Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1704.01173

Everettian Decoherent Histories and Causal Histories

André L. G. Mandolesi

Published Apr 4, 2017• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

D. Wallace has tried to use decoherence to solve the preferred basis problem of Everettian Quantum Mechanics, and this solution lays the foundation for his proof of the Born rule. But this is a circular argument, as approximations used in decoherence usually rely on the probabilistic interpretation of the Hilbert space norm. He claims the norm can measure approximations even without probabilities, but this assumption has not been properly justified. Without it, the combination of the Everettian and decoherent histories formalisms leads to strange consequences, such as a proliferation of small amplitude histories with lots of macroscopic quantum jumps. Still, this erratic behavior may provide a way to justify the approximations, in a new histories formalism, in which macroscopic causal relations play a central role. Small histories, suffering too much interference, may lose causality, being thus discarded as invalid. The remaining branches can present some small interference, opening the possibility of experimental verification.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1704.01173

Related papers

Non-Probabilistic Decoherent Histories and Causal Histories in Everettian Quantum Mechanics

André L. G. Mandolesi

D. Wallace has combined the Decoherent Histories formalism and Everettian Quantum Mechanics, in an attempt to solve the preferred basis problem. This in turn serves as a foundation for his proof of the Born rule. But approximations used in decoherence depend on the probabilistic interpretation of Born weights, resulting in a circular reasoning. We contest his arguments that the approximations are valid even without probabilities, and show that, without them, the combination of those theories leads to unacceptable results. There is a proliferation of ill behaved histories, compromising his proof of the Born rule. We propose the development of a new causal histories formalism, which might improve the situation. Histories of small amplitude are discarded, not on probability grounds, but for suffering too much interference, which blurs causal relations. The remaining histories might still suffer small amounts of interference, leaving open the possibility of experimental verification.

•Apr 4, 2017•0 citations

Decoherence and its Role in Interpretations of Quantum Physics

Simon Matthew Thomas Newey

The purpose of this thesis is to examine different conceptions of decoherence and their significance within interpretations of quantum mechanics. I set out three different conceptions of decoherence found in the literature and examine the relations between them. I argue that only the weakest of these conceptions is empirically well supported, and that the other two rely on claims about the structure of the histories (robust patterns within the wavefunction) which we occupy which require justification. \n \nI also examine the ways in which conceptions of decoherence are used to solve aspects of the quantum measurement problem and support modern interpretations of quantum mechanics. I focus particularly on Wallace's Everettian interpretation of quantum mechanics. I argue that while decoherence is generally successful in supporting this interpretation in a variety of ways, the very strong conception of decoherence on which he relies is itself difficult to justify. \n \nI consider a variety of possible approaches to justifying the use of this strong conception of decoherence and argue that many of them are either unconvincing, or rely on controversial cosmological claims. Finally, I suggest that the best way to justify the use of this strong conception of decoherence is by appealing directly to its indispensability to an otherwise very attractive interpretation of quantum mechanics.

•Feb 1, 2019•1 citation

Analysis of Wallace's Decision Theoretic Proof of the Born Rule in Everettian Quantum Mechanics

André L. G. Mandolesi

We analyse Wallace’s adaptation of Decision Theory to formally prove the Born Rule in Everettian Quantum Mechanics. His proof was reorganized with some improvements, and many details were filled in. In the process, we detected some inconsistencies in his concepts and axioms, as well as other problems, which, if not fixed, would invalidate the proof.

•Apr 20, 2015•0 citations

Decoherence, branching, and the Born rule in a mixed-state Everettian multiverse

Eugene Y. S. Chua, Eddy Keming Chen

Abstract In Everettian quantum mechanics, justifications for the Born rule appeal to self-locating uncertainty or decision theory. Such justifications have focused exclusively on a pure-state Everettian multiverse, represented by a wavefunction. Recent works in quantum foundations suggest that it is viable to consider a mixed-state Everettian multiverse, represented by a (mixed-state) density matrix. Here, we discuss the conceptual foundations for decoherence and branching in a mixed-state multiverse, and extend arguments for the Born rule to this setting. This extended framework provides a unification of ‘classical’ and ‘quantum’ probabilities, and additional theoretical benefits, for the Everettian picture.

arXiv:2307.13218•Synthese•Apr 4, 2025•7 citations

Approximate Decoherence, Recoherence and Records in Isolated Quantum Systems

Philipp Strasberg, Joseph Schindler, Jiaozi Wang +1 more

Using the framework of decoherent histories, we study which past events leave detectable records in isolated quantum systems under the realistic assumption that decoherence is approximate and not perfect. In the first part we establish -- asymptotically for a large class of (pseudo-)random histories -- that the number of reliable records can be much smaller than the number of possible events, depending on the degree of decoherence. In the second part we reveal a clear decoherence structure for long histories based on a numerically exact solution of a random matrix model that, as we argue, captures generic aspects of decoherence. We observe recoherence between histories with a small Hamming distance, for localized histories admitting a high purity Petz recovery state, and for maverick histories that are statistical outliers with respect to Born's rule. From the perspective of the Many Worlds Interpretation, the first part -- which views the self-location problem as a coherent version of quantum state discrimination -- reveals a "branch selection problem", and the second part sheds light on the emergence of Born's rule and the theory confirmation problem.

quant-pharXiv:2601.19703•Jan 28, 2026•2 citations

Probability in the Everett World: Comments on Wallace and Greaves

Huw Price

It is often objected that the Everett interpretation of QM cannot make sense of quantum probabilities, in one or both of two ways: either it can't make sense of probability at all, or it can't explain why probability should be governed by the Born rule. David Deutsch has attempted to meet these objections. He argues not only that rational decision under uncertainty makes sense in the Everett interpretation, but also that under reasonable assumptions, the credences of a rational agent in an Everett world should be constrained by the Born rule. David Wallace has developed and defended Deutsch's proposal, and greatly clarified its conceptual basis. In particular, he has stressed its reliance on the distinguishing symmetry of the Everett view, viz., that all possible outcomes of a quantum measurement are treated as equally real. The argument thus tries to make a virtue of what has usually been seen as the main obstacle to making sense of probability in the Everett world. In this note I outline some objections to the Deutsch-Wallace argument, and to related proposals by Hilary Greaves about the epistemology of Everettian QM. (In the latter case, my arguments include an appeal to an Everettian analogue of the Sleeping Beauty problem.) The common thread to these objections is that the symmetry in question remains a very significant obstacle to making sense of probability in the Everett interpretation.

arXiv:quant-ph/0604191•Apr 26, 2006•97 citations
D. Wallace has tried to use decoherence to solve the preferred basis problem of Everettian Quantum Mechanics, and this solution lays the foundation for his proof of the Born rule. But this is a circular argument, as approximations used in decoherence usually rely on the probabilistic interpretation of the Hilbert space norm. He claims the norm can measure approximations even without probabilities, but this assumption has not been properly justified. Without it, the combination of the Everettian and decoherent histories formalisms leads to strange consequences, such as a proliferation of small amplitude histories with lots of macroscopic quantum jumps. Still, this erratic behavior may provide a way to justify the approximations, in a new histories formalism, in which macroscopic causal relations play a central role. Small histories, suffering too much interference, may lose causality, being thus discarded as invalid. The remaining branches can present some small interference, opening the possibility of experimental verification.
D. Wallace has combined the Decoherent Histories formalism and Everettian Quantum Mechanics, in an attempt to solve the preferred basis problem. This in turn serves as a foundation for his proof of the Born rule. But approximations used in decoherence depend on the probabilistic interpretation of Born weights, resulting in a circular reasoning. We contest his arguments that the approximations are valid even without probabilities, and show that, without them, the combination of those theories leads to unacceptable results. There is a proliferation of ill behaved histories, compromising his proof of the Born rule. We propose the development of a new causal histories formalism, which might improve the situation. Histories of small amplitude are discarded, not on probability grounds, but for suffering too much interference, which blurs causal relations. The remaining histories might still suffer small amounts of interference, leaving open the possibility of experimental verification.
The purpose of this thesis is to examine different conceptions of decoherence and their significance within interpretations of quantum mechanics. I set out three different conceptions of decoherence found in the literature and examine the relations between them. I argue that only the weakest of these conceptions is empirically well supported, and that the other two rely on claims about the structure of the histories (robust patterns within the wavefunction) which we occupy which require justification. \n \nI also examine the ways in which conceptions of decoherence are used to solve aspects of the quantum measurement problem and support modern interpretations of quantum mechanics. I focus particularly on Wallace's Everettian interpretation of quantum mechanics. I argue that while decoherence is generally successful in supporting this interpretation in a variety of ways, the very strong conception of decoherence on which he relies is itself difficult to justify. \n \nI consider a variety of possible approaches to justifying the use of this strong conception of decoherence and argue that many of them are either unconvincing, or rely on controversial cosmological claims. Finally, I suggest that the best way to justify the use of this strong conception of decoherence is by appealing directly to its indispensability to an otherwise very attractive interpretation of quantum mechanics.
Abstract In Everettian quantum mechanics, justifications for the Born rule appeal to self-locating uncertainty or decision theory. Such justifications have focused exclusively on a pure-state Everettian multiverse, represented by a wavefunction. Recent works in quantum foundations suggest that it is viable to consider a mixed-state Everettian multiverse, represented by a (mixed-state) density matrix. Here, we discuss the conceptual foundations for decoherence and branching in a mixed-state multiverse, and extend arguments for the Born rule to this setting. This extended framework provides a unification of ‘classical’ and ‘quantum’ probabilities, and additional theoretical benefits, for the Everettian picture.
Using the framework of decoherent histories, we study which past events leave detectable records in isolated quantum systems under the realistic assumption that decoherence is approximate and not perfect. In the first part we establish -- asymptotically for a large class of (pseudo-)random histories -- that the number of reliable records can be much smaller than the number of possible events, depending on the degree of decoherence. In the second part we reveal a clear decoherence structure for long histories based on a numerically exact solution of a random matrix model that, as we argue, captures generic aspects of decoherence. We observe recoherence between histories with a small Hamming distance, for localized histories admitting a high purity Petz recovery state, and for maverick histories that are statistical outliers with respect to Born's rule. From the perspective of the Many Worlds Interpretation, the first part -- which views the self-location problem as a coherent version of quantum state discrimination -- reveals a "branch selection problem", and the second part sheds light on the emergence of Born's rule and the theory confirmation problem.
It is often objected that the Everett interpretation of QM cannot make sense of quantum probabilities, in one or both of two ways: either it can't make sense of probability at all, or it can't explain why probability should be governed by the Born rule. David Deutsch has attempted to meet these objections. He argues not only that rational decision under uncertainty makes sense in the Everett interpretation, but also that under reasonable assumptions, the credences of a rational agent in an Everett world should be constrained by the Born rule. David Wallace has developed and defended Deutsch's proposal, and greatly clarified its conceptual basis. In particular, he has stressed its reliance on the distinguishing symmetry of the Everett view, viz., that all possible outcomes of a quantum measurement are treated as equally real. The argument thus tries to make a virtue of what has usually been seen as the main obstacle to making sense of probability in the Everett world. In this note I outline some objections to the Deutsch-Wallace argument, and to related proposals by Hilary Greaves about the epistemology of Everettian QM. (In the latter case, my arguments include an appeal to an Everettian analogue of the Sleeping Beauty problem.) The common thread to these objections is that the symmetry in question remains a very significant obstacle to making sense of probability in the Everett interpretation.