Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1708.04193

The quantum mechanical probability density and probability current density operators in the Pauli theory

E. L. Rumyantsev, P. E. Kunavin

Published Aug 14, 2017• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We present systematic construction of probability and probability current densities operators for one-band single particle Pauli equations starting from the operators in Dirac electron model within Second Quantized Approach. These operators are of importance as in probability interpretation of experimental data, so in establishing of boundary conditions. It is shown that derived operators differ significally from their convential Schrodinger-type counterparts. The generalization of continuity equation for probability density under external perturbations and physical meaning of additional source terms is discussed. The presented approach can be useful in analysis of carriers dynamics described within generic multicomponent $\vec{k} \cdot \vec{p}$ Hamiltonians in Envelope Function Approximation (EFA).

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1708.04193

Related papers

The Pauli and Lévy-Leblond equations, and the spin current density

James M Wilkes

Abstract We review the literature on the Pauli equation and its current density, discussing the progression from the original phenomenological version of Pauli to its derivation by Lévy-Leblond from a linearization of the Schrödinger equation. It was established conclusively by Lévy-Leblond’s work that the spin of a spin-1/2 particle such as an electron is non-relativistic in nature, contrary to what was often stated following Dirac’s derivation of a relativistic wave equation, and his subsequent demonstration that Pauli’s spin interaction term appeared in the non-relativistic limit. In this limit, the Gordon decomposition of the associated probability current density was found to contain a spin-dependent term. Such a term does not follow, however, from the usual derivation of the current density from the Pauli equation, although various physically motivated but otherwise ad hoc explanations were put forward to account for it. We comment on the only exception to these of which we are aware implying the spin term in the current was in fact non-relativistic in nature. However, the earlier work of Lévy-Leblond had already shown, with no additional assumptions, that this term was a prominent feature of the current density derived from his equation. Hence, just as with the spin itself, the spin current was non-relativistic, claims to the contrary notwithstanding. We present a somewhat simplified derivation of the Lévy-Leblond equation and its current density, commenting on possibilities for experimental work that might indicate measurable consequences of the spin term in the current density. The presentation is at a level of quantum mechanics, electromagnetic theory, and mathematical methods typical of courses taken by first-year graduate students in physics, assuming some familiarity with Pauli spin matrices and the Dirac equation. Calculations are presented in detail, making the material suitable for use by teachers as supplementary problems for assignments, and development of theoretical concepts peculiar to the Pauli equation and its probability current density.

arXiv:1908.03276•European Journal of Physics•Feb 10, 2020•25 citations

Relativistic Schrödinger equation and probability currents for free particles

David Carfì

In this work, we start from the problem of quantizing the relativistic Hamiltonian of a free massive particle (rest mass different from 0), a problem exceptionally difficult in the standard approaches to quantum mechanics. In fact, in tempered distribution state space, we find the natural way to define the relativistic Hamiltonian operator and its associated Schrödinger equation The existence of a linear continuous Hermitian operator associated with the Einstein's Hamiltonian of a free particle, defined on the entire tempered distribution space, automatically implies the conservation of Born probability flux (which doesn't mean the conservation of particles number, rather it implies the conservation of the total relativistic energy of the solution wave). We, then, deduce the continuity equation for the Born probability density and study some its different (but equivalent) expressions. We determine some possible forms of probability currents and flux velocity fields associated with the particle evolution. We provide the relativistic invariant expression for both Schrödinger equation and probability flux continuity equations.

Proceedings of the International Geometry Center•Jan 13, 2024•3 citations

Obtaining the Probability Vector Current Density in Canonical Quantum Mechanics by Linear Superposition

Steven Kenneth Kauffmann

The quantum mechanics status of the probability vector current density has long seemed to be marginal. On one hand no systematic prescription for its construction is provided, and the special examples of it that are obtained for particular types of Hamiltonian operator could conceivably be attributed to happenstance. On the other hand this concept's key physical interpretation as local average particle flux, which flows from the equation of continuity that it is supposed to satisfy in conjunction with the probability scalar density, has been claimed to breach the uncertainty principle. Given the dispiriting impact of that claim, we straightaway point out that the subtle directional nature of the uncertainty principle makes it consistent with the measurement of local average particle flux. We next focus on the fact that the unique closed-form linear-superposition quantization of any classical Hamiltonian function yields in tandem the corresponding unique linear-superposition closed-form divergence of the probability vector current density. Because the probability vector current density is linked to the quantum physics only through the occurrence of its divergence in the equation of continuity, it is theoretically most appropriate to construct this vector field exclusively from its divergence -- analysis of the best-known "textbook" special example of a probability vector current density shows that it is thus constructed. That special example in fact leads to the physically interesting "Ehrenfest subclass" of probability vector current densities, which are closely related to their classical peers.

arXiv:1302.1086•Feb 2, 2013•0 citations

On charge conservation and the continuity equation for real wavefunctions in unified quantum mechanics

Pushpendra Singh

We present a rigorous derivation of the continuity equation within a real-valued reformulation of unified quantum mechanics (UQM), in which the conventional imaginary unit is systematically represented by the temporal Hilbert transform (HT) operator ℋ 𝑡 . This formulation provides a real-valued representation of quantum dynamics while preserving the fundamental conservation laws of standard quantum theory. By introducing a coupled system for a wavefunction ψ and its HT 𝜙 = ℋ 𝑡 ⁡ [ 𝜓 ] , we identify a conserved density analogous to the probability density of complex quantum mechanics. An explicit calculation yields a local continuity equation, 𝜕 𝑡 𝜌 + 𝛻 · 𝐣 = 0 , together with well-defined expressions for the associated current. The coupled real system exhibits a global SO(2) symmetry, which is isomorphic to the U(1) phase symmetry of the standard formulation and provides the corresponding symmetry interpretation of the conserved current. The analysis further shows how charge and mass continuity follow from the probability continuity equation, demonstrating the internal consistency of the real-valued formulation. We further establish that, within the positive-frequency sector and under the stated spectral conditions, the Schrödinger, UQM, and second-order formulations are equivalent, with a one-to-one correspondence between the Schrödinger initial state and the real-valued Cauchy data. Importantly, the operator correspondence 𝑖 ↔ ℋ 𝑡 is not restricted to the non-relativistic Schrödinger equation; we discuss its operator-level extension to Pauli, Dirac, and many-particle quantum systems under the appropriate spectral and dynamical assumptions. These results establish UQM as a real-valued representation of established quantum dynamics, while clarifying the conditions under which the Hilbert-transform formulation is applicable.

Next research.•Oct 7, 2026•0 citations

Axiomatic Basis of Quantum Mechanics

Ahmad Amer

This chapter introduces an elementary form of the fundamental axioms of quantum mechanics, focusing on the structure and interpretation of state functions within a vector space framework. The properties of linear operators acting on state functions are explored, along with the physical meaning of the state function itself. From this interpretation, boundary conditions and normalization requirements are derived. The chapter presents key results such as the normalization theorem, the time derivative of a physical observable, and Ehrenfest's theorem. It also defines probability density and probability current density, deriving the continuity equation for probability. The uncertainty principle is formally established, and energy conservation is addressed. The eigenvalues and eigenstates of the momentum operator are determined, and normalization using the Dirac delta function is introduced. The free particle wavefunction is derived, concluding with a discussion on the classical limit of quantum mechanics. Metadata/Keywords: quantum axioms, state function, linear operators, probability density, probability current, Ehrenfest's theorem, uncertainty principle, Dirac delta function, momentum eigenstates, classical limit

CRC Press eBooks•Nov 5, 2025•0 citations

The probability operator in quantum theory and quantization of a system of free fields

Sujit Basu, V. V. Kuryshkin

A theoretical framework for quantization, defined by the normalized positive-definite probability operator establishing dynamical correspondence between classical and quantum Poisson brackets, is presented. The resulting quantum theory, unlike the conventional one, admits consistent probabilistic interpretation. It is shown that, in the nonrelativistic case, quantization based on the probability operator leads to the theory known as ‘‘quantum mechanics with a non-negative quantum distribution function.’’ A generalization of the proposed framework to the case of the relativistic theory of fields is attempted. Four auxiliary problems of constructing probability operators of one-dimensional field oscillators in Bose and Fermi algebras are formulated and solved. On the basis of these solutions it is concluded that spinor fields are not quantizable in the Bose algebra with the help of the probability operator (the analog of Pauli’s theorem). An equation for the probability operator of a system of free fields is derived from the principles of dynamical correspondence and translational invariance. The physical meaning of the operators corresponding to classical field amplitudes, such as annihilation and creation operators of field quanta with definite energy-momentum, is shown to emerge as a consequence of this equation. It is shown that the quantization of a system consisting only of tensor fields or only of spinor fields in the formalism of the probability operator leads to difficulties. It is shown further that these difficulties can be removed by considering quantization of a system containing both tensor and spinor fields. As an illustration, quantization of a system consisting of a massive vector field and a massive spinor field is considered and it is found that a noncontradictory quantization requires the mass of the vector particle to be less than that of the spinor particle. The probability operator thus acts as a mechanism of selection of the fields to be quantized already at the level of free fields.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Apr 1, 1990•0 citations
We present systematic construction of probability and probability current densities operators for one-band single particle Pauli equations starting from the operators in Dirac electron model within Second Quantized Approach. These operators are of importance as in probability interpretation of experimental data, so in establishing of boundary conditions. It is shown that derived operators differ significally from their convential Schrodinger-type counterparts. The generalization of continuity equation for probability density under external perturbations and physical meaning of additional source terms is discussed. The presented approach can be useful in analysis of carriers dynamics described within generic multicomponent k⃗⋅p⃗\vec{k} \cdot \vec{p}k⋅p​ Hamiltonians in Envelope Function Approximation (EFA).
Abstract We review the literature on the Pauli equation and its current density, discussing the progression from the original phenomenological version of Pauli to its derivation by Lévy-Leblond from a linearization of the Schrödinger equation. It was established conclusively by Lévy-Leblond’s work that the spin of a spin-1/2 particle such as an electron is non-relativistic in nature, contrary to what was often stated following Dirac’s derivation of a relativistic wave equation, and his subsequent demonstration that Pauli’s spin interaction term appeared in the non-relativistic limit. In this limit, the Gordon decomposition of the associated probability current density was found to contain a spin-dependent term. Such a term does not follow, however, from the usual derivation of the current density from the Pauli equation, although various physically motivated but otherwise ad hoc explanations were put forward to account for it. We comment on the only exception to these of which we are aware implying the spin term in the current was in fact non-relativistic in nature. However, the earlier work of Lévy-Leblond had already shown, with no additional assumptions, that this term was a prominent feature of the current density derived from his equation. Hence, just as with the spin itself, the spin current was non-relativistic, claims to the contrary notwithstanding. We present a somewhat simplified derivation of the Lévy-Leblond equation and its current density, commenting on possibilities for experimental work that might indicate measurable consequences of the spin term in the current density. The presentation is at a level of quantum mechanics, electromagnetic theory, and mathematical methods typical of courses taken by first-year graduate students in physics, assuming some familiarity with Pauli spin matrices and the Dirac equation. Calculations are presented in detail, making the material suitable for use by teachers as supplementary problems for assignments, and development of theoretical concepts peculiar to the Pauli equation and its probability current density.
In this work, we start from the problem of quantizing the relativistic Hamiltonian of a free massive particle (rest mass different from 0), a problem exceptionally difficult in the standard approaches to quantum mechanics. In fact, in tempered distribution state space, we find the natural way to define the relativistic Hamiltonian operator and its associated Schrödinger equation The existence of a linear continuous Hermitian operator associated with the Einstein's Hamiltonian of a free particle, defined on the entire tempered distribution space, automatically implies the conservation of Born probability flux (which doesn't mean the conservation of particles number, rather it implies the conservation of the total relativistic energy of the solution wave). We, then, deduce the continuity equation for the Born probability density and study some its different (but equivalent) expressions. We determine some possible forms of probability currents and flux velocity fields associated with the particle evolution. We provide the relativistic invariant expression for both Schrödinger equation and probability flux continuity equations.
The quantum mechanics status of the probability vector current density has long seemed to be marginal. On one hand no systematic prescription for its construction is provided, and the special examples of it that are obtained for particular types of Hamiltonian operator could conceivably be attributed to happenstance. On the other hand this concept's key physical interpretation as local average particle flux, which flows from the equation of continuity that it is supposed to satisfy in conjunction with the probability scalar density, has been claimed to breach the uncertainty principle. Given the dispiriting impact of that claim, we straightaway point out that the subtle directional nature of the uncertainty principle makes it consistent with the measurement of local average particle flux. We next focus on the fact that the unique closed-form linear-superposition quantization of any classical Hamiltonian function yields in tandem the corresponding unique linear-superposition closed-form divergence of the probability vector current density. Because the probability vector current density is linked to the quantum physics only through the occurrence of its divergence in the equation of continuity, it is theoretically most appropriate to construct this vector field exclusively from its divergence -- analysis of the best-known "textbook" special example of a probability vector current density shows that it is thus constructed. That special example in fact leads to the physically interesting "Ehrenfest subclass" of probability vector current densities, which are closely related to their classical peers.
We present a rigorous derivation of the continuity equation within a real-valued reformulation of unified quantum mechanics (UQM), in which the conventional imaginary unit is systematically represented by the temporal Hilbert transform (HT) operator ℋ 𝑡 . This formulation provides a real-valued representation of quantum dynamics while preserving the fundamental conservation laws of standard quantum theory. By introducing a coupled system for a wavefunction ψ and its HT 𝜙 = ℋ 𝑡 ⁡ [ 𝜓 ] , we identify a conserved density analogous to the probability density of complex quantum mechanics. An explicit calculation yields a local continuity equation, 𝜕 𝑡 𝜌 + 𝛻 · 𝐣 = 0 , together with well-defined expressions for the associated current. The coupled real system exhibits a global SO(2) symmetry, which is isomorphic to the U(1) phase symmetry of the standard formulation and provides the corresponding symmetry interpretation of the conserved current. The analysis further shows how charge and mass continuity follow from the probability continuity equation, demonstrating the internal consistency of the real-valued formulation. We further establish that, within the positive-frequency sector and under the stated spectral conditions, the Schrödinger, UQM, and second-order formulations are equivalent, with a one-to-one correspondence between the Schrödinger initial state and the real-valued Cauchy data. Importantly, the operator correspondence 𝑖 ↔ ℋ 𝑡 is not restricted to the non-relativistic Schrödinger equation; we discuss its operator-level extension to Pauli, Dirac, and many-particle quantum systems under the appropriate spectral and dynamical assumptions. These results establish UQM as a real-valued representation of established quantum dynamics, while clarifying the conditions under which the Hilbert-transform formulation is applicable.
This chapter introduces an elementary form of the fundamental axioms of quantum mechanics, focusing on the structure and interpretation of state functions within a vector space framework. The properties of linear operators acting on state functions are explored, along with the physical meaning of the state function itself. From this interpretation, boundary conditions and normalization requirements are derived. The chapter presents key results such as the normalization theorem, the time derivative of a physical observable, and Ehrenfest's theorem. It also defines probability density and probability current density, deriving the continuity equation for probability. The uncertainty principle is formally established, and energy conservation is addressed. The eigenvalues and eigenstates of the momentum operator are determined, and normalization using the Dirac delta function is introduced. The free particle wavefunction is derived, concluding with a discussion on the classical limit of quantum mechanics. Metadata/Keywords: quantum axioms, state function, linear operators, probability density, probability current, Ehrenfest's theorem, uncertainty principle, Dirac delta function, momentum eigenstates, classical limit
A theoretical framework for quantization, defined by the normalized positive-definite probability operator establishing dynamical correspondence between classical and quantum Poisson brackets, is presented. The resulting quantum theory, unlike the conventional one, admits consistent probabilistic interpretation. It is shown that, in the nonrelativistic case, quantization based on the probability operator leads to the theory known as ‘‘quantum mechanics with a non-negative quantum distribution function.’’ A generalization of the proposed framework to the case of the relativistic theory of fields is attempted. Four auxiliary problems of constructing probability operators of one-dimensional field oscillators in Bose and Fermi algebras are formulated and solved. On the basis of these solutions it is concluded that spinor fields are not quantizable in the Bose algebra with the help of the probability operator (the analog of Pauli’s theorem). An equation for the probability operator of a system of free fields is derived from the principles of dynamical correspondence and translational invariance. The physical meaning of the operators corresponding to classical field amplitudes, such as annihilation and creation operators of field quanta with definite energy-momentum, is shown to emerge as a consequence of this equation. It is shown that the quantization of a system consisting only of tensor fields or only of spinor fields in the formalism of the probability operator leads to difficulties. It is shown further that these difficulties can be removed by considering quantization of a system containing both tensor and spinor fields. As an illustration, quantization of a system consisting of a massive vector field and a massive spinor field is considered and it is found that a noncontradictory quantization requires the mass of the vector particle to be less than that of the spinor particle. The probability operator thus acts as a mechanism of selection of the fields to be quantized already at the level of free fields.