Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1703.08679 · Physical Review Letters

Fractal Dimension of Interfaces in Edwards-Anderson and Long-range Ising Spin Glasses: Determining the Applicability of Different Theoretical Descriptions

Wenlong Wang, M A Moore, Helmut G. Katzgraber

Published Sep 7, 2017• 19 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The fractal dimension of excitations in glassy systems gives information on the critical dimension at which the droplet picture of spin glasses changes to a description based on replica symmetry breaking where the interfaces are space filling. Here, the fractal dimension of domain-wall interfaces is studied using the strong-disorder renormalization group method pioneered by Monthus [Fractals 23, 1550042 (2015)FRACEG0218-348X10.1142/S0218348X15500425] both for the Edwards-Anderson spin-glass model in up to 8 space dimensions, as well as for the one-dimensional long-ranged Ising spin-glass with power-law interactions. Analyzing the fractal dimension of domain walls, we find that replica symmetry is broken in high-enough space dimensions. Because our results for high-dimensional hypercubic lattices are limited by their small size, we have also studied the behavior of the one-dimensional long-range Ising spin-glass with power-law interactions. For the regime where the power of the decay of the spin-spin interactions with their separation distance corresponds to 6 and higher effective space dimensions, we find again the broken replica symmetry result of space filling excitations. This is not the case for smaller effective space dimensions. These results show that the dimensionality of the spin glass determines which theoretical description is appropriate. Our results will also be of relevance to the Gardner transition of structural glasses.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.119.100602

Related papers

Interface free-energy exponent in the one-dimensional Ising spin glass with long-range interactions in both the droplet and broken replica symmetry regions

Timo Aspelmeier, Wenlong Wang, M A Moore +1 more

The one-dimensional Ising spin-glass model with power-law long-range interactions is a useful proxy model for studying spin glasses in higher space dimensions and for finding the dimension at which the spin-glass state changes from having broken replica symmetry to that of droplet behavior. To this end we have calculated the exponent that describes the difference in free energy between periodic and antiperiodic boundary conditions. Numerical work is done to support some of the assumptions made in the calculations and to determine the behavior of the interface free-energy exponent of the power law of the interactions. Our numerical results for the interface free-energy exponent are badly affected by finite-size problems.

arXiv:1606.03990•Physical review. E•Aug 11, 2016•15 citations

Overcoming System-Size Limitations in Spin Glasses

Helmut G. Katzgraber, Mathias Körner, Frauke Liers +1 more

In order to overcome the limitations of small system sizes in spin-glass simulations, we investigate the one-dimensional Ising spin chain with power-law interactions.The model has the advantage over traditional higher-dimensional Hamiltonians in that a large range of system sizes can be studied.In addition, the universality class of the model can be changed by tuning the power law exponent, thus allowing us to scan from the mean-field to long-range and short-range universality classes.We illustrate the advantages of this model by studying the nature of the spin glass state where our results hint towards a replica symmetry breaking scenario.We also compute ground-state energy distributions and show that mean-field and non-mean-field models are intrinsically different. * )Recently Krzakala and Martin, as well as Palassini and Young, suggest an intermediate picture in which droplets have a fractal surface, and their energy is finite in the thermodynamic limit.See Ref. 5) and references therein for details.* * ) Note that we explicitly distinguish between θ , the stiffness exponent for droplet excitations, and θ, the exponent for domain walls, because DP predicts θ = θ , which we want to test here.

arXiv:cond-mat/0509469•Progress of Theoretical Physics Supplement•Jan 1, 2005•12 citations

Geometry of large-scale low-energy excitations in the one-dimensional Ising spin glass with power-law interactions

Helmut G. Katzgraber, A. P. Young

Results are presented for the geometry of low-energy excitations in the one-dimensional Ising spin chain with power-law interactions, in which the model parameters are chosen to yield a finite spin-glass transition temperature. Both finite-temperature and ground-state studies are carried out. For the range of sizes studied the data cannot be fitted to any of the standard spin-glass scenarios without including corrections to scaling. Incorporating such corrections we find that the fractal dimension of the surface of the excitations, is either equal to the space dimension, consistent with replica symmetry breaking, or very slightly less than it. The latter case is consistent with the droplet and ``trivial-nontrivial'' pictures.

arXiv:cond-mat/0307583•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Dec 8, 2003•31 citations

Nature of spin glass order in physical dimensions

Bharadwaj Vedula, M A Moore, Auditya Sharma

We have studied the diluted Heisenberg spin glass model in a three-component random field for the commonly used one-dimensional long-range model where the probability that two spins separated by a distance r interact with one another falls as 1/r^{2σ}, for two values of σ, 0.75 and 0.85. No de Almeida-Thouless line is expected at these σ values. The spin glass correlation length ξ_{SG} varies with the random field as expected from the Imry-Ma argument and the droplet scaling picture of spin glasses. However, when ξ_{SG} becomes comparable to the system size L, there are departures which we attribute to the features deriving from the replica symmetry breaking picture of spin glasses. For the case σ=0.85 these features go away for system sizes with L>L^{*}, where L^{*} is large (≈4000-8000 lattice spacings). In the case of σ=0.75 we have been unable to study large enough systems to determine its value of L^{*}. We sketch a renormalization group scenario to explain how these features could arise. In this scenario finite size effects on the droplet scaling picture in low-dimensional spin glasses produce some aspects of Parisi's replica symmetry breaking theory of the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick model.

arXiv:2410.19069•Physical review. E•Mar 4, 2025•6 citations

Ground-state interface exponents of the diluted Sherrington-Kirkpatrick spin glass

Wenlong Wang

We present a large-scale simulation of the ground state interface properties of the diluted Sherrington-Kirkpatrick spin glass of Gaussian disorder for a broad range of the bond occupation probability $p$ using the strong disorder renormalization group and the population annealing Monte Carlo methods. The model is studied in the framework of the diluted one-dimensional Kotliar-Anderson-Stein spin glass with power-law interactions in the mean-field regime. We find that the interface is space-filling independent of $p$, i.e., the fractal dimension ${d}_{s}=1$. The stiffness exponent $\ensuremath{\theta}$ is likely also independent of $p$, despite that the energy finite-size correction exponent $\ensuremath{\omega}$ varies with $p$ as recently found. The energy finite-size scaling is also analyzed and compared with that of the $\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}J$ disorder, finding that the thermodynamic energy is universal in both $p$ and the disorder, and the exponent $\ensuremath{\omega}$ varies with $p$ but is universal in the disorder.

arXiv:2207.08193•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Oct 27, 2022•2 citations

Temperature Chaos and Bond Chaos in Edwards-Anderson Ising Spin Glasses: Domain-Wall Free-Energy Measurements

M. Sasaki, Koji Hukushima, Hajime Yoshino +1 more

Domain-wall free energy $\ensuremath{\delta}F$, entropy $\ensuremath{\delta}S$, and the correlation function ${C}_{\mathrm{temp}}$ of $\ensuremath{\delta}F$ are measured independently in the four-dimensional $\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}J$ Edwards-Anderson (EA) Ising spin glass. The stiffness exponent $\ensuremath{\theta}$, the fractal dimension of domain walls ${d}_{s}$, and the chaos exponent $\ensuremath{\zeta}$ are extracted from the finite-size scaling analysis of $\ensuremath{\delta}F$, $\ensuremath{\delta}S$, and ${C}_{\mathrm{temp}}$, respectively, well inside the spin-glass phase. The three exponents are confirmed to satisfy the scaling relation $\ensuremath{\zeta}={d}_{s}/2\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\theta}$ derived by the droplet theory within our numerical accuracy. We also study bond chaos induced by random variation of bonds, and find that the bond and temperature perturbations yield the universal chaos effects described by a common scaling function and the chaos exponent. These results strongly support the appropriateness of the droplet theory for the description of chaos effect in the EA Ising spin glasses.

arXiv:cond-mat/0411138•Physical Review Letters•Dec 20, 2005•45 citations
The fractal dimension of excitations in glassy systems gives information on the critical dimension at which the droplet picture of spin glasses changes to a description based on replica symmetry breaking where the interfaces are space filling. Here, the fractal dimension of domain-wall interfaces is studied using the strong-disorder renormalization group method pioneered by Monthus [Fractals 23, 1550042 (2015)FRACEG0218-348X10.1142/S0218348X15500425] both for the Edwards-Anderson spin-glass model in up to 8 space dimensions, as well as for the one-dimensional long-ranged Ising spin-glass with power-law interactions. Analyzing the fractal dimension of domain walls, we find that replica symmetry is broken in high-enough space dimensions. Because our results for high-dimensional hypercubic lattices are limited by their small size, we have also studied the behavior of the one-dimensional long-range Ising spin-glass with power-law interactions. For the regime where the power of the decay of the spin-spin interactions with their separation distance corresponds to 6 and higher effective space dimensions, we find again the broken replica symmetry result of space filling excitations. This is not the case for smaller effective space dimensions. These results show that the dimensionality of the spin glass determines which theoretical description is appropriate. Our results will also be of relevance to the Gardner transition of structural glasses.
The one-dimensional Ising spin-glass model with power-law long-range interactions is a useful proxy model for studying spin glasses in higher space dimensions and for finding the dimension at which the spin-glass state changes from having broken replica symmetry to that of droplet behavior. To this end we have calculated the exponent that describes the difference in free energy between periodic and antiperiodic boundary conditions. Numerical work is done to support some of the assumptions made in the calculations and to determine the behavior of the interface free-energy exponent of the power law of the interactions. Our numerical results for the interface free-energy exponent are badly affected by finite-size problems.
In order to overcome the limitations of small system sizes in spin-glass simulations, we investigate the one-dimensional Ising spin chain with power-law interactions.The model has the advantage over traditional higher-dimensional Hamiltonians in that a large range of system sizes can be studied.In addition, the universality class of the model can be changed by tuning the power law exponent, thus allowing us to scan from the mean-field to long-range and short-range universality classes.We illustrate the advantages of this model by studying the nature of the spin glass state where our results hint towards a replica symmetry breaking scenario.We also compute ground-state energy distributions and show that mean-field and non-mean-field models are intrinsically different. * )Recently Krzakala and Martin, as well as Palassini and Young, suggest an intermediate picture in which droplets have a fractal surface, and their energy is finite in the thermodynamic limit.See Ref. 5) and references therein for details.* * ) Note that we explicitly distinguish between θ , the stiffness exponent for droplet excitations, and θ, the exponent for domain walls, because DP predicts θ = θ , which we want to test here.
Results are presented for the geometry of low-energy excitations in the one-dimensional Ising spin chain with power-law interactions, in which the model parameters are chosen to yield a finite spin-glass transition temperature. Both finite-temperature and ground-state studies are carried out. For the range of sizes studied the data cannot be fitted to any of the standard spin-glass scenarios without including corrections to scaling. Incorporating such corrections we find that the fractal dimension of the surface of the excitations, is either equal to the space dimension, consistent with replica symmetry breaking, or very slightly less than it. The latter case is consistent with the droplet and ``trivial-nontrivial'' pictures.
We have studied the diluted Heisenberg spin glass model in a three-component random field for the commonly used one-dimensional long-range model where the probability that two spins separated by a distance r interact with one another falls as 1/r^{2σ}, for two values of σ, 0.75 and 0.85. No de Almeida-Thouless line is expected at these σ values. The spin glass correlation length ξ_{SG} varies with the random field as expected from the Imry-Ma argument and the droplet scaling picture of spin glasses. However, when ξ_{SG} becomes comparable to the system size L, there are departures which we attribute to the features deriving from the replica symmetry breaking picture of spin glasses. For the case σ=0.85 these features go away for system sizes with L>L^{*}, where L^{*} is large (≈4000-8000 lattice spacings). In the case of σ=0.75 we have been unable to study large enough systems to determine its value of L^{*}. We sketch a renormalization group scenario to explain how these features could arise. In this scenario finite size effects on the droplet scaling picture in low-dimensional spin glasses produce some aspects of Parisi's replica symmetry breaking theory of the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick model.
We present a large-scale simulation of the ground state interface properties of the diluted Sherrington-Kirkpatrick spin glass of Gaussian disorder for a broad range of the bond occupation probability ppp using the strong disorder renormalization group and the population annealing Monte Carlo methods. The model is studied in the framework of the diluted one-dimensional Kotliar-Anderson-Stein spin glass with power-law interactions in the mean-field regime. We find that the interface is space-filling independent of ppp, i.e., the fractal dimension ds=1{d}_{s}=1ds​=1. The stiffness exponent $\ensuremath{\theta}$ is likely also independent of ppp, despite that the energy finite-size correction exponent $\ensuremath{\omega}$ varies with ppp as recently found. The energy finite-size scaling is also analyzed and compared with that of the $\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}J$ disorder, finding that the thermodynamic energy is universal in both ppp and the disorder, and the exponent $\ensuremath{\omega}$ varies with ppp but is universal in the disorder.
Domain-wall free energy $\ensuremath{\delta}F$, entropy $\ensuremath{\delta}S$, and the correlation function Ctemp{C}_{\mathrm{temp}}Ctemp​ of $\ensuremath{\delta}F$ are measured independently in the four-dimensional $\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}J$ Edwards-Anderson (EA) Ising spin glass. The stiffness exponent $\ensuremath{\theta}$, the fractal dimension of domain walls ds{d}_{s}ds​, and the chaos exponent $\ensuremath{\zeta}$ are extracted from the finite-size scaling analysis of $\ensuremath{\delta}F$, $\ensuremath{\delta}S$, and Ctemp{C}_{\mathrm{temp}}Ctemp​, respectively, well inside the spin-glass phase. The three exponents are confirmed to satisfy the scaling relation $\ensuremath{\zeta}={d}_{s}/2\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\theta}$ derived by the droplet theory within our numerical accuracy. We also study bond chaos induced by random variation of bonds, and find that the bond and temperature perturbations yield the universal chaos effects described by a common scaling function and the chaos exponent. These results strongly support the appropriateness of the droplet theory for the description of chaos effect in the EA Ising spin glasses.