Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1706.06171 · Advances in Theoretical and Mathematical Physics

On the positivity of trace class operators

Elena Cordero, Maurice A. de Gosson, Fabio Nicola

Published Jan 1, 2019• 19 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The characterization of positivity properties of Weyl operators is a notoriously difficult problem, and not much progress has been made since the pioneering work of Kastler, Loupias, and Miracle-Sole (KLM). In this paper we begin by reviewing and giving simpler proofs of some known results for trace-class Weyl operators; the latter play an essential role in quantum mechanics. We then apply time-frequency analysis techniques to prove a phase space version of the KLM condition; the main tools are Gabor frames and the Wigner formalism. Finally, discrete approximations of the KLM condition, which are tractable numerically, are provided.

DOI
10.4310/atmp.2019.v23.n8.a4

Related papers

Wigner function and weyl transform, trace class

Mykola Yaremenko

The connection between cross-ambiguity and cross-Wigner functions is studied. The correspondence between the class of symbols and the Weyl operators is established; we obtain the necessary and sufficient conditions on the symbol under which the Weyl operator belongs to the trace class. The theory of Kaster-Loupias-Miracle is developed and the exact conditions on the Weyl operator to be positively defined in the Hilbert space is established.

Research in Mathematics•May 11, 2022•0 citations

Aspects of quantum phase space

Philip Watson

This thesis addresses aspects of quantum phase and sets out to draw attention to a collection of new and extend some not so new techniques utilizing Weyl's correspondence rule and its inverse. The phase formulation of quantum mechanics is as old as quantum mechanics itself and evolved over a period of two decades due to the contributions of H. Weyl \cite{Weyl1950}, E. P. Wigner \cite{Wigner1932}, H. Groenewold \cite{Groenewold1946} and J. E. Moyal \cite{Moyal1949}. Over the ensuing years the phase picture has matured into a practical analytical tool, and has generated a multitude of technical papers, reports, reviews, and expositions from many authors and commentators. One reason for its success is that it offers an intuitive picture of quantum mechanics owing to its \it{classical look and feel}, and it has made an impression, in one way or another, in many fields such as mathematical physics, quantum optics, and physical chemistry.The thesis opens with a brief history of classical phase space, tracing the possible origin of the term ``phase space itself, and chronicles the events leading to the conceptualization (and generalization) of quantum phase space. In Chapter 2 the Weyl correspondence is recast in terms of von Neumann's integral kernel transform and a heuristic analysis is given from this perspective. A characteristic of Weyl's correspondence rule and its inverse is that there are two inherent representations of the same operator. These have been referred to as the Weyl representation and Wigner representation and are related by a symplectic Fourier transform. For an arbitrary outer dyadic operator it is shown that the Weyl representation leads to the \it{modified} Gabor transform (known to Signal Processing), while the Wigner representation specializes to the Bargmann transform and a representation in terms of analytic functions. Calculating Weyl-Wigner (WW) transforms of products of $n$ operators, from first principles, has proved to be a technically difficult problem. However, with the machinery developed in Chapter 2 the problem is reduced to a straightforward algebraic exercise. Finally, forming an $s$-parametrized generalization of Weyl's correspondence rule and focusing on the Weyl representation it is shown to lead to an intimate relationship with the relative state formalism \cite{Ban1998}. Weyl's correspondence rule is only applicable to operators and consequently state vectors $|\psi\rangle$ are not represented in the usual formulation of quantum phase space. This problem is circumvented in Chapter 3 by introducing the notion of a normalized fixed state (or window) vector $|\varphi_0\rangle$ to form an outer dyadic product $\wh{\Psi} = |\psi\rangle\langle\varphi_0|$. The WW transform of this product under the action of the Weyl's rule is a complex valued function of real variables called a phase amplitude and denoted by the symbol $\Psi$. The phase amplitudes have many (and sometimes surprising) properties. For example they: \begin{itemize} \item form the building blocks of Wigner functions $W$ by admitting a generalized Born rule $W = \Psi \star \bar{\Psi}$, and as such can be considered to be a more fundamental objects than Wigner functions; \item superpose and interfere like the state vectors they represent; \item specialize to the Bargmann and Gabor transforms when a Gaussian window is chosen; \end{itemize} \ni In Chapter 4 further aspects of phase amplitudes are explored and discussed. For example it is shown that they: \begin{itemize} \item define phase state vectors which form an over complete set and are elements of a reproducing kernel Hilbert space; \item allow unitary ray representations of the group symmetries of translation, rotation and time reversal; \item evolve in phase under the influence of a propagator $\cal{R}$ which is intimately related to the Wigner propagator $P$. \end{itemize} Chapter 5 considers an extension of phase amplitudes to include systems with finitely many degrees of freedom. These are called spin amplitudes and are obtained by first forming the outer dyadic product of a spin state vector with an arbitrary fixed spin state vector, and then applying a finite-dimensional analogue of the WW transform. The spin amplitude operator is represented as an $n \times n$ matrix, whose elements are products of the spin components of the spin and fixed state vectors. Two kinds of spin amplitudes are considered, arising on the sphere $\cal{S}^2$ or on a $(2j + 1)$ dimensional lattice. In the special case of spin-$\half$ systems it is shown that the spin amplitudes transform as spinors under rotations on both the sphere and lattice. As a physical application the spin amplitudes for a spin-$\half$ magnetic dipole are found for a Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) environment. Chapter 6 considers Schwinger's abstract approach to quantum mechanics which takes into account the inability to indefinitely compensate for fluctuations in the measurement process. The resulting measurement algebra provides a symbolic representation of the physical laws as opposed to the mathematical abstraction (of von Neumann and Dirac) that was justified \it{\'a posteriori} by being in agreement with experiment. Despite Schwinger's prolific work on the subject of measurement algebra, its interpretation in quantum phase remained an open issue. It is shown that the key to formulating a quantum phase in terms of the measurement operators and transformation functions is the determination of a suitable set of basis operators for an arbitrary measurement operator. Many new results follow as a consequence of expanding an arbitrary measurement operator in this basis. In Chapter 7 the quantum-classical interface is explored by considering Hamilton's principal function or action $S(q,v,t)$. Starting from a purely heuristic classical argument, a phase function $U(p,q,t)$ is derived in terms of the classical action and is shown to be proportional to the WW transform of the quantum evolution operator. This association leads to the transform \be U(p,q,t) = A(t) \int e^{ipv/\hbar} e^{iS(q,v,t)/\hbar} \; \rm{d}v, \ee which enables one, in principle, to deduce the Wigner functions of a given system when only the classical action is known. Simple physical systems are used to provide examples illustrating this approach.

•Mar 1, 2012•0 citations

The generalized Weyl correspondence and time-dependent stochastic processes

Manuel Gadella, Luis Miguel Nieto, J. M. Noriega +1 more

The definition and some general properties of the generalized Weyl correspondence between stochastic processes and operator-valued real functions on a Hilbert space plus a trace class operator are given. The relation between the derivatives of an operator-valued function and the derivative of the corresponding stochastic process are studied. When the operator-valued function is the position (or momentum) in the Heisenberg picture, a condition for the positivity of the joint distribution functions of the corresponding process is given, provided that the evolution Hamiltonian be quadratic in the position and momentum. Finally, the case of an arbitrary Hamiltonian evolution for the position operator is studied and the two-dimensional density functions of the process is related to the Wigner function associated to some state ρ̂, and a necessary condition for the positivity of the densities is given.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Dec 1, 1987•2 citations

Distributions of ℏ-positive type and applications

Francis J. Narcowich

States in classical mechanics are probability measures, and their Fourier transforms are continuous functions of positive type. States in the phase-space formulation of quantum mechanics are Wigner distribution functions, and their (symplectic) Fourier transforms have been characterized by Kastler [Commun. Math. Phys. 1, 14 (1965)] and Loupias and Miracle-Sole [Commun. Math. Phys. 2, 31 (1966); Ann. Insto. H. Poincaré 6, 39 (1967)] as being continuous functions of ‘‘ℏ-positive type.’’ In this paper, (Schwartz) distributions of ℏ-positive type, are defined and studied. It is shown that if such distributions are bounded on a certain sequence of test functions, then they are symplectic Fourier transforms of Wigner distribution functions. These results, are applied to a variety of problems ranging from ones involving the quantum Liouville equation to a problem in signal analysis.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Nov 1, 1989•26 citations

Linear perturbations of the Wigner distribution and the Cohen class

Elena Cordero, S. Ivan Trapasso

The Wigner distribution is a milestone of Time–frequency Analysis. In order to cope with its drawbacks while preserving the desirable features that made it so popular, several kinds of modifications have been proposed. This contribution fits into this perspective. We introduce a family of phase-space representations of Wigner type associated with invertible matrices and explore their general properties. As a main result, we provide a characterization for the Cohen’s class [L. Cohen, Generalized phase-space distribution functions, J. Math. Phys. 7 (1996) 781–786; Time–frequency Analysis (Prentice Hall, New Jersey, 1995)]. This feature suggests to interpret this family of representations as linear perturbations of the Wigner distribution. We show which of its properties survive under linear perturbations and which ones are truly distinctive of its central role.

arXiv:1811.07795•Analysis and Applications•Mar 25, 2019•41 citations

Wigner–Weyl correspondence in quantum mechanics for continuous and discrete systems—a Dirac-inspired view

S. Chaturvedi, Elisa Ercolessi, Giuseppe Marmo +3 more

Drawing inspiration from Dirac's work on functions of non-commuting observables, we develop an approach to phase-space descriptions of operators and the Wigner–Weyl correspondence in quantum mechanics, complementary to standard formulations. This involves a two-step process: introducing phase-space descriptions based on placing position dependences to the left of momentum dependences (or the other way around); then carrying out a natural transformation to eliminate a kernel which appears in the expression for the trace of the product of two operators. The method works uniformly for both continuous Cartesian degrees of freedom and for systems with finite-dimensional state spaces. It is interesting that the kernel encountered is naturally expressible in terms of geometric phases, and its removal involves extracting its square root in a suitable manner.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Jan 24, 2006•81 citations
The characterization of positivity properties of Weyl operators is a notoriously difficult problem, and not much progress has been made since the pioneering work of Kastler, Loupias, and Miracle-Sole (KLM). In this paper we begin by reviewing and giving simpler proofs of some known results for trace-class Weyl operators; the latter play an essential role in quantum mechanics. We then apply time-frequency analysis techniques to prove a phase space version of the KLM condition; the main tools are Gabor frames and the Wigner formalism. Finally, discrete approximations of the KLM condition, which are tractable numerically, are provided.
This thesis addresses aspects of quantum phase and sets out to draw attention to a collection of new and extend some not so new techniques utilizing Weyl's correspondence rule and its inverse. The phase formulation of quantum mechanics is as old as quantum mechanics itself and evolved over a period of two decades due to the contributions of H. Weyl \cite{Weyl1950}, E. P. Wigner \cite{Wigner1932}, H. Groenewold \cite{Groenewold1946} and J. E. Moyal \cite{Moyal1949}. Over the ensuing years the phase picture has matured into a practical analytical tool, and has generated a multitude of technical papers, reports, reviews, and expositions from many authors and commentators. One reason for its success is that it offers an intuitive picture of quantum mechanics owing to its \it{classical look and feel}, and it has made an impression, in one way or another, in many fields such as mathematical physics, quantum optics, and physical chemistry.The thesis opens with a brief history of classical phase space, tracing the possible origin of the term ``phase space itself, and chronicles the events leading to the conceptualization (and generalization) of quantum phase space. In Chapter 2 the Weyl correspondence is recast in terms of von Neumann's integral kernel transform and a heuristic analysis is given from this perspective. A characteristic of Weyl's correspondence rule and its inverse is that there are two inherent representations of the same operator. These have been referred to as the Weyl representation and Wigner representation and are related by a symplectic Fourier transform. For an arbitrary outer dyadic operator it is shown that the Weyl representation leads to the \it{modified} Gabor transform (known to Signal Processing), while the Wigner representation specializes to the Bargmann transform and a representation in terms of analytic functions. Calculating Weyl-Wigner (WW) transforms of products of nnn operators, from first principles, has proved to be a technically difficult problem. However, with the machinery developed in Chapter 2 the problem is reduced to a straightforward algebraic exercise. Finally, forming an sss-parametrized generalization of Weyl's correspondence rule and focusing on the Weyl representation it is shown to lead to an intimate relationship with the relative state formalism \cite{Ban1998}. Weyl's correspondence rule is only applicable to operators and consequently state vectors ∣ψ⟩|\psi\rangle∣ψ⟩ are not represented in the usual formulation of quantum phase space. This problem is circumvented in Chapter 3 by introducing the notion of a normalized fixed state (or window) vector ∣φ0⟩|\varphi_0\rangle∣φ0​⟩ to form an outer dyadic product $\wh{\Psi} = |\psi\rangle\langle\varphi_0|$. The WW transform of this product under the action of the Weyl's rule is a complex valued function of real variables called a phase amplitude and denoted by the symbol Ψ\PsiΨ. The phase amplitudes have many (and sometimes surprising) properties. For example they: \begin{itemize} \item form the building blocks of Wigner functions WWW by admitting a generalized Born rule W=Ψ⋆ΨˉW = \Psi \star \bar{\Psi}W=Ψ⋆Ψˉ, and as such can be considered to be a more fundamental objects than Wigner functions; \item superpose and interfere like the state vectors they represent; \item specialize to the Bargmann and Gabor transforms when a Gaussian window is chosen; \end{itemize} \ni In Chapter 4 further aspects of phase amplitudes are explored and discussed. For example it is shown that they: \begin{itemize} \item define phase state vectors which form an over complete set and are elements of a reproducing kernel Hilbert space; \item allow unitary ray representations of the group symmetries of translation, rotation and time reversal; \item evolve in phase under the influence of a propagator R\cal{R}R which is intimately related to the Wigner propagator PPP. \end{itemize} Chapter 5 considers an extension of phase amplitudes to include systems with finitely many degrees of freedom. These are called spin amplitudes and are obtained by first forming the outer dyadic product of a spin state vector with an arbitrary fixed spin state vector, and then applying a finite-dimensional analogue of the WW transform. The spin amplitude operator is represented as an n×nn \times nn×n matrix, whose elements are products of the spin components of the spin and fixed state vectors. Two kinds of spin amplitudes are considered, arising on the sphere S2\cal{S}^2S2 or on a (2j+1)(2j + 1)(2j+1) dimensional lattice. In the special case of spin-$\half$ systems it is shown that the spin amplitudes transform as spinors under rotations on both the sphere and lattice. As a physical application the spin amplitudes for a spin-$\half$ magnetic dipole are found for a Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) environment. Chapter 6 considers Schwinger's abstract approach to quantum mechanics which takes into account the inability to indefinitely compensate for fluctuations in the measurement process. The resulting measurement algebra provides a symbolic representation of the physical laws as opposed to the mathematical abstraction (of von Neumann and Dirac) that was justified \it{\'a posteriori} by being in agreement with experiment. Despite Schwinger's prolific work on the subject of measurement algebra, its interpretation in quantum phase remained an open issue. It is shown that the key to formulating a quantum phase in terms of the measurement operators and transformation functions is the determination of a suitable set of basis operators for an arbitrary measurement operator. Many new results follow as a consequence of expanding an arbitrary measurement operator in this basis. In Chapter 7 the quantum-classical interface is explored by considering Hamilton's principal function or action S(q,v,t)S(q,v,t)S(q,v,t). Starting from a purely heuristic classical argument, a phase function U(p,q,t)U(p,q,t)U(p,q,t) is derived in terms of the classical action and is shown to be proportional to the WW transform of the quantum evolution operator. This association leads to the transform \be U(p,q,t) = A(t) \int e^{ipv/\hbar} e^{iS(q,v,t)/\hbar} \; \rm{d}v, \ee which enables one, in principle, to deduce the Wigner functions of a given system when only the classical action is known. Simple physical systems are used to provide examples illustrating this approach.
The definition and some general properties of the generalized Weyl correspondence between stochastic processes and operator-valued real functions on a Hilbert space plus a trace class operator are given. The relation between the derivatives of an operator-valued function and the derivative of the corresponding stochastic process are studied. When the operator-valued function is the position (or momentum) in the Heisenberg picture, a condition for the positivity of the joint distribution functions of the corresponding process is given, provided that the evolution Hamiltonian be quadratic in the position and momentum. Finally, the case of an arbitrary Hamiltonian evolution for the position operator is studied and the two-dimensional density functions of the process is related to the Wigner function associated to some state ρ̂, and a necessary condition for the positivity of the densities is given.
States in classical mechanics are probability measures, and their Fourier transforms are continuous functions of positive type. States in the phase-space formulation of quantum mechanics are Wigner distribution functions, and their (symplectic) Fourier transforms have been characterized by Kastler [Commun. Math. Phys. 1, 14 (1965)] and Loupias and Miracle-Sole [Commun. Math. Phys. 2, 31 (1966); Ann. Insto. H. Poincaré 6, 39 (1967)] as being continuous functions of ‘‘ℏ-positive type.’’ In this paper, (Schwartz) distributions of ℏ-positive type, are defined and studied. It is shown that if such distributions are bounded on a certain sequence of test functions, then they are symplectic Fourier transforms of Wigner distribution functions. These results, are applied to a variety of problems ranging from ones involving the quantum Liouville equation to a problem in signal analysis.
The Wigner distribution is a milestone of Time–frequency Analysis. In order to cope with its drawbacks while preserving the desirable features that made it so popular, several kinds of modifications have been proposed. This contribution fits into this perspective. We introduce a family of phase-space representations of Wigner type associated with invertible matrices and explore their general properties. As a main result, we provide a characterization for the Cohen’s class [L. Cohen, Generalized phase-space distribution functions, J. Math. Phys. 7 (1996) 781–786; Time–frequency Analysis (Prentice Hall, New Jersey, 1995)]. This feature suggests to interpret this family of representations as linear perturbations of the Wigner distribution. We show which of its properties survive under linear perturbations and which ones are truly distinctive of its central role.
Drawing inspiration from Dirac's work on functions of non-commuting observables, we develop an approach to phase-space descriptions of operators and the Wigner–Weyl correspondence in quantum mechanics, complementary to standard formulations. This involves a two-step process: introducing phase-space descriptions based on placing position dependences to the left of momentum dependences (or the other way around); then carrying out a natural transformation to eliminate a kernel which appears in the expression for the trace of the product of two operators. The method works uniformly for both continuous Cartesian degrees of freedom and for systems with finite-dimensional state spaces. It is interesting that the kernel encountered is naturally expressible in terms of geometric phases, and its removal involves extracting its square root in a suitable manner.