Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1705.08927 · Quantum Science and Technology

Compiling quantum circuits to realistic hardware architectures using temporal planners

Davide Venturelli, Minh Do, Eleanor Gilbert Rieffel, Jeremy Frank

Published Dec 20, 2017• 140 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract To run quantum algorithms on emerging gate-model quantum hardware, quantum circuits must be compiled to take into account constraints on the hardware. For near-term hardware, with only limited means to mitigate decoherence, it is critical to minimize the duration of the circuit. We investigate the application of temporal planners to the problem of compiling quantum circuits to newly emerging quantum hardware. While our approach is general, we focus on compiling to superconducting hardware architectures with nearest neighbor constraints. Our initial experiments focus on compiling Quantum Alternating Operator Ansatz (QAOA) circuits whose high number of commuting gates allow great flexibility in the order in which the gates can be applied. That freedom makes it more challenging to find optimal compilations but also means there is a greater potential win from more optimized compilation than for less flexible circuits. We map this quantum circuit compilation problem to a temporal planning problem, and generated a test suite of compilation problems for QAOA circuits of various sizes to a realistic hardware architecture. We report compilation results from several state-of-the-art temporal planners on this test set. This early empirical evaluation demonstrates that temporal planning is a viable approach to quantum circuit compilation.

DOI
10.1088/2058-9565/aaa331

Related papers

Temporal Planning for Compilation of Quantum Approximate Optimization Circuits

Davide Venturelli, Minh Do, Eleanor Gilbert Rieffel +1 more

We investigate the application of temporal planners to the problem of compiling quantum circuits to emerging quantum hardware. While our approach is general, we focus our initial experiments on Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) circuits that have few ordering constraints and thus allow highly parallel plans. We report on experiments using several temporal planners to compile circuits of various sizes to a realistic hardware architecture. This early empirical evaluation suggests that temporal planning is a viable approach to quantum circuit compilation.

International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence•Jul 28, 2017•47 citations

Planning for Compilation of a Quantum Algorithm for Graph Coloring

Do Minh, Wang Zhihui, Bryan O’Gorman +3 more

The problem of compiling general quantum algorithms for implementation on near-term quantum processors has been introduced to the AI community. Previous work demonstrated that temporal planning is an attractive approach for part of this compilationtask, specifically, the routing of circuits that implement the Quantum Alternating Operator Ansatz (QAOA) applied to the MaxCut problem on a quantum processor architecture. In this paper, we extend the earlier work to route circuits that implement QAOA for Graph Coloring problems. QAOA for coloring requires execution of more, and more complex, operations on the chip, which makes routing a more challenging problem. We evaluate the approach on state-of-the-art hardware architectures from leading quantum computing companies. Additionally, we apply a planning approach to qubit initialization. Our empirical evaluation shows that temporal planning compares well to reasonable analytic upper bounds, and that solving qubit initialization with a classical planner generally helps temporal planners in finding shorter-makespan compilations for QAOA for Graph Coloring. These advances suggest that temporal planning can be an effective approach for more complex quantum computing algorithms and architectures.

arXiv:2002.10917•Frontiers in artificial intelligence and applications•Jan 1, 2020•14 citations

Circuit Compilation Methodologies for Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm

Mahabubul Alam, Abdullah Ash Saki, Swaroop Ghosh

The quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA) is a promising quantum-classical hybrid algorithm to solve hard combinatorial optimization problems. The multi-qubit CPHASE gates used in the quantum circuit for QAOA are commutative i.e., the order of the gates can be altered without changing the output state. This re-ordering leads to the execution of more gates in parallel and a smaller number of additional SWAP gates to compile the QAOA-circuit. Consequently, the circuit-depth and cumulative gate-count become lower which is beneficial for circuit execution time and noise resilience. A less number of gates indicates a lower accumulation of gate-errors, and a reduced circuit-depth means less decoherence time for the qubits. However, finding the best-ordered circuit is a difficult problem and does not scale well with circuit size. This paper presents four generic methodologies to optimize QAOA-circuits by exploiting gate re-ordering. We demonstrate a reduction in gate-count by ≈23.0% and circuit-depth by ≈53.0% on average over a conventional approach without incurring any compilation-time penalty. We also present a variation-aware compilation which enhances the compiled circuit success probability by ≈62.7% for the target hardware over the variation unaware approach. A new metric, Approximation Ratio Gap (ARG), is proposed to validate the quality of the compiled QAOA-circuit instances on actual devices. Hardware implementation of a number of QAOA instances shows ≈25.8% improvement in the proposed metric on average over the conventional approach on ibmq 16 melbourne.

IEEE/ACM International Symposium on Microarchitecture (MICRO)•Oct 1, 2020•78 citations

Comparing and Integrating Constraint Programming and Temporal Planning for Quantum Circuit Compilation

Kyle E. C. Booth, Minh Do, J. Christopher Beck +3 more

Recently, the makespan-minimization problem of compiling a general class of quantum algorithms into near-term quantum processors has been introduced to the AI community. The research demonstrated that temporal planning is a strong approach for a class of quantum circuit compilation (QCC) problems. In this paper, we explore the use of constraint programming (CP) as an alternative and complementary approach to temporal planning. We extend previous work by introducing two new problem variations that incorporate important characteristics identified by the quantum computing community. We apply temporal planning and CP to the baseline and extended QCC problems as both stand-alone and hybrid approaches. Our hybrid methods use solutions found by temporal planning to warm start CP, leveraging the ability of the former to find satisficing solutions to problems with a high degree of task optionality, an area that CP typically struggles with. The CP model, benefiting from inferred bounds on planning horizon length and task counts provided by the warm start, is then used to find higher quality solutions. Our empirical evaluation indicates that while stand-alone CP is only competitive for the smallest problems, CP in our hybridization with temporal planning out-performs stand-alone temporal planning in the majority of problem classes.

arXiv:1803.06775•Proceedings of the International Conference on Automated Planning and Scheduling•Jun 15, 2018•36 citations

A Structured Method for Compilation of QAOA Circuits in Quantum Computing

Yuwei Jin, Luo, Jason, Lucent Fong +5 more

Quantum Approximation Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) is a highly advocated variational algorithm for solving the combinatorial optimization problem. One critical feature in the quantum circuit of QAOA algorithm is that it consists of two-qubit operators that commute. The flexibility in reordering the two-qubit gates allows compiler optimizations to generate circuits with better depths, gate count, and fidelity. However, it also imposes significant challenges due to additional freedom exposed in the compilation. Prior studies lack the following: (1) Performance guarantee, (2) Scalability, and (3) Awareness of regularity in scalable hardware. We propose a structured method that ensures linear depth for any compiled QAOA circuit on multi-dimensional quantum architectures. We also demonstrate how our method runs on Google Sycamore and IBM Non-linear architectures in a scalable manner and in linear time. Overall, we can compile a circuit with up to 1024 qubits in 10 seconds with a 3.8X speedup in depth, 17% reduction in gate count, and 18X improvement for circuit ESP.

arXiv:2112.06143•Dec 12, 2021•15 citations

Quantum circuit compilation by genetic algorithm for quantum approximate optimization algorithm applied to MaxCut problem

Lis Arufe, Miguel Ángel González, Angelo Oddi +2 more

The Quantum Circuit Compilation Problem (QCCP) is challenging to the Artificial Intelligence community. It was already tackled with temporal planning, constraint programming, greedy heuristics and other techniques. In this paper, QCCP is formulated as a scheduling problem and solved by a genetic algorithm. We focus on QCCP for Quantum Approximation Optimization Algorithms (QAOA) applied to the MaxCut problem and consider Noisy Intermediate Scale Quantum (NISQ) hardware architectures. Based on the fact that these algorithms apply a set of basic quantum operations repeatedly over a number of rounds, we propose a genetic algorithm approach, termed Decomposition Based Genetic Algorithm (DBGA), that in each round extends the partial solutions obtained for the previous ones. DBGA is compared to the state of the art across a set of conventional instances. The results of the experimental study provided interesting insight in the problem structure and showed that DBGA is quite competitive with the state of the art. In particular, DBGA outperformed the best current method on the largest instances and provided new best solutions to most of them.

Swarm and Evolutionary Computation•Jan 7, 2022•27 citations
Abstract To run quantum algorithms on emerging gate-model quantum hardware, quantum circuits must be compiled to take into account constraints on the hardware. For near-term hardware, with only limited means to mitigate decoherence, it is critical to minimize the duration of the circuit. We investigate the application of temporal planners to the problem of compiling quantum circuits to newly emerging quantum hardware. While our approach is general, we focus on compiling to superconducting hardware architectures with nearest neighbor constraints. Our initial experiments focus on compiling Quantum Alternating Operator Ansatz (QAOA) circuits whose high number of commuting gates allow great flexibility in the order in which the gates can be applied. That freedom makes it more challenging to find optimal compilations but also means there is a greater potential win from more optimized compilation than for less flexible circuits. We map this quantum circuit compilation problem to a temporal planning problem, and generated a test suite of compilation problems for QAOA circuits of various sizes to a realistic hardware architecture. We report compilation results from several state-of-the-art temporal planners on this test set. This early empirical evaluation demonstrates that temporal planning is a viable approach to quantum circuit compilation.
We investigate the application of temporal planners to the problem of compiling quantum circuits to emerging quantum hardware. While our approach is general, we focus our initial experiments on Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) circuits that have few ordering constraints and thus allow highly parallel plans. We report on experiments using several temporal planners to compile circuits of various sizes to a realistic hardware architecture. This early empirical evaluation suggests that temporal planning is a viable approach to quantum circuit compilation.
The problem of compiling general quantum algorithms for implementation on near-term quantum processors has been introduced to the AI community. Previous work demonstrated that temporal planning is an attractive approach for part of this compilationtask, specifically, the routing of circuits that implement the Quantum Alternating Operator Ansatz (QAOA) applied to the MaxCut problem on a quantum processor architecture. In this paper, we extend the earlier work to route circuits that implement QAOA for Graph Coloring problems. QAOA for coloring requires execution of more, and more complex, operations on the chip, which makes routing a more challenging problem. We evaluate the approach on state-of-the-art hardware architectures from leading quantum computing companies. Additionally, we apply a planning approach to qubit initialization. Our empirical evaluation shows that temporal planning compares well to reasonable analytic upper bounds, and that solving qubit initialization with a classical planner generally helps temporal planners in finding shorter-makespan compilations for QAOA for Graph Coloring. These advances suggest that temporal planning can be an effective approach for more complex quantum computing algorithms and architectures.
The quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA) is a promising quantum-classical hybrid algorithm to solve hard combinatorial optimization problems. The multi-qubit CPHASE gates used in the quantum circuit for QAOA are commutative i.e., the order of the gates can be altered without changing the output state. This re-ordering leads to the execution of more gates in parallel and a smaller number of additional SWAP gates to compile the QAOA-circuit. Consequently, the circuit-depth and cumulative gate-count become lower which is beneficial for circuit execution time and noise resilience. A less number of gates indicates a lower accumulation of gate-errors, and a reduced circuit-depth means less decoherence time for the qubits. However, finding the best-ordered circuit is a difficult problem and does not scale well with circuit size. This paper presents four generic methodologies to optimize QAOA-circuits by exploiting gate re-ordering. We demonstrate a reduction in gate-count by ≈23.0% and circuit-depth by ≈53.0% on average over a conventional approach without incurring any compilation-time penalty. We also present a variation-aware compilation which enhances the compiled circuit success probability by ≈62.7% for the target hardware over the variation unaware approach. A new metric, Approximation Ratio Gap (ARG), is proposed to validate the quality of the compiled QAOA-circuit instances on actual devices. Hardware implementation of a number of QAOA instances shows ≈25.8% improvement in the proposed metric on average over the conventional approach on ibmq 16 melbourne.
Recently, the makespan-minimization problem of compiling a general class of quantum algorithms into near-term quantum processors has been introduced to the AI community. The research demonstrated that temporal planning is a strong approach for a class of quantum circuit compilation (QCC) problems. In this paper, we explore the use of constraint programming (CP) as an alternative and complementary approach to temporal planning. We extend previous work by introducing two new problem variations that incorporate important characteristics identified by the quantum computing community. We apply temporal planning and CP to the baseline and extended QCC problems as both stand-alone and hybrid approaches. Our hybrid methods use solutions found by temporal planning to warm start CP, leveraging the ability of the former to find satisficing solutions to problems with a high degree of task optionality, an area that CP typically struggles with. The CP model, benefiting from inferred bounds on planning horizon length and task counts provided by the warm start, is then used to find higher quality solutions. Our empirical evaluation indicates that while stand-alone CP is only competitive for the smallest problems, CP in our hybridization with temporal planning out-performs stand-alone temporal planning in the majority of problem classes.
Quantum Approximation Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) is a highly advocated variational algorithm for solving the combinatorial optimization problem. One critical feature in the quantum circuit of QAOA algorithm is that it consists of two-qubit operators that commute. The flexibility in reordering the two-qubit gates allows compiler optimizations to generate circuits with better depths, gate count, and fidelity. However, it also imposes significant challenges due to additional freedom exposed in the compilation. Prior studies lack the following: (1) Performance guarantee, (2) Scalability, and (3) Awareness of regularity in scalable hardware. We propose a structured method that ensures linear depth for any compiled QAOA circuit on multi-dimensional quantum architectures. We also demonstrate how our method runs on Google Sycamore and IBM Non-linear architectures in a scalable manner and in linear time. Overall, we can compile a circuit with up to 1024 qubits in 10 seconds with a 3.8X speedup in depth, 17% reduction in gate count, and 18X improvement for circuit ESP.
The Quantum Circuit Compilation Problem (QCCP) is challenging to the Artificial Intelligence community. It was already tackled with temporal planning, constraint programming, greedy heuristics and other techniques. In this paper, QCCP is formulated as a scheduling problem and solved by a genetic algorithm. We focus on QCCP for Quantum Approximation Optimization Algorithms (QAOA) applied to the MaxCut problem and consider Noisy Intermediate Scale Quantum (NISQ) hardware architectures. Based on the fact that these algorithms apply a set of basic quantum operations repeatedly over a number of rounds, we propose a genetic algorithm approach, termed Decomposition Based Genetic Algorithm (DBGA), that in each round extends the partial solutions obtained for the previous ones. DBGA is compared to the state of the art across a set of conventional instances. The results of the experimental study provided interesting insight in the problem structure and showed that DBGA is quite competitive with the state of the art. In particular, DBGA outperformed the best current method on the largest instances and provided new best solutions to most of them.