Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1709.01030 · Physical Review Applied

Low-Latency Digital Signal Processing for Feedback and Feedforward in Quantum Computing and Communication

Yves Salathé, Philipp Kurpiers, Thomas M. Karg, Claus Lang, Christian Kraglund Andersen, Abdulkadir Akın, Sebastian Krinner, Christopher Eichler, Andreas J. Wallraff

Published Mar 16, 2018• 85 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Feedback is a main component of many algorithms for quantum computing and communication. A key requirement for any quantum feedback scheme is that the $l\phantom{\rule{0}{0ex}}a\phantom{\rule{0}{0ex}}t\phantom{\rule{0}{0ex}}e\phantom{\rule{0}{0ex}}n\phantom{\rule{0}{0ex}}c\phantom{\rule{0}{0ex}}y$ of the feedback loop ($i.e.$ the time between beginning to measure a state and the end of feedback action on the state) must be significantly shorter than the coherence time of the system. In this work a superconducting qubit is initialized in its ground state by active feedback, using a field-programmable gate array (FPGA) with very short latency. This in-depth discussion of the FPGA-based processing unit provides a useful reference for future development of feedback electronics for quantum systems.

DOI
10.1103/physrevapplied.9.034011

Related papers

Low-latency readout electronics for dynamic superconducting quantum computing

Cheng Guo, Jin Lin, Lianchen Han +9 more

Dynamic quantum computing can support quantum error correction circuits to build a large general-purpose quantum computer, which requires electronic instruments to perform the closed-loop operation of readout, processing, and control within 1% of the qubit coherence time. In this paper, we present low-latency readout electronics for dynamic superconducting quantum computing. The readout electronics use a low-latency analog-to-digital converter to capture analog signals, a field-programmable gate array (FPGA) to process digital signals, and the general I/O resources of the FPGA to forward the readout results. Running an algorithm based on the design of multichannel parallelism and single instruction multiple data on an FPGA, the readout electronics achieve a readout latency of 40 ns from the last sample input to the readout valid output. The feedback data link for cross-instrument communication shows a communication latency of 48 ns when 16 bits of data are transmitted over a 2 m-length cable using a homologous clock to drive the transceiver. With codeword-based triggering mechanisms, readout electronics can be used in dynamic superconducting quantum computing.

AIP Advances•Apr 1, 2022•11 citations

Demonstrating real-time feedback that enhances the performance of measurement sequence with cat states in a cavity

Nissim Ofek, Andrei Petrenko, Y. Liu +9 more

back offers not just the convenience of streamlined data acquisition, but is an essential element in any quantum computational architecture that requires branching based on measurement outcomes. State-preparation, mitigating the effects of qubit decoherence, and recording the trajectories of quantum systems are just a few of the many potential applications of real-time feedback. Photon number parity measurements of cat states in superconducting resonators are a particularly useful platform for demonstrating the clear advantages of having sophisticated feedback schemes to enhance the performance a proposed error-correction protocol [Leghtas et.al. PRL 2013]. In a cQED architecture, where a transmon qubit is coupled to two superconducting cavities, we present a field-programmable gate array (FPGA) device capable of making decisions and calculations with latency times far shorter than the lifetimes of any of the system’s constituents. This level of performance opens the door to realizing many complex, previously unfeasible, experiments in superconducting qubit systems.

Bulletin of the American Physical Society•Mar 6, 2015•1 citation

An FPGA-Based Low Latency AWG for Superconducting Quantum Computers

Yuchen Yang, Zhongtao Shen, Xing Zhu +3 more

This paper reports the development of a low-latency arbitrary waveform generator (AWG), which is suitable for the control and measurement of superconducting quantum computers. It can generate qubit control signals and measurement signals in real time. Compared with commercial AWG, our AWG has less latency and higher analog bandwidth. Compressing latency can reduce system feedback time, and higher analog bandwidth improves the system's integration by mounting more qubits on the readout line. The AWG integrates four high-speed digital-to-analog converters (DACs), phase-locked loop (PLL) circuits, field-programmable gate arrays (FPGAs), and related circuits into a standard PXI 3U board. The waveform generator module, communication interface module, clock module, and configuration module are realized utilizing the FPGA. The FPGA-based hardware architecture enables AWG to be flexibly configured to meet the various needs of quantum experiments. The four-channel AWG has a 2-GSa/s sampling rate, a 14-bit resolution, and 500 MHz bandwidth. The jitter in the AWG output waveform is approximately 3 ps; the latency of the AWG (the time from the feedback trigger received until a feedback pulse is generated) is approximately 55 ns. These designs form the basis of realizing control system for large-scale quantum computing.

IEEE International Instrumentation and Measurement Technology Conference•May 17, 2021•7 citations

Demonstrating real-time and low-latency quantum error correction with superconducting qubits

Laura Caune, Luka Skorić, Nick S. Blunt +22 more

Quantum error correction will be essential for quantum computers to realise their full potential. As quantum computers advance towards demonstrating a universal fault-tolerant logical gate set, implementing scalable and low-latency real-time decoding will be crucial to avoid an exponential slowdown and maintain a fast logical clock rate. Here, we demonstrate low-latency feedback with a scalable FPGA decoder integrated into the control system of a superconducting quantum processor. We perform an 8-qubit stability experiment with up to 25 decoding rounds and a sub-microsecond mean decoding time per round, providing strong evidence that the backlog problem will be avoided when the decoder is operated as a streaming decoder on a superconducting hardware with the strictest speed requirements. We observe logical error suppression as the number of decoding rounds is increased. We also implement and time a fast-feedback experiment demonstrating a decoding response time of 9.6 μs for a total of 9 measurement rounds.

arXiv:2410.05202•Nature Communications•Jun 1, 2026•84 citations

Low-Latency Digital Feedback for Stochastic Quantum Calibration Using Cryogenic CMOS

Nathan Eli Miller, Laith A. Shamieh, Saibal Mukhopadhyay

In order to develop quantum computing systems towards practically useful applications, their physical quantum bits (qubits) must be able to operate with minimal error. Recent work has demonstrated stochastic gate calibration protocols for quantum systems which are meant to track drifting control parameters and tune gate operations to high fidelity. These protocols critically rely on low-latency feedback between the quantum system and its classical control hardware, which is impossible without on-board classical compute from FPGAs or ASICs. In this work, we analyze the performance of a single-shot stochastic calibration protocol for indefinite outcome quantum circuits under various latency conditions based on timing considerations from experimental quantum systems. We also demonstrate the benefits that can be achieved with ASIC implementation of the protocol by synthesizing the classical control logic in a 28 nm CMOS design node, with simulations extended to 14 nm FinFET and at both room and cryogenic temperatures. We show that these classes of quantum calibration protocols can be easily implemented within contemporary control system architectures for low-latency performance without significant power or resource utilization, allowing for the rapid tuning and drift control of any gate-model quantum system towards fault-tolerant computation.

Design, Automation, and Test in Europe•Mar 31, 2025•1 citation

Realizing a deep reinforcement learning agent for real-time quantum feedback

Kevin Reuer, Jonas Landgraf, Thomas Fösel +10 more

Realizing the full potential of quantum technologies requires precise real-time control on time scales much shorter than the coherence time. Model-free reinforcement learning promises to discover efficient feedback strategies from scratch without relying on a description of the quantum system. However, developing and training a reinforcement learning agent able to operate in real-time using feedback has been an open challenge. Here, we have implemented such an agent for a single qubit as a sub-microsecond-latency neural network on a field-programmable gate array (FPGA). We demonstrate its use to efficiently initialize a superconducting qubit and train the agent based solely on measurements. Our work is a first step towards adoption of reinforcement learning for the control of quantum devices and more generally any physical device requiring low-latency feedback.

arXiv:2210.16715•Nature Communications•Nov 6, 2023•81 citations
Feedback is a main component of many algorithms for quantum computing and communication. A key requirement for any quantum feedback scheme is that the l\phantom{\rule{0}{0ex}}a\phantom{\rule{0}{0ex}}t\phantom{\rule{0}{0ex}}e\phantom{\rule{0}{0ex}}n\phantom{\rule{0}{0ex}}c\phantom{\rule{0}{0ex}}y of the feedback loop (i.e.i.e.i.e. the time between beginning to measure a state and the end of feedback action on the state) must be significantly shorter than the coherence time of the system. In this work a superconducting qubit is initialized in its ground state by active feedback, using a field-programmable gate array (FPGA) with very short latency. This in-depth discussion of the FPGA-based processing unit provides a useful reference for future development of feedback electronics for quantum systems.
Dynamic quantum computing can support quantum error correction circuits to build a large general-purpose quantum computer, which requires electronic instruments to perform the closed-loop operation of readout, processing, and control within 1% of the qubit coherence time. In this paper, we present low-latency readout electronics for dynamic superconducting quantum computing. The readout electronics use a low-latency analog-to-digital converter to capture analog signals, a field-programmable gate array (FPGA) to process digital signals, and the general I/O resources of the FPGA to forward the readout results. Running an algorithm based on the design of multichannel parallelism and single instruction multiple data on an FPGA, the readout electronics achieve a readout latency of 40 ns from the last sample input to the readout valid output. The feedback data link for cross-instrument communication shows a communication latency of 48 ns when 16 bits of data are transmitted over a 2 m-length cable using a homologous clock to drive the transceiver. With codeword-based triggering mechanisms, readout electronics can be used in dynamic superconducting quantum computing.
back offers not just the convenience of streamlined data acquisition, but is an essential element in any quantum computational architecture that requires branching based on measurement outcomes. State-preparation, mitigating the effects of qubit decoherence, and recording the trajectories of quantum systems are just a few of the many potential applications of real-time feedback. Photon number parity measurements of cat states in superconducting resonators are a particularly useful platform for demonstrating the clear advantages of having sophisticated feedback schemes to enhance the performance a proposed error-correction protocol [Leghtas et.al. PRL 2013]. In a cQED architecture, where a transmon qubit is coupled to two superconducting cavities, we present a field-programmable gate array (FPGA) device capable of making decisions and calculations with latency times far shorter than the lifetimes of any of the system’s constituents. This level of performance opens the door to realizing many complex, previously unfeasible, experiments in superconducting qubit systems.
This paper reports the development of a low-latency arbitrary waveform generator (AWG), which is suitable for the control and measurement of superconducting quantum computers. It can generate qubit control signals and measurement signals in real time. Compared with commercial AWG, our AWG has less latency and higher analog bandwidth. Compressing latency can reduce system feedback time, and higher analog bandwidth improves the system's integration by mounting more qubits on the readout line. The AWG integrates four high-speed digital-to-analog converters (DACs), phase-locked loop (PLL) circuits, field-programmable gate arrays (FPGAs), and related circuits into a standard PXI 3U board. The waveform generator module, communication interface module, clock module, and configuration module are realized utilizing the FPGA. The FPGA-based hardware architecture enables AWG to be flexibly configured to meet the various needs of quantum experiments. The four-channel AWG has a 2-GSa/s sampling rate, a 14-bit resolution, and 500 MHz bandwidth. The jitter in the AWG output waveform is approximately 3 ps; the latency of the AWG (the time from the feedback trigger received until a feedback pulse is generated) is approximately 55 ns. These designs form the basis of realizing control system for large-scale quantum computing.
Quantum error correction will be essential for quantum computers to realise their full potential. As quantum computers advance towards demonstrating a universal fault-tolerant logical gate set, implementing scalable and low-latency real-time decoding will be crucial to avoid an exponential slowdown and maintain a fast logical clock rate. Here, we demonstrate low-latency feedback with a scalable FPGA decoder integrated into the control system of a superconducting quantum processor. We perform an 8-qubit stability experiment with up to 25 decoding rounds and a sub-microsecond mean decoding time per round, providing strong evidence that the backlog problem will be avoided when the decoder is operated as a streaming decoder on a superconducting hardware with the strictest speed requirements. We observe logical error suppression as the number of decoding rounds is increased. We also implement and time a fast-feedback experiment demonstrating a decoding response time of 9.6 μs for a total of 9 measurement rounds.
In order to develop quantum computing systems towards practically useful applications, their physical quantum bits (qubits) must be able to operate with minimal error. Recent work has demonstrated stochastic gate calibration protocols for quantum systems which are meant to track drifting control parameters and tune gate operations to high fidelity. These protocols critically rely on low-latency feedback between the quantum system and its classical control hardware, which is impossible without on-board classical compute from FPGAs or ASICs. In this work, we analyze the performance of a single-shot stochastic calibration protocol for indefinite outcome quantum circuits under various latency conditions based on timing considerations from experimental quantum systems. We also demonstrate the benefits that can be achieved with ASIC implementation of the protocol by synthesizing the classical control logic in a 28 nm CMOS design node, with simulations extended to 14 nm FinFET and at both room and cryogenic temperatures. We show that these classes of quantum calibration protocols can be easily implemented within contemporary control system architectures for low-latency performance without significant power or resource utilization, allowing for the rapid tuning and drift control of any gate-model quantum system towards fault-tolerant computation.
Realizing the full potential of quantum technologies requires precise real-time control on time scales much shorter than the coherence time. Model-free reinforcement learning promises to discover efficient feedback strategies from scratch without relying on a description of the quantum system. However, developing and training a reinforcement learning agent able to operate in real-time using feedback has been an open challenge. Here, we have implemented such an agent for a single qubit as a sub-microsecond-latency neural network on a field-programmable gate array (FPGA). We demonstrate its use to efficiently initialize a superconducting qubit and train the agent based solely on measurements. Our work is a first step towards adoption of reinforcement learning for the control of quantum devices and more generally any physical device requiring low-latency feedback.