Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1711.02928 · Physical Review A

Comment on “Spontaneous collapse: A solution to the measurement problem and a source of the decay in mesonic systems”

Antoine Tilloy

Published Nov 7, 2017• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In a recent article [Phys. Rev. A 94, 052128 (2016)], the authors compute the predictions of two collapse models on the transition probabilities of neutral mesons. Notably, they claim to find an influence on the decay rates and attempt to prove that a new parameter $\ensuremath{\theta}(0)$ is required to fully characterize the noise of standard collapse models. These two claims are incorrect and motivated by flawed computations. This Comment derives the correct transition probabilities exactly from the master equation, explains how they could be computed perturbatively in a safe way, and finally shows where the main mistake of the authors of the original article was made.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.96.056101

Related papers

Spontaneous collapse: A solution to the measurement problem and a source of the decay in mesonic systems

Kyrylo Simonov, Beatrix C. Hiesmayr

Dynamical reduction models propose a solution to the measurement problem in quantum mechanics: the collapse of the wave function becomes a physical process. We compute the predictions to decaying and flavor-oscillating neutral mesons for the two most promising collapse models, the QMUPL (quantum mechanics with universal position localization) model and the mass-proportional CSL (continuous spontaneous localization) model. Our results are showing (i) a strong sensitivity to the very assumptions of the noise field underlying those two collapse models and (ii) under particular assumptions the CSL case allows one even to recover the decay dynamics. This in turn allows one to predict the effective collapse rates solely based on the measured values for the oscillation (mass differences) and the measured values of the decay constants. The four types of neutral mesons ($K$ meson, $D$ meson, ${B}_{d}$ meson, and ${B}_{s}$ meson) lead surprisingly to ranges comparable to those put forward by Adler [J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 40, 2935 (2007)] and Ghirardi, Rimini, and Weber [Phys. Rev. D 34, 470 (1986)]. Our results show that these systems at high energies are very sensitive to possible modifications of the standard quantum theory, making them a very powerful laboratory to rule out certain collapse scenarios and study the detailed physical processes solving the measurement problem.

arXiv:1606.01682•Physical Review A•Nov 28, 2016•9 citations

Particle mixing and the emergence of classicality: A spontaneous-collapse-model view

Kyrylo Simonov

Spontaneous collapse models aim to resolve the measurement problem in quantum mechanics by considering wave-function collapse as a physical process. We analyze how these models affect a decaying flavor-oscillating system whose evolution is governed by a phenomenological non-Hermitian Hamiltonian. In turn, we apply two popular collapse models, the Quantum Mechanics with Universal Position Localization and the Continuous Spontaneous Localization models, to a neutral meson system. By using the equivalence between the approaches to the time evolution of decaying systems with a non-Hermitian Hamiltonian and a dissipator of the Lindblad form in an enlarged Hilbert space, we show that spontaneous collapse can induce the decay dynamics in both quantum state and master equations. Moreover, we show that the decay property of a flavor-oscillating system is intimately connected to the time (a)symmetry of the noise field underlying the collapse mechanism. This (a)symmetry, in turn, is related to the definition of the stochastic integral and can provide a physical intuition behind the It\ifmmode \bar{o}\else \={o}\fi{}-Stratonovich dilemma in stochastic calculus.

arXiv:2008.11137•Physical Review A•Aug 25, 2020•5 citations

Can a spontaneous collapse in flavour oscillations be tested at KLOE?

Kyrylo Simonov, Beatrix C. Hiesmayr

Why do we never see a table in a superposition of here and there? This problem gets a solution by so called collapse models assuming the collapse as a genuinely physical process. Here we consider two specific collapse models and apply them to systems at high energies, i.e. flavour oscillating neutral meson systems. We find on one hand a potentially new interpretation of the decay rates introduced by hand in the standard formalism and on the other hand that these systems at high energies constrain by experimental data the possible collapse scenarios.

arXiv:1705.00913•EPJ Web of Conferences•Jan 1, 2018•5 citations

Collapse models with non-white noises

Stephen L Adler, Angelo Bassi

We set up a general formalism for models of spontaneous wave function collapse with dynamics represented by a stochastic differential equation driven by general Gaussian noises, not necessarily white in time. In particular, we show that the non-Schrodinger terms of the equation induce the collapse of the wave function to one of the common eigenstates of the collapsing operators, and that the collapse occurs with the correct quantum probabilities. We also develop a perturbation expansion of the solution of the equation with respect to the parameter which sets the strength of the collapse process; such an approximation allows one to compute the leading order terms for the deviations of the predictions of collapse models with respect to those of standard quantum mechanics. This analysis shows that to leading order, the ``imaginary'' noise trick can be used for non-white Gaussian noise.

arXiv:0708.3624•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Nov 28, 2007•112 citations

How to Teach and Think About Spontaneous Wave Function Collapse Theories: Not Like Before

Shan Gao

A simple and natural introduction to the concept and formalism of spontaneous wave function collapse can and should be based on textbook knowledge of standard quantum state collapse and monitoring. This approach explains the origin of noise driving the paradigmatic stochastic Schrödinger equations of spontaneous localization of the wave function $Ψ$. It reveals, on the other hand, that these equations are empirically redundant and the master equations of the noise-averaged state $\hatρ$ are the only empirically testable dynamics in current spontaneous collapse theories.

arXiv:1710.02814•Cambridge University Press eBooks•Apr 20, 2018•7 citations

Comment on ‘‘Spontaneous and induced emission of soft bosons: Exact non-Markovian solution’’

K. Wódkiewicz

A Comment on the Letter by Benjamin Fain, Phys. Rev. Lett. 61, 2197 (1988).Received 17 February 1989DOI:https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.63.2693©1989 American Physical Society

Physical Review Letters•Dec 11, 1989•6 citations
In a recent article [Phys. Rev. A 94, 052128 (2016)], the authors compute the predictions of two collapse models on the transition probabilities of neutral mesons. Notably, they claim to find an influence on the decay rates and attempt to prove that a new parameter \ensuremathθ(0)\ensuremath{\theta}(0)\ensuremathθ(0) is required to fully characterize the noise of standard collapse models. These two claims are incorrect and motivated by flawed computations. This Comment derives the correct transition probabilities exactly from the master equation, explains how they could be computed perturbatively in a safe way, and finally shows where the main mistake of the authors of the original article was made.
Dynamical reduction models propose a solution to the measurement problem in quantum mechanics: the collapse of the wave function becomes a physical process. We compute the predictions to decaying and flavor-oscillating neutral mesons for the two most promising collapse models, the QMUPL (quantum mechanics with universal position localization) model and the mass-proportional CSL (continuous spontaneous localization) model. Our results are showing (i) a strong sensitivity to the very assumptions of the noise field underlying those two collapse models and (ii) under particular assumptions the CSL case allows one even to recover the decay dynamics. This in turn allows one to predict the effective collapse rates solely based on the measured values for the oscillation (mass differences) and the measured values of the decay constants. The four types of neutral mesons (KKK meson, DDD meson, Bd{B}_{d}Bd​ meson, and Bs{B}_{s}Bs​ meson) lead surprisingly to ranges comparable to those put forward by Adler [J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 40, 2935 (2007)] and Ghirardi, Rimini, and Weber [Phys. Rev. D 34, 470 (1986)]. Our results show that these systems at high energies are very sensitive to possible modifications of the standard quantum theory, making them a very powerful laboratory to rule out certain collapse scenarios and study the detailed physical processes solving the measurement problem.
Spontaneous collapse models aim to resolve the measurement problem in quantum mechanics by considering wave-function collapse as a physical process. We analyze how these models affect a decaying flavor-oscillating system whose evolution is governed by a phenomenological non-Hermitian Hamiltonian. In turn, we apply two popular collapse models, the Quantum Mechanics with Universal Position Localization and the Continuous Spontaneous Localization models, to a neutral meson system. By using the equivalence between the approaches to the time evolution of decaying systems with a non-Hermitian Hamiltonian and a dissipator of the Lindblad form in an enlarged Hilbert space, we show that spontaneous collapse can induce the decay dynamics in both quantum state and master equations. Moreover, we show that the decay property of a flavor-oscillating system is intimately connected to the time (a)symmetry of the noise field underlying the collapse mechanism. This (a)symmetry, in turn, is related to the definition of the stochastic integral and can provide a physical intuition behind the It\ifmmode \bar{o}\else \={o}\fi{}-Stratonovich dilemma in stochastic calculus.
Why do we never see a table in a superposition of here and there? This problem gets a solution by so called collapse models assuming the collapse as a genuinely physical process. Here we consider two specific collapse models and apply them to systems at high energies, i.e. flavour oscillating neutral meson systems. We find on one hand a potentially new interpretation of the decay rates introduced by hand in the standard formalism and on the other hand that these systems at high energies constrain by experimental data the possible collapse scenarios.
We set up a general formalism for models of spontaneous wave function collapse with dynamics represented by a stochastic differential equation driven by general Gaussian noises, not necessarily white in time. In particular, we show that the non-Schrodinger terms of the equation induce the collapse of the wave function to one of the common eigenstates of the collapsing operators, and that the collapse occurs with the correct quantum probabilities. We also develop a perturbation expansion of the solution of the equation with respect to the parameter which sets the strength of the collapse process; such an approximation allows one to compute the leading order terms for the deviations of the predictions of collapse models with respect to those of standard quantum mechanics. This analysis shows that to leading order, the ``imaginary'' noise trick can be used for non-white Gaussian noise.
A simple and natural introduction to the concept and formalism of spontaneous wave function collapse can and should be based on textbook knowledge of standard quantum state collapse and monitoring. This approach explains the origin of noise driving the paradigmatic stochastic Schrödinger equations of spontaneous localization of the wave function ΨΨΨ. It reveals, on the other hand, that these equations are empirically redundant and the master equations of the noise-averaged state ρ^\hatρρ^​ are the only empirically testable dynamics in current spontaneous collapse theories.