Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1708.04022 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Universal boundary entropies in conformal field theory: A quantum Monte Carlo study

Wei Tang, Lei Chen, Wei Li, Xin Xie, Hong-Hao Tu, Lei Wang

Published Sep 19, 2017• 28 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In addition to the celebrated Affleck-Ludwig entropy originating from the open boundaries of the path-integral manifold, recent research has shown that the entropy correction on nonorientable manifolds such as the Klein bottle is also a universal characterization of critical systems with an emergent conformal field theory (CFT). Here, the authors show that the Klein bottle entropy can be interpreted as a boundary effect by transforming the Klein bottle into an orientable manifold, whereby the Klein bottle entropy bears a resemblance to the Affleck-Ludwig entropy. The authors then propose a generic scheme to extract these universal boundary entropies from lattice models. Numerical results for the $q$-state Potts model are compared with the CFT predictions.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.96.115136

Related papers

Conformal thermal tensor network and universal entropy on topological manifolds

Lei Chen, Haoxin Wang, Lei Wang +1 more

Thermal quantum critical systems, with partition functions expressed as conformal tensor networks, are revealed to exhibit universal entropy corrections on nonorientable manifolds. Through high-precision tensor network simulations of several quantum chains, we identify the universal entropy ${S}_{\mathcal{K}}=lnk$ on the Klein bottle, where $k$ relates to quantum dimensions of the primary fields in conformal field theory (CFT). Different from the celebrated Affleck-Ludwig boundary entropy $lng$ $(g$ reflects noninteger ground-state degeneracy), ${S}_{\mathcal{K}}$ has $no$ boundary dependence or surface energy terms accompanying it, and can be very conveniently extracted from thermal data. On the M\"obius-strip manifold, we uncover an entropy ${S}_{\mathcal{M}}=\frac{1}{2}(lng+lnk)$ in CFT, where $\frac{1}{2}lng$ is associated with the only open edge of the M\"obius strip and $\frac{1}{2}lnk$ is associated with the nonorientable topology. As a useful application, we employ the universal entropy to accurately pinpoint the quantum phase transitions, even for those without local order parameters.

arXiv:1708.04034•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Nov 21, 2017•18 citations

Universal Entropy of Conformal Critical Theories on a Klein Bottle

Hong-Hao Tu

We show that rational conformal field theories in 1+1 dimensions on a Klein bottle, with a length L and width β, satisfying L≫β, have a universal entropy. This universal entropy depends on the quantum dimensions of the primary fields and can be accurately extracted by taking a proper ratio between the Klein bottle and torus partition functions, enabling the characterization of conformal critical theories. The result is checked against exact calculations in quantum spin-1/2 XY and Ising chains.

arXiv:1707.05812•Physical Review Letters•Dec 28, 2017•39 citations

Universal Scaling of Klein Bottle Entropy near Conformal Critical Points

Yueshui Zhang, Anton Hulsch, Hua-Chen Zhang +3 more

We show that the Klein bottle entropy [H.-H. Tu, Phys. Rev. Lett. 119, 261603 (2017)PRLTAO0031-900710.1103/PhysRevLett.119.261603] for conformal field theories perturbed by a relevant operator is a universal function of the dimensionless coupling constant. The universal scaling of the Klein bottle entropy near criticality provides an efficient approach to extract the scaling dimension of lattice operators via data collapse. As paradigmatic examples, we validate the universal scaling of the Klein bottle entropy for Ising and Z_{3} parafermion conformal field theories with various perturbations using numerical simulation with continuous matrix product operator approach.

arXiv:2211.09745•Physical Review Letters•Apr 14, 2023•13 citations

Klein bottle entropy of compactified boson conformal field theory

Wei Tang, X. C. Xie, Lei Wang +1 more

We extend the scope of the Klein bottle entropy, originally introduced by Tu [Phys. Rev. Lett. 119, 261603 (2017)] in the rational conformal field theory (CFT), to the compactified boson CFT, which are relevant to the studies of Luttinger liquids. We first review the Klein bottle entropy in rational CFT and discuss details of how to extract the Klein bottle entropy from lattice models using the example of the transverse field Ising model. We then go beyond the scope of rational CFT and study the Klein bottle entropy $lng$ in the compactified boson CFT, which turns out to have a straightforward relation to the compactification radius $R$, $lng=lnR$. This relation indicates a convenient and efficient method to extract the Luttinger parameter from lattice model calculations. Our numerical results on the Klein bottle entropy in the spin-$1/2$ XXZ chain show excellent agreement with the CFT predictions, up to some small deviations near the isotropic point, which we attribute to the marginally irrelevant terms. For the $S=1$ XXZ chain that cannot be exactly solved, our numerical results provide an accurate numerical determination of the Luttinger parameter in this model.

arXiv:1805.01300•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Mar 5, 2019•18 citations

Universality of finite-size corrections to geometrical entanglement in one-dimensional quantum critical systems

Xijing Liu, Bing-Quan Hu, Sam Young Cho +2 more

Recently, the finite-size corrections to the geometrical entanglement per lattice site in the spin-1/2 chain have been numerically shown to scale inversely with system size, and its prefactor b has been suggested to be possibly universal [Q-Q. Shi et al., New J. Phys. 12, 025008 (2010)]. As possible evidence of its universality, the numerical values of the prefactors have been confirmed analytically by using the Affleck-Ludwig boundary entropy with a Neumann boundary condition for a free compactified field [J-M. Stephan et al., Phys. Rev. B 82, 180406(R) (2010)]. However, the Affleck-Ludwig boundary entropy is not unique and does depend on conformally invariant boundary conditions. Here, we show that a unique Affleck-Ludwig boundary entropy corresponding to a finitesize correction to the geometrical entanglement per lattice site exists and show that the ratio of the prefactor b to the corresponding minimum groundstate degeneracy gmin for the Affleck- Ludwig boundary entropy is a constant for any critical region of the spin-1 XXZ system with the single-ion anisotropy, i.e., b/(2 log2 g min ) = −1. Previously studied spin-1/2 systems, including the quantum three-state Potts model, have verified the universal ratio. Hence, the inverse finite-size correction to the geometrical entanglement per lattice site and its prefactor b are universal for one-dimensional critical systems.

Journal of the Korean Physical Society•Oct 1, 2016•1 citation

Klein bottle ratio of two-dimensional ferromagnetic Potts models

Zi-Han Wang, Li-Ping Yang

The weakly first-order nature of the two-dimensional five-state ferromagnetic Potts model poses challenges for numerical study. Using density-matrix and tensor-network renormalization group methods, we investigate these transitions of the $q$-state Potts model via the Klein bottle ratio $g$ on original and dual lattices. Finite-size scaling of $g$ as a function of transverse system size $L_y$ accurately locates the critical points for $q = 3, 4, 5, 6$. We further examine the transfer-matrix spectra and entanglement entropy, extracting central charges through toroidal and Klein bottle boundary conditions. For $q = 5$, the extracted central charge ($c \approx 1.14811$) is close to the real part of the theoretical value $c_{5\text{-Potts}} = 1.1375 \pm 0.0211 i$ predicted by complex conformal field theories(CFTs). The observed drift in the scaling exponent $b$ effectively distinguishes the continuous transition from the weakly first-order regime. Furthermore, the extrapolated divergence of $g$ confirms the first-order character of the $q=5$ Potts model, while for the $q=4$ model, both the CFT-predicted eigenvalue distribution and the logarithmic corrections are numerically verified.

arXiv:2604.00870•Physical review. E•Oct 22, 2026•0 citations
In addition to the celebrated Affleck-Ludwig entropy originating from the open boundaries of the path-integral manifold, recent research has shown that the entropy correction on nonorientable manifolds such as the Klein bottle is also a universal characterization of critical systems with an emergent conformal field theory (CFT). Here, the authors show that the Klein bottle entropy can be interpreted as a boundary effect by transforming the Klein bottle into an orientable manifold, whereby the Klein bottle entropy bears a resemblance to the Affleck-Ludwig entropy. The authors then propose a generic scheme to extract these universal boundary entropies from lattice models. Numerical results for the qqq-state Potts model are compared with the CFT predictions.
Thermal quantum critical systems, with partition functions expressed as conformal tensor networks, are revealed to exhibit universal entropy corrections on nonorientable manifolds. Through high-precision tensor network simulations of several quantum chains, we identify the universal entropy SK=lnk{S}_{\mathcal{K}}=lnkSK​=lnk on the Klein bottle, where kkk relates to quantum dimensions of the primary fields in conformal field theory (CFT). Different from the celebrated Affleck-Ludwig boundary entropy lnglnglng (g(g(g reflects noninteger ground-state degeneracy), SK{S}_{\mathcal{K}}SK​ has nonono boundary dependence or surface energy terms accompanying it, and can be very conveniently extracted from thermal data. On the M\"obius-strip manifold, we uncover an entropy SM=12(lng+lnk){S}_{\mathcal{M}}=\frac{1}{2}(lng+lnk)SM​=21​(lng+lnk) in CFT, where 12lng\frac{1}{2}lng21​lng is associated with the only open edge of the M\"obius strip and 12lnk\frac{1}{2}lnk21​lnk is associated with the nonorientable topology. As a useful application, we employ the universal entropy to accurately pinpoint the quantum phase transitions, even for those without local order parameters.
We show that rational conformal field theories in 1+1 dimensions on a Klein bottle, with a length L and width β, satisfying L≫β, have a universal entropy. This universal entropy depends on the quantum dimensions of the primary fields and can be accurately extracted by taking a proper ratio between the Klein bottle and torus partition functions, enabling the characterization of conformal critical theories. The result is checked against exact calculations in quantum spin-1/2 XY and Ising chains.
We show that the Klein bottle entropy [H.-H. Tu, Phys. Rev. Lett. 119, 261603 (2017)PRLTAO0031-900710.1103/PhysRevLett.119.261603] for conformal field theories perturbed by a relevant operator is a universal function of the dimensionless coupling constant. The universal scaling of the Klein bottle entropy near criticality provides an efficient approach to extract the scaling dimension of lattice operators via data collapse. As paradigmatic examples, we validate the universal scaling of the Klein bottle entropy for Ising and Z_{3} parafermion conformal field theories with various perturbations using numerical simulation with continuous matrix product operator approach.
We extend the scope of the Klein bottle entropy, originally introduced by Tu [Phys. Rev. Lett. 119, 261603 (2017)] in the rational conformal field theory (CFT), to the compactified boson CFT, which are relevant to the studies of Luttinger liquids. We first review the Klein bottle entropy in rational CFT and discuss details of how to extract the Klein bottle entropy from lattice models using the example of the transverse field Ising model. We then go beyond the scope of rational CFT and study the Klein bottle entropy lnglnglng in the compactified boson CFT, which turns out to have a straightforward relation to the compactification radius RRR, lng=lnRlng=lnRlng=lnR. This relation indicates a convenient and efficient method to extract the Luttinger parameter from lattice model calculations. Our numerical results on the Klein bottle entropy in the spin-1/21/21/2 XXZ chain show excellent agreement with the CFT predictions, up to some small deviations near the isotropic point, which we attribute to the marginally irrelevant terms. For the S=1S=1S=1 XXZ chain that cannot be exactly solved, our numerical results provide an accurate numerical determination of the Luttinger parameter in this model.
Recently, the finite-size corrections to the geometrical entanglement per lattice site in the spin-1/2 chain have been numerically shown to scale inversely with system size, and its prefactor b has been suggested to be possibly universal [Q-Q. Shi et al., New J. Phys. 12, 025008 (2010)]. As possible evidence of its universality, the numerical values of the prefactors have been confirmed analytically by using the Affleck-Ludwig boundary entropy with a Neumann boundary condition for a free compactified field [J-M. Stephan et al., Phys. Rev. B 82, 180406(R) (2010)]. However, the Affleck-Ludwig boundary entropy is not unique and does depend on conformally invariant boundary conditions. Here, we show that a unique Affleck-Ludwig boundary entropy corresponding to a finitesize correction to the geometrical entanglement per lattice site exists and show that the ratio of the prefactor b to the corresponding minimum groundstate degeneracy gmin for the Affleck- Ludwig boundary entropy is a constant for any critical region of the spin-1 XXZ system with the single-ion anisotropy, i.e., b/(2 log2 g min ) = −1. Previously studied spin-1/2 systems, including the quantum three-state Potts model, have verified the universal ratio. Hence, the inverse finite-size correction to the geometrical entanglement per lattice site and its prefactor b are universal for one-dimensional critical systems.
The weakly first-order nature of the two-dimensional five-state ferromagnetic Potts model poses challenges for numerical study. Using density-matrix and tensor-network renormalization group methods, we investigate these transitions of the qqq-state Potts model via the Klein bottle ratio ggg on original and dual lattices. Finite-size scaling of ggg as a function of transverse system size LyL_yLy​ accurately locates the critical points for q=3,4,5,6q = 3, 4, 5, 6q=3,4,5,6. We further examine the transfer-matrix spectra and entanglement entropy, extracting central charges through toroidal and Klein bottle boundary conditions. For q=5q = 5q=5, the extracted central charge (c≈1.14811c \approx 1.14811c≈1.14811) is close to the real part of the theoretical value c5-Potts=1.1375±0.0211ic_{5\text{-Potts}} = 1.1375 \pm 0.0211 ic5-Potts​=1.1375±0.0211i predicted by complex conformal field theories(CFTs). The observed drift in the scaling exponent bbb effectively distinguishes the continuous transition from the weakly first-order regime. Furthermore, the extrapolated divergence of ggg confirms the first-order character of the q=5q=5q=5 Potts model, while for the q=4q=4q=4 model, both the CFT-predicted eigenvalue distribution and the logarithmic corrections are numerically verified.