Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1707.02620 · Physical Review Letters

Almost-Quantum Correlations Violate the No-Restriction Hypothesis

Ana Belén Sainz, Yelena Guryanova, Antonio Acín, Miguel Navascués

Published May 18, 2018• 31 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

To identify which principles characterize quantum correlations, it is essential to understand in which sense this set of correlations differs from that of almost-quantum correlations. We solve this problem by invoking the so-called no-restriction hypothesis, an explicit and natural axiom in many reconstructions of quantum theory stating that the set of possible measurements is the dual of the set of states. We prove that, contrary to quantum correlations, no generalized probabilistic theory satisfying the no-restriction hypothesis is able to reproduce the set of almost-quantum correlations. Therefore, any theory whose correlations are exactly, or very close to, the almost-quantum correlations necessarily requires a rule limiting the possible measurements. Our results suggest that the no-restriction hypothesis may play a fundamental role in singling out the set of quantum correlations among other nonsignaling ones.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.120.200402

Related papers

Quantum Correlations Are Stronger Than All Nonsignaling Correlations Produced by n -Outcome Measurements

Matthias Kleinmann, Adán Cabello

We show that, for any n, there are m-outcome quantum correlations, with m>n, which are stronger than any nonsignaling correlation produced from selecting among n-outcome measurements. As a consequence, for any n, there are m-outcome quantum measurements that cannot be constructed by selecting locally from the set of n-outcome measurements. This is a property of the set of measurements in quantum theory that is not mandatory for general probabilistic theories. We also show that this prediction can be tested through high-precision Bell-type experiments and identify past experiments providing evidence that some of these strong correlations exist in nature. Finally, we provide a modified version of quantum theory restricted to having at most n-outcome quantum measurements.

arXiv:1505.04179•Physical Review Letters•Oct 7, 2016•30 citations

Almost-quantum correlations violate the isotropy and homogeneity principles in flat space

A. Fahmi

One of fascinating phenomena of nature is quantum nonlocality, which is observed upon measurements on spacelike entangled systems. However, there are sets of post-quantum models which have stronger correlations than quantum mechanics, wherein instantaneous communication remains impossible. The set of almost quantum correlations is one of post-quantum models which satisfies all kinematic axioms of standard quantum correlations except one, meanwhile they contain correlations slightly stronger than quantum correlations. There arises the natural question whether there is some fundamental principle of nature which can genuinely characterizes quantum correlations. Here, we provide an answer and close this gap by invoking the isotropy and homogeneity principles of the flat space as a conclusive and distinguishing criterion to rule out the almost-quantum correlations model. In particular, to characterize quantum correlations we impose the isotropy and homogeneity symmetry group structure on the almost quantum correlations model and request that the joint probability distributions corresponding to the Born rule remain invariant. We prove that this condition is sufficient (and necessary) to reduce the almost quantum correlations model to quantum mechanics in both bipartite and multipartite systems.

arXiv:2411.07631•Nov 12, 2024•1 citation

Almost Quantum Correlations are Inconsistent with Specker's Principle

Tomáš Gonda, Ravi Kunjwal, David Schmid +2 more

Ernst Specker considered a particular feature of quantum theory to be especially fundamental, namely that pairwise joint measurability of sharp measurements implies their global joint measurability ( vimeo.com/52923835 ). To date, Specker's principle seemed incapable of singling out quantum theory from the space of all general probabilistic theories. In particular, its well-known consequence for experimental statistics, the principle of consistent exclusivity, does not rule out the set of correlations known as almost quantum, which is strictly larger than the set of quantum correlations. Here we show that, contrary to the popular belief, Specker's principle cannot be satisfied in any theory that yields almost quantum correlations.

arXiv:1712.01225•Quantum•Aug 27, 2018•22 citations

Correlations in nature are not merely quantum dichotomic

Matthias Kleinmann, Adán Cabello

We show that, for any n, there are m-outcome quantum correlations, with m>n, which are stronger than any nonsignaling correlation produced from selecting among n-outcome measurements. As a consequence, for any n, there are m-outcome quantum measurements that cannot be constructed by selecting locally from the set of n-outcome measurements. This is a property of the set of measurements in quantum theory that is not mandatory for general probabilistic theories. We also show that this prediction can be tested through high-precision Bell-type experiments and identify past experiments providing evidence that some of these strong correlations exist in nature. Finally, we provide a modified version of quantum theory restricted to having at most n-outcome quantum measurements.

•May 15, 2015•1 citation

Naturally restricted subsets of nonsignaling correlations: typicality and convergence

Pei-Sheng Lin, Tamás Vértesi, Yeong-Cherng Liang

It is well-known that in a Bell experiment, the observed correlation between measurement outcomes – as predicted by quantum theory – can be stronger than that allowed by local causality, yet not fully constrained by the principle of relativistic causality. In practice, the characterization of the set Q of quantum correlations is carried out, often, through a converging hierarchy of outer approximations. On the other hand, some subsets of Q arising from additional constraints [e.g., originating from quantum states having positive-partial-transposition (PPT) or being finite-dimensional maximally entangled (MES)] turn out to be also amenable to similar numerical characterizations. How, then, at a quantitative level, are all these naturally restricted subsets of nonsignaling correlations different? Here, we consider several bipartite Bell scenarios and numerically estimate their volume relative to that of the set of nonsignaling correlations. Within the number of cases investigated, we have observed that (1) for a given number of inputs ns (outputs no ), the relative volume of both the Bell-local set and the quantum set increases (decreases) rapidly with increasing no ( ns ) (2) although the so-called macroscopically local set Q1 may approximate Q well in the two-input scenarios, it can be a very poor approximation of the quantum set when ns > no (3) the almost-quantum set Q~1 is an exceptionally-good approximation to the quantum set (4) the difference between Q and the set of correlations originating from MES is most significant when no=2 , whereas (5) the difference between the Bell-local set and the PPT set generally becomes more significant with increasing no . This last comparison, in particular, allows us to identify Bell scenarios where there is little hope of realizing the Bell violation by PPT states and those that deserve further exploration.

arXiv:2107.05646•Quantum•Jul 14, 2022•10 citations

Characterization of nonsignaling bipartite correlations corresponding to quantum states

Markus Frembs, Andreas Döring

Characterizing quantum correlations from physical principles is a central problem in the field of quantum information theory. Entanglement breaks bounds on correlations put forth by Bell's theorem, thus challenging the notion of local causality as a physical principle. A natural relaxation is to study no-signalling as a constraint on joint probability distributions. It was shown that, when considered with respect to so-called locally quantum observables, bipartite nonsignalling correlations never exceed their quantum counterparts; still, such correlations generally do not derive from quantum states. This leaves open the search for additional principles which identify quantum states within the larger set of (collections of) nonsignalling joint probability distributions over locally quantum observables. Here, we suggest a natural generalization of no-signalling in the form of no-disturbance to dilated systems. We prove that nonsignalling joint probability distributions satisfying this extension correspond with bipartite quantum states up to a choice of time orientation in subsystems.

arXiv:2204.11471•Physical Review A•Dec 19, 2022•4 citations
To identify which principles characterize quantum correlations, it is essential to understand in which sense this set of correlations differs from that of almost-quantum correlations. We solve this problem by invoking the so-called no-restriction hypothesis, an explicit and natural axiom in many reconstructions of quantum theory stating that the set of possible measurements is the dual of the set of states. We prove that, contrary to quantum correlations, no generalized probabilistic theory satisfying the no-restriction hypothesis is able to reproduce the set of almost-quantum correlations. Therefore, any theory whose correlations are exactly, or very close to, the almost-quantum correlations necessarily requires a rule limiting the possible measurements. Our results suggest that the no-restriction hypothesis may play a fundamental role in singling out the set of quantum correlations among other nonsignaling ones.
We show that, for any n, there are m-outcome quantum correlations, with m>n, which are stronger than any nonsignaling correlation produced from selecting among n-outcome measurements. As a consequence, for any n, there are m-outcome quantum measurements that cannot be constructed by selecting locally from the set of n-outcome measurements. This is a property of the set of measurements in quantum theory that is not mandatory for general probabilistic theories. We also show that this prediction can be tested through high-precision Bell-type experiments and identify past experiments providing evidence that some of these strong correlations exist in nature. Finally, we provide a modified version of quantum theory restricted to having at most n-outcome quantum measurements.
One of fascinating phenomena of nature is quantum nonlocality, which is observed upon measurements on spacelike entangled systems. However, there are sets of post-quantum models which have stronger correlations than quantum mechanics, wherein instantaneous communication remains impossible. The set of almost quantum correlations is one of post-quantum models which satisfies all kinematic axioms of standard quantum correlations except one, meanwhile they contain correlations slightly stronger than quantum correlations. There arises the natural question whether there is some fundamental principle of nature which can genuinely characterizes quantum correlations. Here, we provide an answer and close this gap by invoking the isotropy and homogeneity principles of the flat space as a conclusive and distinguishing criterion to rule out the almost-quantum correlations model. In particular, to characterize quantum correlations we impose the isotropy and homogeneity symmetry group structure on the almost quantum correlations model and request that the joint probability distributions corresponding to the Born rule remain invariant. We prove that this condition is sufficient (and necessary) to reduce the almost quantum correlations model to quantum mechanics in both bipartite and multipartite systems.
Ernst Specker considered a particular feature of quantum theory to be especially fundamental, namely that pairwise joint measurability of sharp measurements implies their global joint measurability ( vimeo.com/52923835 ). To date, Specker's principle seemed incapable of singling out quantum theory from the space of all general probabilistic theories. In particular, its well-known consequence for experimental statistics, the principle of consistent exclusivity, does not rule out the set of correlations known as almost quantum, which is strictly larger than the set of quantum correlations. Here we show that, contrary to the popular belief, Specker's principle cannot be satisfied in any theory that yields almost quantum correlations.
We show that, for any n, there are m-outcome quantum correlations, with m>n, which are stronger than any nonsignaling correlation produced from selecting among n-outcome measurements. As a consequence, for any n, there are m-outcome quantum measurements that cannot be constructed by selecting locally from the set of n-outcome measurements. This is a property of the set of measurements in quantum theory that is not mandatory for general probabilistic theories. We also show that this prediction can be tested through high-precision Bell-type experiments and identify past experiments providing evidence that some of these strong correlations exist in nature. Finally, we provide a modified version of quantum theory restricted to having at most n-outcome quantum measurements.
It is well-known that in a Bell experiment, the observed correlation between measurement outcomes – as predicted by quantum theory – can be stronger than that allowed by local causality, yet not fully constrained by the principle of relativistic causality. In practice, the characterization of the set Q of quantum correlations is carried out, often, through a converging hierarchy of outer approximations. On the other hand, some subsets of Q arising from additional constraints [e.g., originating from quantum states having positive-partial-transposition (PPT) or being finite-dimensional maximally entangled (MES)] turn out to be also amenable to similar numerical characterizations. How, then, at a quantitative level, are all these naturally restricted subsets of nonsignaling correlations different? Here, we consider several bipartite Bell scenarios and numerically estimate their volume relative to that of the set of nonsignaling correlations. Within the number of cases investigated, we have observed that (1) for a given number of inputs ns (outputs no ), the relative volume of both the Bell-local set and the quantum set increases (decreases) rapidly with increasing no ( ns ) (2) although the so-called macroscopically local set Q1 may approximate Q well in the two-input scenarios, it can be a very poor approximation of the quantum set when ns > no (3) the almost-quantum set Q~1 is an exceptionally-good approximation to the quantum set (4) the difference between Q and the set of correlations originating from MES is most significant when no=2 , whereas (5) the difference between the Bell-local set and the PPT set generally becomes more significant with increasing no . This last comparison, in particular, allows us to identify Bell scenarios where there is little hope of realizing the Bell violation by PPT states and those that deserve further exploration.
Characterizing quantum correlations from physical principles is a central problem in the field of quantum information theory. Entanglement breaks bounds on correlations put forth by Bell's theorem, thus challenging the notion of local causality as a physical principle. A natural relaxation is to study no-signalling as a constraint on joint probability distributions. It was shown that, when considered with respect to so-called locally quantum observables, bipartite nonsignalling correlations never exceed their quantum counterparts; still, such correlations generally do not derive from quantum states. This leaves open the search for additional principles which identify quantum states within the larger set of (collections of) nonsignalling joint probability distributions over locally quantum observables. Here, we suggest a natural generalization of no-signalling in the form of no-disturbance to dilated systems. We prove that nonsignalling joint probability distributions satisfying this extension correspond with bipartite quantum states up to a choice of time orientation in subsystems.