Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1707.03464

Uncertainty relations and joint numerical ranges

Konrad Szymański

Published Jul 11, 2017• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Noncommutativity lies in the heart of quantum theory and provides rich set of interesting questions in physics and mathematics. In this work I present some of them through the concept of Joint Numerical Range (JNR) - the set of simultaneously attainable averages of quantum observables, which in general need not commute. Full description of JNR geometry quickly becomes complex as the dimensionality of quantum system grows. In this thesis I present already existing results in the theory of JNR, generalizations of the formalism and applications of JNR in the theory of phase transitions and uncertainty relations.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1707.03464

Related papers

Numerical ranges and geometry in quantum information: Entanglement, uncertainty relations, phase transitions, and state interconversion

Szymański, Konrad

Studying the geometry of sets appearing in various problems of quantum information helps in understanding different parts of the theory. It is thus worthwhile to approach quantum mechanics from the angle of geometry -- this has already provided a multitude of interesting results. In this thesis I demonstrate results relevant to numerical ranges -- the sets of simultaneously attainable expectation values of several observables. In particular, I apply this notion in the problems related to uncertainty relations, entanglement detection, and determining bounds for the value of spectral gap. Apart from this, I present geometric structures helping with the question of state interconversion using channels commuting with a particular representation of a group.

arXiv:2303.07390•Mar 13, 2023•1 citation

Uncertainty relations on the joint numerical range of operators

Arun Sehrawat

Abstract The expectation values of operators drawn from a single quantum state cannot be outside of a particular region, called their allowed region or the joint numerical range of the operators. We present a method to obtain all necessary and sufficient constraints—from Hermiticity, normalization, and positivity of a state and through the Born rule—that analytically defines the allowed region. Then, we present the allowed regions for the Heisenberg–Weyl operators, the angular momentum operators, and for their functions in dimension two to infinity. Especially, we consider three kinds of functions—combinations of powers of the ladder operators, powers of the angular momentum operators, and their anticommutators—and discover the allowed regions of different shapes. Here we also introduce uncertainty measures on the joint numerical range that are different from the standard deviation and the Shannon entropy. With the measures, we achieve a new kind of tight uncertainty relations for the Weyl- and the angular-momentum-operators. Overall, we demonstrate how the joint numerical range and the uncertainty relations change as the dimension grows. We apply the quantum de Finetti theorem to attain the allowed regions and tight uncertainty relations in the limit where the dimension goes to infinity.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Aug 19, 2019•2 citations

Bounding the Joint Numerical Range of Pauli Strings by Graph Parameters

Zhen‐Peng Xu, René Schwonnek, Andreas Winter

The relations among a given set of observables on a quantum system are effectively captured by their so-called joint numerical range, which is the set of tuples of jointly attainable expectation values. Here we explore geometric properties of this construct for Pauli strings, whose pairwise commutation and anticommutation relations determine a graph G . We investigate the connection between the parameters of this graph and the structure of minimal ellipsoids encompassing the joint numerical range, and we develop this approach in different directions. As a consequence, we find counterexamples to a conjecture by de Gois [Phys. Rev. A 107, 062211 (2023)], and answer an open question raised by Hastings and O’Donnell [, pp. 776–789], which implies a new graph parameter that we call “ β ( G ) .” Furthermore, we provide new insights into the perennial problem of estimating the ground-state energy of a many-body Hamiltonian. Our methods give lower bounds on the ground-state energy, which are typically hard to come by, and might therefore be useful in a variety of related fields. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

PRX Quantum•Apr 22, 2024•19 citations

Uncertainty relations in quantum theory

René Schwonnek

Uncertainty relations are commonly praised as one of the central pillars of quantum theory. Usually, they are taught in the first weeks of a beginners lecture, and introduced in the ?rst chapters of a textbook. However, their precise operational meaning and a formulation in a general context, i.e. beyond the example of position and momentum observables, are often left out. The reasoning for this is twofold: On one hand, an exact operational definition of uncertainty, indeterminacy and a corresponding uncertainty principle has been the content of many debates since the early days of quantum mechanics until today. From a modern perspective, we have the consent that there are at least the two notions of preparation and measurement uncertainty: the first notion prohibits the existence of dissipation free states and the latter one the existence of error free joint measurements. On the other hand, we have that, the mathematical tools, which are needed for comprehensive treatment of uncertainty relations in a general context, are still under development and usually go far beyond the mathematical level of an introductory course. In this thesis we will investigate these two notions of uncertainty, their corre- sponding uncertainty relations, such as their interplay. The aim of this thesis is to give answers to the central questions: (1.) Which quantities should be used to formulate uncertainty? (2.) How can we compute uncertainty relations for those? (3.) Are there connections between the two notions of uncertainty? We will do this, whenever possible, in a most general context and with a focus on relevant examples, otherwise. Therefore, we will consider constructions of mea- surement errors and deviation measures that quantify uncertainty, based on, so called, cost functions. Commonly used uncertainty measures like variances, en- tropies, and the Hamming distance are examples for these. We will investigate the structure of the corresponding uncertainty relations and provide several methods that enable us to compute them. The third question is addressed by a theorem that shows, for sharp observables, that measurement uncertainty relations can be lower bounded by preparation uncertainty relations, whenever the same cost function is used.

•Jan 1, 2018•2 citations

Allowed region of the mean values of angular momentum observables and their uncertainty relations

Arun Sehrawat

The expectation values of operators drawn from a single quantum state cannot be outside of a particular region, called their allowed region or the joint numerical range of the operators. Basically, the allowed region is an image of the state space under the Born rule. The maximum-eigenvalue-states---of every linear combination of the operators of interest---are sufficient to generate boundary of the allowed region. In this way, we obtain the numerical range of certain Hermitian operators (observables) that are functions of the angular momentum operators. Especially, we consider here three kinds of functions---combinations of powers of the ladder operators, powers of the angular momentum operators and their anticommutators---and discover the allowed regions of different shapes. By defining some specific concave (and convex) functions on the joint numerical range, we also achieve tight uncertainty (and certainty) relations for the observables. Overall, we demonstrate how the numerical range and uncertainty relations change as the angular momentum quantum number grows. Finally, we apply the quantum de Finetti theorem by taking a multi-qubit system and attain the allowed regions and tight uncertainty relations in the limit where the quantum number goes to infinity.

arXiv:1810.07937•Oct 18, 2018•0 citations

Bounding the joint numerical range of Pauli strings by graph parameters

Zhen‐Peng Xu, René Schwonnek, Andreas Winter

The interplay between the quantum state space and a specific set of measurements can be effectively captured by examining the set of jointly attainable expectation values. This set is commonly referred to as the (convex) joint numerical range. In this work, we explore geometric properties of this construct for measurements represented by tensor products of Pauli observables, also known as Pauli strings. The structure of pairwise commutation and anticommutation relations among a set of Pauli strings determines a graph $G$, sometimes also called the frustration graph. We investigate the connection between the parameters of this graph and the structure of minimal ellipsoids encompassing the joint numerical range. Such an outer approximation can be very practical since ellipsoids can be handled analytically even in high dimensions. We find counterexamples to a conjecture from [C. de Gois, K. Hansenne and O. Gühne, arXiv:2207.02197], and answer an open question in [M. B. Hastings and R. O'Donnell, Proc. STOC 2022, pp. 776-789], which implies a new graph parameter that we call $β(G)$. Besides, we develop this approach in different directions, such as comparison with graph-theoretic approaches in other fields, applications in quantum information theory, numerical methods, properties of the new graph parameter, etc. Our approach suggests many open questions that we discuss briefly at the end.

arXiv:2308.00753•Aug 1, 2023•7 citations
Noncommutativity lies in the heart of quantum theory and provides rich set of interesting questions in physics and mathematics. In this work I present some of them through the concept of Joint Numerical Range (JNR) - the set of simultaneously attainable averages of quantum observables, which in general need not commute. Full description of JNR geometry quickly becomes complex as the dimensionality of quantum system grows. In this thesis I present already existing results in the theory of JNR, generalizations of the formalism and applications of JNR in the theory of phase transitions and uncertainty relations.
Studying the geometry of sets appearing in various problems of quantum information helps in understanding different parts of the theory. It is thus worthwhile to approach quantum mechanics from the angle of geometry -- this has already provided a multitude of interesting results. In this thesis I demonstrate results relevant to numerical ranges -- the sets of simultaneously attainable expectation values of several observables. In particular, I apply this notion in the problems related to uncertainty relations, entanglement detection, and determining bounds for the value of spectral gap. Apart from this, I present geometric structures helping with the question of state interconversion using channels commuting with a particular representation of a group.
Abstract The expectation values of operators drawn from a single quantum state cannot be outside of a particular region, called their allowed region or the joint numerical range of the operators. We present a method to obtain all necessary and sufficient constraints—from Hermiticity, normalization, and positivity of a state and through the Born rule—that analytically defines the allowed region. Then, we present the allowed regions for the Heisenberg–Weyl operators, the angular momentum operators, and for their functions in dimension two to infinity. Especially, we consider three kinds of functions—combinations of powers of the ladder operators, powers of the angular momentum operators, and their anticommutators—and discover the allowed regions of different shapes. Here we also introduce uncertainty measures on the joint numerical range that are different from the standard deviation and the Shannon entropy. With the measures, we achieve a new kind of tight uncertainty relations for the Weyl- and the angular-momentum-operators. Overall, we demonstrate how the joint numerical range and the uncertainty relations change as the dimension grows. We apply the quantum de Finetti theorem to attain the allowed regions and tight uncertainty relations in the limit where the dimension goes to infinity.
The relations among a given set of observables on a quantum system are effectively captured by their so-called joint numerical range, which is the set of tuples of jointly attainable expectation values. Here we explore geometric properties of this construct for Pauli strings, whose pairwise commutation and anticommutation relations determine a graph G . We investigate the connection between the parameters of this graph and the structure of minimal ellipsoids encompassing the joint numerical range, and we develop this approach in different directions. As a consequence, we find counterexamples to a conjecture by de Gois [Phys. Rev. A 107, 062211 (2023)], and answer an open question raised by Hastings and O’Donnell [, pp. 776–789], which implies a new graph parameter that we call “ β ( G ) .” Furthermore, we provide new insights into the perennial problem of estimating the ground-state energy of a many-body Hamiltonian. Our methods give lower bounds on the ground-state energy, which are typically hard to come by, and might therefore be useful in a variety of related fields. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
Uncertainty relations are commonly praised as one of the central pillars of quantum theory. Usually, they are taught in the first weeks of a beginners lecture, and introduced in the ?rst chapters of a textbook. However, their precise operational meaning and a formulation in a general context, i.e. beyond the example of position and momentum observables, are often left out. The reasoning for this is twofold: On one hand, an exact operational definition of uncertainty, indeterminacy and a corresponding uncertainty principle has been the content of many debates since the early days of quantum mechanics until today. From a modern perspective, we have the consent that there are at least the two notions of preparation and measurement uncertainty: the first notion prohibits the existence of dissipation free states and the latter one the existence of error free joint measurements. On the other hand, we have that, the mathematical tools, which are needed for comprehensive treatment of uncertainty relations in a general context, are still under development and usually go far beyond the mathematical level of an introductory course. In this thesis we will investigate these two notions of uncertainty, their corre- sponding uncertainty relations, such as their interplay. The aim of this thesis is to give answers to the central questions: (1.) Which quantities should be used to formulate uncertainty? (2.) How can we compute uncertainty relations for those? (3.) Are there connections between the two notions of uncertainty? We will do this, whenever possible, in a most general context and with a focus on relevant examples, otherwise. Therefore, we will consider constructions of mea- surement errors and deviation measures that quantify uncertainty, based on, so called, cost functions. Commonly used uncertainty measures like variances, en- tropies, and the Hamming distance are examples for these. We will investigate the structure of the corresponding uncertainty relations and provide several methods that enable us to compute them. The third question is addressed by a theorem that shows, for sharp observables, that measurement uncertainty relations can be lower bounded by preparation uncertainty relations, whenever the same cost function is used.
The expectation values of operators drawn from a single quantum state cannot be outside of a particular region, called their allowed region or the joint numerical range of the operators. Basically, the allowed region is an image of the state space under the Born rule. The maximum-eigenvalue-states---of every linear combination of the operators of interest---are sufficient to generate boundary of the allowed region. In this way, we obtain the numerical range of certain Hermitian operators (observables) that are functions of the angular momentum operators. Especially, we consider here three kinds of functions---combinations of powers of the ladder operators, powers of the angular momentum operators and their anticommutators---and discover the allowed regions of different shapes. By defining some specific concave (and convex) functions on the joint numerical range, we also achieve tight uncertainty (and certainty) relations for the observables. Overall, we demonstrate how the numerical range and uncertainty relations change as the angular momentum quantum number grows. Finally, we apply the quantum de Finetti theorem by taking a multi-qubit system and attain the allowed regions and tight uncertainty relations in the limit where the quantum number goes to infinity.
The interplay between the quantum state space and a specific set of measurements can be effectively captured by examining the set of jointly attainable expectation values. This set is commonly referred to as the (convex) joint numerical range. In this work, we explore geometric properties of this construct for measurements represented by tensor products of Pauli observables, also known as Pauli strings. The structure of pairwise commutation and anticommutation relations among a set of Pauli strings determines a graph GGG, sometimes also called the frustration graph. We investigate the connection between the parameters of this graph and the structure of minimal ellipsoids encompassing the joint numerical range. Such an outer approximation can be very practical since ellipsoids can be handled analytically even in high dimensions. We find counterexamples to a conjecture from [C. de Gois, K. Hansenne and O. Gühne, arXiv:2207.02197], and answer an open question in [M. B. Hastings and R. O'Donnell, Proc. STOC 2022, pp. 776-789], which implies a new graph parameter that we call β(G)β(G)β(G). Besides, we develop this approach in different directions, such as comparison with graph-theoretic approaches in other fields, applications in quantum information theory, numerical methods, properties of the new graph parameter, etc. Our approach suggests many open questions that we discuss briefly at the end.