Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1711.07347 · Journal of Physics Communications

Observation-based symmetry breaking measures

Ivan Fernandez‐Corbaton

Published Aug 14, 2018• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Symmetry is one of the most general and useful concepts in physics. A system that has a symmetry is fundamentally constrained by it. The same constraints do not apply when the symmetry is broken. The quantitative determination of how much a system breaks a symmetry allows to reach beyond this binary situation and is a necessary step towards the quantitative connection between symmetry breaking and its effects. We introduce measures of symmetry breaking for a system interacting with external fields (particles). They can be computed from measurements of the system-mediated coupling strengths between subspaces of incoming and outgoing fields (particles) that transform in a definite way under the symmetry. The generality of these symmetry breaking measures and their tight connection to experimental measurements make them applicable to a very wide range of physics, like quantification of phase transitions, constraints in dynamical evolution, and the search for hidden symmetries.

DOI
10.1088/2399-6528/aada25

Related papers

Quantum Mechanics in symmetry language

H. Ziaeepour

We consider symmetry as a foundational concept in quantum mechanics and rewrite quantum mechanics and measurement axioms in this description. We argue that issues related to measurements and physical reality of states can be better understood in this view. In particular, the abstract concept of symmetry provides a basis-independent definition for observables. Moreover, we show that the apparent projection/collapse of the state as the final step of measurement or decoherence is the result of breaking of symmetries. This phenomenon is comparable with a phase transition by spontaneous symmetry breaking, and makes the process of decoherence and classicality a natural fate of complex systems consisting of many interacting subsystems. Additionally, we demonstrate that the property of state space as a vector space representing symmetries is more fundamental than being an abstract Hilbert space, and its $L2$ integrability can be obtained from the imposed condition of being a representation of a symmetry group and general properties of probability distributions.

arXiv:1305.4349•May 19, 2013•4 citations

Symmetry, Asymmetry and Quantum Information

Iman Marvian

It is impossible to overstate the importance of symmetry in physics and mathematics. Symmetry arguments play a central role in a broad range of problems from simplifying a system of linear equations to a deep role in organizing the fundamental principles of physics. They are used, for instance, in Noether’s theorem to find the consequences of symmetry of a dynamics. For many systems of interest, the dynamics are sufficiently complicated that one cannot hope to characterize their evolution completely, whereas by appealing to the symmetries of the dynamical laws one can easily infer many useful results. \n \nIn part I of this thesis we study the problem of finding the consequences of symmetry of a (possibly open) dynamics from an information-theoretic perspective. The study of this problem naturally leads us to the notion of asymmetry of quantum states. The asymmetry of a state relative to some symmetry group specifies how and to what extent the given symmetry is broken by the state. Characterizing these is found to be surprisingly useful to constrain which final states of the system can be reached from a given initial state. Another motivation for the study of asymmetry comes from the field of quantum metrology and relatedly the field of quantum reference frames. It turns out that the degree of success one can achieve in many metrological tasks depends only on the asymmetry properties of the state used for metrology. We show that some ideas and tools developed in the field of quantum information theory are extremely useful to study the notion of asymmetry of states and therefore to find the consequences of symmetry of an open or closed system dynamics. \n \nIn part II of this thesis we present a novel application of symmetry arguments in the field of quantum estimation theory. We consider a family of multi-copy estimation problems wherein one is given n copies of an unknown quantum state according to some prior distribution and the goal is to estimate certain parameters of the given state. In particular, we are interested to know whether collective measurements are useful and if so to find an upper bound on the amount of entanglement which is required to achieve the optimal estimation. We introduce a new approach to this problem by considering the symmetries of the prior and the symmetries of the parameters to be estimated. We show that based on these symmetries one can find strong constraints on the amount of entanglement required to implement the optimal measurement. In order to infer properties of the optimal estimation procedure from the symmetries of the parameters and the prior we come up with a generalization of Schur-Weyl duality. Just as Schur-Weyl duality has many applications to quantum information theory and quantum algorithms so too does this generalization. In this thesis we explore some of these applications.

•Sep 28, 2012•67 citations

Quantum Simulations of Interacting Systems with Broken Time-Reversal Symmetry

Yotam Shapira, Tom Manovitz, Nitzan Akerman +2 more

Many-body systems of quantum interacting particles in which time-reversal symmetry is broken give rise to a variety of rich collective behaviors and are, therefore, a major target of research in modern physics.Quantum simulators can potentially be used to explore and understand such systems, which are often beyond the computational reach of classical simulation.Of these, platforms with universal quantum control can experimentally access a wide range of physical properties.However, simultaneously achieving strong programmable interactions, strong time-reversal symmetry breaking, and high-fidelity quantum control in a scalable manner is challenging.Here, we realize quantum simulations of interacting, time-reversal-broken quantum systems in a universal trapped-ion quantum processor.Using a recently proposed, scalable scheme, we implement time-reversal-breaking synthetic gauge fields, shown for the first time in a trappedion chain, along with unique coupling geometries, potentially extendable to simulation of multidimensional systems.Our high-fidelity single-site resolution in control and measurement, along with highly programmable interactions, allow us to perform full state tomography of a ground state showcasing persistent current and to observe dynamics of a time-reversal-broken system with nontrivial interactions.Our results open a path toward simulation of time-reversal-broken many-body systems with a wide range of features and coupling geometries.

arXiv:2205.11178•Physical Review X•May 9, 2023•21 citations

Spontaneous symmetry breaking

Franco Strocchi

Since the mechanism of spontaneous symmetry breaking has such a relevant impact for the description of physical systems, its explanation should be based on physical considerations with a direct operational meaning. To this purpose, it is useful to recognize that the operational/experimental description of a physical system (not necessarily quantum!) involves the following elements: the set A of its measurable quantities, briefly called observables ; the measurement of the time evolution of the observables; the set ∑ of configurations or states in which the system may be prepared, according to well defined protocols of experimental preparations; the measurement of an observable A , when the system is in the state ω is operationally defined by the experimental expectation 〈A〉 ω

Scuola Normale Superiore eBooks•Jan 1, 2019•2 citations

Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking as the Mechanism of Quantum Measurement

Michael Grady

It is proposed that an event that constitutes a quantum measurement corresponds to the spontaneous breaking of a symmetry in the measuring device over time.

arXiv:hep-th/9409049•Sep 9, 1994•18 citations

Quantum Fisher Information as a Measure of Symmetry Breaking in Quantum Many-Body Systems

Shion Yamashika, Shimpei Endo, Hiroyasu Tajima

Symmetry breaking underlies diverse phenomena from phase transitions in condensed matter to fundamental interactions in gauge theories. Despite many proposed indicators, a general quantification of symmetry breaking that is faithful, computable, and valid in the thermodynamic limit has remained elusive. Here, within quantum resource theory, we propose the quantum Fisher information (QFI) as such a measure. We demonstrate its utility by computing QFI for paradigmatic models: in the BCS superconductor, the QFI counts the number of Cooper pairs; in the transverse-field XY spin chains, it captures topological phase transition that has no local order parameter; and in quantum quench dynamics, it allows us to exactly derive the microscopic origin and conditions of the quantum Mpemba effect in terms of excitation propagation, including in the thermodynamic limit--beyond the reach of previous analyses. Our results show that the QFI, which is a complete resource monotone in the resource theory of asymmetry that plays the role of entanglement entropy in entanglement theory, faithfully captures symmetry breaking in condensed-matter systems. These results highlight the QFI as a universal and physically meaningful diagnostic of symmetry breaking in both equilibrium and non-equilibrium quantum many-body systems.

arXiv:2509.07468•Sep 9, 2025•16 citations
Symmetry is one of the most general and useful concepts in physics. A system that has a symmetry is fundamentally constrained by it. The same constraints do not apply when the symmetry is broken. The quantitative determination of how much a system breaks a symmetry allows to reach beyond this binary situation and is a necessary step towards the quantitative connection between symmetry breaking and its effects. We introduce measures of symmetry breaking for a system interacting with external fields (particles). They can be computed from measurements of the system-mediated coupling strengths between subspaces of incoming and outgoing fields (particles) that transform in a definite way under the symmetry. The generality of these symmetry breaking measures and their tight connection to experimental measurements make them applicable to a very wide range of physics, like quantification of phase transitions, constraints in dynamical evolution, and the search for hidden symmetries.
We consider symmetry as a foundational concept in quantum mechanics and rewrite quantum mechanics and measurement axioms in this description. We argue that issues related to measurements and physical reality of states can be better understood in this view. In particular, the abstract concept of symmetry provides a basis-independent definition for observables. Moreover, we show that the apparent projection/collapse of the state as the final step of measurement or decoherence is the result of breaking of symmetries. This phenomenon is comparable with a phase transition by spontaneous symmetry breaking, and makes the process of decoherence and classicality a natural fate of complex systems consisting of many interacting subsystems. Additionally, we demonstrate that the property of state space as a vector space representing symmetries is more fundamental than being an abstract Hilbert space, and its L2L2L2 integrability can be obtained from the imposed condition of being a representation of a symmetry group and general properties of probability distributions.
It is impossible to overstate the importance of symmetry in physics and mathematics. Symmetry arguments play a central role in a broad range of problems from simplifying a system of linear equations to a deep role in organizing the fundamental principles of physics. They are used, for instance, in Noether’s theorem to find the consequences of symmetry of a dynamics. For many systems of interest, the dynamics are sufficiently complicated that one cannot hope to characterize their evolution completely, whereas by appealing to the symmetries of the dynamical laws one can easily infer many useful results. \n \nIn part I of this thesis we study the problem of finding the consequences of symmetry of a (possibly open) dynamics from an information-theoretic perspective. The study of this problem naturally leads us to the notion of asymmetry of quantum states. The asymmetry of a state relative to some symmetry group specifies how and to what extent the given symmetry is broken by the state. Characterizing these is found to be surprisingly useful to constrain which final states of the system can be reached from a given initial state. Another motivation for the study of asymmetry comes from the field of quantum metrology and relatedly the field of quantum reference frames. It turns out that the degree of success one can achieve in many metrological tasks depends only on the asymmetry properties of the state used for metrology. We show that some ideas and tools developed in the field of quantum information theory are extremely useful to study the notion of asymmetry of states and therefore to find the consequences of symmetry of an open or closed system dynamics. \n \nIn part II of this thesis we present a novel application of symmetry arguments in the field of quantum estimation theory. We consider a family of multi-copy estimation problems wherein one is given n copies of an unknown quantum state according to some prior distribution and the goal is to estimate certain parameters of the given state. In particular, we are interested to know whether collective measurements are useful and if so to find an upper bound on the amount of entanglement which is required to achieve the optimal estimation. We introduce a new approach to this problem by considering the symmetries of the prior and the symmetries of the parameters to be estimated. We show that based on these symmetries one can find strong constraints on the amount of entanglement required to implement the optimal measurement. In order to infer properties of the optimal estimation procedure from the symmetries of the parameters and the prior we come up with a generalization of Schur-Weyl duality. Just as Schur-Weyl duality has many applications to quantum information theory and quantum algorithms so too does this generalization. In this thesis we explore some of these applications.
Many-body systems of quantum interacting particles in which time-reversal symmetry is broken give rise to a variety of rich collective behaviors and are, therefore, a major target of research in modern physics.Quantum simulators can potentially be used to explore and understand such systems, which are often beyond the computational reach of classical simulation.Of these, platforms with universal quantum control can experimentally access a wide range of physical properties.However, simultaneously achieving strong programmable interactions, strong time-reversal symmetry breaking, and high-fidelity quantum control in a scalable manner is challenging.Here, we realize quantum simulations of interacting, time-reversal-broken quantum systems in a universal trapped-ion quantum processor.Using a recently proposed, scalable scheme, we implement time-reversal-breaking synthetic gauge fields, shown for the first time in a trappedion chain, along with unique coupling geometries, potentially extendable to simulation of multidimensional systems.Our high-fidelity single-site resolution in control and measurement, along with highly programmable interactions, allow us to perform full state tomography of a ground state showcasing persistent current and to observe dynamics of a time-reversal-broken system with nontrivial interactions.Our results open a path toward simulation of time-reversal-broken many-body systems with a wide range of features and coupling geometries.
Since the mechanism of spontaneous symmetry breaking has such a relevant impact for the description of physical systems, its explanation should be based on physical considerations with a direct operational meaning. To this purpose, it is useful to recognize that the operational/experimental description of a physical system (not necessarily quantum!) involves the following elements: the set A of its measurable quantities, briefly called observables ; the measurement of the time evolution of the observables; the set ∑ of configurations or states in which the system may be prepared, according to well defined protocols of experimental preparations; the measurement of an observable A , when the system is in the state ω is operationally defined by the experimental expectation 〈A〉 ω
Symmetry breaking underlies diverse phenomena from phase transitions in condensed matter to fundamental interactions in gauge theories. Despite many proposed indicators, a general quantification of symmetry breaking that is faithful, computable, and valid in the thermodynamic limit has remained elusive. Here, within quantum resource theory, we propose the quantum Fisher information (QFI) as such a measure. We demonstrate its utility by computing QFI for paradigmatic models: in the BCS superconductor, the QFI counts the number of Cooper pairs; in the transverse-field XY spin chains, it captures topological phase transition that has no local order parameter; and in quantum quench dynamics, it allows us to exactly derive the microscopic origin and conditions of the quantum Mpemba effect in terms of excitation propagation, including in the thermodynamic limit--beyond the reach of previous analyses. Our results show that the QFI, which is a complete resource monotone in the resource theory of asymmetry that plays the role of entanglement entropy in entanglement theory, faithfully captures symmetry breaking in condensed-matter systems. These results highlight the QFI as a universal and physically meaningful diagnostic of symmetry breaking in both equilibrium and non-equilibrium quantum many-body systems.