Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1708.08460 · SciPost Physics

Absence of Luttinger's theorem for fermions with power-law Green functions

Kridsanaphong Limtragool, Zhidong Leong, Philip Phillips

Published Nov 16, 2018• 7 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We investigate the validity of Luttinger’s theorem (or Luttinger sum rule) in two scale-invariant fermionic models. We find that, in general, Luttinger’s theorem does not hold in a system of fermions with power-law Green functions which do not necessarily preserve particle-hole symmetry. However, Ref. [1,2] showed that Luttinger liquids, another scale-invariant fermionic model, respect Luttinger’s theorem. To understand the difference, we examine the spinless Luttinger liquid model. We find two properties which make the Luttinger sum rule valid in this model: particle-hole symmetry and lmG(\omega=0,-\infty)=0 l m G ( ω = 0 , − ∞ ) = 0 . We conjecture that these two properties represent sufficient, but not necessary, conditions for the validity of the Luttinger sum rule in condensed matter systems.

DOI
10.21468/scipostphys.5.5.049

Related papers

Necessary and sufficient conditions for the validity of Luttinger’s theorem

Joshuah T. Heath, Kevin S Bedell

Abstract Luttinger’s theorem is a major result in many-body physics that states the volume of the Fermi surface is directly proportional to the particle density. In its ‘hard’ form, Luttinger’s theorem implies that the Fermi volume is invariant with respect to interactions (as opposed to a ‘soft’ Luttinger’s theorem, where this invariance is lost). Despite it is simplicity, the conditions on the fermionic self energy under which Luttinger’s theorem is valid remains a matter of debate, with possible requirements for its validity ranging from particle-hole symmetry to analyticity about the Fermi surface. In this paper, we propose the minimal requirements for the application of a hard Luttinger’s theorem to a generic fermionic system of arbitrary interaction strength by invoking the Atiyah–Singer index theorem to quantify the topologically-robust behavior of a generalized Fermi surface. We show that the applicability of a hard Luttinger’s theorem in a D-dimensional system is directly dependent on the existence of a (D − 1)-dimensional manifold of gapless chiral excitations at the Fermi level, regardless of whether the system exhibits Luttinger or Fermi surfaces (i.e., manifolds of zeroes of the Green’s function and inverse Green’s function, respectively). The exact form of the self-energy which guarantees validity of a hard Luttinger’s theorem is derived, and agreement with current experiments, numerics, and theories are discussed.

arXiv:1906.00929•New Journal of Physics•Apr 14, 2020•35 citations

Topological interpretation of the Luttinger theorem

Kazuhiro Seki, Seiji Yunoki

Based solely on the analytical properties of the single-particle Green's function of fermions at finite temperatures, we show that the generalized Luttinger theorem inherently possesses topological aspects. The topological interpretation of the generalized Luttinger theorem can be introduced because (i) the Luttinger volume is represented as the winding number of the single-particle Green's function and, thus, (ii) the deviation of the theorem, expressed with a ratio between the interacting and noninteracting single-particle Green's functions, is also represented as the winding number of this ratio. The formulation based on the winding number naturally leads to two types of the generalized Luttinger theorem. Exploring two examples of single-band translationally invariant interacting electrons, i.e., simple metal and Mott insulator, we show that the first type falls into the original statement for Fermi liquids given by Luttinger, where poles of the single-particle Green's function appear at the chemical potential, while the second type corresponds to the extended one for nonmetallic cases with no Fermi surface such as insulators and superconductors generalized by Dzyaloshinskii, where zeros of the single-particle Green's function appear at the chemical potential. This formulation also allows us to derive a sufficient condition for the validity of the Luttinger theorem of the first type by applying the Rouche's theorem in complex analysis as an inequality. Moreover, we can rigorously prove in a nonperturbative manner, without assuming any detail of a microscopic Hamiltonian, that the generalized Luttinger theorem of both types is valid for generic interacting fermions as long as the particle-hole symmetry is preserved. Finally, we show that the winding number of the single-particle Green's function can also be associated with the distribution function of quasiparticles, and therefore the number of quasiparticles is equal to the Luttinger volume. This implies that the fundamental hypothesis of the Landau's Fermi-liquid theory, the number of fermions being equal to that of quasiparticles, is guaranteed if the Luttinger theorem is valid since the theorem states that the number of fermions is equal to the Luttinger volume. All these general statements are made possible because of the finding that the Luttinger volume is expressed as the winding number of the single-particle Green's function at finite temperatures, for which the complex analysis can be readily exploited.

arXiv:1708.00986•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Aug 18, 2017•49 citations

Derivation of the Luttinger theorem

Richard M. Martin, Lucia Reining, David M. Ceperley

This appendix summarizes the arguments of the papers by Luttinger and Ward to derive the Luttinger theorem that is stated in Sec. 3.6. This is not a proof that the theorem applies to all possible states of a crystal; it is the derivation of arguments that it applies to all states that can be analytically continued from some non-interacting system, i.e., a “normal state of matter” as defined in Sec. 3.4. The derivation is an example of the use of the T ≠ 0 Green's functions in App. D and the conclusions for T = 0. The Luttinger theorem is a cornerstone in the theory of condensed matter. As described qualitatively in Sec. 3.6, it requires that the volume enclosed by the Fermi surface is conserved independent of interactions, i.e., it is the same as for a system of non-interacting particles. Similarly, the Friedel sum rule is the requirement that the sum of phase shifts around an impurity is determined by charge neutrality, which was derived by Friedel [163] for non-interacting electrons. This section is devoted to a short summary of the original work of Luttinger and Ward and the extension of the arguments to the Freidel sum rule [166]. Here we explicitly indicate the chemical potential μ , since the variation from μ is essential to the arguments. There are two key points: in the interacting system the wavevector in the Brillouin zone k is conserved so that excitations can be labeled k , and the self-energy ∑ k ( ω ) is purely real at the Fermi energy ω = μ at temperature T = 0. The latter point is an essential feature of a Fermi liquid or a “normal metal,” which is justified by the argument that the phase space for scattering at T = 0 vanishes as ω → μ (see Sec. 7.5). Thus, at the Fermi energy the Green's function as a function of k is the same as for an independent-particle problem with eigenvalues. (Of course, for an interacting system at any other energy cannot be described by independent particles.) In an independent-particle system at T = 0 the occupation numbers jump from 1 to 0 as a function of k at the Fermi surface, and in the interacting system there is still a discontinuity in n k that defines the surface (Sec. 7.5).

Cambridge University Press eBooks•May 31, 2016•1 citation

Nonuniversality of the one-particle Green’s function of a Luttinger liquid

V. Meden

The one-particle Green's function of the Tomonaga-Luttinger model for one-dimensional interacting electrons is discussed. For certain directions within the plane of space-time coordinates the exponent of the asymptotic power law decay is not given by the Luttinger liquid parameters ${K}_{\ensuremath{\rho}}$ and ${K}_{\ensuremath{\sigma}}.$ The consequences for Luttinger liquids in general and their spectral properties are discussed.

arXiv:cond-mat/9810336•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Aug 15, 1999•44 citations

Breakdown of the Luttinger sum rule within the Mott-Hubbard insulator

J. Kokalj, Peter Prelovšek

The validity of the Luttinger sum rule is investigated within the prototype tight-binding model of interacting fermions in one dimension, i.e., the $t\text{\ensuremath{-}}V$ model including the next-nearest-neighbor hopping ${t}^{\ensuremath{'}}$, in order to break the particle-hole symmetry. Scaling analysis of finite-system results at half filling reveals evident breakdown of the sum rule in the large gap regime at $V⪢t$ while the sum rule appears to recover together with vanishing of the Mott-Hubbard gap.

arXiv:0803.4468•Physical Review B•Oct 9, 2008•16 citations

A pole in the self-energy does not always imply a violation of the Luttinger theorem

Ar. Abanov, Andrey V. Chubukov

Luttinger theorem relates Fermi surface volume to electron density per spin $n$. It holds in an arbitrary Fermi liquid but is widely believed to break when a fermionic self-energy has a pole. We show that this is not necessarily the case. As an example, we consider a fermionic system consisting of two gapped bands, originating from a self-energy $Σ(ω, \mathbf{k})$ with a pole, and a narrow residual quasiparticle band crossing $ω=0$, with a small residue $Z \ll 1$ (a residual Fermi liquid). We consider Model I, in which $Z$ also renormalizes quasiparticle bandwidth $W$ to $ZW$ and Model II, in which $W$ remains unrenormalized. The Green's function for such a system $G(ω, \mathbf{k})$ contains two zeros and three poles --- one from the quasiparticle band and two from the gapped bands. Yet, we show that in Model I, the Luttinger-Ward analysis is fully applicable for any $Z >0$, and the results are exactly the same as if the gapped bands did not exist. For Model II, the Luttinger-Ward analysis recovers once $Z$ exceeds some critical value, which depends on fermionic density.

arXiv:2610.04663•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Nov 10, 2026•0 citations
We investigate the validity of Luttinger’s theorem (or Luttinger sum rule) in two scale-invariant fermionic models. We find that, in general, Luttinger’s theorem does not hold in a system of fermions with power-law Green functions which do not necessarily preserve particle-hole symmetry. However, Ref. [1,2] showed that Luttinger liquids, another scale-invariant fermionic model, respect Luttinger’s theorem. To understand the difference, we examine the spinless Luttinger liquid model. We find two properties which make the Luttinger sum rule valid in this model: particle-hole symmetry and lmG(\omega=0,-\infty)=0 l m G ( ω = 0 , − ∞ ) = 0 . We conjecture that these two properties represent sufficient, but not necessary, conditions for the validity of the Luttinger sum rule in condensed matter systems.
Abstract Luttinger’s theorem is a major result in many-body physics that states the volume of the Fermi surface is directly proportional to the particle density. In its ‘hard’ form, Luttinger’s theorem implies that the Fermi volume is invariant with respect to interactions (as opposed to a ‘soft’ Luttinger’s theorem, where this invariance is lost). Despite it is simplicity, the conditions on the fermionic self energy under which Luttinger’s theorem is valid remains a matter of debate, with possible requirements for its validity ranging from particle-hole symmetry to analyticity about the Fermi surface. In this paper, we propose the minimal requirements for the application of a hard Luttinger’s theorem to a generic fermionic system of arbitrary interaction strength by invoking the Atiyah–Singer index theorem to quantify the topologically-robust behavior of a generalized Fermi surface. We show that the applicability of a hard Luttinger’s theorem in a D-dimensional system is directly dependent on the existence of a (D − 1)-dimensional manifold of gapless chiral excitations at the Fermi level, regardless of whether the system exhibits Luttinger or Fermi surfaces (i.e., manifolds of zeroes of the Green’s function and inverse Green’s function, respectively). The exact form of the self-energy which guarantees validity of a hard Luttinger’s theorem is derived, and agreement with current experiments, numerics, and theories are discussed.
Based solely on the analytical properties of the single-particle Green's function of fermions at finite temperatures, we show that the generalized Luttinger theorem inherently possesses topological aspects. The topological interpretation of the generalized Luttinger theorem can be introduced because (i) the Luttinger volume is represented as the winding number of the single-particle Green's function and, thus, (ii) the deviation of the theorem, expressed with a ratio between the interacting and noninteracting single-particle Green's functions, is also represented as the winding number of this ratio. The formulation based on the winding number naturally leads to two types of the generalized Luttinger theorem. Exploring two examples of single-band translationally invariant interacting electrons, i.e., simple metal and Mott insulator, we show that the first type falls into the original statement for Fermi liquids given by Luttinger, where poles of the single-particle Green's function appear at the chemical potential, while the second type corresponds to the extended one for nonmetallic cases with no Fermi surface such as insulators and superconductors generalized by Dzyaloshinskii, where zeros of the single-particle Green's function appear at the chemical potential. This formulation also allows us to derive a sufficient condition for the validity of the Luttinger theorem of the first type by applying the Rouche's theorem in complex analysis as an inequality. Moreover, we can rigorously prove in a nonperturbative manner, without assuming any detail of a microscopic Hamiltonian, that the generalized Luttinger theorem of both types is valid for generic interacting fermions as long as the particle-hole symmetry is preserved. Finally, we show that the winding number of the single-particle Green's function can also be associated with the distribution function of quasiparticles, and therefore the number of quasiparticles is equal to the Luttinger volume. This implies that the fundamental hypothesis of the Landau's Fermi-liquid theory, the number of fermions being equal to that of quasiparticles, is guaranteed if the Luttinger theorem is valid since the theorem states that the number of fermions is equal to the Luttinger volume. All these general statements are made possible because of the finding that the Luttinger volume is expressed as the winding number of the single-particle Green's function at finite temperatures, for which the complex analysis can be readily exploited.
This appendix summarizes the arguments of the papers by Luttinger and Ward to derive the Luttinger theorem that is stated in Sec. 3.6. This is not a proof that the theorem applies to all possible states of a crystal; it is the derivation of arguments that it applies to all states that can be analytically continued from some non-interacting system, i.e., a “normal state of matter” as defined in Sec. 3.4. The derivation is an example of the use of the T ≠ 0 Green's functions in App. D and the conclusions for T = 0. The Luttinger theorem is a cornerstone in the theory of condensed matter. As described qualitatively in Sec. 3.6, it requires that the volume enclosed by the Fermi surface is conserved independent of interactions, i.e., it is the same as for a system of non-interacting particles. Similarly, the Friedel sum rule is the requirement that the sum of phase shifts around an impurity is determined by charge neutrality, which was derived by Friedel [163] for non-interacting electrons. This section is devoted to a short summary of the original work of Luttinger and Ward and the extension of the arguments to the Freidel sum rule [166]. Here we explicitly indicate the chemical potential μ , since the variation from μ is essential to the arguments. There are two key points: in the interacting system the wavevector in the Brillouin zone k is conserved so that excitations can be labeled k , and the self-energy ∑ k ( ω ) is purely real at the Fermi energy ω = μ at temperature T = 0. The latter point is an essential feature of a Fermi liquid or a “normal metal,” which is justified by the argument that the phase space for scattering at T = 0 vanishes as ω → μ (see Sec. 7.5). Thus, at the Fermi energy the Green's function as a function of k is the same as for an independent-particle problem with eigenvalues. (Of course, for an interacting system at any other energy cannot be described by independent particles.) In an independent-particle system at T = 0 the occupation numbers jump from 1 to 0 as a function of k at the Fermi surface, and in the interacting system there is still a discontinuity in n k that defines the surface (Sec. 7.5).
The validity of the Luttinger sum rule is investigated within the prototype tight-binding model of interacting fermions in one dimension, i.e., the $t\text{\ensuremath{-}}V$ model including the next-nearest-neighbor hopping ${t}^{\ensuremath{'}}$, in order to break the particle-hole symmetry. Scaling analysis of finite-system results at half filling reveals evident breakdown of the sum rule in the large gap regime at V⪢tV⪢tV⪢t while the sum rule appears to recover together with vanishing of the Mott-Hubbard gap.
Luttinger theorem relates Fermi surface volume to electron density per spin nnn. It holds in an arbitrary Fermi liquid but is widely believed to break when a fermionic self-energy has a pole. We show that this is not necessarily the case. As an example, we consider a fermionic system consisting of two gapped bands, originating from a self-energy Σ(ω,k)Σ(ω, \mathbf{k})Σ(ω,k) with a pole, and a narrow residual quasiparticle band crossing ω=0ω=0ω=0, with a small residue Z≪1Z \ll 1Z≪1 (a residual Fermi liquid). We consider Model I, in which ZZZ also renormalizes quasiparticle bandwidth WWW to ZWZWZW and Model II, in which WWW remains unrenormalized. The Green's function for such a system G(ω,k)G(ω, \mathbf{k})G(ω,k) contains two zeros and three poles --- one from the quasiparticle band and two from the gapped bands. Yet, we show that in Model I, the Luttinger-Ward analysis is fully applicable for any Z>0Z >0Z>0, and the results are exactly the same as if the gapped bands did not exist. For Model II, the Luttinger-Ward analysis recovers once ZZZ exceeds some critical value, which depends on fermionic density.