigh limit) and also to manipulate the spatial radiation characteristic of the light sources. Both remarkable properties of higher-order intensity correlations have been experimentally verified using statistically independent pseudothermal light sources. Due to the fact that the reported correlation measurements require neither special quantum tailoring of light nor N-photon absorbing media, they are of particular interest for the field of quantum imaging and quantum information processing. The thesis is divided into three main parts: In the first part (Chapter 2 and 3) we introduce a quantum path formalism which allows to describe multi-photon interferences arising in both classical and nonclassical light fields. This quantum path approach explains the origin of the underlying interference mechanism of the higher-order spatial intensity correlation functions in a transparent and simple manner. Moreover, it enables us to compare the multi-photon interferences obtained by nonclassical single-photon emitters with those generated by classical light sources. In the course of this discussion it appears that Dirac's famous statement “Each photon interferes only with itself. Interference between two different photons never occurs.” should better read “A multi-photon state of independent photons only interferes with itself. Interference between different multi-photon states never occurs.” This general statement summarizes the physics behind all multi-photon interference phenomena investigated in this thesis. In the second part of the thesis (Chapter 4) we investigate particular multi-photon interference measurements of independent light sources in the context of quantum imaging. We demonstrate that the Nth-order spatial intensity correlation functions display at specific ‘magic’ detector positions the ability to filter sub-wavelength information out of the light fields arising from N incoherently radiating light sources. These multi-photon interference patterns achieve a higher resolution for N>2 than the classical Abbe/Rayleigh limit for imaging the light source. In case of N single-photon emitters we theoretically show that the super-resolving interference patterns obtained for the ‘magic’ detector positions are identical to the ones generated by NOON states with N-1 photons. Quite unexpected, the same is true for N thermal light sources, except for a reduced visibility. Experimental results with up to eight independent thermal light sources confirm this approach to improve the spatial resolution in imaging. In the last part of this thesis (Chapter 5) we finally demonstrate that multi-photon detections can lead to a strong angular focussing of incoherent photons emitted again by either uncorrelated single-photon sources or statistically independent classical light sources. For this effect the sources can be far away from each other and do not interact. The mth-order intensity correlation measurement causes source correlations which produce a heralded peaked emission pattern for the initially uncorrelated light sources. In particular, we show that if m-1 photons have been detected in a particular direction, the conditional probability to detect the mth photon in the same direction can be as high as 100 %. Owing to the great flexibility of detector positions for the correlation measurement, a wide variety of additional detection schemes exists which produces similar directional photon emission patterns. This theoretically predicted measurement-induced focussing was experimentally confirmed with up to eight pseudothermal light sources for three particular detection schemes.
It is shown theoretically and experimentally that the third-order interference of intensities, which is studied in many works performed in the last decade and is usually attributed to three-photon entanglement, can also be observed for classical light with a high visibility up to 81.8%. The calculations show that classical sources ensure an even higher visibility of the interference pattern up to 94.4% for fourth order intensity interference. Thus, a large visibility of the interference pattern of the third and higher orders cannot be considered an attribute of the nonclassical character of the effect.
The higher-order coherence functions of optical fields involving phase fluctuations have not yet been studied extensively. We discuss here an experiment which can in principle yield the fourth-order coherence function. This experiment is a study of the correlation function of the irradiance fluctuations obtained in some interference experiments. Two kinds of delay are then used: optical delays in the interferometer and electrical delays with suitable variations in the correlator.The results of the experiment are calculated theoretically with a particular statistical model of laser light. The possibility of using a spectrum analyzer instead of a correlator is discussed.
We consider possible ways to recognize multi-photon entangled states in experiment. A commonly used technique is to measure higher-order multi-photon correlation functions and their dependence on certain phase delays (multi-photon interference). Theoretically and experimentally, we show that multi-photon interference can have very high visibility for classical sources: up to 81.8% in the three-photon case and up to 94.4% in the four-photon one. Therefore, the visibility of multi-photon interference should not be used as a criterion of multi-photon entangled states generation. Instead, we suggest to characterize multi-photon entanglement by the photon-number dependence of the normalized correlation functions.