Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1712.01614 · The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science

Two Forms of Inconsistency in Quantum Foundations

Jeremy Steeger, Nicholas Teh

Published Nov 30, 2018• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Recently, there has been some discussion of how Dutch book arguments might be used to demonstrate the rational incoherence of certain hidden variable models of quantum theory (Feintzeig [2015]; Feintzeig and Fletcher [2017]; Wroński and Godziszewski [2017]). In this paper, we argue that the ‘form of inconsistency’ underlying this alleged irrationality is deeply and comprehensively related to the more familiar ‘inconsistency’ phenomenon of contextuality. Our main result is that the hierarchy of contextuality due to Abramsky and Brandenburger ([2011]) corresponds to a hierarchy of additivity/convexity-violations that yields formal Dutch books of different strengths. We then use this result to provide a partial assessment of whether these formal Dutch books can be given a convincing normative interpretation.

DOI
10.1093/bjps/axy071

Related papers

Logic of Local Inference for Contextuality in Quantum Physics and Beyond

Kohei Kishida

Contextuality in quantum physics provides a key resource for quantum information and computation. The topological approach in [Abramsky and Brandenburger, New J. Phys., 2011, Abramsky et al., CSL 2015, 2015] characterizes contextuality as "global inconsistency" coupled with "local consistency", revealing it to be a phenomenon also found in many other fields. This has yielded a logical method of detecting and proving the "global inconsistency" part of contextuality. Our goal is to capture the other, "local consistency" part, which requires a novel approach to logic that is sensitive to the topology of contexts. To achieve this, we formulate a logic of local inference by using context-sensitive theories and models in regular categories. This provides a uniform framework for local consistency, and lays a foundation for high-level methods of detecting, proving, and moreover using contextuality as computational resource.

arXiv:1605.08949•Leibniz international proceedings in informatics•Jan 1, 2016•15 citations

Logical and topological contextuality in quantum mechanics and beyond

Giovanni Carù

The main subjects of this thesis are non-locality and contextuality, two fundamental features of quantum mechanics that constitute valuable resources for quantum computation. Our analysis is based on Abramsky & Brandenburger's sheaf theoretic framework, which captures both these phenomena in a unified treatment and in a very general setting. This high-level description transcends quantum physics and allows to precisely characterise the notion of contextuality as the apparent paradox realised by data being locally consistent but globally inconsistent. More specifically, we aim to develop a deeper understanding of so-called logical forms of contextuality, i.e. situations where the phenomenon can be witnessed using purely logical arguments, disregarding probabilities. The sheaf theoretic description of logical contextuality has recently inspired the development of a topological treatment of the phenomenon based on sheaf cohomology. In this thesis, we embark on a detailed analysis of the cohomology of contextuality, exposing key shortcomings in the current methods, and introducing an (almost) complete cohomological characterisation of logical forms of contextuality. More specifically, we show that, in its current formulation, sheaf cohomology does not constitute a complete invariant for contextuality, not even in its strongest forms, and that higher cohomology groups cannot be used to study the phenomenon. Then, we solve these issues by introducing a novel construction, which derives refined versions of the presheaves describing empirical models to expose their deeper extendability properties, resulting in a sheaf cohomological invariant which is applicable to the vast majority of empirical models, and conjectured to work universally. We propose a general theory of contextual semantics using the language of valuation algebras. In particular, we give a general definition of contextual behaviour as a fundamental gap between local agreement and global disagreement of information sources. Not only does this formalism aptly capture and generalise the known instances of contextuality beyond quantum theory, but it also provides inspiration for further applications of the phenomenon, and paves the way for the transfer of results and techniques between different fields. We give a prime example of this potential by developing faster algorithms to detect contextuality based on mainstream methods of generic inference. Finally, we turn our attention back to instances of contextuality in quantum physics, and study strong contextuality in multi-qubit states. We give a complete combinatorial characterisation of All-vs-Nothing proofs of strong contextuality in stabiliser quantum mechanics. This allows to produce the complete list of all stabiliser states exhibiting this kind of contextuality, which consitututes an important resource in certain models of quantum computation. Then, we extend our search for strongly contextual behaviour beyond stabiliser states, and identify the minimum quantum resources needed to realise strong non-locality. Additional results include a partial classification of strongly non-local models comprised of three-qubit states and local projective measurements, and the introduction of a new infinite family of strongly non-local three-qubit states.

•Jan 1, 2019•3 citations

Facets of contextual realism in quantum mechanics

A. K. Pan, Dipankar Home, Dipankar Home +2 more

In recent times, there is an upsurge of interest in demonstrating the quantum contextuality. In this proceedings, we explore the two different forms of arguments that have been used for showing the contextual character of quantum mechanics. First line of study concerns the violations of the noncontextual realist models by quantum mechanics, where second line of study that is qualitatively distinct from the earlier one, demonstrates the contextuality within the formalism of quantum mechanics.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2011•0 citations

Contextuality, Cohomology and Paradox

Samson Abramsky, Rui Soares Barbosa, Kohei Kishida +2 more

Contextuality is a key feature of quantum mechanics that provides an important non-classical resource for quantum information and computation. Abramsky and Brandenburger used sheaf theory to give a general treatment of contextuality in quantum theory [New Journal of Physics 13 (2011) 113036]. However, contextual phenomena are found in other fields as well, for example database theory. In this paper, we shall develop this unified view of contextuality. We provide two main contributions: firstly, we expose a remarkable connection between contexuality and logical paradoxes; secondly, we show that an important class of contextuality arguments has a topological origin. More specifically, we show that "All-vs-Nothing" proofs of contextuality are witnessed by cohomological obstructions.

arXiv:1502.03097•Leibniz international proceedings in informatics•Jan 1, 2015•118 citations

Foreword: Unperformed Experiments Have No Results

Christopher A. Fuchs, Jan-Åke Larsson, Luigi Accardi +6 more

This year in Växjö we thought we would try an experiment—it felt high time for a new result. Much of the foundations discussion of previous years has focussed on EPR‐style arguments and the meaning and experimental validity of various Bell inequality violations. Yet, there is another pillar of the quantum foundations puzzle that has hardly received any attention in our great series of meetings: It is the phenomenon first demonstrated by Kochen and Specker, quantum contextuality. Recently there has been a rapid growth of activity aimed toward better understanding this aspect of quantum mechanics, which Asher Peres sloganized by the phrase, “unperformed experiments have no results.” Below is a sampling of some important papers on the topic for the reader not yet familiar with the subject. What is the source of this phenomenon? Does it depend only on high level features of quantum mechanics, or is it deep in the conceptual framework on which the theory rests? Might it, for instance, arise from the way quantum mechanics amends the classic laws of probability? What are the mathematically simplest ways contextuality can be demonstrated? How might the known results be made amenable to experimental tests? These were the sorts of discussions we hoped the session would foster.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2009•0 citations

Contextuality, Locality, and the Interpretation of Bell Violations

Partha Ghose

The ontological significance of violations of Bell inequalities is reexamined. Bell's theorem admits several mathematically equivalent formulations that support different interpretive perspectives. The present paper develops one such perspective using contextuality, the sheaf-theoretic framework of Abramsky and Brandenburger, and Nelson's stochastic mechanics.

quant-pharXiv:2604.26916•Journal of Theoretical Experimental and Applied Physics•Apr 30, 2026•0 citations
Recently, there has been some discussion of how Dutch book arguments might be used to demonstrate the rational incoherence of certain hidden variable models of quantum theory (Feintzeig [2015]; Feintzeig and Fletcher [2017]; Wroński and Godziszewski [2017]). In this paper, we argue that the ‘form of inconsistency’ underlying this alleged irrationality is deeply and comprehensively related to the more familiar ‘inconsistency’ phenomenon of contextuality. Our main result is that the hierarchy of contextuality due to Abramsky and Brandenburger ([2011]) corresponds to a hierarchy of additivity/convexity-violations that yields formal Dutch books of different strengths. We then use this result to provide a partial assessment of whether these formal Dutch books can be given a convincing normative interpretation.
Contextuality in quantum physics provides a key resource for quantum information and computation. The topological approach in [Abramsky and Brandenburger, New J. Phys., 2011, Abramsky et al., CSL 2015, 2015] characterizes contextuality as "global inconsistency" coupled with "local consistency", revealing it to be a phenomenon also found in many other fields. This has yielded a logical method of detecting and proving the "global inconsistency" part of contextuality. Our goal is to capture the other, "local consistency" part, which requires a novel approach to logic that is sensitive to the topology of contexts. To achieve this, we formulate a logic of local inference by using context-sensitive theories and models in regular categories. This provides a uniform framework for local consistency, and lays a foundation for high-level methods of detecting, proving, and moreover using contextuality as computational resource.
The main subjects of this thesis are non-locality and contextuality, two fundamental features of quantum mechanics that constitute valuable resources for quantum computation. Our analysis is based on Abramsky & Brandenburger's sheaf theoretic framework, which captures both these phenomena in a unified treatment and in a very general setting. This high-level description transcends quantum physics and allows to precisely characterise the notion of contextuality as the apparent paradox realised by data being locally consistent but globally inconsistent. More specifically, we aim to develop a deeper understanding of so-called logical forms of contextuality, i.e. situations where the phenomenon can be witnessed using purely logical arguments, disregarding probabilities. The sheaf theoretic description of logical contextuality has recently inspired the development of a topological treatment of the phenomenon based on sheaf cohomology. In this thesis, we embark on a detailed analysis of the cohomology of contextuality, exposing key shortcomings in the current methods, and introducing an (almost) complete cohomological characterisation of logical forms of contextuality. More specifically, we show that, in its current formulation, sheaf cohomology does not constitute a complete invariant for contextuality, not even in its strongest forms, and that higher cohomology groups cannot be used to study the phenomenon. Then, we solve these issues by introducing a novel construction, which derives refined versions of the presheaves describing empirical models to expose their deeper extendability properties, resulting in a sheaf cohomological invariant which is applicable to the vast majority of empirical models, and conjectured to work universally. We propose a general theory of contextual semantics using the language of valuation algebras. In particular, we give a general definition of contextual behaviour as a fundamental gap between local agreement and global disagreement of information sources. Not only does this formalism aptly capture and generalise the known instances of contextuality beyond quantum theory, but it also provides inspiration for further applications of the phenomenon, and paves the way for the transfer of results and techniques between different fields. We give a prime example of this potential by developing faster algorithms to detect contextuality based on mainstream methods of generic inference. Finally, we turn our attention back to instances of contextuality in quantum physics, and study strong contextuality in multi-qubit states. We give a complete combinatorial characterisation of All-vs-Nothing proofs of strong contextuality in stabiliser quantum mechanics. This allows to produce the complete list of all stabiliser states exhibiting this kind of contextuality, which consitututes an important resource in certain models of quantum computation. Then, we extend our search for strongly contextual behaviour beyond stabiliser states, and identify the minimum quantum resources needed to realise strong non-locality. Additional results include a partial classification of strongly non-local models comprised of three-qubit states and local projective measurements, and the introduction of a new infinite family of strongly non-local three-qubit states.
Contextuality is a key feature of quantum mechanics that provides an important non-classical resource for quantum information and computation. Abramsky and Brandenburger used sheaf theory to give a general treatment of contextuality in quantum theory [New Journal of Physics 13 (2011) 113036]. However, contextual phenomena are found in other fields as well, for example database theory. In this paper, we shall develop this unified view of contextuality. We provide two main contributions: firstly, we expose a remarkable connection between contexuality and logical paradoxes; secondly, we show that an important class of contextuality arguments has a topological origin. More specifically, we show that "All-vs-Nothing" proofs of contextuality are witnessed by cohomological obstructions.
This year in Växjö we thought we would try an experiment—it felt high time for a new result. Much of the foundations discussion of previous years has focussed on EPR‐style arguments and the meaning and experimental validity of various Bell inequality violations. Yet, there is another pillar of the quantum foundations puzzle that has hardly received any attention in our great series of meetings: It is the phenomenon first demonstrated by Kochen and Specker, quantum contextuality. Recently there has been a rapid growth of activity aimed toward better understanding this aspect of quantum mechanics, which Asher Peres sloganized by the phrase, “unperformed experiments have no results.” Below is a sampling of some important papers on the topic for the reader not yet familiar with the subject. What is the source of this phenomenon? Does it depend only on high level features of quantum mechanics, or is it deep in the conceptual framework on which the theory rests? Might it, for instance, arise from the way quantum mechanics amends the classic laws of probability? What are the mathematically simplest ways contextuality can be demonstrated? How might the known results be made amenable to experimental tests? These were the sorts of discussions we hoped the session would foster.