Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1709.09303 · Physical Review A

Exact path-integral evaluation of locally interacting systems: The subtlety of operator ordering

Nobuhiko Taniguchi

Published Oct 10, 2017• 9 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We discuss how one calculates the coherent path integrals for locally interacting systems, where some inconsistencies with exact results have been reported previously. It is shown that the operator ordering subtlety that is hidden in the local interaction term modifies the Hubbard-Stratonovich transformation in the continuous time formulation, and it helps reproduce known results by the operator method. We also demonstrate that many-body effects in the strong interaction limit can be well characterized by the free-particle theory that is subject to annealed random potentials and dynamical gauge (or phase) fields. The present treatment expands the conventional paradigm of the one-particle description, and it provides a simple, viable picture for strongly correlated materials of either bosonic or fermionic systems.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.96.042105

Related papers

Hubbard–Stratonovich transformation and consistent ordering in the coherent state path integral: insights from stochastic calculus

Adam Rançon

Abstract Recently, doubts have been cast on the validity of the continuous-time coherent state path integral. This has led to controversies regarding the correct way of performing calculations with path integrals, and to several alternative definitions of what should be their continuous limit. Furthermore, the issue of a supposedly proper ordering of the Hamiltonian operator, entangled with the continuous-time limit, has led to considerable confusion in the literature. Since coherent state path integrals are at the basis of the modern formulation of many-body quantum theory, it should be laid on solid foundations. Here, we show that the issues raised above are coming from the illegitimate use of the (standard) rules of calculus, which are not necessarily valid in path integrals. This is well known in the context of stochastic equations, in particular in their path integral formulation. This insight allows for solving these issues and addressing the correspondence between the various orderings at the level of the path integral. We also use this opportunity to address the proper calculation of a functional determinant in the presence of a Hubbard–Stratonovich field, which shares in the controversies.

arXiv:1906.02571•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Jan 17, 2020•8 citations

Coherent-state path integrals in quantum thermodynamics

Luca Salasnich, Cesare Vianello

In these notes, we elucidate some subtle aspects of coherent-state path integrals, focusing on their application to the equilibrium thermodynamics of quantum many-particle systems. These subtleties emerge when evaluating path integrals in the continuum, either in imaginary time or in Matsubara-frequency space. Our central message is that, when handled with due care, the path integral yields results identical to those obtained from the canonical Hamiltonian approach. We illustrate this through a pedagogical treatment of several paradigmatic systems: the bosonic and fermionic harmonic oscillators, the single-site Bose-Hubbard and Hubbard models, the weakly-interacting Bose gas with finite-range interactions, and the BCS superconductor with finite-range interactions.

arXiv:2511.11547•SciPost Physics Lecture Notes•Feb 18, 2026•2 citations

Path Integral Methods for Single Band Hubbard Model

N. Heydari, S. Azakov

We review various ways to express the partition function of the single-band Hubard model as a path integral. The emphasis is made on the derivation of the action in the integrand of the path integral and the results obtained from this approach are discussed only briefly. Since the single-band Hubbard model is a pure fermionic model on the lattice and its Hamiltonian is a polynomial in creation and annihilation fermionic operators, with the help of the fermionic coherent states of holomorphic representions the partition function of the model can be straightforwardly expressed as a path integral with respect to Grassmann fields. Then the question arises how to calculate this path integral specially in the most interesting case of the strong coupling, which is described by the term quartic in the fermion fields. The standard way to get rid of this quartic term is to use so-called Hubbard-Stratonovich transformation by introducing auxilary boson field (this procedure is usually called bosonization). Since there are several equivalent forms of the interaction term in the single-band Hubbard model the bosonization procedure is not unique. In the first section of the article we discuss two types of bosoniztions one with two real scalar fields (charge and spin fields) and another with a real vector field. The second section is devoted to a spin-rotation-invariant bosonization procedure invented by Schulz and Weng, Ting and Lee, where an arbitary quantization axis is introduced at each point in space and time and an integration over all possible orientations enters the path integral measure. Spin rotation invariant formulation is necessary to study e.g. spiral magnetization. In the third section we present the contstruction of a path integral for the partition function when the single-band Hubbard Hamiltonian is written in terms of the Hubbard operators, which are elements of the doubly graded semi-simple algebra. In this case one should use generalized coherent states for superalgebra in order to get a path integral formulation. We follow the procedure proposed recently by T ngler and Kopp, to investigate the case of strong coupling.

•Apr 1, 1997•0 citations

Quantum Monte Carlo Method without Hubbard-Stratonovich Transformation for Many-body Systems

J. Wang, Weiwei Pan, D. Y. Sun

By precisely writing down the matrix element of the local Boltzmann operator ($e^(-{\tau}h$), where h is the paired operator formed by two interacting terms conjugate to each other), we have proposed a new path integral formulation for quantum field theory and developed a corresponding Monte Carlo algorithm. Our formula presents remarkable outcomes such that: 1) the Hubbard-Stratonovich transformation is not necessary, and the auxiliary field is no longer needed, which can improve the computational efficiency. 2) The new formula improves the accuracy of the Suzuki-Trotter decomposition. Our method also provides a potential theoretical framework for analyzing and solving the fermion sign problem. As an example, we studied the one-dimensional half-filled Hubbard model at a finite temperature. The obtained results were in excellent agreement with the known solutions. The new formula and Monte Carlo algorithm could be used in various studies.

•Oct 17, 2021•0 citations

Coherent state path integral approach to correlated electron systems with deformed Hubbard operators: from Fermi liquid to Mott insulator

Xiao-Yong Feng, Jianhui Dai

In strongly correlated electron systems the constraint which prohibits the double electron occupation at local sites can be realized by either the infinite Coulomb interaction or the correlated hopping interaction described by the Hubbard operators, but they both render the conventional field theory inapplicable. Relaxing such the constraint leads to a class of correlated hopping models based on the deformed Hubbard operators which smoothly interpolate the locally free and strong coupling limits by a tunable interaction parameter $0\leq λ\leq 1$. Here we propose a coherent state path integral approach appropriate to the deformed Hubbard operators for {\it arbitrary} $λ$. It is shown that this model system exhibits the correlated Fermi liquid behavior characterized by the enhanced Wilson ratio for all $λ$. It is further found that in the presence of on-site Coulomb interaction a finite Mott gap appears between the upper and lower Hubbard bands, with the upper band spectral weight being heavily reduced by $λ$. Our approach stands in general spatial dimensions and reveals an unexpected interplay between the correlated hopping and the Coulomb repulsion.

arXiv:1904.12499•Apr 29, 2019•1 citation

Functional Integrals for Correlated Electrons

Heinz J. Schulz

The application of functional integral methods and the Hubbard--Stratonovich transformation to the Hubbard model is discussed. For the attractive case, using a simple gauge transformation of the superconducting order parameter field, the effective action for the low-energy phase excitations is derived. Inclusion of the electromagnetic field is straightforward. For the repulsive case at half--filling use of a fluctuating spin reference frame allows a derivation of the effective nonlinear sigma model for arbitrary coupling strength U. Results for the spin-wave velocity and the spin stiffness are obtained for arbitrary U. Away from half--filling, at large U an effective action for doped fermions and the spins is found which is related to the slave fermion formulation of the correlated fermion problem. The formalism is generalized to include the full SU(2)xSU(2) symmetry of the Hubbard model. This allows the derivation of a Ginzburg-Landau like theory that includes both particle-hole and particle-particle excitations. (paper at the NATO workshop on the Hubbard model, San Sebastian, Spain, oct. 1993)

arXiv:cond-mat/9402103•Feb 24, 1994•9 citations
We discuss how one calculates the coherent path integrals for locally interacting systems, where some inconsistencies with exact results have been reported previously. It is shown that the operator ordering subtlety that is hidden in the local interaction term modifies the Hubbard-Stratonovich transformation in the continuous time formulation, and it helps reproduce known results by the operator method. We also demonstrate that many-body effects in the strong interaction limit can be well characterized by the free-particle theory that is subject to annealed random potentials and dynamical gauge (or phase) fields. The present treatment expands the conventional paradigm of the one-particle description, and it provides a simple, viable picture for strongly correlated materials of either bosonic or fermionic systems.
Abstract Recently, doubts have been cast on the validity of the continuous-time coherent state path integral. This has led to controversies regarding the correct way of performing calculations with path integrals, and to several alternative definitions of what should be their continuous limit. Furthermore, the issue of a supposedly proper ordering of the Hamiltonian operator, entangled with the continuous-time limit, has led to considerable confusion in the literature. Since coherent state path integrals are at the basis of the modern formulation of many-body quantum theory, it should be laid on solid foundations. Here, we show that the issues raised above are coming from the illegitimate use of the (standard) rules of calculus, which are not necessarily valid in path integrals. This is well known in the context of stochastic equations, in particular in their path integral formulation. This insight allows for solving these issues and addressing the correspondence between the various orderings at the level of the path integral. We also use this opportunity to address the proper calculation of a functional determinant in the presence of a Hubbard–Stratonovich field, which shares in the controversies.
In these notes, we elucidate some subtle aspects of coherent-state path integrals, focusing on their application to the equilibrium thermodynamics of quantum many-particle systems. These subtleties emerge when evaluating path integrals in the continuum, either in imaginary time or in Matsubara-frequency space. Our central message is that, when handled with due care, the path integral yields results identical to those obtained from the canonical Hamiltonian approach. We illustrate this through a pedagogical treatment of several paradigmatic systems: the bosonic and fermionic harmonic oscillators, the single-site Bose-Hubbard and Hubbard models, the weakly-interacting Bose gas with finite-range interactions, and the BCS superconductor with finite-range interactions.
We review various ways to express the partition function of the single-band Hubard model as a path integral. The emphasis is made on the derivation of the action in the integrand of the path integral and the results obtained from this approach are discussed only briefly. Since the single-band Hubbard model is a pure fermionic model on the lattice and its Hamiltonian is a polynomial in creation and annihilation fermionic operators, with the help of the fermionic coherent states of holomorphic representions the partition function of the model can be straightforwardly expressed as a path integral with respect to Grassmann fields. Then the question arises how to calculate this path integral specially in the most interesting case of the strong coupling, which is described by the term quartic in the fermion fields. The standard way to get rid of this quartic term is to use so-called Hubbard-Stratonovich transformation by introducing auxilary boson field (this procedure is usually called bosonization). Since there are several equivalent forms of the interaction term in the single-band Hubbard model the bosonization procedure is not unique. In the first section of the article we discuss two types of bosoniztions one with two real scalar fields (charge and spin fields) and another with a real vector field. The second section is devoted to a spin-rotation-invariant bosonization procedure invented by Schulz and Weng, Ting and Lee, where an arbitary quantization axis is introduced at each point in space and time and an integration over all possible orientations enters the path integral measure. Spin rotation invariant formulation is necessary to study e.g. spiral magnetization. In the third section we present the contstruction of a path integral for the partition function when the single-band Hubbard Hamiltonian is written in terms of the Hubbard operators, which are elements of the doubly graded semi-simple algebra. In this case one should use generalized coherent states for superalgebra in order to get a path integral formulation. We follow the procedure proposed recently by T ngler and Kopp, to investigate the case of strong coupling.
By precisely writing down the matrix element of the local Boltzmann operator (e(−τhe^(-{\tau}he(−τh), where h is the paired operator formed by two interacting terms conjugate to each other), we have proposed a new path integral formulation for quantum field theory and developed a corresponding Monte Carlo algorithm. Our formula presents remarkable outcomes such that: 1) the Hubbard-Stratonovich transformation is not necessary, and the auxiliary field is no longer needed, which can improve the computational efficiency. 2) The new formula improves the accuracy of the Suzuki-Trotter decomposition. Our method also provides a potential theoretical framework for analyzing and solving the fermion sign problem. As an example, we studied the one-dimensional half-filled Hubbard model at a finite temperature. The obtained results were in excellent agreement with the known solutions. The new formula and Monte Carlo algorithm could be used in various studies.
In strongly correlated electron systems the constraint which prohibits the double electron occupation at local sites can be realized by either the infinite Coulomb interaction or the correlated hopping interaction described by the Hubbard operators, but they both render the conventional field theory inapplicable. Relaxing such the constraint leads to a class of correlated hopping models based on the deformed Hubbard operators which smoothly interpolate the locally free and strong coupling limits by a tunable interaction parameter 0≤λ≤10\leq λ\leq 10≤λ≤1. Here we propose a coherent state path integral approach appropriate to the deformed Hubbard operators for {\it arbitrary} λλλ. It is shown that this model system exhibits the correlated Fermi liquid behavior characterized by the enhanced Wilson ratio for all λλλ. It is further found that in the presence of on-site Coulomb interaction a finite Mott gap appears between the upper and lower Hubbard bands, with the upper band spectral weight being heavily reduced by λλλ. Our approach stands in general spatial dimensions and reveals an unexpected interplay between the correlated hopping and the Coulomb repulsion.
The application of functional integral methods and the Hubbard--Stratonovich transformation to the Hubbard model is discussed. For the attractive case, using a simple gauge transformation of the superconducting order parameter field, the effective action for the low-energy phase excitations is derived. Inclusion of the electromagnetic field is straightforward. For the repulsive case at half--filling use of a fluctuating spin reference frame allows a derivation of the effective nonlinear sigma model for arbitrary coupling strength U. Results for the spin-wave velocity and the spin stiffness are obtained for arbitrary U. Away from half--filling, at large U an effective action for doped fermions and the spins is found which is related to the slave fermion formulation of the correlated fermion problem. The formalism is generalized to include the full SU(2)xSU(2) symmetry of the Hubbard model. This allows the derivation of a Ginzburg-Landau like theory that includes both particle-hole and particle-particle excitations. (paper at the NATO workshop on the Hubbard model, San Sebastian, Spain, oct. 1993)