Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1712.04669 · Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical

General quantum theory—unification of classical and modal quantum theories

Koen Thas

Published Jul 6, 2020• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract Inspired by classical (‘actual’) quantum theory over C and modal quantum theory (MQT), which is a model of quantum theory over certain finite fields, we introduce general quantum theory as a quantum theory—in the København interpretation—over general division rings with involution, in which the inner product ‘is’ a ( σ , 1)-Hermitian form φ . This unites all known such approaches in one and the same theory, and we show that many of the known results such as no-cloning, no-deleting, quantum teleportation and super-dense quantum coding, which are known in classical quantum theory over C and in some MQTs, hold for any general quantum theory. Our approach is totally different (and more general) than Hardy’s axiomatic approach [15], and generalized probability theories. On the other hand, in many general quantum theories, a geometrical object which we call ‘quantum kernel’ arises, which is invariant under the unitary group U ( V , φ ), and which carries the geometry of a so-called polar space. This object cannot be seen in classical quantum theory over C , but it is present, for instance, in all known MQTs. We use this object to construct new quantum (teleportation) coding schemes, which mix quantum theory with the geometry of the quantum kernel (and the action of the unitary group). We also show that in characteristic 0, every general quantum theory over an algebraically closed field behaves like classical quantum theory over C at many levels, and that all such theories share one model, which we pin down as the ‘minimal model,’ which is countable and defined over Q ¯ . Moreover, to make the analogy with classical quantum theory even more striking, we show that Born’s rule holds in any such theory. So all such theories are not modal at all. Finally, we obtain an extension theory for general quantum theories in characteristic 0 which allows one to extend any such theory over algebraically closed fields (such as classical complex quantum theory) to larger theories in which a quantum kernel is present. In this sense, these singular objects are always virtually around in abundance.

DOI
10.1088/1751-8121/aba307

Related papers

Absolute Quantum Theory (after Chang, Lewis, Minic and Takeuchi), and a Road to Quantum Deletion

Koen Thas

In a recent paper, Chang et al. have proposed studying “quantum F u n ”: the q ↦ 1 limit of modal quantum theories over finite fields F q , motivated by the fact that such limit theories can be naturally interpreted in classical quantum theory. In this letter, we first make a number of rectifications of statements made in that paper. For instance, we show that quantum theory over F 1 does have a natural analogon of an inner product, and so orthogonality is a well-defined notion, contrary to what was claimed in Chang et al. Starting from that formalism, we introduce time evolution operators and observables in quantum F u n , and we determine the corresponding unitary group. Next, we obtain a typical no-cloning result in the general realm of quantum F u n . Finally, we obtain a no-deletion result as well. Remarkably, we show that we can perform quantum deletion by almost unitary operators, with a probability tending to 1. Although we develop the construction in quantum F u n , it is also valid in any other quantum theory (and thus also in classical quantum theory in complex Hilbert spaces).

arXiv:1808.09694•Symmetry•Feb 2, 2019•0 citations

Quantum mechanics over sets

David Ellerman

In the tradition of toy models of quantum mechanics in vector spaces over finite fields (e.g., Schumacher and Westmoreland's "modal quantum theory"), one finite field stands out, 2, since vectors over 2 have an interpretation as natural mathematical objects, i.e., sets. This engages a sets-to-vector-spaces bridge that is part of the mathematical folklore to translate both ways between set concepts and vector space concepts. Using that bridge, the mathematical framework of (finite-dimensional) quantum mechanics can be transported down to sets resulting in quantum mechanics over sets or QM/sets. This approach leads to a different treatment of Dirac's brackets than in "modal quantum theory" (MQT), and that gives a full probability calculus (unlike MQT that only has zero-one modalities of impossible and possible). That, in turn, leads to a rather fulsome theory of QM over sets that includes "logical" models of the double-slit experiment, Bell's Theorem, quantum information theory, quantum computing, and much else. Indeed, QM/sets is proposed as the "logic" of QM in the old-fashioned sense of "logic" as giving the simplified essentials of a theory. QM/sets is also a key part of a broader research program to provide an interpretation of QM based on the notion of "objective indefiniteness," a program that grew out the recent development of the logic of partitions mathematically dual to the usual Boolean logic of subsets.

arXiv:1310.8221•Bulletin of the American Physical Society•Oct 30, 2013•12 citations

An introduction to the general boundary formulation of quantum field theory

Daniele Colosi

We give a brief introduction to the so-called general boundary formulation (GBF) of quantum theory. This new axiomatic formulation provides a description of the quantum dynamics which is manifestly local and does not rely on a metric background structure for its definition. We present the basic ingredients of the GBF, in particular we review the core axioms that assign algebraic structures to geometric ones, the two quantisation schemes so far developed for the GBF and the probability interpretation which generalizes the standard Born rule. Finally we briefly discuss some of the results obtained studying specific quantum field theories within the GBF.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jul 3, 2015•0 citations

Quantum Theory

Huzihiro Araki

Abstract In this chapter we explain how we can describe quantum theory within the general framework given in Chapter 1. We do not discuss various theories concerning the question of how quantum theory can (or cannot) be deduced from experimental facts or from a verifiable axiomatic system. Instead we start by introducing the assumptions of quantum theory. The main content is the algebraic viewpoint of quantum theory based on the theory of operator algebras, the GNS construction which supplies the fundamental relation between the description of the states by Hilbert space vectors and the description of the states in this general framework, the Wigner theorem which is basic for the mathematical description of quantum mechanical symmetries, and its generalizations. The basic definitions and theorems about Hilbert spaces and operator algebras are collected in the appendix.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Oct 21, 1999•0 citations

Generalized Quantum Theory

R. Collins

Beginning with the definition of a duplicated experiment and the fact that the resulting data are summarized as a set of configurations of some observables, together with frequencies of occurrence of each configuration, we derive the formal structure of conventional quantum theory using only the statistical properties of such data, and show that certain elements of the theory have heretofore been overlooked. This derivation yields a rather broad generalization of the theory which suggests new methods for describing phase transitions and possibly fundamental particles as well.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Jan 15, 1970•9 citations

Cloning, deleting, and hiding in modal quantum theory

Diamond, Phillip, Benjamin W. Schumacher

We examine the toy model of modal quantum theory (MQT), an analogue of actual quantum theory based on finite fields. In particular, we investigate how several essential ``no-go'' results (for cloning, deleting and hiding processes) work in MQT. Cloning and deleting are still forbidden in MQT, though the details of these results are somewhat different in the new context. However, the information of a modal qubit can be completely hidden in the correlations between two entangled modal qubits.

arXiv:2310.04397•Oct 6, 2023•0 citations
Abstract Inspired by classical (‘actual’) quantum theory over C and modal quantum theory (MQT), which is a model of quantum theory over certain finite fields, we introduce general quantum theory as a quantum theory—in the København interpretation—over general division rings with involution, in which the inner product ‘is’ a ( σ , 1)-Hermitian form φ . This unites all known such approaches in one and the same theory, and we show that many of the known results such as no-cloning, no-deleting, quantum teleportation and super-dense quantum coding, which are known in classical quantum theory over C and in some MQTs, hold for any general quantum theory. Our approach is totally different (and more general) than Hardy’s axiomatic approach [15], and generalized probability theories. On the other hand, in many general quantum theories, a geometrical object which we call ‘quantum kernel’ arises, which is invariant under the unitary group U ( V , φ ), and which carries the geometry of a so-called polar space. This object cannot be seen in classical quantum theory over C , but it is present, for instance, in all known MQTs. We use this object to construct new quantum (teleportation) coding schemes, which mix quantum theory with the geometry of the quantum kernel (and the action of the unitary group). We also show that in characteristic 0, every general quantum theory over an algebraically closed field behaves like classical quantum theory over C at many levels, and that all such theories share one model, which we pin down as the ‘minimal model,’ which is countable and defined over Q ¯ . Moreover, to make the analogy with classical quantum theory even more striking, we show that Born’s rule holds in any such theory. So all such theories are not modal at all. Finally, we obtain an extension theory for general quantum theories in characteristic 0 which allows one to extend any such theory over algebraically closed fields (such as classical complex quantum theory) to larger theories in which a quantum kernel is present. In this sense, these singular objects are always virtually around in abundance.
In a recent paper, Chang et al. have proposed studying “quantum F u n ”: the q ↦ 1 limit of modal quantum theories over finite fields F q , motivated by the fact that such limit theories can be naturally interpreted in classical quantum theory. In this letter, we first make a number of rectifications of statements made in that paper. For instance, we show that quantum theory over F 1 does have a natural analogon of an inner product, and so orthogonality is a well-defined notion, contrary to what was claimed in Chang et al. Starting from that formalism, we introduce time evolution operators and observables in quantum F u n , and we determine the corresponding unitary group. Next, we obtain a typical no-cloning result in the general realm of quantum F u n . Finally, we obtain a no-deletion result as well. Remarkably, we show that we can perform quantum deletion by almost unitary operators, with a probability tending to 1. Although we develop the construction in quantum F u n , it is also valid in any other quantum theory (and thus also in classical quantum theory in complex Hilbert spaces).
In the tradition of toy models of quantum mechanics in vector spaces over finite fields (e.g., Schumacher and Westmoreland's "modal quantum theory"), one finite field stands out, 2, since vectors over 2 have an interpretation as natural mathematical objects, i.e., sets. This engages a sets-to-vector-spaces bridge that is part of the mathematical folklore to translate both ways between set concepts and vector space concepts. Using that bridge, the mathematical framework of (finite-dimensional) quantum mechanics can be transported down to sets resulting in quantum mechanics over sets or QM/sets. This approach leads to a different treatment of Dirac's brackets than in "modal quantum theory" (MQT), and that gives a full probability calculus (unlike MQT that only has zero-one modalities of impossible and possible). That, in turn, leads to a rather fulsome theory of QM over sets that includes "logical" models of the double-slit experiment, Bell's Theorem, quantum information theory, quantum computing, and much else. Indeed, QM/sets is proposed as the "logic" of QM in the old-fashioned sense of "logic" as giving the simplified essentials of a theory. QM/sets is also a key part of a broader research program to provide an interpretation of QM based on the notion of "objective indefiniteness," a program that grew out the recent development of the logic of partitions mathematically dual to the usual Boolean logic of subsets.
We give a brief introduction to the so-called general boundary formulation (GBF) of quantum theory. This new axiomatic formulation provides a description of the quantum dynamics which is manifestly local and does not rely on a metric background structure for its definition. We present the basic ingredients of the GBF, in particular we review the core axioms that assign algebraic structures to geometric ones, the two quantisation schemes so far developed for the GBF and the probability interpretation which generalizes the standard Born rule. Finally we briefly discuss some of the results obtained studying specific quantum field theories within the GBF.
Abstract In this chapter we explain how we can describe quantum theory within the general framework given in Chapter 1. We do not discuss various theories concerning the question of how quantum theory can (or cannot) be deduced from experimental facts or from a verifiable axiomatic system. Instead we start by introducing the assumptions of quantum theory. The main content is the algebraic viewpoint of quantum theory based on the theory of operator algebras, the GNS construction which supplies the fundamental relation between the description of the states by Hilbert space vectors and the description of the states in this general framework, the Wigner theorem which is basic for the mathematical description of quantum mechanical symmetries, and its generalizations. The basic definitions and theorems about Hilbert spaces and operator algebras are collected in the appendix.
Beginning with the definition of a duplicated experiment and the fact that the resulting data are summarized as a set of configurations of some observables, together with frequencies of occurrence of each configuration, we derive the formal structure of conventional quantum theory using only the statistical properties of such data, and show that certain elements of the theory have heretofore been overlooked. This derivation yields a rather broad generalization of the theory which suggests new methods for describing phase transitions and possibly fundamental particles as well.
We examine the toy model of modal quantum theory (MQT), an analogue of actual quantum theory based on finite fields. In particular, we investigate how several essential ``no-go'' results (for cloning, deleting and hiding processes) work in MQT. Cloning and deleting are still forbidden in MQT, though the details of these results are somewhat different in the new context. However, the information of a modal qubit can be completely hidden in the correlations between two entangled modal qubits.