Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1708.04912 · New Journal of Physics

Entanglement scaling at first order quantum phase transitions

A Yuste, C Cartwright, Gabriele De Chiara, Anna Sanpera

Published Feb 28, 2018• 17 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

First order quantum phase transitions (1QPTs) are signalled, in the thermodynamic limit, by discontinuous changes in the ground state properties. These discontinuities affect expectation values of observables, including spatial correlations. When a 1QPT is crossed in the vicinity of a second order one, due to the correlation length divergence of the latter, the corresponding ground state is modified and it becomes increasingly difficult to determine the order of the transition when the size of the system is finite. Here we show that, in such situations, it is possible to apply finite size scaling (FSS) to entanglement measures, as it has recently been done for the order parameters and the energy gap, in order to recover the correct thermodynamic limit (Campostrini et al 2014 Phys. Rev. Lett. 113 070402). Such a FSS can unambiguously discriminate between first and second order phase transitions in the vicinity of multicritical points even when the singularities displayed by entanglement measures lead to controversial results.

DOI
10.1088/1367-2630/aab2db

Related papers

Finite-Size Scaling at First-Order Quantum Transitions

Massimo Campostrini B, Jacopo Nespolo, Andrea Pelissetto C +1 more

We study finite-size effects at first-order quantum transitions (FOQTs). We show that the low-energy properties show a finite-size scaling (FSS) behavior, the relevant scaling variable being the ratio of the energy associated with the perturbation driving the transition and the finite-size energy gap at the FOQT point. The size dependence of the scaling variable is therefore essentially determined by the size dependence of the gap at the transition, which in turn depends on the boundary conditions. Our results have broad validity and, in particular, apply to any FOQT characterized by the degeneracy and crossing of the two lowest-energy states in the infinite-volume limit. In this case, a phenomenological two-level theory provides exact expressions for the scaling functions. Numerical results for the quantum Ising chain in transverse and parallel magnetic fields support the FSS Ansätzes.

arXiv:1405.6823•Physical Review Letters•Aug 13, 2014•71 citations

Fidelity and entanglement entropy for infinite-order phase transitions

Jin Zhang

We study the fidelity and the entanglement entropy for the ground states of quantum systems that have infinite-order quantum phase transitions. In particular, we consider the quantum O(2) model with a spin-$S$ truncation, where there is an infinite-order Gaussian (IOG) transition for $S=1$ and there are Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless (BKT) transitions for $S\ensuremath{\ge}2$. We show that the height of the peak in the fidelity susceptibility (${\ensuremath{\chi}}_{F}$) converges to a finite thermodynamic value as a power law of $1/L$ for the IOG transition and as $1/ln(L)$ for BKT transitions. The peak position of ${\ensuremath{\chi}}_{F}$ resides inside the gapped phase for both the IOG transition and BKT transitions. On the other hand, the derivative of the block entanglement entropy with respect to the coupling constant (${S}_{vN}^{\ensuremath{'}}$) has a peak height that diverges as ${ln}^{2}(L)$ for $S=1$ and ${ln}^{3}(L)$ for $S\ensuremath{\ge}2$ and can be used to locate both kinds of transitions accurately. We include higher-order corrections for finite-size scalings and obtain the value of the central charge consistent with $c=1$ predicted by conformal field theory. The crossing point of ${\ensuremath{\chi}}_{F}$ between different system sizes is at the IOG point for $S=1$ but is inside the gapped phase for $S\ensuremath{\ge}2$, while those of ${S}_{vN}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ are at the phase-transition points for all $S$ truncations. Our work elaborates on how to use the finite-size scaling of ${\ensuremath{\chi}}_{F}$ or ${S}_{vN}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ to detect infinite-order quantum phase transitions and discusses the efficiency and accuracy of the two methods.

arXiv:2108.09966•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Nov 11, 2021•12 citations

Quantum phase transitions in fully connected spin models: An entanglement perspective

Michele Filippone, Sébastien Dusuel, Julien Vidal

We consider a set of fully connected spin models that display first- or second-order transitions and for which we compute the ground-state entanglement in the thermodynamical limit. We analyze several entanglement measures (concurrence, R\'enyi entropy, and negativity) and show that, in general, discontinuous transitions lead to a jump of these quantities at the transition point. Interestingly, we also find examples where this is not the case.

arXiv:1101.3654•Physical Review A•Feb 25, 2011•51 citations

Ground-state fidelity at first-order quantum transitions

Davide Rossini, Ettore Vicari

We analyze the scaling behavior of the fidelity, and the corresponding susceptibility, emerging in finite-size many-body systems whenever a given control parameter $\ensuremath{\lambda}$ is varied across a quantum phase transition. For this purpose we consider a finite-size scaling (FSS) framework. Our working hypothesis is based on a scaling assumption of the fidelity in terms of the FSS variables associated with $\ensuremath{\lambda}$ and its variation $\ensuremath{\delta}\ensuremath{\lambda}$. This framework entails the FSS predictions for continuous transitions and enables one to extend them to first-order transitions, where the FSS becomes qualitatively different. The latter is supported by analytical and numerical analyses of the quantum Ising chain along its first-order quantum transition line, driven by an external longitudinal field.

arXiv:1807.01674•Physical review. E•Dec 26, 2018•42 citations

Global geometric entanglement in transverse-field XY spin chains: finite and infinite systems

Tzu-Chieh Wei, Smitha Vishveshwara, Paul M. Goldbart

The entanglement in quantum XY spin chains of arbitrary length is investigated via the geometric measure of entanglement. The emergence of entanglement is explained intuitively from the perspective of perturbations. The model is solved exactly and the energy spectrum is determined and analyzed in particular for the lowest two levels for both finite and infinite systems. The overlaps for these two levels are calculated analytically for arbitrary number of spins. The entanglement is hence obtained by maximizing over a single parameter. The corresponding ground-state entanglement surface is then determined over the entire phase diagram, and its behavior can be used to delineate the boundaries in the phase diagram. For example, the field-derivative of the entanglement becomes singular along the critical line. The form of the divergence is derived analytically and it turns out to be dictated by the universality class controlling the quantum phase transition. The behavior of the entanglement near criticality can be understood via a scaling hypothesis, analogous to that for free energies. The entanglement density vanishes along the so-called disorder line in the phase diagram, the ground space is doubly degenerate and spanned by two product states. The entanglement for the superposition of the lowest two states is also calculated. The exact value of the entanglement depends on the specific form of superposition. However, in the thermodynamic limit the entanglement density turns out to be independent of the superposition. This proves that the entanglement density is insensitive to whether the ground state is chosen to be the spontaneously $Z_2$ symmetry broken one or not. The finite-size scaling of entanglement at critical points is also investigated from two different view points. First, the maximum in the field-derivative of the entanglement density is computed and fitted to a logarithmic dependence of the system size, thereby deducing the correlation length exponent for the Ising class using only the behavior of entanglement. Second, the entanglement density itself is shown to possess a correction term inversely proportional to the system size, with the coefficient being universal (but with different values for the ground state and the first excited state, respectively).

arXiv:1012.4114•Quantum Information and Computation•Mar 1, 2011•12 citations

Finite-Size Scaling Theory of Rényi Thermal Entropy for Second-Order, First-Order, and Weakly First-Order Quantum Phase Transitions

Zhe Wang, Yanzhang Zhu, Chunhao Guo +4 more

Establishing the nature of a quantum phase transition in finite-size simulations—whether continuous, first order, or weakly first order—is a fundamental challenge in quantum many-body computation. The weakly first-order transition is particularly elusive: its anomalously large correlation length invariably mimics a continuous critical point at accessible system sizes, and no unified finite-size scaling theory has existed to distinguish these scenarios under realistic computational constraints. In this work, we address this problem by introducing a finite-size scaling framework based on the Rényi thermal entropy (RTE) and its derivative (DRTE). We derive the finite-size scaling forms for the RTE and DRTE at continuous, first-order, and weakly first-order quantum phase transitions and show that the DRTE isolates the universal contribution of the free energy and strengthens the characteristics of various phase transitions in finite sizes. Using quantum Monte Carlo simulations, we demonstrate accurate data collapse and extraction of critical exponents at ( 2 + 1 )-dimensional O ( N ) critical points. Most importantly, the DRTE provides a definitive signature of weakly first-order transitions at visitable sizes—a zero crossing and a double-peak structure—which we observe in the debated deconfined quantum criticality candidates such as the J − Q and SU(8) J 1 − J 2 models. Our approach offers a general, order-parameter-agnostic, and numerically efficient diagnostic tool, resolving long-standing ambiguities between continuous and weakly first-order scenarios in the finite-size simulations.

arXiv:2506.16111•Physical Review X•Oct 6, 2026•4 citations
First order quantum phase transitions (1QPTs) are signalled, in the thermodynamic limit, by discontinuous changes in the ground state properties. These discontinuities affect expectation values of observables, including spatial correlations. When a 1QPT is crossed in the vicinity of a second order one, due to the correlation length divergence of the latter, the corresponding ground state is modified and it becomes increasingly difficult to determine the order of the transition when the size of the system is finite. Here we show that, in such situations, it is possible to apply finite size scaling (FSS) to entanglement measures, as it has recently been done for the order parameters and the energy gap, in order to recover the correct thermodynamic limit (Campostrini et al 2014 Phys. Rev. Lett. 113 070402). Such a FSS can unambiguously discriminate between first and second order phase transitions in the vicinity of multicritical points even when the singularities displayed by entanglement measures lead to controversial results.
We study finite-size effects at first-order quantum transitions (FOQTs). We show that the low-energy properties show a finite-size scaling (FSS) behavior, the relevant scaling variable being the ratio of the energy associated with the perturbation driving the transition and the finite-size energy gap at the FOQT point. The size dependence of the scaling variable is therefore essentially determined by the size dependence of the gap at the transition, which in turn depends on the boundary conditions. Our results have broad validity and, in particular, apply to any FOQT characterized by the degeneracy and crossing of the two lowest-energy states in the infinite-volume limit. In this case, a phenomenological two-level theory provides exact expressions for the scaling functions. Numerical results for the quantum Ising chain in transverse and parallel magnetic fields support the FSS Ansätzes.
We study the fidelity and the entanglement entropy for the ground states of quantum systems that have infinite-order quantum phase transitions. In particular, we consider the quantum O(2) model with a spin-SSS truncation, where there is an infinite-order Gaussian (IOG) transition for S=1S=1S=1 and there are Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless (BKT) transitions for $S\ensuremath{\ge}2$. We show that the height of the peak in the fidelity susceptibility (${\ensuremath{\chi}}_{F}$) converges to a finite thermodynamic value as a power law of 1/L1/L1/L for the IOG transition and as 1/ln(L)1/ln(L)1/ln(L) for BKT transitions. The peak position of ${\ensuremath{\chi}}_{F}$ resides inside the gapped phase for both the IOG transition and BKT transitions. On the other hand, the derivative of the block entanglement entropy with respect to the coupling constant (${S}_{vN}^{\ensuremath{'}}$) has a peak height that diverges as ln2(L){ln}^{2}(L)ln2(L) for S=1S=1S=1 and ln3(L){ln}^{3}(L)ln3(L) for $S\ensuremath{\ge}2$ and can be used to locate both kinds of transitions accurately. We include higher-order corrections for finite-size scalings and obtain the value of the central charge consistent with c=1c=1c=1 predicted by conformal field theory. The crossing point of ${\ensuremath{\chi}}_{F}$ between different system sizes is at the IOG point for S=1S=1S=1 but is inside the gapped phase for $S\ensuremath{\ge}2$, while those of ${S}_{vN}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ are at the phase-transition points for all SSS truncations. Our work elaborates on how to use the finite-size scaling of ${\ensuremath{\chi}}_{F}$ or ${S}_{vN}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ to detect infinite-order quantum phase transitions and discusses the efficiency and accuracy of the two methods.
We analyze the scaling behavior of the fidelity, and the corresponding susceptibility, emerging in finite-size many-body systems whenever a given control parameter $\ensuremath{\lambda}$ is varied across a quantum phase transition. For this purpose we consider a finite-size scaling (FSS) framework. Our working hypothesis is based on a scaling assumption of the fidelity in terms of the FSS variables associated with $\ensuremath{\lambda}$ and its variation $\ensuremath{\delta}\ensuremath{\lambda}$. This framework entails the FSS predictions for continuous transitions and enables one to extend them to first-order transitions, where the FSS becomes qualitatively different. The latter is supported by analytical and numerical analyses of the quantum Ising chain along its first-order quantum transition line, driven by an external longitudinal field.
The entanglement in quantum XY spin chains of arbitrary length is investigated via the geometric measure of entanglement. The emergence of entanglement is explained intuitively from the perspective of perturbations. The model is solved exactly and the energy spectrum is determined and analyzed in particular for the lowest two levels for both finite and infinite systems. The overlaps for these two levels are calculated analytically for arbitrary number of spins. The entanglement is hence obtained by maximizing over a single parameter. The corresponding ground-state entanglement surface is then determined over the entire phase diagram, and its behavior can be used to delineate the boundaries in the phase diagram. For example, the field-derivative of the entanglement becomes singular along the critical line. The form of the divergence is derived analytically and it turns out to be dictated by the universality class controlling the quantum phase transition. The behavior of the entanglement near criticality can be understood via a scaling hypothesis, analogous to that for free energies. The entanglement density vanishes along the so-called disorder line in the phase diagram, the ground space is doubly degenerate and spanned by two product states. The entanglement for the superposition of the lowest two states is also calculated. The exact value of the entanglement depends on the specific form of superposition. However, in the thermodynamic limit the entanglement density turns out to be independent of the superposition. This proves that the entanglement density is insensitive to whether the ground state is chosen to be the spontaneously Z2Z_2Z2​ symmetry broken one or not. The finite-size scaling of entanglement at critical points is also investigated from two different view points. First, the maximum in the field-derivative of the entanglement density is computed and fitted to a logarithmic dependence of the system size, thereby deducing the correlation length exponent for the Ising class using only the behavior of entanglement. Second, the entanglement density itself is shown to possess a correction term inversely proportional to the system size, with the coefficient being universal (but with different values for the ground state and the first excited state, respectively).
Establishing the nature of a quantum phase transition in finite-size simulations—whether continuous, first order, or weakly first order—is a fundamental challenge in quantum many-body computation. The weakly first-order transition is particularly elusive: its anomalously large correlation length invariably mimics a continuous critical point at accessible system sizes, and no unified finite-size scaling theory has existed to distinguish these scenarios under realistic computational constraints. In this work, we address this problem by introducing a finite-size scaling framework based on the Rényi thermal entropy (RTE) and its derivative (DRTE). We derive the finite-size scaling forms for the RTE and DRTE at continuous, first-order, and weakly first-order quantum phase transitions and show that the DRTE isolates the universal contribution of the free energy and strengthens the characteristics of various phase transitions in finite sizes. Using quantum Monte Carlo simulations, we demonstrate accurate data collapse and extraction of critical exponents at ( 2 + 1 )-dimensional O ( N ) critical points. Most importantly, the DRTE provides a definitive signature of weakly first-order transitions at visitable sizes—a zero crossing and a double-peak structure—which we observe in the debated deconfined quantum criticality candidates such as the J − Q and SU(8) J 1 − J 2 models. Our approach offers a general, order-parameter-agnostic, and numerically efficient diagnostic tool, resolving long-standing ambiguities between continuous and weakly first-order scenarios in the finite-size simulations.